Aquatic Sciences

, Volume 73, Issue 2, pp 289–304 | Cite as

“Dead Zone” dynamics in Lake Erie: the importance of weather and sampling intensity for calculated hypolimnetic oxygen depletion rates

  • Joseph D. ConroyEmail author
  • Leon Boegman
  • Hongyan Zhang
  • William J. Edwards
  • David A. Culver
Research Article


Calculated hypolimnetic oxygen depletion (HOD) rates depend not only on environmental factors but also logistical ones. In particular, lack of understanding of the effects of weather in addition to how sampling effort determines calculated HOD rates complicates ecological understanding and environmental management of lake ecosystems. To better determine the roles of weather and sampling effort, we combined (1) weekly measurements of temperature and dissolved oxygen (DO) concentrations from seven stations in the Sandusky subbasin of Lake Erie’s central basin during 2005, (2) contemporaneous measures of storm activity and tributary discharge, and (3) a two-dimensional coupled hydrodynamic, chemical, and biological model of Lake Erie to investigate (1) how increased storm activity and tributary discharge affected short- (daily) and long-term (seasonal) dynamics of hypolimnetic hypoxia, and (2) how spatial (number of sites sampled) and temporal (sampling frequency) sampling effort affected calculated HOD rates. Our model closely replicated field-observed DO dynamics. When comparing baseline modeled dynamics to those in a second simulation with twice the number of days with high winds, however, we found that with more storm activity (1) periods of entrainment became more frequent, (2) the hypolimnion was warmer, (3) thermal stratification occurred 1 month later, whereas autumnal turnover occurred at least 1 week earlier shortening the duration of stratification by 1–2 months, and (4) HOD rates increased 12%. Further, spatial and temporal sampling intensity also affected calculated HOD rates. Consequently, adequately quantifying actual HOD rates requires sufficient sampling effort and the particular role of weather should be assessed with rigorous field and simulation studies, especially if HOD rates are used to indicate management success.


Storm-induced mixing Hypoxia Anoxia CE-QUAL-W2 



Collection of field data was supported by the Ohio Lake Erie Protection Fund (project 04-16), Franz Theodore Stone Laboratory, and the Ohio Sea Grant College Program; initial adaptation of CE-QUAL-W2 to Lake Erie was supported by the Ohio Sea Grant College Program (project R/EM 20); and, the addition of more detailed phytoplankton groups, zooplankton, and zebra mussels was supported by the Ohio Lake Erie Protection Fund (project 98-17). Ohio Lake Erie Protection Fund projects were administered by the Ohio Lake Erie Commission. Further field data collection for model parameterization and a portion of the time of J.D.C. was supported by the Ohio Division of Wildlife, Department of Natural Resources as part of the Federal Aid in Sport Fish Restoration Program (F-69-P, Sport Fish Management in Ohio) administered jointly by the United States Fish and Wildlife Service and the Division of Wildlife. Ram Yerubandi, Environment Canada, provided the thermistor chain data. M.A. Thomas, D.D. Kane, E.L. Quinlan, M. Beam, M. DuFour, and S. Percival were instrumental in assisting with field data collection. Comments provided by Doran Mason, Libby Jewett, Josef Ackerman and seven additional reviewers improved the quality of our manuscript.


  1. Beeton AM (1965) Eutrophication of the St. Lawrence Great Lakes. Limnol Oceanogr 10:240–254CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Boegman L (2006) A model of the stratification and hypoxia in central Lake Erie. In: Ivey GN (ed) Proceedings of the 6th international symposium on stratified flows, University of Western Australia, pp 608–613Google Scholar
  3. Boegman L, Loewen MR, Hamblin PF, Culver DA (2001) Application of a two-dimensional hydrodynamic reservoir model to Lake Erie. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 58:858–869CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Boegman L, Loewen MR, Culver DA, Hamblin PF, Charlton MN (2008a) Spatial-dynamic modeling of algal biomass in Lake Erie: relative impacts of zebra mussels and nutrient loading. J Environ Eng 134:456–468CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Boegman L, Loewen MR, Hamblin PF, Culver DA (2008b) Vertical mixing and weak stratification over zebra mussel colonies in western Lake Erie. Limnol Oceanogr 53:1093–1110CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bolsenga SJ, Herdendorf CE (1993) Lake Erie and Lake St. Clair handbook. Wayne State University, DetroitGoogle Scholar
  7. Bridgeman TB, Schloesser DW, Krause AE (2006) Recruitment of Hexagenia mayfly nymphs in western Lake Erie linked to environmental variability. Ecol Appl 16:601–611PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Burns NM (1976) Oxygen depletion in the central and eastern basins of Lake Erie, 1970. J Fish Res Board Can 33:512–519CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Burns NM, Ross C (eds) (1972) Project Hypo: an intensive study of the Lake Erie central basin hypolimnion and related surface water phenomena. Canada Centre for Inland Waters Paper No. 6, and United States Environmental Protection Agency Technical Report TS-05-71-208-24. Information Canada and United States Environmental Protection AgencyGoogle Scholar
  10. Burns NM, Rockwell DC, Bertram PE, Dolan DM, Ciborowski JJH (2005) Trends in temperature, Secchi depth, and dissolved oxygen depletion rates in the central basin of Lake Erie, 1983–2002. J Great Lakes Res 31(Suppl. 2):35–49CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Charlton MN (1980a) Oxygen depletion in Lake Erie: has there been any change? Can J Fish Aquat Sci 37:72–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Charlton MN (1980b) Hypolimnion oxygen consumption in lakes: discussion of productivity and morphometry effects. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 37:1531–1539CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Charlton MN (1987) Lake Erie oxygen revisited. J Great Lakes Res 13:697–708CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Charlton MN, Milne JE (2004) Review of thirty years of change in Lake Erie water quality. National Water Research Institute Contribution No. 04-167Google Scholar
  15. Charlton MN, Milne JE, Booth WG, Chiocchio F (1993) Lake Erie offshore in 1990: restoration and resilience in the Central Basin. J Great Lakes Res 19:291–309CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Conroy JD (2007) Testing the algal loading hypothesis: the importance of Sandusky River phytoplankton inputs to offshore Lake Erie processes. Ph.D. dissertation, The Ohio State UniversityGoogle Scholar
  17. Conroy JD, Culver DA (2005) Do dreissenids affect Lake Erie ecosystem stability processes? Am Midl Nat 153:20–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Conroy JD, Edwards WJ, Pontius RA, Kane DD, Zhang H, Shea JF, Richey JN, Culver DA (2005a) Soluble nitrogen and phosphorus excretion of exotic freshwater mussels (Dreissena spp.): potential impacts for nutrient remineralisation in western Lake Erie. Freshw Biol 50:1146–1162CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Conroy JD, Kane DD, Dolan DM, Edwards WJ, Charlton MN, Culver DA (2005b) Temporal trends in Lake Erie plankton biomass: roles of external phosphorus loading and dreissenid mussels. J Great Lakes Res 31(Suppl. 2):89–110CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Conroy JD, Kane DD, Culver DA (2008) Declining Lake Erie ecosystem health: evidence from a multi-year, lake-wide plankton study. In: Munawar M, Heath R (eds) Checking the pulse of Lake Erie, Ecovision World Monograph Series, Aquatic Ecosystem Health and Management Society, pp 369–408Google Scholar
  21. Delorme LD (1982) Lake Erie oxygen; the prehistoric record. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 39:1021–1029CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. DePinto JV, Young TC, McIlroy LM (1986) Great Lakes water quality improvement. Environ Sci Technol 20:752–759CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Diaz RJ, Rosenberg R (2008) Spreading dead zones and consequences for marine ecosystems. Science 321:926–929PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Dobson HH, Gilbertson M (1971) Oxygen depletion in the hypolimnion of the central basin of Lake Erie, 1929–1970. In: Proceedings of the conference on Great Lakes Research, vol 14, pp 743–748Google Scholar
  25. Dolan D (1993) Point source loading of phosphorus to Lake Erie: 1986–1990. J Great Lakes Res 19:212–223CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Dolan DM, McGunagle KP (2005) Lake Erie total phosphorus loading analysis and update: 1996–2002. J Great Lakes Res 31(Suppl. 2):11–22CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Edwards WJ, Conroy JD, Culver DA (2005a) Hypolimnetic oxygen depletion dynamics in the central basin of Lake Erie. J Great Lakes Res 31(Suppl. 2):262–271CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Edwards WJ, Rehmann CR, McDonald E, Culver DA (2005b) The impact of a benthic filter feeder: limitations imposed by physical transport of algae to the benthos. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 62:205–214CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Fish CJ (1960) Limnological survey of eastern and central Lake Erie 1928–1929. United States Fish and Wildlife Service, Special Scientific Report—Fisheries, No. 334Google Scholar
  30. Harris GP, Vollenweider RA (1982) Paleolimnological evidence of early eutrophication in Lake Erie. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 39:618–626CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Hawley N, Johengen TH, Rao YR, Ruberg SA, Beletsky D, Ludsin SA, Eadie BJ, Schwab DJ, Croley TE, Brandt SB (2006) Lake Erie hypoxia prompts Canada–U.S. study. Eos Trans 87:313–324CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. IJC (International Joint Commission) (1987). Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement of 1978, Revised, signed in Ottawa, Canada, 18 November 1987. IJC, United States and CanadaGoogle Scholar
  33. Ivey GN, Boyce FM (1982) Entrainment by bottom currents in Lake Erie. Limnol Oceanogr 27:1029–1038CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Lam DC, Schertzer WM, Fraser AS (1983) Simulation of Lake Erie water quality responses to loading and weather variations. National Water Research Institute, Inland Waters Directorate, Canada Center for Inland Waters, Scientific Series, No. 134Google Scholar
  35. Lam DC, Schertzer WM, Fraser AS (1987) Oxygen depletion in Lake Erie: modeling the physical, chemical, and biological interactions, 1972 and 1979. J Great Lakes Res 13:770–781CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Loewen MR, Ackerman JD, Hamblin PF (2007) Environmental implications of stratification and turbulent mixing in a shallow lake basin. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 64:43–57CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Matzinger A, Müller B, Niederhauser P, Schmid M, Wüest A (2010) Hypolimnetic oxygen consumption by sediment-based reduced substances in former eutrophic lakes. Limnol Oceanogr 55:2073–2084CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Munawar M, Munawar IF (1976) A lakewide study of phytoplankton biomass and its species composition in Lake Erie, April–December 1970. J Fish Res Board Can 33:581–600CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Patterson JC, Allanson BR, Ivey GN (1985) A dissolved oxygen budget for Lake Erie in summer. Freshw Biol 15:683–694CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Rabalais NN, Turner RE, Wiseman WJ (2002) Gulf of Mexico hypoxia, A.K.A. “The Dead Zone”. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 33:235–263CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Rao YR, Hawley N, Charlton MN, Schertzer WM (2008) Physical processes and hypoxia in the central basin of Lake Erie. Limnol Oceanogr 53:2007–2020CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Reynoldson TB, Hamilton AL (1993) Historic changes in populations of burrowing mayflies (Hexagenia limbata) from Lake Erie based on sediment tusk profiles. J Great Lakes Res 19:250–257CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Rosa F, Burns NM (1987) Lake Erie central basin oxygen depletion changes from 1929–1980. J Great Lakes Res 13:684–696CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Sly PG (1976) Lake Erie and its basin. J Fish Res Board Can 33:355–370CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Vanni MJ, Headworth JL (2004) Cross-habitat transport of nutrients by omnivorous fish along a productivity gradient: integrating watersheds and reservoir food webs. In: Polis GA, Power ME, Huxel GR (eds) Food webs at the landscape level. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 43–61Google Scholar
  46. Wüest A, Piepke G, Van Senden DC (2000) Turbulent kinetic energy balance as a tool for estimating vertical diffusivity in wind-forced stratified waters. Limnol Oceanogr 45:1388–1400CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Zhang H, Culver DA, Boegman L (2008) A two-dimensional ecological model of Lake Erie: application to estimate dreissenid impacts on large lake plankton populations. Ecol Model 214:219–241CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Basel AG 2010

Authors and Affiliations

  • Joseph D. Conroy
    • 1
    • 6
    Email author
  • Leon Boegman
    • 2
  • Hongyan Zhang
    • 3
  • William J. Edwards
    • 4
  • David A. Culver
    • 5
  1. 1.Aquatic Ecology Laboratory, Department of Evolution, Ecology, and Organismal BiologyThe Ohio State UniversityColumbusUSA
  2. 2.Department of Civil EngineeringQueen’s UniversityKingstonCanada
  3. 3.Cooperative Institute for Limnology and Ecosystems ResearchUniversity of MichiganAnn ArborUSA
  4. 4.Department of BiologyNiagara UniversityLewistonUSA
  5. 5.Department of Evolution, Ecology, and Organismal BiologyThe Ohio State UniversityColumbusUSA
  6. 6.Inland Fisheries Research Unit, Division of WildlifeOhio Department of Natural ResourcesHebronUSA

Personalised recommendations