Abstract
Background
The relationship between employment and improved mental health is well documented. However, no research has examined whether this relationship applies to poor single mothers. Given recent changes in the labor market where poor women are disproportionately employed in unstable jobs, the competing demands of work and childcare may operate to prevent poor women from reaping the mental health benefits of employment. Understanding these connections has become more salient not just for mental health epidemiology but for policies targeting employment and poverty.
Methods
This study draws on four waves of data from the Welfare Client Longitudinal Study. Generalized estimating equations are utilized to assess the role of current employment and employment continuity on the depression status of poor single mothers over time. Through a comparison of results drawn from a dichotomous categorization of current employment with results drawn from measures of employment continuity, this study is also able to assess whether it is employment per se or the characteristics of employment that matter.
Results
Overall, the results from this study suggest that current employment improves the mental health of many poor single mothers. However, the circumstances most likely to improve their mental health are full-time or stable, longer term employment.
Conclusions
The results from this study are of concern given that the lack of employment continuity is a growing trend in the U.S. labor market and poor women are disproportionately employed in these types of unstable jobs. These findings, thus, have wide-reaching implications for welfare policy as they provide an important and timely perspective in our understanding of the impact of the changing face of employment on poor women.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Kessler R, House J, Turner B (1987) Unemployment and health in a community sample. J Health Soc Behav 28(1):51–59
Gore S, Mangione TW (1983) Social roles, sex roles and psychological distress: additive and interactive models of sex differences. J Health Soc Behav 24(4):300–312
Kessler RC, McRae J, James A (1982) The effect of wives’ employment on the mental health of married men and women. Am Soc Rev 47(2):216–227
Matthews S, Power C (2002) Socio-economic gradients in psychological distress: a focus on women, social roles and work-home characteristics. Soc Sci Med 54:799–810
Dooley D, Fielding J, Levi L (1996) Health and unemployment. Annu Rev Public Health 17:449–465
Ross CE, Mirowsky J (1995) Does employment affect health? J Health Soc Behav 36:230–243
Warr P, Jackson P (1985) Factors influencing the psychological impact of prolonged unemployment and of re-employment. Psychol Med 15:795–807
Graetz B (1993) Health consequences of employment and unemployment: longitudinal evidence for young men and women. Soc Sci Med 36(6):715–724
Kessler RC et al (2003) The epidemiology of major depressive disorder: results from the national comorbidity survey replications (NCS-R). J Am Med Assoc 289(23):3095–3105
Claussen B, Bjorndal A, Hjort PF (1993) Health and re-employment in a two year follow up of long term unemployed. J Epidemiol Community Health 47:14–18
Claussen B (1999) Health and re-employment in a five-year follow-up of long-term unemployed. Scand J Public Health 2:94–100
Kessler R, Turner B, House J (1989) Unemployment, reemployment, and emotional functioning in a community sample. Am Soc Rev 54(4):648–657
Wanberg C (1997) Antecedents and outcomes of coping behaviors among unemployed and reemployed individuals. J Appl Psychol 82(5):731–744
Aneshensel CS, Frerichs RR, Clark VA (1981) Family roles and sex differences in depression. J Health Soc Behav 22:379–393
Gyamfi P, Brooks-Gunn J, Jackson A (2001) Associations between employment and financial and parental stress in low-income single black mothers. Women Health 32(1–2):119–135
Danziger SK, Carlson MJ, Henly JR (2001) Post-welfare employment and psychological well-being. Women Health 32(1–2):47–78
Ali J, Avison WR (1997) Employment transitions and psychological distress: the contrasting experiences of single and married mothers. J Health Soc Behav 38(4):345–362
Baker D, North K, Team AS (1999) Does employment improve the health of lone mothers? Soc Sci Med 49:121–131
Cleary PD, Mechanic D (1983) Sex differences in psychological distress among married people. J Health Soc Behav 24(2):111–121
Marchand A et al (2003) The moderating effect of alcohol intake on the relationship between work strains and psychological distress. J Stud Alcohol 64:419–427
Bardasi E, Francesconi M (2004) The impact of atypical employment on individual wellbeing: evidence from a panel of British workers. Soc Sci Med 58:1671–1688
Grzywacz JG, Dooley D (2003) “Good jobs” to “bad jobs”: replicated evidence of an employment continuum from two large surveys. Soc Sci Med 56:1749–1760
Dooley D, Prause J (2004) The social costs of underemployment: inadequate employment as disguised unemployment. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, p 274
Edin K, Lein L (1997) Making ends meet: how single mother survive welfare and low-wage work. Russell Sage Foundation, New York
Shipler DK (2004) The working poor: invisible in America. New York, Vintage Books, p 329
Warr PB (1987) Work, unemployment, and mental health. Oxford Science Publications, Oxford University Press, Clarendon Press, Oxford, p xiv, 361
Weisner C, Schmidt L (1995) The community epidemiology laboratory: studying alcohol problems in community and agency-based populations. Addiction 90:329–342
US General Accounting Office (1993) Drug use measurement: strengths, limitations, and recommendations for improvement. US General Accounting Office, Washington, DC
Caetano R, Weisner C (1995) The association between DSM-III-R alcohol dependence, psychological distress and drug use. Addiction 90(3):351–359
Caetano R (1991) Correlates of DSM-III-R alcohol dependence in treatment and general populations. Drug Alcohol Depend 28:225–239
Weisner C, Schmidt L (1993) Alcohol and drug problems among diverse health and social service populations. Am J Public Health 83(6):824–829
Weisner C, Schmidt L (1992) Gender disparities in treatment for alcohol problems. J Am Med Assoc 268(14):1872–1876
Hennekens CH, Buring JE (1987) Epidemiology in medicine. Little, Brown and Company, Boston, p 383
Odierna DH, Schmidt LA (2008) Lost and found: on the effects of failure to include hard-to-reach respondents in public health research. Am J Public Health. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2007.111138
Odierna DH (2006) Learning to see the invisible: marginalization, attrition, and health disparities in a study of welfare and substance use, in School of Public Health. University of California, Berkeley, p 211
Schmidt L et al (2007) Substance abuse and employment among welfare mothers: from welfare-to-work and back again? Subst Use Misuse 42(7):1069–1087
Zabkiewicz D, Schmidt L (2009) The mental health benefits of work among welfare recipients: do they apply to women with drinking problems? J Behav Health Serv Res 36(1):96–110
Callahan SR (1999) Understanding health-status barriers that hinder the transition from welfare to work. National Governors’ Association, Washington, DC
Rosen D et al (2003) Psychiatric disorders and substance dependence among unmarried low-income mothers. Health Soc Work 28(2):157–165
Zaslow MJ (2001) Maternal depressive symptoms and low literacy as potential barriers to employment in a sample of families receiving welfare: are there two-generational implications? In: Lennon MC et al (eds) Welfare, work, and well-being. The Haworth Medical Press, New York, pp 211–251
CalWORKS Project, Mental Health, Domestic Violence and Substance (2002) Abuse: need for and use of services among adult female TANF participants. California Institute for Mental Health, Sacramento
Jayakody R, Danziger S, Pollack H (2000) Welfare reform, substance use and mental health. J Health Politics Policy Law 25(4):623–652
Zedlewski SR (1999) Work activity and obstacles to work among TANF recipients. The Urban Institute, Washington, DC
Goodwin SN et al (2002) Alcohol & other drug, mental health, and domestic violence issues: effects on employment and welfare tenure after one year. California Institute for Mental Health, Sacramento
Danziger S et al (1999) Barriers to work among welfare recipients. Focus 20(2):31–35
Derogatis LR (1992) The brief symptom inventory (BSI) administration, scoring & procedures manual—II. Clinical Psychometric Research, Inc., Baltimore, pp 1–67
Morlan KK, Tan S-Y (1998) Comparison of the brief psychiatric rating scale and the brief symptom inventory. J Clin Psychol 547(7):885–894
Derogatis LR, Cleary P (1977) Confirmation of the dimensional structure of the SCL-90: a study in construct validation. J Clin Psychol 33(4):981–989
Broday S, Mason J (1991) Internal consistency of the brief symptom inventory for counseling-center clients. Psychol Rep 68:94
Guelzow MG, Bird GW, Koball EH (1991) An exploratory path analysis of the stress process for dual-career men and women. J Marriage Fam 53(1):151–164
Allen TD et al (2000) Consequences associated with work-to-family conflict: a review and agenda for future research. J Occup Health Psychol 5(2):278–308
Jackson AP (1997) Effects of concerns about child care among single, employed black mothers with preschool children. Am J Community Psychol 25(5):657–673
Siefert K et al (2000) Social and environmental predictors of maternal depression in current and recent welfare recipients. Am J Orthopsychiatr 70(4):510–522
Ross CE, Mirowsky J, Goldsteen K (1990) The impact of the family on health: the decade in review. J Marraige Fam 52(4):1059–1078
Mulvaney C, Kendrick D (2005) Depressive symptoms in mothers of pre-school children. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 40:202–208
Loprest P (1999) Families who left welfare: who are they and how are they doing?. The Urban Institute, Washington, DC
Jahoda M (1988) Economic recession and mental health: some conceptual issues. J Soc Issues 44(4):13–23
Jahoda M (1982) Employment and unemployment: a social-psychological analysis. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, p 112
Essex MJ et al (2006) Exploring risk factors for the emergence of children’s mental health problems. Arch Gen Psychiatry 63:1246–1256
Ford T et al (2007) A prospective study of childhood psychopathology: independent predictors of change over three years. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 42:953–961
Laracuenta M (2006) The relationship between parental depression and children’s depression in a Latino sample, in department of psychology. Pace University, New York
Marchand A et al (2003) Occupational variations in drinking and psychological distress: a multilevel analysis. Work 21:153–163
Zivot M, Jacobs L (2004) Welfare client longitudinal study: demographic changes in our study county, 1989–2001. Alcohol Research Group, Berkeley
Schmidt L, McCarty D (2000) Welfare reform and the changing landscape of substance abuse services for low-income women. Alcohol Clin Exp Res 24(8):1298–1311
Zabkiewicz D (2008) Do poor women reap the mental health benefits of work? Results from the 2000 National Alcohol Survey. Alcohol Research Group, Emeryville
Moffitt RA et al (2002) The characteristics of families remaining on welfare. Johns Hopkins University and Pennsylvania State University, pp 1–35
Dooley D, Catalano R, Wilson G (1994) Depression and unemployment: panel findings from the epidemiologic catchment area study. Am J Community Psychol 22(6):745–765
Saarijarvi S, Salminen JK, Toikka TB (2001) Alexithymia and depression: a 1-year follow-up study in outpatients with major depression. J Psychosom Res 51:729–733
Hale D, Cochran C (1992) Age differences in self-reported symptoms of psychological distress. J Clin Psychol 48(5):633–637
Acosta F, Nguyen L, Yamamoto J (1994) Using the brief symptom inventory to profile monolingual Spanish speaking psychiatric outpatients. J Clin Psychol 50(5):723–726
Ahluwalia SK et al (2001) Symptoms of depression among welfare recipients: a concern for two generations. Child Trends, Washington, DC, pp 1–5
Wells KB et al (1989) The functioning and well-being of depressed patients. J Am Med Assoc 262(7):914–919
Broadhead WE et al (1990) Depression, disability days, and days lost from work in a prospective epidemiologic survey. J Am Med Assoc 264(19):2524–2528
Piroth K, Schmidt L (1999) Welfare client longitudinal study, technical report #3: the validity of retrospective self-reports of welfare histories. Alcohol Research Group, Berkeley
Wiley J, Zabkiewicz D, Jacobs L (2003) Studying patterns of service use among welfare populations: an analysis of self-report and administrative records. In: American Public Health Association 131st annual meeting. San Francisco, CA
Wiley J, Zabkiewicz D, Schmidt L (2002) Comparisons between self-reports of aid receipt from timeline follow-back and administrative records. Alcohol Research Group, Berkeley
Stewart WF et al (2003) Cost of lost productive work time among us workers with depression. J Am Med Assoc 289(23):3135–3144
Ettner SL, Frank RG, Kessler RC (1997) The impact of psychiatric disorders on labor market outcomes. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, pp 1–38
Acknowledgments
This study was made possible by grants from the U.S. National Institutes on Health, National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism to the Alcohol Research Group, Public Health Institute, including: Center Grant (AA-05595), R01 Project Grant (AA-10015), R21 Grant for Secondary Analysis of Existing Health Services Data (AA-12159) and T32 Training Grant (AA-007240). The author is grateful to Laura Schmidt and Jim Wiley for their comments on earlier versions of this manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Zabkiewicz, D. The mental health benefits of work: do they apply to poor single mothers?. Soc Psychiat Epidemiol 45, 77–87 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-009-0044-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00127-009-0044-2