Journal of Population Economics

, Volume 29, Issue 4, pp 1249–1277 | Cite as

Immigrant employment and earnings growth in Canada and the USA: evidence from longitudinal data

  • Neeraj Kaushal
  • Yao Lu
  • Nicole Denier
  • Julia Shu-Huah Wang
  • Stephen J. Trejo
Original Paper

Abstract

We study the short-term trajectories of employment, hours worked, and real wages of immigrants in Canada and the USA using nationally representative longitudinal datasets covering 1996–2008. Models with person fixed effects show that, on average, immigrant men in Canada do not experience any relative growth in these three outcomes compared to men born in Canada. Immigrant men in the USA, on the other hand, experience positive annual growth in all three domains relative to US-born men. This difference is largely on account of low-educated immigrant men, who experience faster or longer periods of relative growth in employment and wages in the USA than in Canada. We further compare longitudinal and cross-sectional trajectories and find that the latter over-estimate wage growth of earlier arrivals, presumably reflecting selective return migration.

Keywords

US immigrants Canadian immigrants Economic assimilation Longitudinal data Immigration Employment Wages Comparative study 
JEL Classification J15 J3 J18 

References

  1. Antecol H, Kuhn P, Trejo SJ (2006) Assimilation via prices or quantities? Sources of immigrant earnings growth in Australia, Canada, and the United States. J Hum Resour 41:821–840CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Aydemir A, Robinson C (2008) Global labour markets, return, and onward migration. Can J Econ / Rev Can Econ 41(4):1285–1311CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Aydemir A, Skuterud M (2005) Explaining the deteriorating entry earnings of Canada’s immigrant cohorts 1966–2000. Can J Econ 38:641–672CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Aydemir A, Skuterud M (2008) The immigrant wage differential within and across establishments. Ind Labor Relat Rev 61:334–352CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Aydemir A, Sweetman A (2008) First and second generation immigrant educational attainment and labor market outcomes: a comparison of the United States and Canada. Res Labor Econ 27:215–270CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Baglay S (2012) Provincial nominee programs: a note on policy implications and future research needs. J Int Migr Integr 13(1):121–141Google Scholar
  7. Baker M, Benjamin D (1994) The performance of immigrants in the Canadian labour market. J Labour Econ 12(3):369–405CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Banerjee R (2009) Income growth of new immigrants in Canada: evidence from the survey of labor and income dynamics. Ind Relat 64(3):466–488Google Scholar
  9. Beach C, Green AG, Worswick C (2006) Impacts of the point system and immigration policy levers on skill characteristics of Canadian immigrants (Working Papers 1115). Queen’s Department of Economics, KingstonGoogle Scholar
  10. Beckhusen J, Florax RJGM, Poot J, Waldorf BS (2013) Attracting global talent and then what? Overeducated immigrants in the United States. J Reg Sci 53(5):834–854CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Beenstock M (2006) Longitudinal analysis of earnings assimilation among immigrants in Quebec. Unpublished paper, Hebrew University of JerusalemGoogle Scholar
  12. Bloom DE, Grenier G, Gunderson M (1995) The changing labour market position of Canadian immigrants. Can J Econ 28(4):987–1005CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Bonikowska A, Hou F, Picot G (2011) A Canada-US comparison of labour market outcomes among highly educated immigrants. Can Public Policy 37:25–48CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Borjas GJ (1985) Changes in cohort quality, and the earnings of immigrants. J Labor Econ 3(4):463–489CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Borjas GJ (1989) Immigrant and emigrant earnings: a longitudinal study. Econ Inq 27:21–37CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Borjas G (1994) The economics of immigration. J Econ Lit 32:1667–1717Google Scholar
  17. Borjas G (2007) Mexican immigration to the United States (ed) National Bureau of Economic Research, Inc.Google Scholar
  18. Boyd M (2013) Accreditation and the labor market integration of internationally trained engineers and physicians in Canada. In: Triadafilopoulos T (ed) Wanted and welcome? Policies for highly skilled immigrants in comparative perspective. Springer, New York, pp 165–197Google Scholar
  19. Boyd M, Schellenberg G (2007) Re-accreditation and the occupations of immigrant doctors and engineers. Canadian Social Trends, Fall, 2–10Google Scholar
  20. Boyd M, Thomas D (2002) Skilled immigrant labour: country of origin and the occupational locations of male engineers. Can Stud Popul 29(1):71–99Google Scholar
  21. U.S. Census Bureau (2008) SIPP user’s guide: chapter 6 nonsampling errors. Retrieved: http://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/programs-surveys/sipp/methodology/SIPP_USERS_Guide_Chapter6_2008.pdf
  22. U.S. Census Bureau (2015b) SIPP introduction and history. Retrieved: http://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/sipp/about/sipp-introduction-history.html
  23. Chiswick B (1978) The effect of Americanization on the earnings of foreign-born men. J Polit Econ 86:897–921CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Chiswick B, Miller PW (2009) Educational mismatch: are high-skilled immigrants really working at high-skilled jobs and the price they pay if they aren’t? (IZA Discussion Paper 4280). The Institute for the Study of Labor, Bonn, Retrieved June 10, 2014, from http://ftp.iza.org/dp4280.pdf Google Scholar
  25. Duleep HO, Dowhan DJ (2002) Insights from longitudinal data on the earnings growth of U.S. foreign-born men. Demography 39:485–506CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Frenette M, Morissette R (2005) Will they ever converge? Earnings of immigrant and Canadian-born workers over the last two decades. Int Migr Rev 39(1):228–257CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Girard M, Smith MR (2013) Working in a regulated occupation in Canada: an immigrant–native born comparison. J Int Migr Integr 14(2):219–244Google Scholar
  28. Government of Canada (2010) Employment insurance regular benefits. Retrieved from: http://www.servicecanada.gc.ca/eng/ei/types/regular.shtml#Number
  29. Government of Canada (2014) Immigration overview: permanent and temporary residents. Retrieved from: http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/resources/statistics/facts2010/permanent/01.asp
  30. Green D, Worswick C (2009) Entry earnings of immigrant men in Canada: the roles of labour market entry effects and the returns to foreign experience. Retrieved from the University of British Columbia Vancouver School of Economics website: http://www.economics.ubc.ca/files/2013/05/pdf_paper_david-green-entry-earnings-immigrant-men.pdf
  31. Hall M, Farkas G (2008) Does human capital raise earnings for immigrants in the low-skill labor market? Demography 45(3):619–639CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Hayes JM, Hill LE (2008) Immigrant pathways to legal permanent residence: now and under a merit-based system. Technical Appendix. California Counts, Population Trends and Profiles, PPIC, 9(4)Google Scholar
  33. Hoefer M, Rytina N, Campbell C (2006) Estimates of the unauthorized immigrant population residing in the United States: January 2005. Retrieved from Office of Immigration Statistics, Policy Directorate, U.S. Department of Homeland Security: http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/statistics/publications/ILL_PE_2005.pdf
  34. Hu W (2000) Immigrant earnings assimilation: estimates from longitudinal data. Am Econ Rev 90:368–372CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Ibarraran P, Lubotsky D (2007) Mexican immigration and self selection: new evidence from the 2000 Mexican Census, NBER Chapters. In: Mexican immigration to the United States, p 159–192. National Bureau of Economic Research, IncGoogle Scholar
  36. Citizenship and Immigration Canada (2013) Facts and figures 2013—immigration overview: permanent residents. Retrieved from: http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/resources/statistics/facts2013/permanent/02.asp
  37. Kaushal N (2011) Earning trajectories of highly educated immigrants: does place of education matter? Ind Labor Relat Rev 64:323–340CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Kaushal N, Lu Y (2014) Recent immigration to Canada and the United States: a mixed tale of positive and negative relative selection. Int Migr RevGoogle Scholar
  39. Kim S (2012) Economic assimilation of foreign-born workers in the United States: an overlapping rotating panel analysis. Working paper, University of WashingtonGoogle Scholar
  40. Klinthäll M (2006) Retirement return migration from Sweden. Int Migr 44(2):153–180CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Klinthäll M (2007) Refugee return migration: return migration from Sweden to Chile, Iran and Poland 1973–1996. J Refug Stud 20(4):579–598CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Kuhn PJ, Riddell C (2010) The long-term effects of unemployment insurance: evidence from New Brunswick and Maine, 1940–1991. Ind Labor Relat Rev 63:183–204CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Li PS (2003) Initial earnings and catch-up capacity of immigrants. Can Public Policy / Anal Polit 29(3):319–337CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Lubotsky D (2007) Chutes or ladders? A longitudinal analysis of immigrant earnings. J Polit Econ 115:820–867CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Maron N, Connell J (2008) Back to Nukunuku: employment, identity and return migration in Tonga. Asia Pac Viewpoint 49(2):168–184CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Masferrer C, Roberts BR (2012) Going back home? Changing demography and geography of Mexican return migration. Popul Res Policy Rev 31(4):465–496CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Massey D, Malone N (2002) Pathways to legal immigration. Popul Res Policy Rev 21(6):473–504CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Mattoo A, Meagu IC, Ozden C (2008) Brain waste? Educated immigrants in the US labor market. J Dev Econ 87(2):255–269CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. McDonald JT, Warman C, Worswick C (2012) Immigrant selection systems and occupational outcomes of international medical graduates in Canada and the United States (SEDAP Research Paper 293). Social and Economic Dimensions of an Aging Population, Hamilton, Retrieved June 10, 2014, from http://socserv.mcmaster.ca/sedap/p/sedap293.pdf Google Scholar
  50. Mincer J (1962). “Labor-force participation of married women: a study of labor supply”. In: H. Gregg Lewis (ed.) Aspects of labor economics. Princeton NJ, Princeton University PressGoogle Scholar
  51. National Research Council. (2009). Reengineering the Survey of income and program participation. Panel on the Census Bureau’s Reengineered Survey of Income and Program Participation, Constance F. Citro and John Karl Scholz, Editors. Committee on National Statistics, Division of Behavioral and Social Sciences and Education. Washington, DC: The National Academies PressGoogle Scholar
  52. Neumark D, Salas JMI, Wascher W (2014) Revisiting the minimum wage—employment debate: Throwing out the baby with the bathwater?. Ind Labor Relat Rev 67(3):608–648Google Scholar
  53. O’Connor JS, Orloff AS, Shaver S (1999) States, markets, families: gender, liberalism and social policy in Australia, Canada, Great Britain and the United States. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Pandey M, Townsend J (2011) Quantifying the effects of the provincial nominee programs. Can Public Policy 37(4):495–512CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Passel J, Cohn D (2012a) Unauthorized immigrants: 11.1 million in 2011. Pew Research Center’s Hispanic Trends Project, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  56. Passel J, Cohn D (2012b) U.S. foreign-born population: how much change from 2009 to 2010? Pew Research Center’s Hispanic Trends Project, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  57. Picot G, Piraino P (2013) Immigrant earnings growth: selection bias or real progress? Can J Econ 46(4):1510–1536CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Reitz JG (2001) Immigrant skill utilization in the Canadian labour market: implications of human capital research. J Int Migr Integr / Rev Integr Migr Int 2(3):347–378CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Schoeni RF (1998) Labor market assimilation of immigrant women. Ind Labor Relat Rev 51(3):483–504CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Statistics Canada (2011) Immigration and ethnocultural diversity in Canada. Retrieved: http://www12.statcan.gc.ca/nhs-enm/2011/as-sa/99-010-x/99-010-x2011001-eng.pdf
  61. Statistics Canada (2012) Survey of Labour and Income Dynamics (SLID)—a survey overview. Document 75F0011X. Retrieved: http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/75f0011x/75f0011x2013001-eng.htm
  62. Sweetman A, Warman C (2010) How far does the points system stretch? The spouses of skilled worker principal applicants”. In: McDonald T, Ruddick E, Sweetman A, Worswick C (eds) Canadian immigration: economic evidence for a dynamic policy environment. McGill-Queen’s University Press, Kingston, pp 183–207Google Scholar
  63. U.S. Department of Homeland Security (2013) Yearbook of immigration statistics: 2012. Washington, D.C. Retrieved from: http://www.dhs.gov/publication/yearbook-2012
  64. U.S. Department of Homeland Security (2014) Yearbook of immigration statistics. Washington, D.C. Retrieved from: https://www.dhs.gov/yearbook-immigration-statistics
  65. U.S. Department of Labor (2013) State unemployment insurance benefits. Washington, D.C. Retrieved from: http://workforcesecurity.doleta.gov/unemploy/uifactsheet.asp
  66. Wald S, Fang T (2008) Overeducated immigrants in the Canadian labour market: evidence from the workplace and employee survey. Can Public Policy 34(4):457–480CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Warman C (2007) Ethnic enclaves and immigrant earnings growth. Can J Econ 40(2):401–422CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Warman CR, Worswick C (2004) Immigrant earnings performance in Canadian cities: 1981 through 2001. Can J Urban Res 13(1):62–84Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2016

Authors and Affiliations

  • Neeraj Kaushal
    • 1
  • Yao Lu
    • 2
  • Nicole Denier
    • 3
  • Julia Shu-Huah Wang
    • 1
    • 4
  • Stephen J. Trejo
    • 5
  1. 1.School of Social WorkColumbia UniversityNew YorkUSA
  2. 2.Department of SociologyColumbia UniversityNew YorkUSA
  3. 3.Department of SociologyMcGill UniversityMontrealCanada
  4. 4.Department of Social Work and Social AdministrationThe University of Hong KongPok Fu LamHong Kong
  5. 5.Department of EconomicsUniversity of TexasAustinUSA

Personalised recommendations