Abstract
Rationale
Translational research, especially research that bridges studies with humans and nonhuman species, is critical to advancing our understanding of human disorders such as addiction. This advancement requires reliable and rigorous models to study the underlying constructs contributing to the maladaptive behavior.
Objective
In this commentary, we address some of the challenges of conducting translational research by examining a single procedure, place conditioning. Place conditioning is commonly used with laboratory animals to study the conditioned rewarding effects of drugs, and recent studies indicate that a similar procedure can be used in humans.
Results
We discuss the opportunities and challenges of making the procedure comparable across species, as well as discuss the benefits of more systematically applying the procedure to humans.
Conclusion
We argue that the capacity of humans to report verbally on their internal experiences (perceptions, affective states, likes and dislikes) add an important dimension to the understanding of the procedures used in laboratory animals.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aapro MS, Molassiotis A, Olver I (2005) Anticipatory nausea and vomiting. Supportive Care in Cancer: Official Journal of the Multinational Association of Supportive Care in Cancer 13(2):117–121
Astur RS, Carew AW, Deaton BE (2014) Conditioned place preferences in humans using virtual reality. Behav Brain Res 267:173–177
Astur RS, Palmisano AN, Hudd EC, Carew AW, Deaton BE, Kuhney FS, Niezrecki RN, Santos M (2015) Pavlovian conditioning to food reward as a function of eating disorder risk. Behav Brain Res 291:277–282
Astur RS, Palmisano AN, Carew AW, Deaton BE, Kuhney FS, Niezrecki RN, Hudd EC, Mendicino KL, Ritter CJ (2016) Conditioned place preferences in humans using secondary reinforcers. Behav Brain Res 297:15–19
Ayres JJB, Philbin D, Cassidy S, Bellino L, Redlinger E (1992) Some parameters of latent inhibition. Learn Motiv 23(3):269–287
Banz BC, Worhunsky PD, Pittman BP, Astur RS, Tennen HA, Raskin SA, Austad CS, Wood RM, Fallahi CR, Potenza MN, Pearlson GD (2019) Relationships between drinking quantity and frequency and behavioral and hippocampal BOLD responses during working memory performance involving allocentric spatial navigation in college students. Drug Alcohol Depend 201:236–243
Bardo MT, Bevins RA (2000) Conditioned place preference: what does it add to our preclinical understanding of drug reward? Psychopharmacology 153(1):31–43
Bardo MT, Neisewander JL (1986) Single-trial conditioned place preference using intravenous morphine. Pharmacol Biochem Behav 25(5):1101–1105
Bardo MT, Rowlett JK, Harris MJ (1995) Conditioned place preference using opiate and stimulant drugs: a meta-analysis. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 19(1):39–51
Baron D, Holland CM, Carlson K, Wolfrum E, Thompson BL (2020) Adapting social conditioned place preference for use in young children. Neurobiol Learn Mem 172:107235
Bevins RA, Cunningham CL (2006) Place conditioning: a methodological analysis. In: Tasks and techniques: a sampling of methodologies for the investigation of animal learning, behavior, and cognition. Nova Science, Hauppauge, NY, pp 99–110
Bevins RA, Besheer J (2005) Novelty reward as a measure of anhedonia. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 29(4–5):707–714
Biénkowski P, Kuca P, Kostowski W (1995) Conditioned place preference after prolonged pre-exposure to ethanol. Pol J Pharmacol 47(2):189–191
Cahill CM, Xue L, Grenier P, Magnussen C, Lecour S, Olmstead MC (2013) Changes in morphine reward in a model of neuropathic pain. Behav Pharmacol 24(3):207–213
Carr GD, Fibiger HC, Phillips AG (1989) Conditioned place preference as a measure of drug reward. The Neuropharmacological Basis of Reward 433:264–319
Childs E, de Wit H (2009) Amphetamine-induced place preference in humans. Biol Psychiat 65(10):900–904
Childs E, de Wit H (2013) Contextual conditioning enhances the psychostimulant and incentive properties of d-amphetamine in humans. Addict Biol 18(6):985–992
Childs E, de Wit H (2016) Alcohol-induced place conditioning in moderate social drinkers. Addiction 111(12):2157–2165
Childs E, Astur RS, de Wit H (2017) Virtual reality conditioned place preference using monetary reward. Behav Brain Res 322(Pt A):110–114
Cunningham CL, Prather LK (1992) Conditioning trial duration affects ethanol-induced conditioned place preference in mice. Anim Learn Behav 20(2):187–194
Cunningham CL, Howard MA, Gill SJ, Rubinstein M, Low MJ, Grandy DK (2000) Ethanol-conditioned place preference is reduced in dopamine D2 receptor-deficient mice. Pharmacol Biochem Behav 67(4):693–699
Cunningham CL, Gremel CM, Groblewski PA (2006) Drug-induced conditioned place preference and aversion in mice. Nat Protoc 1(4):1662–1670
de Wit H, Uhlenhuth EH, Pierri J, Johanson CE (1987) Individual differences in behavioral and subjective responses to alcohol. Alcohol Clin Exp Res 11(1):52–59
Erb SM, Parker LA (1994) Individual differences in novelty-induced activity do not predict strength of amphetamine-induced place conditioning. Pharmacol Biochem Behav 48(3):581–586
Ettenberg A, Raven MA, Danluck DA, Necessary BD (1999) Evidence for opponent-process actions of intravenous cocaine. Pharmacol Biochem Behav 64(3):507–512
Fleming AS, Korsmit M, Deller M (1994) Rat pups are potent reinforcers to the maternal animal: Effects of experience, parity, hormones, and dopamine function. Psychobiology 22(1):44–53
Folley BS, Astur R, Jagannathan K, Calhoun VD, Pearlson GD (2010) Anomalous neural circuit function in schizophrenia during a virtual Morris water task. Neuroimage 49(4):3373–3384
Griffiths RR, Balster RL (1979) Opioids: similarity between evaluations of subjective effects and animal self-administration results. Clin Pharmacol Ther 25(5 Pt 1):611–617
Ikemoto S, Donahue KM (2005) A five-minute, but not a fifteen-minute, conditioning trial duration induces conditioned place preference for cocaine administration into the olfactory tubercle. Synapse 56(1):57–59
Itzhak Y, Roger-Sánchez C, Kelley JB, Anderson KL (2010) Discrimination between cocaine-associated context and cue in a modified conditioned place preference paradigm: role of the nNOS gene in cue conditioning. Int J Neuropsych / Official Scientific Journal of the Collegium InternaNeuropsychopharmacologicum 13(2):171–180
Jasinski DR (1991) History of abuse liability testing in humans. Br J Addict 86(12):1559–1562
King T, Vera-Portocarrero L, Gutierrez T, Vanderah TW, Dussor G, Lai J, Fields HL, Porreca F (2009) Unmasking the tonic-aversive state in neuropathic pain. Nat Neurosci 12(11):1364–1366
King A, Vena A, Hasin DS, deWit H, O’Connor SJ, Cao D (2021) Subjective Responses to Alcohol in the Development and Maintenance of Alcohol Use Disorder. Am J Psychiatry 178(6):560–571
Klebaur JE, Bardo MT (1999) Individual differences in novelty seeking on the playground maze predict amphetamine conditioned place preference. Pharmacol Biochem Behav 63(1):131–136
Koek W (2016) Morphine-induced conditioned place preference and effects of morphine pre-exposure in adolescent and adult male C57BL/6J mice. Psychopharmacology 233(11):2015–2024
Krishnan S, Heer C, Cherian C, Sheffield MEJ (2022) Reward expectation extinction restructures and degrades CA1 spatial maps through loss of a dopaminergic reward proximity signal. Nat Commun 13(1):6662
Lamb RJ, Preston KL, Schindler CW, Meisch RA, Davis F, Katz JL, Henningfield JE, Goldberg SR (1991) The reinforcing and subjective effects of morphine in post-addicts: a dose-response study. J Pharmacol Exp Ther 259(3):1165–1173
Lee AM, Calarco CA, McKee SA, Mineur YS, Picciotto MR (2020) Variability in nicotine conditioned place preference and stress-induced reinstatement in mice: Effects of sex, initial chamber preference, and guanfacine. Genes Brain Behav 19(3):e12601
Li J, Murray CH, Weafer J, de Wit H (2020) Subjective Effects of Alcohol Predict Alcohol Choice in Social Drinkers. Alcohol Clin Exp Res 44(12):2579–2587
Linhardt M, Kiser DP, Pauli P, Hilger K (2022) Approach and avoidance beyond verbal measures: A quantitative meta-analysis of human conditioned place preference studies. Behav Brain Res 426:113834
Lutz JA, Childs E (2021) Alcohol conditioned contexts enhance positive subjective alcohol effects and consumption. Behav Proc 187:104340
Lynch WJ, Nicholson KL, Dance ME, Morgan RW, Foley PL (2010) Animal models of substance abuse and addiction: implications for science, animal welfare, and society. Comp Med 60(3):177–188
Mattson BJ, Williams S, Rosenblatt JS, Morrell JI (2001) Comparison of two positive reinforcing stimuli: pups and cocaine throughout the postpartum period. Behav Neurosci 115(3):683–694
Mayo LM, de Wit H (2016) Acquisition of Conditioned Responses to a Novel Alcohol-Paired Cue in Social Drinkers. J Stud Alcohol Drugs 77(2):317–326
Mayo LM, Fraser D, Childs E, Momenan R, Hommer DW, de Wit H, Heilig M (2013) Intergenerational transmission of stress in humans. Neuropsychopharmacology 38(6):921–929
McKendrick G, Graziane NM (2020) Drug-Induced Conditioned Place Preference and Its Practical Use in Substance Use Disorder Research. Front Behav Neurosci 14:582147
McKendrick G, Garrett H, Tanniru S, Ballard S, Sun D, Silberman Y, Grigson PS, Graziane NM (2020) A novel method to study reward-context associations and drug-seeking behaviors. J Neurosci Methods 343:108857
Molet M, Billiet G, Bardo MT (2013) Conditioned place preference and aversion for music in a virtual reality environment. Behav Proc 92:31–35
Murray JE, Bevins RA (2010) Cannabinoid conditioned reward and aversion: behavioral and neural processes. ACS Chem Neurosci 1(4):265–278
Napier TC, Herrold AA, de Wit H (2013) Using conditioned place preference to identify relapse prevention medications. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 37(9 Pt A):2081–2086
Navratilova E, Xie JY, King T, Porreca F (2013) Evaluation of reward from pain relief. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1282:1–11
Nentwig TB, Myers KP, Grisel JE (2017) Initial subjective reward to alcohol in Sprague-Dawley rats. Alcohol 58:19–22
Palmisano AN, Hudd EC, McQuade CM, de Wit H, Astur RS (2018) The effects of nicotine on conditioning, extinction, and reinstatement in humans. Addict Behav 77:51–58
Pavlov PI (2010) Conditioned reflexes: an investigation of the physiological activity of the cerebral cortex. Ann Neurosci 17(3):136–141. https://doi.org/10.5214/ans.0972-7531.1017309
Radell ML, Myers CE, Beck KD, Moustafa AA, Allen MT (2016) The Personality Trait of Intolerance to Uncertainty Affects Behavior in a Novel Computer-Based Conditioned Place Preference Task. Front Psychol 7:1175
Reichel CM, Bevins RA (2008) Competition between the conditioned rewarding effects of cocaine and novelty. Behav Neurosci 122(1):140–150
Reichel CM, Bevins RA (2010) Competition between novelty and cocaine conditioned reward is sensitive to drug dose and retention interval. Behav Neurosci 124(1):141–151
Rock EM, Sticht MA, Limebeer CL, Parker LA (2016) Cannabinoid Regulation of Acute and Anticipatory Nausea. Cannabis and Cannabinoid Research 1(1):113–121
Prus AJ, James JR, Rosecrans JA (2009) Conditioned place preference. In: Buccafusco JJ (ed) Methods of behavior analysis in neuroscience, 2nd edn. CRC Press/Taylor & Francis, Boca Raton, FL. Chapter 4. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK5229/
Rossi NA, Reid LD (1976) Affective states associated with morphine injections. Physiol Psychol 4(3):269–274
Scherma M, Fattore L, Fratta W, Fadda P (2021) Conditioned Place Preference (CPP) in Rats: From Conditioning to Reinstatement Test. Methods Mol Biol 2201:221–229
Seidman MH, Lau CE, Chen R, Falk JL (1992) Orally self-administered cocaine: reinforcing efficacy by the place preference method. Pharmacol Biochem Behav 43(1):235–241
Seymour CM, Wagner JJ (2008) Simultaneous expression of cocaine-induced behavioral sensitization and conditioned place preference in individual rats. Brain Res 1213:57–68
Shimosato K, Watanabe S (2003) Concurrent evaluation of locomotor response to novelty and propensity toward cocaine conditioned place preference in mice. J Neurosci Methods 128(1–2):103–110
Shipman SL, Astur RS (2008) Factors affecting the hippocampal BOLD response during spatial memory. Behav Brain Res 187(2):433–441
Shipman SL, Malison RT, Siegel S, Rizzo AA, Astur RS (2006) Cocaine Induced Place Preference in a Virtual Environment. In 2006 International Workshop on Virtual Rehabilitation. https://doi.org/10.1109/iwvr.2006.1707528
Siddiqi SH, Kording KP, Parvizi J, Fox MD (2022) Causal mapping of human brain function. Nat Rev Neurosci 23(6):361–375
Spragg SDS (1940) Morphine addiction in chimpanzees. Comparative Psychology Monographs 15:7
Spyraki C, Fibiger HC, Phillips AG (1982) Attenuation by haloperidol of place preference conditioning using food reinforcement. Psychopharmacology 77(4):379–382
Stephens DN, Crombag HS, Duka T (2013) The challenge of studying parallel behaviors in humans and animal models. Curr Top Behav Neurosci 13:611–645
Takahashi K, Toyoshima M, Ichitani Y, Yamada K (2020) Enhanced methamphetamine-induced conditioned place preference in risk-taking rats. Behav Brain Res 378:112299
Tenk CM, Wilson H, Zhang Q, Pitchers KK, Coolen LM (2009) Sexual reward in male rats: effects of sexual experience on conditioned place preferences associated with ejaculation and intromissions. Horm Behav 55(1):93–97
Thiel KJ, Okun AC, Neisewander JL (2008) Social reward-conditioned place preference: a model revealing an interaction between cocaine and social context rewards in rats. Drug Alcohol Depend 96(3):202–212
Tzschentke TM (1998) Measuring reward with the conditioned place preference paradigm: a comprehensive review of drug effects, recent progress and new issues. Prog Neurobiol 56(6):613–672
Tzschentke TM (2007) Measuring reward with the conditioned place preference (CPP) paradigm: update of the last decade. Addict Biol 12(3–4):227–462
van den Akker K, Jansen A, Frentz F, Havermans RC (2013) Impulsivity makes more susceptible to overeating after contextual appetitive conditioning. Appetite 70:73–80
Vanderschuren LJMJ, Ahmed SH (2013) Animal studies of addictive behavior. Cold Spring Harb Perspect Med 3(4):a011932
Van Hedger K, Cavallo JS, Ruiz NA, de Wit H (2018) Conditioning nausea in a laboratory setting: A pilot study. In bioRxiv, p. 243121. https://doi.org/10.1101/243121
Venniro M, Banks ML, Heilig M, Epstein DH, Shaham Y (2020) Improving translation of animal models of addiction and relapse by reverse translation. Nat Rev Neurosci 21(11):625–643
Wilkinson JL, Bevins RA (2008) Intravenous nicotine conditions a place preference in rats using an unbiased design. Pharmacol Biochem Behav 88(3):256–264
Williams SB, Arriaga M, Korgaonkar AA, Morón JA, Han EB (2019) Hippocampal Activity Dynamics During Contextual Reward Association in Virtual Reality Place Conditioning. In bioRxiv :545608. https://doi.org/10.1101/545608
Zarrindast M-R, Ebrahimi-Ghiri M, Rostami P, Rezayof A (2007) Repeated pre-exposure to morphine into the ventral pallidum enhances morphine-induced place preference: involvement of dopaminergic and opioidergic mechanisms. Behav Brain Res 181(1):35–41
Funding
SK was supported by T32DA043469, RAB was supported by GM130461 and DA046109 and HdW was supported by DA02812.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher's note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
This article belongs to a Special Issue on Innovating translational models of affective disorders
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Krishnan, S., Bevins, R.A. & de Wit, H. Place conditioning in humans: opportunities for translational research. Psychopharmacology 240, 2221–2230 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00213-023-06316-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00213-023-06316-8