Insulin resistance and cortisol metabolism. Reply to Kerstens MN, Dullaart RPF [letter]
- 418 Downloads
KeywordsCortisol Glucocorticoid receptor Glucocorticoids Insulin resistance Insulin sensitivity Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease Obesity Salt resistance
homeostasis model assessment of insulin resistance
To the Editor:
We thank M. N. Kerstens and R. P. F. Dullaart for their interest in our paper . Our results show that there was an inverse relationship between cortisol clearance from the plasma and whole-body insulin sensitivity as measured by the hyperinsulinaemic–euglycaemic clamp in middle-aged men (mean age 53.0 years, mean BMI 32.0 kg/m2) . Importantly, we show that this relationship was independent of potential confounding factors such as body fat and fatty liver. These findings were contrary to our expectations and we agree that it is now crucial to undertake careful kinetic studies to study cortisol production (and excretion) in more detail to determine specifically whether cortisol production is increased. We agree that by measuring urinary free cortisol we have only assessed a small fraction of all urinary cortisol metabolites. It is possible that there is increased renal loss of cortisol with insulin resistance that we have not detected.
We appreciate that we have not assessed salt resistance in our subjects, but there is no consensus as to whether salt loading worsens, improves, or has no effect on insulin sensitivity [3, 4, 5, 6]. Kerstens et al.  studied cortisol metabolism, insulin sensitivity (according to homeostasis model assessment of insulin resistance [HOMA-IR]) and renal haemodynamics in 19 salt-resistant and nine salt-sensitive normotensive subjects after a low- and high-salt diet. Although in their letter  Kerstens and Dullaart pass comment on their observation of a significant positive relationship between percentage change in HOMA-IR and percentage change in plasma cortisol during salt loading  (at variance with our findings), it should be noted that in the same study  they also describe a significant inverse relationship between percentage change in HOMA-IR and percentage change in the sum of urinary metabolites (in keeping with our findings). Moreover, the authors studied young men and women (mean age 24 years) who were lean (mean BMI 22 kg/m2). In contrast, we studied middle-aged men only and our volunteers were predominantly obese. The relationships between cortisol metabolism and insulin sensitivity may differ in insulin-resistant, obese individuals and insulin-sensitive, thin individuals. It is also plausible that ageing affects the relationship between cortisol metabolism and insulin sensitivity.
There are many factors that may potentially confound a relationship between aspects of cortisol metabolism and insulin sensitivity, such as body fat percentage, fat distribution or fatty liver status. We have adjusted for these confounders in the regression analyses. Kerstens et al.  did not comment on confounding by these or other factors.
We have recently shown that in fasting plasma samples (collected at 09:00 hours), cortisol was decreased in South Asians with features of the metabolic syndrome compared with white northern Europeans living in the UK, despite both groups having similar BMIs (BMI 25.6 kg/m2 for both groups) . This finding is in keeping with the original description by Bjorntorp  of a flat, rigid day curve for plasma cortisol, with poor feedback control in insulin-resistant individuals with abdominal obesity, increased leptin levels, hyperglycaemia, dyslipidaemia and hypertension. Moreover, there is increased skeletal muscle glucocorticoid receptor expression with obesity and features of the metabolic syndrome [10, 11]. Thus, in insulin-resistant, obese individuals it is plausible that the flat, rigid day curve with decreased morning cortisol concentrations may represent increased tissue cortisol clearance. If there is increased tissue cortisol uptake and increased tissue glucocorticoid receptor expression in key insulin-sensitive tissues, then it is possible that a Cushing’s syndrome phenotype or metabolic syndrome phenotype could result.
In conclusion, we concur with Kerstens and Dullart that more research is needed to carefully delineate cortisol biosynthesis and clearance pathways. We consider that these studies are needed, particularly in relation to insulin sensitivity, non-alcoholic fatty liver disease and the metabolic syndrome phenotype in different ethnic groups.
Duality of interest
The authors declare that there is no duality of interest associated with this manuscript.
- 6.Townsend RR, Kapoor S, McFadden CB (2007) Salt intake and insulin sensitivity in healthy human volunteers. Clin Sci (Lond) (DOI 10.1042/CS20060361 [Epub ahead of print])