Skip to main content

On the effects of public and private transfers on capital accumulation: some lessons from the NTA aggregates

Abstract

Intergenerational transfers are a very important part of our daily economic activity. These transfers, whether familial or public, may influence our economic decisions to the same extent that financial markets do. In this paper, we seek to shed some light on the effects of transfers on capital accumulation in the face of demographic aging. In particular, a general equilibrium overlapping generations model with realistic public and familial transfers drawn from the National Transfer Accounts project is implemented to Spain. Given that, in this case, net familial transfers mainly go from parents to children while public transfers go from children to parents, it is shown that the Spanish baby boom and baby bust could lead to capital depletion and a reduction in consumption per capita.

This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.

Fig. 1
Fig. 2
Fig. 3
Fig. 4
Fig. 5

Notes

  1. The term demographic dividend has been used in economic demography literature, and it is full of economic meaning. The first dividend refers to the positive initial effect of a demographic transition on consumption per capita: the so called support ratio of workers to consumers increases in the first stages of the demographic transition (Bloom and Williamson 1998). This effect always occurs and is temporary—it disappears as those workers age. In contrast, the second demographic dividend, called capital deepening in economic terms, is not automatic and might be persistent.

  2. National Transfer Account database (NTA), http://www.ntaccounts.org.

  3. The calibration procedure is shown in Appendix A.1 in Supplementary material.

  4. As detailed in the demography section in the online material, we deviate from many of the available large-scale OLG models for Spain and other countries (Börsch-Supan et al. 2006) in that our economy is in steady state in 1870 rather than in 1960, capturing most of the Spanish demographic transition features.

  5. See Willis (1988) for a first attempt to include exogenous family transfers in the OLG framework. See also Lee (1994) for an application estimating the size of transfer and real wealth in the USA.

  6. This definition of life-cycle deficit differs from that of Kotlikoff and Summers (1981). Recall that, by estimating savings from lifetime income and (only) private consumption data, the authors indirectly measured the relevance of intergenerational transfers on capital accumulation; see Lee (1994).

  7. As NTA assumes the individual is the fundamental unit, net transfers received by firms from the government are also imputed to individuals.

  8. In an open economy, the sum of all private transfers is equal to the value of net transfers with the rest of the world.

  9. Current estimates of NTA profiles do not explicitly report bequests given. As a consequence, the ABR profile implicitly includes bequests received (h). This fact implies that if the amount of bequests is sizable, ABR will be higher than expected at younger ages.

  10. It should be noted from the definition of LCD that the NTA framework introduces public consumption explicitly into the flow budget constraint, as seen in Eq. 14 in Section 3.1.

  11. For the definition of T and K, we follow that of Willis (1988), Lee (1994), and Bommier and Lee (2003).

  12. Total wealth by an individual at age x equals the present value, survival weighted, of the stream of public and private consumption less gross labor income. Let the present value of consumption and gross labor income be denoted by \(\tilde{c}\) and \(\tilde{H}_x\). Then, the intertemporal budget constraint is given by the following:

    $$ w_x=\tilde{c}_x-\tilde{H}_x=a_x+t_x\Rightarrow \tilde{c}_x=\tilde{H}_x+a_x+t_x. $$
    (8)

    Thus, for \(\tilde{c}_x>(<)\tilde{H}_x+a_x\) it is necessary that t x  > ( < )0.

  13. An alternative approach could be to maximize the expected utility of the adult in the household (Tobin 1967; Deaton and Muellbauer 1980; Ríos-Rull 2001). To illustrate this point, let us assume the following standard household problem:

    $$ \begin{array}{rll} V_{x}(a_{x})&=&\max\limits_{c_{x}}\left\{u\left(c_{x}/\lambda_{x}\right)+\beta V_{x+1}(a_{x+1})\right\},\\ \text{s.t. }a_{x+1}&=&(1+r)a_{x}+{y_l}_{x}-c_{x}, \text{ for $x\in\{T_w,\dots,\Omega-1\}$}, \end{array} $$
    (9)

    where c x is now the total household consumption with a household head of age x.

    Assuming a logarithmic instantaneous utility function and substituting the flow budget constraint into the Bellman equation

    $$ V_{x}(a_{x})=\max\limits_{a_{x+1}}\left\{\log\left(\frac{(1+r)a_{x}-a_{x+1}+{y_l}_{x}}{\lambda_{x}}\right)+\beta V_{x+1}(a_{x+1})\right\}. $$
    (10)

    Differentiating with respect to a x + 1 and using the envelope theorem gives the Euler equation

    $$ c_{x+1}=c_x\beta(1+r). $$
    (11)

    Equation 11 implies that household saving does not change over the lifespan for a constant household labor income stream, even when the number of equivalent adult consumers in the household increases. However, a cross-country comparison of consumption profiles using NTA data suggests that adults smooth consumption at the individual level.

  14. In particular, the effect of credit rationing on the probability of giving transfers is analyzed as a way to discriminate between altruistic and strategic motives for giving transfers and the constitutional model.

  15. The specific formula applied to each transfer has been placed in Appendix A.1 in Supplementary material.

  16. Although the increase in public debt with respect to GDP in 2009 is expected to have an important impact in the short and medium run in interest rates, it is likely that a misleading progressive income tax will have a stronger effect in the long run on the accumulation of capital.

  17. This is a very interesting question that has been previously modeled for the Spanish case by Jimenez-Martin and Sanchez-Martin (2007) to analyze the effect that minimum pension benefits has on the optimal age of retirement or by Díaz-Giménez and Díaz-Saavedra (2009) to study how a change in the mandatory age of retirement affects the sustainability of the Spanish pension system.

  18. In fact, the total dependency ratio in Spain from the year 2000 to 2010 was the lowest of the last century.

  19. See Fig. A-7 in the Appendix of Supplementary material.

  20. Assuming a Cobb–Douglas production function with a capital share of α = .36, capital-to-output ratio values of 3.75 and 3.27 correspond to capital per effective units of labor values of 7.9 and 6.35, respectively, which are contained in the solid black line in Fig. 5.

  21. Assuming a Cobb–Douglas production function, the increase in labor productivity was calculated according to the formula:

    $$\log \frac{\omega_{t+T}}{\omega_{t}}=\log \frac{A_{t+T}}{A_{t}} +\alpha\log\frac{k_{t+T}}{ k_{t}}.$$

    Assuming that at time t + T, any variable X t + T can be expressed according to an initial value X t times a constant growth rate g X during T periods, then we find that the growth rate of salaries g w is equal to \(g_A+\alpha g_k\approx 1.26\mbox{\%}+0.36\cdot 0.93\mbox{\%}=1.59\mbox{\%}\), where the set {g A , g k } correspond to the growth rate of the labor-augmenting technological progress and the growth rate of effective units of capital, respectively.

  22. We have assumed that the observed employment rates by age in 2010 linearly improve to the values projected by the European Policy Committee in 2009.

References

  • Aassve A, Billari FC, Mazzuco S, Ongaro F (2002) Leaving home: a comparative analysis of ECHP data. J Eur Soc Policy 12(4):259–275

    Google Scholar 

  • Auerbach AJ, Gokhale J, Kotlikoff LJ (1991) Generational accounts: a meaningful alternative to deficit accounting. Tax Policy Econ 5:55–110

    Google Scholar 

  • Bixby LR, Robles A (2008) Los dividendos demográficos y la economía del ciclo vital en Costa Rica. Papeles Poblac 14(55):9–34

    Google Scholar 

  • Bloom DE, Williamson JG (1998) Demographic transitions and economic miracles in emerging Asia. World Bank Econ Rev 12(3):419–455

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Bommier A, Lee RD (2003) Overlapping generations models with realistic demography J Popul Econ 16(1):135–160

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Börsch-Supan A, Ludwig A, Winter J (2006) Ageing, pension reform and capital flows: a multi-country simulation model. Economica 73(292):625–658

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Braun AR, Ikeda D, Joines DH (2009) The saving rate in Japan: why it has fallen and why it will remain low. Int Econ Rev 50(1):291–321

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Cigno A (1993) Intergenerational transfers without altruism: family, market and state. Eur J Polit Econ 9(4):505–518

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Cigno A, Luporini A (2006) Optimal policy towards families with different amounts of social capital, in the presence of asymmetric information and stochastic fertility. CESIFO Work Pap (1664)

  • Cigno A, Giannelli GC, Rosati FC, Vuri D (2006) Is there such a thing as a family constitution? A test based on credit rationing. Rev Econ Househ 4(3):183–204

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • d’Albis H (2007) Demographic structure and capital accumulation. J Econ Theory 132(1):411–434

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Deaton AS, Muellbauer J (1980) Economics and consumer behaviour. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge

    Book  Google Scholar 

  • Diamond PA (1965) National debt in a neoclassical growth model. Am Econ Rev 55(5):1126–1150

    Google Scholar 

  • Díaz-Giménez J, Díaz-Saavedra J (2009) Delaying retirement in Spain. Rev Econ Dyn 12:147–167

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Easterlin RA (1980) Birth and fortune: the impact of numbers on personal welfare. Basic Books, New York

    Google Scholar 

  • European Commission (DG ECFIN) and the European Policy Committee (AWG) (2009) 2009 ageing report: economic and budgetary projections for the EU-27 member states (2008–2060). Technical Report 2, European Commission

  • Gan L, Hurd M, McFadden D (2005) Individuals subjective survival curves. In: Wise D (ed) Analyses in the economics of aging. National Bureau of Economic Research Conference Report, The University of Chicago Press, pp 377–412

  • Gokhale J, Kotlikoff LJ, Sabelhaus J, Bosworth B, Haveman R (1996) Understanding the postwar decline in US saving: a cohort analysis. Brookings Pap Econ Act 1996(1):315–407

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Hassett KA, Hubbard RG (2002) Tax policy and business investment. In: Auerbach AJ, Feldstein M (eds) Handbook of public economics. Handbook of public economics, chap 20, vol 3, pp 1293–1343. Elsevier Science Publisher BV, New York

    Google Scholar 

  • Jimenez-Martin S, Sanchez-Martin AR (2007) An evaluation of the life cycle effects of minimum pensions on retirement behavior. J Appl Econ 22(5):923–950

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Judd KL (1998) Numerical methods in economics. Massachussetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachussetts

    Google Scholar 

  • Kotlikoff L, Summers L (1981) The role of intergenerational transfers in aggregate capital accumulation. J Polit Econ 89(2):706–732

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Lau S-HP (2009) Demographic structure and capital accumulation: a quantitative assesment. J Econ Dyn Control 33:554–567

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Lee RD (1994) Age structure, intergenerational transfer, and wealth: a new approach, with applications to the United States. J Hum Resour 29(4):1027–1063

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Lee RD, Mason A (2010) Some macroeconomic aspects of global population aging. Demogr 47-Supplement, S151–S172

    Google Scholar 

  • Lee RD, Mason A, Miller T (2000) Life cycle saving and the demographic transition: the case of Taiwan. Popul Dev Rev 26:194–219

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Mason A, Lee RD (2006) Reform and support systems for the elderly in developing countries: capturing the second demographic dividend. GENUS LXII(2):11–35

    Google Scholar 

  • Patxot C, Renteria E, Sanchez-Romero M, Souto G (2011) Integrated results for GA and NTA for Spain: some implications for the sustainability of welfare state. Moneda Credito 231:7–51

    Google Scholar 

  • Ríos-Rull J-V (2001) Population changes and capital accumulation: the aging of the baby boom. Adv Macroecon 1(1):Article 7

  • Rojas JA (2005) Life cycle earnings, cohort size effects and social security: a quantitative exploration. J Public Econ 89:465–485

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Samuelson PA (1958) An exact consumption-loan model of interest with or without the social contrivance of money. J Polit Econ 66:467–482

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Sanchez-Martin AR (2010) Endogenous retirement and public pension system reform in Spain. Econ Model 27(1):336–349

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Tobin J (1967) Life cycle saving and balanced growth. In: Fellner W et al (eds) Ten economic studies in the tradition of Irving fisher. Wiley, New York

    Google Scholar 

  • Willis RJ (1988) A theory of the equilibrium interest rate in an overlapping generations model: life cycles, institutions, and population growth. In: Lee R et al (eds) Economics of changingage distributions in developed countries. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 106–138

    Google Scholar 

  • Yaari M (1965) Uncertain lifetime, life insurance, and the theory of the consumer. Rev Econ Stud 5(3):304–317

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Acknowledgements

We are extremely thankful to Ronald D. Lee, Andrew Mason, Gretchen Donehower, David Reher, participants of various seminars/conferences, and two anonymous referees for giving us very useful comments, suggestions, and ideas. We have received helpful research assistance from Ignacio Moral and language editing from Miriam Hils Cosgrove. We are also grateful to the Center on Economics and Demography of Aging and the Department of Demography at UC Berkeley for their hospitality.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Miguel Sánchez-Romero.

Additional information

Responsible editor: Alessandro Cigno

This work received institutional support from the Spanish Science and Technology System (Projects No ECO2009-10003 and ECO2008-04997/ECON), the Catalan Government Science Network (Projects No SGR2009-600 and SGR2009-359 as well as from XREPP- Xarxa de referència en Economia i Política Públiques), the Fulbright Commission (reference 2007-0445), the European Science Foundation (09-ECRP-021), and the Max Planck Society.

Electronic Supplementary Material

Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.

(PDF 604 KB)

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Sánchez-Romero, M., Patxot, C., Rentería, E. et al. On the effects of public and private transfers on capital accumulation: some lessons from the NTA aggregates. J Popul Econ 26, 1409–1430 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00148-012-0422-z

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00148-012-0422-z

Keywords

  • Second demographic dividend
  • Transfers
  • Computable general equilibrium

JEL Classification

  • D58
  • J11
  • H53