Abstract
Controversies over operative versus closed immobilization of traumatic complex multiple ligamentous knee injury are still debated. The aim of our study is to evaluate the outcome of reconstructive vs non-reconstructive (closed immobilization) treatment outcomes. This is a retrospective review of cases seen at our institution. All cases admitted with a diagnosis of knee dislocation, defined as patients with multidirectional knee instability in the setting of trauma, were reviewed. Twenty-nine consecutive patients from January of 1996 to June of 2002 were reviewed. Twenty-six patients (89.7%) were successfully recalled and their functional outcome analyzed. Comparing the operated group (n=15, 57.7%) with closed immobilized patients (n=11, 42.3%), there was no statistical difference in the range of motion (mean difference 8.55°, p=0.202). While the operated group had more flexion contracture (mean difference 3.9°, p=0.002), they had better stability and better overall knee function as measured by the International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) score (the mean difference of IKDC score was 12.13, p=0.005). In the operated group of 15 patients, we compared partial repair (n=7) with complete repair of all torn ligaments (n=8). Superior results were noted in the group with complete repair of all structures, with comparable range of motion (mean difference 0.6°, p=0.861) and flexion contractures (mean difference 1.0°, p=0.795) but better stability and IKDC score (mean difference of IKDC score 13.6, p=0.003). Our conclusion is that operative treatment with complete repair of all torn structures produces the best overall knee function with better knee stability and patient satisfaction.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Meyers MH, Harvey JP Jr (1971) Traumatic dislocation of the knee. A study of 18 cases. J Bone Joint Surg Am 53:16–29
Shields L, Mital M, Cave EF (1969) Complete dislocation of the knee: experience at the Massachusetts General Hospital. J Trauma 9:192–215
Montgomery JB (1987) Dislocation of the knee. Orthop Clin North Am 18:149–156
Wascher DC, Dvirnak PC, Decoster TA (1997) Knee dislocation: initial assessment and implications for treatment. J Orthop Trauma 11:525–529
Treiman GS, Yellin AE, Weaver FA et al (1992) Examination of a patient with a knee dislocation: the case for selective angiography. Arch Surg 127:1056–1061
Moore TM (1981) Fracture-dislocation of the knee. Clin Orthop 156:128–140
Kennedy JC (1963) Complete dislocation of the knee joint. J Bone Joint Surg Am 45:889–904
McCoy GF, Hannon DG, Barr RJ, Templeton J (1987) Vascular injury associated with low-velocity dislocations of the knee. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 69: 285–287
Taylor AR, Arden GP, Rainey HA (1972) Traumatic dislocation of the knee: report of 43 cases with special reference to conservative treatment. J Bone Joint Surg Br 54:96–102
Mitchell JT (1930) Dislocation of the knee. J Bone Joint Surg 12:640–642
Thomsen PB, Rud B, Jensen UH (1984) Stability and motion after dislocation of the knee. Acta Orthop Scand 55:278–283
Roman PD, Hopson CN, Zennie EJ Jr (1987) Traumatic dislocation of the knee: a report of 30 cases and literature review. Orthop Rev 16:917–924
Shelbourne KD, Porter DA, Clingman JA, McCarroll JR, Retting AC (1991) Low velocity knee dislocation. Orthop Rev 20:995–1004
Sisto DJ, Warren RF (1985) Complete dislocation of the knee: a follow-up study of operative treatment. Clin Orthop 198:94–101
Heister L (1973) A general system of surgery. Clarke, London
Yeh WL, Tu YK, Su JY, Hsu RW (1999) Knee dislocation: treatment of high velocity knee dislocation. J Trauma 46:693–701
Noyes FR, Barber-Westin SD (1997) Reconstruction of the anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments after knee dislocation: use of early protected postoperative motion to decrease arthrofibrosis. Am J Sports Med 25:769–778
Wascher DC, Becker JR, Dexter JG, Blevins FT (1999) Reconstruction of the anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments after knee dislocation. Results using fresh-frozen non-irradiated allografts. Am J Sports Med 27:189–196
Bratt HD, Newman AP (1993) Complete dislocation of the knee without disruption of both cruciate ligaments. J Trauma 34:383–389
Shelbourne KD, Pritchard J, Rettig AC, McCarroll JR, Vanmeter CD (1992) Knee dislocations with intact PCL. Orthop Rev 21:607–608, 610–611
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wong, CH., Tan, JL., Chang, HC. et al. Knee dislocations—a retrospective study comparing operative versus closed immobilization treatment outcomes. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 12, 540–544 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00167-003-0490-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00167-003-0490-4