Abstract
The geopotential coefficients of a number of recent and past models have been examined with the aim of calibrating their formal (or published) errors, principally by direct comparison with the same coefficients of a precise and wholly independent satellite-only reference field determined (in 2010) predominantly from over 7 years of μ/s low–low GRACE inter-satellite range rate observations (ITG-GRACE2010S). In all of these comparisons the reference field used, over specified spectral ranges, has much smaller reported errors than the ones to be calibrated. In particular we find that a recently published field (in 2010) using gravity gradient and position data from ESA’s GOCE satellite, GO_CONS_GCF_2_TIM_R1, has formal errors which are significantly optimistic for the lowest degrees (n) but with increasing realism where the gradiometer gains influence over the position information (15 < n < 120). Other GOCE models do not afford an unbiased error calibration. Validating error calibration with the independent reference model, of two past comprehensive fields (containing both satellite and surface data), confirms that one of them (JGM3, published in 1994, complete to n = 70) reported generally realistic formal errors while another (EGM96, published in 1998, complete to n = 360, tested only for n < 150) had significantly optimistic ones for most n < 100 but with better realism when affected only by the surface information.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bruinsma SI, Marty JC, Balmino G, Biancale R, Foerste C, Abrikosov O, Neumayer H (2010) GOCE gravity field recovery by means of the direct numerical method, paper presented at the ESA Living Planet Symposium, Eur. Space Agency, Bergen Norway, June 28–2 July
Colombo O, Kleusberg A (1983) Applications of an orbiting gradiometer. Bull Geod 57: 89
Colombo O (1984) Altimetry, orbits and tides. NASA Tech Memo 86180: 173
Drinkwater MR, Floberghagen R, Haagmans R, Muzi D, Popescu A et al (2003) GOCE: ESA’s first Earth explorer core mission. In: Beutler G (ed) Earth gravity field from space—from sensors to earth science, Space Sci. Ser. ISSI, vol 18. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, pp 419–432
ICGEM (International Centre for Global Earth Models) (2010) http://icgem.gfz-potsdam.de/ICGEM/ICGEM.html
Kaula WM (1966) Theory of satellite geodesy. Blaisdell Publishing Company, Waltham, Mass., Equation 5.15
Klees R, Koop R, Visser P, van den Ijssel J (2000) Efficient gravity field recovery from GOCE gravity gradient observations. J Geoid 74(1–8): 561–571. doi:10.1007/s001900000118
Lemoine FG, Kenyon SC, Factor JK, Trimmer RG, Pavlis NK, Chinn DS, Cox CM, Klosko SM, Luthcke SB, Torrence MH, Wang YM, Willaimson RG, Pavlis EC, Rapp RH, Olson TR (1998) The development of the Joint NASA-GSFC and the National Imagery and Mapping Agency (NIMA) Geopotential Model EGM96, NASA Technical Paper NASA TP 199820686, Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt
Lerch FJ, Marsh JG, Klosko SM, Patel G, Chinn D, Pavlis EC, Wagner CA (1991) An improved error assessment for the GEM-T1 gravitational model. J Geophys Res 96(B12): 20023–20040
Martin C, Roy N (1970) Error model for the SAO standard Earth. In: The uses of artificial satellites for geodesy, vol 161, American Geophysical Union Monograph 15, Washington, USA
Mayer-Gürr T, Eicker A, Ilk KH, Kurtenbach E (2010a) ITG-Grace2010s gravity field model. http://www.uni-bonn.de/apmg/index.php?id=itg-grace2010
Mayer-Gürr T, Eicker A, Kurtenbach E, Ilk KH (2010) ITGGRACE Global static and temporal gravity field models from GRACE data. In: Flechtner F (ed) et al System earth via geodetic-geophysical space techniques. Springer, New York, pp 159–168. doi:10.1007/978-3-642-10228-8_13
Migliaccio F, Reguzzoni M, Sanso F, Tcherning CC, Veicherts M (2010) GOCE data analysis; the space-wise approach and the first space-wise gravity field model, paper presented at the ESA Living Planet Symposium, Eur. Space Agency, Bergen, Norway, June 28–2 July
Pail R, Goiginger H, Mayrhofer R, Schuh WD, Brockmann J, Krasbutter I, Hoeck E, Fecher T (2010) GOCE gravity field model derived from orbit and gradiometer data applying the time-wise method, In: Proceedings of the ESE Living Planet Symposium, 28 June–2 July 2010; Bergen, Norway; ESA Publication SP-686, ESA/ESTEC. ISBN (Online) 978-92-9221-250-6, ISSN 1609-042X
Pail R, Bruinsma S, Migliaccio F, Forste C, Goiginger H, Schuh W-D, Hoeck E, Recuzzoni M, Brockmann JM, Abrikosov O, Veicherts M, Fecher T, Mayrhofer R, Krasbutter T, Sanso F, Tcherning CC (2011) First GOCE gravity field models derived by three different approaches. J Geod. doi:10.1007/s00190-11-0467-x
Pavlis N, Holmes S, Kenyon S, Factor J (2008) An earth gravity model to degree and order 2160-EGM2008. Presented at the 2008 General Assembly of the European Geosciences Union meeting, Vienna, Austria, April 13–18
Sneeuw N, van Gelderen M (1997) The polar gap. In: Sanso F, Rummel R (eds) Geodetic boundary value problems in view of the one centimeter Geoid. Lecture Notes in Earth Sciences, vol 65. Springer, Berlin, pp 559–568
Tapley B, Watkins M, Ries J, Eanes R, Poole S, Kim H, Shutz R, Shum C, Nerem R, Lerch F, Marshall J, Klosko S, Pavlis N, Williamson R (1996) The joint gravity model 3. J Geophys Res 101(B12): 28029–28049
Tapley B, Ries J, Bettadpur S, Chambers D, Cheng M, Condi F, Poole S (2007) The GGM03S mean earth gravity field from GRACE, EOS Trans, AGU vol 88, # 52, Fall Meeting Suppl., Abstract G42A-03, 2007
Wagner C, Lerch F (1978) The accuracy of geopotential models. Planet Space Sci 26: 1081–1141
Wagner C, McAdoo D, Klokocnik J, Kostelecky J (2006) Degradation of geopotential recovery from short repeat-cycle orbits: application to GRACE monthly fields. J Geod 80: 94–103
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wagner, C.A., McAdoo, D.C. Error calibration of geopotential harmonics in recent and past gravitational fields. J Geod 86, 99–108 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00190-011-0494-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00190-011-0494-7