Empirical Economics

, Volume 46, Issue 2, pp 701–731 | Cite as

Still puzzling: evaluating the price puzzle in an empirically identified structural vector autoregression

  • Selva Demiralp
  • Kevin D. Hoover
  • Stephen J. Perez


The price puzzle, an increase in the price level associated with a contractionary monetary shock, is investigated in a rich, 12-variable SVAR in which various factors that have been mooted as solutions are considered jointly. SVARs for the pre-1980 and post-1990 periods are identified empirically using a graph-theoretic causal search algorithm combined with formal tests of the implied overidentifying restrictions. In this SVAR, the pre-1980 price puzzle depends on the characterization of monetary policy, and the post-1990 price puzzle is statistically insignificant. Commonly suggested theoretical resolutions to the price puzzle are shown to have causal implications inconsistent with the data.


Price puzzle Monetary policy Graph theory Causal search  Output gap Transmission mechanism 

JEL Classification

C32 C51 E32 E44 E51 



Demiralp’s research was funded by Turkish Academy of Sciences (TÜBA).


  1. Akleman DG, Bessler DA, Burton DM (1999) Modeling corn exports and exchange rates with directed graphs and statistical loss functions. In: Glymour C, Cooper GF (eds) Computation, causation, and discovery. American Association for Artificial Intelligence and MIT Press, Menlo Park and Cambridge, pp 497–520Google Scholar
  2. Awokuse TO (2005) Export-led growth and the Japanese economy: evidence from VAR and directed acyclical graphs. Appl Econ Lett 12(14):849–858CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Barth MJ, Ramey V (2001) The cost channel of monetary transmission. In: Bernanke BS, Rogoff K (eds) NBER macroeconomics annual 2001. MIT Press, Cambridge, pp 199–240Google Scholar
  4. Bernanke BS, Blinder AS (1992) The federal funds rate and the channels of monetary transmission. Am Econ Rev 82(4):901–921Google Scholar
  5. Bernanke BS, Mihov I (1998) The liquidity effect and long-run neutrality. Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy 49. North-Holland, Amsterdam, pp 149–194Google Scholar
  6. Bessler DA, Lee S (2002) Money and prices: U.S. data 1869–1914 (a study with directed graphs). Empir Econ 27:427–446CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Bessler DA, Loper N (2001) Economic development: evidence from directed acyclical graphs. Manch Sch 69(4):457–476CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Brissimis SN, Magginas NS (2006) Forward-looking information in VAR models and the price puzzle. J Monet Econ 53(6):1225–1234CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Carpenter S, Demiralp S (2012) Money reserves, and the transmission of monetary policy: Does the money multiplier exist? J MAcroecon 34:59–75Google Scholar
  10. Christiano LJ, Eichenbaum M, Evans CL (1996) The effects of monetary policy shocks: evidence from the flow of funds. Rev Econ Stat 78(1):16–34CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Christiano LJ, Eichenbaum M, Evans CL (1999) Monetary policy shocks: what have we learned and to what end? In: Taylor JB, Woodford M (eds) Handbook of macroeconomics, vol 1A. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 65–148Google Scholar
  12. Christiano LJ, Eichenbaum M, Evans CL (2005) Nominal rigidities and the dynamic effects of a shock to monetary policy. J Polit Econ 113(1):1–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Cooper GF (1999) An overview of the representation and discovery of causal relationships using Bayesian networks. In: Glymour C, Cooper GF (eds) Computation, causation, and discovery. American Association for Artificial Intelligence and MIT Press, Menlo Park and Cambridge, pp 3–64Google Scholar
  14. Davig T, Leeper E, Chung H (2003) Monetary and fiscal policy switching. J Money Credit Bank 39(4): 809–842Google Scholar
  15. Demiralp S, Hoover KD (2003) Searching for the causal structure of a vector autoregression. Oxf Bull Econ Stat 65(Suppl):745–767CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Demiralp S, Hoover KD, Perez SJ (2008) A bootstrap method for identifying and evaluating a structural vector autoregression. Oxf Bull Econ Stat 70(4):509–533CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Doornik JA, Hendry DF (2007) PcGive Professional 12, vols 1–3 and accompanying PcGive, version 12 software. Timberlake Consultants, LondonGoogle Scholar
  18. Eichenbaum M (1992) Comments ‘Interpreting the macroeconomic time series facts: the effects of monetary policy’. Eur Econ Rev 36(5):1001–1011CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Faust J, Swanson ET, Wright JH (2004) Identifying VARs based on high frequency futures data. J Monet Econ 51(6):1107–1131CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Fisher FM (1966) The identification problem in econometrics. McGraw-Hill, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  21. Giordani P (2004) An alternative explanation of the price puzzle. J Monet Econ 51(6):1271–1296CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Haigh MS, Nomikos NK, Bessler DA (2004) Integration and causality in international freight markets: modeling with error correction and directed acyclical graphs. South Econ J 71(1):145–162CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Hamilton JD, Jorda O (2002) A model of the federal funds rate target. J Polit Econ 10(5):1135–1167CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Hanson MS (2004) The ‘price puzzle’ reconsidered. J Monet Econ 51(7):1385–1413CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Hendry DF, Krolzig H-M (2001) Automatic econometric model selection using PcGets \(1.0\) and accompanying PcGets, version 1.0 software. Timberlake Consultants, LondonGoogle Scholar
  26. Hendry DF, Lu M, Mizon GE (2009) Model identification and nonunique structure. In: Castle JL, Shephard N (eds) The methodology and practice of econometrics: a Festschrift in honour of David F. Hendry. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 343–364CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Hoover KD (2005) Automatic inference of contemporaneous causal order of a system of equations. Econom Theory 21(1):69–77CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Hoover KD, Perez SJ (1999) Data mining reconsidered: encompassing and the general-to-specific approach to specification search. Econom J 2(2):167–191CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Hoover KD, Perez SJ (2004) Truth and robustness in cross country growth regressions. Oxf Bull Econ Stat 66(5):765–798CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Hoover KD, Demiralp S, Perez SJ (2009) Empirical identification of the vector autoregression: the causes and effects of US M2. In: Castle JL, Shephard N (eds) The methodology and practice of econometrics: a Festschrift in honour of David F. Hendry. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 37–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Hurvich CM, Tsai C-L (1991) Bias of the corrected AIC criterion for underfitted regression and time series models. Biometrika 86(3):499–509Google Scholar
  32. Juselius K (2006) The cointegrated VAR model: methodology and applications. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  33. Krolzig H-M, Hendry DF (2001) Computer automation of general-to-specific model selection procedures. J Econ Dyn Control 25(6–7):831–866CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Leeper EM, Roush JE (2003) Putting M back in monetary policy. J Money Credit Bank 35(6; Part 2): 1217–1256CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Leeper EM, Sims CA, Zha T (1996) What does monetary policy do? Brookings Pap Econ Act 2:1–78CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Meulendyke A-M (1998) U.S. monetary policy and financial markets. Federal Reserve Bank of New York, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  37. Pearl J (2000) Causality: models, reasoning, and inference. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  38. Reale M, Wilson GT (2001) Identification of vector AR models with recursive structural errors using conditional independence graphs. Stat Methods Appl 10(1–3):49–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Reale M, Wilson GT (2002) The sampling properties of conditional independence graphs for structural vector autoregressions. Biometrica 89:457–461CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Scheines R, Spirtes P, Glymour C, Meek C (1994) Tetrad II: users manual. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJGoogle Scholar
  41. Sims CA (1980) Macroeconomic and reality. Econometrica 48(1):1–48Google Scholar
  42. Sims CA (1992) Interpreting the macroeconomic time series facts: the effects of monetary policy. Eur Econ Rev 36(5):975–1000CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Spirtes P, Clark Glymour C, Scheines R (2001) Causation, prediction, and search, 2nd edn. MIT Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  44. Strongin S (1995) The identification of monetary policy disturbances: explaining the liquidity puzzle. J Monet Econ 35(3):463–497CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Swanson NR, Granger CWJ (1997) Impulse-response functions based on a causal approach to residual orthogonalization in vector autoregressions. J Am Stat Assoc 92:357–367CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Wold H (1954) Causality and econometrics. Econometrica 22(2):162–177CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Yang J, Bessler DA (2004) The international price transmission in stock index futures markets. Econ Inq 42(3):370–386CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2013

Authors and Affiliations

  • Selva Demiralp
    • 1
  • Kevin D. Hoover
    • 2
    • 3
  • Stephen J. Perez
    • 4
  1. 1.Department of EconomicsKoç UniversityIstanbulTurkey
  2. 2.Department of EconomicsDuke UniversityDurhamUSA
  3. 3.Department of PhilosophyDuke UniversityDurhamUSA
  4. 4.Department of EconomicsCalifornia State University, SacramentoSacramentoUSA

Personalised recommendations