Journal of Population Economics

, Volume 28, Issue 2, pp 393–422 | Cite as

Can’t buy mommy’s love? Universal childcare and children’s long-term cognitive development

  • Christina Felfe
  • Natalia Nollenberger
  • Núria Rodríguez-Planas
Original Paper


What happens to children’s long-run cognitive development when introducing universal high-quality childcare for 3-year-olds mainly crowds out family care? To answer this question, we take advantage of a sizeable expansion of publicly subsidized full-time high-quality childcare for 3-year-olds in Spain in the early 1990s. Identification relies on variation in the initial speed of the expansion of childcare slots across states. Using a difference-in-difference approach, we find strong evidence for sizeable improvements in children’s reading skills at age 15 (0.15 standard deviation) and weak evidence for a reduction in grade retentions during primary school (2.5 percentage points). The effects are driven by girls and disadvantaged children.


Universal high-quality childcare Long-term consequences Cognitive skills 

JEL Classification

J13 I28 


  1. Adserà A (2004) Changing fertility rates in developed countries. The impact of labor market institutions. J Popul Econ 17(1):17–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Amuedo-Dorantes C, de la Rica S (2009) The timing of work and work-family conflicts in Spain: who has a split work schedule and why? IZA discussion paper 4542Google Scholar
  3. Baker M, Milligan K (2011) Maternity leave and children’s cognitive and behavioral development. NBER working paper 17105.Google Scholar
  4. Baker M, Gruber J, Milligan K (2008) Universal child care, maternal labor supply, and family well-being. J Polit Econ 116(4):709–745CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Bauchmüller R, Gørtz M, Würtz-Rasmussen A (2014) Long-run benefits from universal high-quality preschooling. Early Child Res Q 29(4):457–470.Google Scholar
  6. Berlinski S, Galiani S (2007) The effect of a large expansion in pre-primary school facilities on preschool attendance and maternal employment. Labour Econ 14(3):665–680CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Berlinski S, Galiani S, Manacorda M (2008) Giving children a better start: preschool attendance and school-age profiles. J Public Econ 92(5):1416–1440CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Berlinski S, Galiani S, Gertler P (2009) The effect of pre-primary education on primary school performance. J Public Econ 93(1–2):219–234CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Bettinger E, Haegeland T, Rege M (2013) Home with mom: the effects of stay-at-home parents on children’s long-run educational outcomes. CESifo working papers 4274Google Scholar
  10. Bettio F, Villa P (1998) A Mediterranean perspective on the breakdown of the relationship between participation and fertility. Cambridge J Econ 22(2):137–171CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Black S, Devereux P, Loken K, Salvanes K (2012) Care or cash? The effect of child care subsidies on student performance. NBER working paper 18086Google Scholar
  12. Blau D, Currie J (2006) Preschool, day care, and after school care: who's minding the kids? In: Hanushek E, Welsh F (eds) Handbook of economics of education vol 2. Amsterdam, North Holland Press, pp. 1163–278Google Scholar
  13. Carneiro P, Løken K, Salvanes K (2011) A flying start? Maternity leave benefits and long run outcomes of children. IZA discussion paper 5793Google Scholar
  14. Cascio E (2009) Do investments in universal early education pay off? Long-term effects of introducing into public schools. NBER working paper 14951Google Scholar
  15. Datta Gupta N, Simonsen M (2010) Non-cognitive child outcomes and universal high quality child care. J Public Econ 94(1–2):30–42CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Drange N, Havnes T, Sandsør A (2012) Kindergarten for all: long run effects of a universal intervention. Stat Norway DP 695Google Scholar
  17. Duflo E (2001) Schooling and labor market consequences of school construction in Indonesia: evidence from an unusual policy experiment. Am Econ Rev 91(4):795–813CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Dustmann C, Schöenberg U (2012) Expansions in maternity leave coverage on children long-term outcomes. Am Econ J Appl Econ 4(3):190–224CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Economist. Does subsidized preschool pay-off? 13 February 2013Google Scholar
  20. Economist, Fighting over the kinder. 17 August 2013Google Scholar
  21. El País, La LOGSE, 15 años después (by Elena Martín Ortega). 3 October 2005Google Scholar
  22. Felfe C, Lalive R (2012) Early child care and child development: for whom it works and why. IZA Discussion Papers 7100.Google Scholar
  23. Felgueroso F, Gutiérrez M, Jimenez S (2014) Why school dropout remained so high in the last two decades? The role of the educational law (LOGSE). IZA J Labor Policy 3:9, 9 May 2014CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Fernández-Kranz D, Rodríguez-Planas N (2011) The part-time penalty in a segmented labor market. Labour Econ 18(5):591–606CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Fitzpatrick M (2008) Starting school at four: the effect of universal pre-kindergarten on children’s academic achievement. BE J Econ Anal Poli 8(1):1–38Google Scholar
  26. Gathmann C, Saß B (2012) Taxing childcare: effects on family labor supply and children. IZA discussion paper 6640Google Scholar
  27. Gormley W Jr, Gayer T (2005) Promoting school readiness in Oklahoma. An evaluation of Tulsa’s pre-k program. J Hum Resour 3:533–558Google Scholar
  28. Gutierrez-Domenech M (2005) Employment transitions after motherhood in Spain. Labour 19:123–148CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Havnes T, Mogstad M (2011) No child left behind: subsidized child care and children’s long-run outcomes. Am Econ J Econ Policy 3:97–129CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Lenneberg, E (1964) The capacity of language acquisition. In: J Fodor and J Katz (eds) The structure of language. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, pp 579–603Google Scholar
  31. Liu Q, Oskar S (2010) The duration of paid parental leave and children’s scholastic performance. BE J Econ Anal Poli 10(1):1935–1682Google Scholar
  32. Loeb S, Bridges M, Bassok D, Fuller B, Rumberger R (2007) How much is too much? The influence of preschool centers on children’s social and cognitive development. Econ Educ Rev 26:52–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. LOGSE, Ley Orgánica 1, 1990 de Ordenación General del Sistema Educativo, 03.10.2013, BOE No. 238, 28927–28942Google Scholar
  34. Magnuson K, Ruhm C, Waldfogel J (2007) Does prekindergarten improve school preparation and performance? Econ Educ Rev 26(1):33–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Montessori M (1963) The secret of childhood. Ballentine Books, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  36. New York Times. German Lawmakers Spar Over Child Care Subsidy, by Melissa Eddy. 6 Jun 2012Google Scholar
  37. Nollenberger N, Rodríguez-Planas, N (2011) Child care, maternal employment and persistence: a natural experiment from Spain. IZA discussion paper 5888Google Scholar
  38. OECD (2006). PISA 2006 science competencies for tomorrow’s worldGoogle Scholar
  39. Rasmussen A (2010) Increasing the length of parents’ birth-related leave: the effect on children’s long-term educational outcomes. Labour Econ 17(1):91–100CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  • Christina Felfe
    • 1
    • 2
  • Natalia Nollenberger
    • 3
  • Núria Rodríguez-Planas
    • 4
    • 5
  1. 1.Universität St. GallenSt. GallenSwitzerland
  2. 2.CESifoMunichGermany
  3. 3.School of Business and ManagementQueen Mary University of LondonLondonUK
  4. 4.Queens CollegeCUNYQueensUSA
  5. 5.IZABonnGermany

Personalised recommendations