Abstract
Reliability-based design optimization (RBDO) is an active field of research with an ever increasing number of contributions. Numerous methods have been proposed for the solution of RBDO, a complex problem that combines optimization and reliability analysis. Classical approaches are based on approximation methods and have been classified in review papers. In this paper, we first review classical approaches based on approximation methods such as FORM, and also more recent methods that rely upon surrogate modelling and Monte Carlo simulation. We then propose a generalization of the existing surrogate-assisted and simulation-based RBDO techniques using a unified framework that includes three independent blocks, namely adaptive surrogate modelling, reliability analysis, and optimization. These blocks are non-intrusive with respect to each other and can be plugged independently in the framework. After a discussion on numerical considerations that require attention for the framework to yield robust solutions to various types of problems, the latter is applied to three examples (using two analytical functions and a finite element model). Kriging and support vector machines regression together with their own active learning schemes are considered in the surrogate model block. In terms of reliability analysis, the proposed framework is illustrated using both crude Monte Carlo and subset simulation. Finally, the covariance matrix adaptation-evolution scheme (CMA-ES), a global search algorithm, or sequential quadratic programming (SQP), a local gradient-based method, is used in the optimization block. The comparison of the results to benchmark studies shows the effectiveness and efficiency of the proposed framework.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Agarwal H, Renaud J (2004) Reliability-based design optimization using response surfaces in application to multidisciplinary systems. Eng Opt 36(3):291–311
Agarwal H, Mozumder CK, Renaud JE, Watson LT (2007) An inverse-measure-based unilevel architecture for reliability-based design optimization. Struct Multidisc Optim 33(3):217–227
Aoues Y, Chateauneuf A (2010) Benchmark study of numerical methods for reliability-based design optimization. Struct Multidisc Optim 41(2):277–294
Arnold DV, Hansen N (2012) A (1 + 1)-CMA-ES for constrained optimisation. In: Soule T, Moore JH (eds) Genetic and evolutionary computation conference, pp 297–304
Au SK (2005) Reliability-based design sensitivity by efficient simulation. Comput Struct 83(14):1048–1061
Au SK, Beck JL (2001) Estimation of small failure probabilities in high dimensions by subset simulation. Prob Eng Mech 16(4):263–277
Bachoc F (2013) Cross validation and maximum likelihood estimations of hyper-parameters of Gaussian processes with model misspecifications. Comput Stat Data Anal 66:55–69
Basudhar A, Missoum S (2008) Adaptive explicit decision functions for probabilistic design and optimization using support vector machines. Comput Struct 86(19–20):1904–1917
Basudhar A, Missoum S (2010) An improved adaptive sampling scheme for the construction of explicit boundaries. Struct Multidisc Optim 42(4):517–529
Beaurepaire P, Jensen HA, Schuëller GI, Valdebenito MA (2013) Reliability-based optimization using bridge importance sampling. Prob Eng Mech 34:48–57
Beck AT, Gomes WJS (2012) A comparison of deterministic, reliability-based and risk-based structural optimization under uncertainty. Prob Eng Mech 28:18–29
Bichon BJ, Eldred MS, Swiler L, Mahadevan S, McFarland J (2008) Efficient global reliability analysis for nonlinear implicit performance functions. AIAA J 46(10):2459–2468
Boronson E, Missoum M (2017) Stochastic optimization of nonlinear energy sinks. Struct Multidisc Optim 55:633–646
Bourinet JM (2018) Reliability analysis and optimal design under uncertainty - Focus on adaptive surrogate-based approaches. Université Blaise Pascal, Clermont-Ferrand, France, habilitation à diriger des recherches, p 243
Chapelle O, Vapnik V, Bengio Y (2002) Model selection for small sample regression. Mach Learn 48 (1):9–23
Chateauneuf A (2008) Structural design optimization considering uncertainties. Taylor & Francis, chap 1, pp 3–30
Chen X, Hasselman KT, Neil DJ (1997) Reliability-based structural design optimization for practical applications. In: 38th Structures, Structural Dynamics, and Materials Conference, pp 2724–2732
Chen Z, Peng S, Li X, Qiu H, Xiong H, Gao L, Li P (2015) An important boundary sampling method for reliability-based design optimization using Kriging model. Struct Multidisc Optim 52(1):55–70
Cheng G, Xu L, Jiang L (2006) A sequential approximate programming strategy for reliability-based structural optimization. Comput Struct 84(21):1353–1367
Cho TM, Lee BC (2011) Reliability-based design optimization using convex linearization and sequential optimization and reliability assessment method. Struct Saf 33(1):42–50
de Angelis M, Patelli E, Beer M (2015) Advanced line sampling for efficient robust reliability analysis. Struct Saf 52(B):170–182
Ditlevsen O, Madsen H (1996) Structural reliability methods. Wiley, Chichester
Du X, Chen W (2004) Sequential optimization and reliability assessment method for efficient probabilistic design. J Mech Design 126(2):225–233
Dubourg V (2011) Adaptive surrogate models for reliability analysis and reliability-based design optimization. PhD thesis université Blaise Pascal, Clermont-Ferrand, France
Dubourg V, Sudret B, Bourinet JM (2011) Reliability-based design optimization using Kriging and subset simulation. Struct Multidisc Optim 44(5):673–690
Enevoldsen I, Sørensen JD (1994) Reliability-based optimization in structural engineering. Struct Saf 15 (3):169–196
Foschi RO, Li H, Zhang J (2002) Reliability and performance-based design: a computational approach and applications. Struct Saf 24(2–4):205–218
Frangopol DM (1985) Structural optimization using reliability concepts. J Struct Eng 111(11):2288–2301
Frangopol DM, Maute K (2003) Life-cycle reliability-based optimization of civil and aerospace structures. Comput Struct 81:397–410
Gao T, Li J (2017) A derivative-free trust-region algorithm for reliability-based optimization. Struct Multidisc Optim 55(4):1535–1539
Gaspar B, Teixeira AP, Guedes Soares C (2017) Adaptive surrogate model with active refinement combining Kriging and a trust region method. Reliab Eng Syst Saf 165:277–291
Geyer S, Papaiannou I, Straub D (2019) Cross-entropy-based importance sampling using gaussian densities revisited. Struct Saf 76:15–27
Hansen N, Ostermeier A (2001) Completely derandomized self-adaptation in evolution strategies. Evol Comput 9(2):159–195
Hilton HH, Feigen M (1960) Minimum weight analysis based on structural reliability. J Aerospace Sci 27 (9):641–652
Jia G, Taflanidis AA (2013) Non-parametric stochastic subset optimization for optimal-reliability design problems. Comput Struct 126:86–99
Jiang C, Qiu H, Gao L, Cai X, Li P (2017) An adaptive hybrid single-loop method for reliability-based design optimization using iterative control strategy. Struct Multidisc Optim, pp 1–16
Kaveh A, Talatahari S (2009) Particle swarm optimizer, and colony strategy and harmony search scheme hybridized for optimization of truss structures. Comput Struct 87:1267–283
Kaymaz I (2007) Approximation methods for reliability-based design optimization problems. GAMM-Mitt 30 (2):225–268
Kharmanda G, Mohamed A, Lemaire M (2002) Efficient reliability-based design optimization using a hybrid space with application to finite element analysis. Struct Multidisc Optim, 24(3)
Kurtz N, Song J (2013) Cross-entropy-based adaptive importance sampling using gaussian mixture. Struct Saf 42:35–44
Kuschel N, Rackwitz R (1997) Two basic problems in reliability-based structural optimization. Math Method Oper Res 46(3):309–333
Lacaze S, Missoum M (2014) A generalized max-min sample for surrogate updates. Struct Multidisc Optim 49:683–687
Lacaze S, Missoum S (2013) Reliability-based design optimization using Kriging and support vector machines. In: Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Structural Safety and Reliability (ICOSSAR), June 16–20, 2013, New York, United States, p 2013
Lataniotis C, Marelli S, Sudret B (2018) The gaussian process modeling module in UQLab. Soft Computing in Civil Engineering 2(3):91–116
Lee I, Choi KK, Du L, Gorsich D (2008) Inverse analysis method using MPP-based dimension reduction for reliability-based design optimization of nonlinear and multi-dimensional systems. Comput Methods Appl Mech Engrg 198:14–27
Lee I, Choi KK, Zhao L (2011) Sampling-based RBDO using the stochastic sensitivity analysis and dynamic Kriging method. Struct Multidisc Optim 44(3):299–317
Lee JO, Yang YS, Ruy WS (2002) A comparative study of reliability-index and target-performance-based probabilistic structural design optimization. Comput Struct 80:257–269
Lee PM (1997) Bayesian statistics: an introduction, 2nd edn. Wiley Publishing, London
Lee T, Jung J (2008) A sampling technique enhancing accuracy and efficiency of metamodel-based RBDO: Constraint boundary sampling. Comput Struct 86(13–14):1463–1476
Lehký D, Slowik O, Novák D (2017) Reliability-based design: Artificial neural networks and double-loop reliability-based optimization approaches. Adv Eng Soft, pp 1–13
Li G, Meng Z, Hu H (2015) An adaptive hybrid approach for reliability-based design optimization. Struct Multidisc Optim 51(5):1051–1065
Li W, Yang L (1994) An effective optimization procedure based on structural reliability. Comput Struct 52(5):1061–1067
Li X, Qiu H, Chen Z, Gao L, Shao X (2016) A local Kriging approximation method using MPP for reliability-based design optimization. Comput Struct 162:102–115
Liang J, Mourelatos Z, Tu J (2004) A single-loop method for reliability-based design optimization. In: Proc. DETC’04 ASME 2004 Design engineering technical conferences and computers and information in engineering conference, Sept. 28 – Oct. 2, 2004, Salt Lake City, Utah, USA
Liang J, Mourelatos ZP, Nikolaidis E (2007) A single-loop approach for system reliability-based design optimization. J Mech Des 129(12):1215–1224
Lim J, Lee B (2016) A semi-single-loop method using approximation of most probable point for reliability-based design optimization. Struct Multidisc Optim 53(4):745–757
Liu WS, Cheung SH (2017) Reliability-based design optimization with approximate failure probability function in partitioned design space. Reliab Eng Syst Saf 167:602–611
Madsen HO, Hansen PF (1992) A comparison of some algorithms for reliability based structural optimization and sensitivity analysis. In: Rackwitz R, Thoft-Christensen P (eds) Reliability and Optimization of Structural Systems’91. Lectures Notes in Engineering, vol 76. Springer, Berlin, pp 443–451
Marelli S, Sudret B (2014) UQLab: a framework for uncertainty quantification in Matlab. In: Vulnerability, uncertainty, and risk (Proc. 2nd int. Conf. on vulnerability, risk analysis and management (ICVRAM2014), Liverpool, United Kingdom), pp 2554–2563
McKay MD, Beckman RJ, Conover WJ (1979) A comparison of three methods for selecting values of input variables in the analysis of output from a computer code. Technometrics 2:239–245
Moustapha M, Sudret B (2017) Quantile-based optimization under uncertainties using bootstrap polynomial chaos expansions. In: Proc 12th Internatinoal Conference on Structural Safety and Reliability (ICOSSAR), August 6–10, Vienna, Austria, p 2017
Moustapha M, Sudret B, Bourinet JM, Guillaume B (2016) Quantile-based optimization under uncertainties using adaptive Kriging surrogate models. Struct Multidisc Optim 54(6):1403–1421
Moustapha M, Lataniotis C, Marelli S, Sudret B (2018a) UQLAb user manual – support vector machines for regression. Tech rep, chair of risk, safety & uncertainty quantification, ETH Zurich, report # UQLab-V1.1–111
Moustapha M, Sudret B, Bourinet JM, Guillaume B (2018b) Comparative study of Kriging and support vector regression for structural engineering applications. ASCE-ASME J Risk Uncertainty Eng Syst, Part A: Civ Eng 4(2)
Moustapha M, Marelli S, Sudret B (2019) UQLab user manual- Reliability-based design optimization. Tech rep, chair of risk, safety & uncertainty quantification, ETH Zurich, report # UQLab-V1.2–114
Nikolaidis E, Burdisso R (1988) Reliability-based optimization: a safety index approach. Comput Struct 28(6):781–788
Papadrakakis M, Lagaros ND, Plevris V (2005) Design optimization of steel structures considering uncertainties. Eng Struct 27(9):1408–1418
Papaioannou I, Betz W, Zwirglmaier K, Straub D (2015) MCMC Algorithms for subset simulation. Prob Eng Mech 41:89–103
Pradlwarter HJ, Schuëller G I, Koutsourelakis PS, Charmpis DC (2007) Application of line sampling simulation method to reliability benchmark problems. Struct Saf 29(3):208–221
Rahman S, Wei D (2008) Design sensitivity and reliability-based structural optimization by univariate decomposition. Struct Multidisc Optim 35(3):245–261
Rahman S, Xu H (2004) A univariate dimension-reduction method for multi-dimensional integration in stochastic mechanics. Prob Eng Mech 19:393–408
Rashki M, Miri M, Moghaddam MA (2014) A simulation-based method for reliability-based design optimization problems with highly nonlinear constraints. Autom Constr 47:24–36
Rasmussen CE, Williams CKI (2006) Gaussian processes for machine learning, Internet edn. Adaptive computation and machine learning. MIT Press, Cambridge
Royset JO (2004) Reliability-based optimal design using sample average approximations. Prob Eng Mech 19:331–343
Royset JO, Der Kiureghian A, Polak E (2001) Reliability-based optimal structural design by the decoupling approach. Reliab Eng Sys Safety 73(3):213–221
Santner TJ, Williams BJ, Notz WI (2003) The design and analysis of computer experiments. Springer, New York
Shetty NK, Guedes-Soares C, Thoft-Christensen P, Jensen FM (1998) Fire safety assessment and optimal design of passive fire protection for offshore structures. Reliab Eng Syst Saf 61(1–2):139–149
Smola AJ, Schölkopf B (2004) A tutorial on support vector regression. Stat Comput 14:199–222
Sobol’ IM (1967) Distribution of points in a cube and approximate evaluation of integrals. USSR Comput Maths Math Phys 7:86–112
Song H (2013) Efficient sampling-based RBDO by using virtual support vector machine and improving the accuracy of the Kriging method. PhD thesis, University of Iowa, USA
Spall JC (1998a) Implementation of the simultaneous perturbation algorithm for stochastic optimization. IEEE Trans Aerosp Electron Syst 34(3):817–823
Spall JC (1998b) An overview of the simultaneous perturbation method for efficient optimization. Johns Hopkins Apl Technical Digest 19(4):482–492
Spall JC (2003a) Introduction to stochastic search and optimization: Estimation, simulation and control, Wiley, chap 14: Simulation-based optimization I: regression, common random numbers, and selection methods
Spall JC (2003b) Introduction to stochastic search and optimization: Estimation, simulation and control. Wiley, New York
Strömberg N (2017) Reliability-based design optimization using SORM and SQP. Struct Multidisc Optim 56(3):631–645
Taflanidis AA (2007) Stochastic system design and applications to stochastic robust structural control. PhD thesis, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California, USA
Taflanidis AA, Beck JL (2008) Stochastic subset optimization for optimal reliability problems. Prob Eng Mech 23:324–338
Taflanidis AJ, Medina AC (2014) Adaptive Kriging for simulation-based design under uncertainty: Development of metamodels in augmented input space and adaptive tuning of their characteristics. In: Proc 4th international Conference on Simulation and Modeling Methodologies, Technologies and Applications, August 28-30, 2014, Vienna, Austria
Torre E, Marelli S, Embrechts P, Sudret B (2018) A general framework for data-driven uncertainty quantification under complex input dependencies using vine copulas. Prob Eng Mech (in press)
Tu J, Choi KK, Park YH (1999) A new study on reliability-based design optimization. J Mech Des 121:557–564
Valdebenito AM, Schuëller GI (2010) A survey on approaches for reliability-based optimization. Struct Multidisc Optim 42:645–663
Vapnik VN (1995) The nature of statistical learning theory. Springer, New York
Wang GG (2003) Adaptive response surface method using inherited Latin Hypercube design points. J Mech Design 125:210–220
Wang I-J, Spall JC (1998) A constrained simulation perturbation stochastic approximation algorithm based on penalty functions. In: Proceedings of the 1998 IEEE ISIC/CIRA/ISAS Joint Conference, Sept. 14–17, 1998, Gaithersburg, MD, USA
Youn BD (2007) Adaptive-loop method for non-deterministic design optimization. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part O: Journal of Risk and Reliability 221(2):107– 116
Youn BD, Choi KK, Du L (2005) Enriched performance measure approach for reliability-based design optimization. AIAA J 43(4):874–884
Zhang J, Taflanidis AA, Medina JC (2017) Sequential approximate optimization for design under uncertainty problems utilizing Kriging metamodeling in augmented input space. Comput Methods Appl Mech Engrg 315:369–395
Zou T, Mahadevan S (2006) A direct decoupling approach for efficient reliability-based design optimization. Struct Multidisc Optim 31:190–200
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Responsible Editor: Erdem Acar
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Moustapha, M., Sudret, B. Surrogate-assisted reliability-based design optimization: a survey and a unified modular framework. Struct Multidisc Optim 60, 2157–2176 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00158-019-02290-y
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00158-019-02290-y