Abstract
Structural symmetry is observed in the majority of fundamental protein folds and gene duplication and fusion evolutionary processes are postulated to be responsible. However, convergent evolution leading to structural symmetry has also been proposed; additionally, there is debate regarding the extent to which exact primary structure symmetry is compatible with efficient protein folding. Issues of symmetry in protein evolution directly impact strategies for de novo protein design as symmetry can substantially simplify the design process. Additionally, when considering gene duplication and fusion in protein evolution, there are two competing models: “emergent architecture” and “conserved architecture”. Recent experimental work has shed light on both the evolutionary process leading to symmetric protein folds as well as the ability of symmetric primary structure to efficiently fold. Such studies largely support a “conserved architecture” evolutionary model, suggesting that complex protein architecture was an early evolutionary achievement involving oligomerization of smaller polypeptides.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Harrison PM, Kumar A, Lang N, Snyder M, Gerstein M (2002) A question of size: the eukaryotic proteome and problems in defining it. Nucleic Acids Res 30:1083–1090
Schad E, Tompa P, Hegyi H (2011) The relationship between proteome size, structural disorder and organism complexity. Genome Biol 12:R120
Thornton JM, Orengo CA, Todd AE, Pearl FM (1999) Protein folds, functions and evolution. J Mol Biol 293(2):333–342
McLachlan AD (1972) Gene duplication in carp muscle calcium binding protein. Nat New Biol 240(98):83–85
McLachlan AD (1976) Evidence for gene duplication in collagen. J Mol Biol 107(2):159–174
McLachlan AD, Walker JE (1977) Evolution of serum albumin. J Mol Biol 112(4):543–558
Tang J, James MN, Hsu IN, Jenkins JA, Blundell TL (1978) Structural evidence for gene duplication in the evolution of the acid proteases. Nature 271:618–621
McLachlan AD (1979) Three-fold structural pattern in the soybean trypsin inhibitor (Kunitz). J Mol Biol 133:557–563
McLachlan AD (1979) Gene duplications in the structural evolution of chymotrypsin. J Mol Biol 128:49–79
McLachlan AD (1980) Repeated structure and possible gene duplications in high potential iron protein and rubredoxin. J Mol Evol 15(4):309–315
Lang D, Thoma R, Henn-Sax M, Sterner R, Wilmanns M (2000) Structural evidence for evolution of the beta/alpha barrel scaffold by gene duplication and fusion. Science 289(5484):1546–1550
Hocker B, Schmidt S, Sterner R (2002) A common evolutionary origin of two elementary enzyme folds. FEBS Lett 510(3):133–135
Soding J, Lupas AN (2003) More than the sum of their parts: on the evolution of proteins from peptides. Bioessays 25:837–846
Carvalho AL, Dias FM, Prates JA, Nagy T, Gilbert HJ, Davies GJ, Ferreira LM, Romão MJ, Fontes CM (2003) Cellulosome assembly revealed by the crystal structure of the cohesin-dockerin complex. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 100:13809–13814
Jeltsch A (1999) Circular permutations the molecular evolution of DNA methyltransferases. J Mol Evol 49:161–164
Peisajovich SG, Rockah L, Tawfik DS (2006) Evolution of new protein topologies through multistep gene rearrangements. Nat Genet 38:168–174
Bjorklund AK, Ekman D, Elofsson A (2006) Expansion of protein domain repeats. PLoS One 2:959–969
Nacher JC, Hayashida M, Akutsu T (2010) The role of internal duplication in the evolution of multi-domain proteins. Biosystems 101:127–135
Zhang J (2003) Evolution by gene duplication: an update. Trends Ecol Evol 18:292–298
Wright CF, Teichmann SA, Clarke J, Dobson CM (2005) The importance of sequence diversity in the aggregation and evolution of proteins. Nature 438:878–881
Yadid I, Tawfik DS (2011) Functional β-propeller lectins by tandem duplications of repetitive units. Prot Eng Des Sel 24(1–2):185–195
Borgia MB, Borgia A, Best RB, Steward A, Nettels D, Wunderlich BS, Schuler B, Clarke J (2011) Single-molecule fluorescence reveals sequence-specific misfolding in multidomain proteins. Nature 474:662–665
Mukhopadhyay D (2000) The molecular evolutionary history of a winged bean α-chymotrypsin inhibitor and modeling of its mutations through structural analysis. J Mol Evol 50:214–223
Ponting CP, Russell RB (2000) Identification of distant homologues of fibroblast growth factors suggests a common ancestor for all beta-trefoil proteins. J Mol Biol 302:1041–1047
Liu L, Iwata K, Yohda M, Miki K (2002) Structural insight into gene duplication, gene fusion and domain swapping in the evolution of PLP-independent amino acid racemases. FEBS Lett 528:114–118
Yadid I, Tawfik DS (2007) Reconstruction of functional β-propeller lectins via homo-oligomeric assembly of shorter fragments. J Mol Biol 365:10–17
Akanuma S, Matsuba T, Ueno E, Umeda N, Yamagishi A (2010) Mimicking the evolution of a thermally stable monomeric four-helix bundle by fusion of four identical single-helix peptides. J Biochem 147:371–379
Richter M, Bosnali M, Carstensen L, Seitz T, Durchschlag H, Blanquart S, Merkl R, Sterner R (2010) Computational and experimental evidence for the evolution of a (βα)8-barrel protein from an ancestral quarter-barrel stabilized by disulfide bonds. J Mol Biol 398:763–773
Lee J, Blaber M (2011) Experimental support for the evolution of symmetric protein architecture from a simple peptide motif. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 108:126–130
Yadid I, Kirshenbaum N, Sharon M, Dym O, Tawfik DS (2010) Metamorphic proteins mediate evolutionary transitions of structure. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 107:7287–7292
Banner DW, Bloomer A, Petsko GA, Phillips DC, Wilson IA (1976) Atomic coordinates for triose phosphate isomerase from chicken. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 72(1):146–155
Lesk AM, Branden CL, Chothia C (1989) Structural principles of alpha/beta barrel proteins: the packing of the interior of the sheet. Proteins 5(2):139–148
Reardon D, Farber GK (1995) The structure and evolution of α/β barrel proteins. FASEB J 9:497–503
Luger K, Hommel U, Herold M, Hofsteenge J, Kirschner K (1989) Correct folding of circularly permuted variants of a βα barrel enzyme in vivo. Science 243:206–210
Eder J, Kirschner K (1992) Stable substructures of eightfold βα-barrel proteins: fragment complementation of phosphoribosylanthranilate isomerase. Biochemistry 31:3617–3625
Henn-Sax M, Hocker B, Wilmanns M, Sterner R (2001) Divergent evolution of (βα)8-barrel enzymes. Biol Chem 382:1315–1320
Seitz T, Bocola M, Claren J, Sterner R (2007) Stabilization of a (beta-alpha)8-barrel protein designed from identical half barrels. J Mol Biol 372:114–129
Akanuma S, Yamagishi A (2008) Experimental evidence for the existence of a stable half-barrel subdomain in the (β/α)8-barrel fold. J Molec Biol 382:458–466
Blow DM, Janin J, Sweet RM (1974) Mode of action of soybean trypsin inhibitor (Kunitz) as a model for specific protein–protein interactions. Nature 249:54–57
Sweet RM, Wright HT, Janin J, Chothia CH, Blow DM (1974) Crystal structure of the complex of porcine trypsin with soybean trypsin inhibitor (Kunitz) at 2.6 angstrom resolution. Biochemistry 13:4212–4228
Rutenber E, Ready M, Robertus JD (1987) Structure and evolution of ricin B chain. Nature 326:624–626
Feng J, Li M, Huang Y, Xiao Y (2010) Symmetric key structural residues in symmetric proteins with beta-trefoil fold. PLoS One 5:e14138. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0014138
Brych SR, Blaber SI, Logan TM, Blaber M (2001) Structure and stability effects of mutations designed to increase the primary sequence symmetry within the core region of a β-trefoil. Protein Sci 10:2587–2599
Brych SR, Kim J, Logan TM, Blaber M (2003) Accommodation of a highly symmetric core within a symmetric protein superfold. Protein Sci 12:2704–2718
Brych SR, Dubey VK, Bienkiewicz E, Lee J, Logan TM, Blaber M (2004) Symmetric primary and tertiary structure mutations within a symmetric superfold: a solution, not a constraint, to achieve a foldable polypeptide. J Mol Biol 344(3):769–780
Dubey VK, Lee J, Blaber M (2005) Redesigning symmetry-related “mini-core” regions of FGF-1 to increase primary structure symmetry: thermodynamic and functional consequences of structural symmetry. Protein Sci Publ Protein Soc 14(9):2315–2323
Lee J, Blaber SI, Dubey VK, Blaber M (2011) A polypeptide “building block” for the β-trefoil fold identified by “top-down symmetric deconstruction”. J Mol Biol 407:744–763
Broom A, Doxey AC, Lobsanov YD, Berthin LG, Rose DR, Howell PL, McConkey BJ, Meiering EM (2012) Modular evolution and the origins of symmetry: reconstruction of a three-fold symmetric globular protein. Structure 20:1–11
Murzin AG, Lesk AM, Chothia C (1992) β-Trefoil fold. Patterns of structure and sequence in the Kunitz inhibitors interleukins-1β and 1β and fibroblast growth factors. J Mol Biol 223:531–543
Blaber M, DiSalvo J, Thomas KA (1996) X-ray crystal structure of human acidic fibroblast growth factor. Biochemistry 35:2086–2094
Chaudhuri I, Soding J, Lupas AN (2008) Evolution of the β-propeller fold. Proteins 71:795–803
Kostlánová N, Mitchell EP, Lortat-Jacob H, Oscarson S, Lahmann M, Gilboa-Garber N, Chambat G, Wimmerová M, Imberty A (2005) The fucose-binding lectin from Ralstonia solanacearum. A new type of beta-propeller architecture formed by oligomerization and interacting with fucoside, fucosyllactose, and plant xyloglucan. J Biol Chem 280:27839–27849
Shannon CE (1948) A mathematical theory of communication. Bell Syst Tech J 27(3):379–423
Blaber M, Lee J (2012) Designing proteins from simple motifs: opportunities in top-down symmetric deconstruction. Curr Opin Structural Biol. doi:10.1016/j.sbi.2012.05.008
Nikkhah M, Jawad-Alami Z, Demydchuk M, Ribbons D, Paoli M (2006) Engineering of β-propeller protein scaffolds by multiple gene duplication and fusion of an idealized WD repeat. Biomol Eng 23:185–194
Alsenaidy MA, Wang T, Kim JH, Joshi SB, Lee J, Blaber M, Volkin DB, Middaugh CR (2012) An empirical phase diagram approach to investigate conformational stability of “second-generation” functional mutants of acidic fibroblast growth factor (FGF-1). Protein Sci Publ Protein Soc 21(3):418–432
Beadle BM, Shoichet BK (2002) Structural basis of stability: function tradeoffs in enzymes. J Mol Biol 321:285–296
Tokuriki N, Stricher F, Serrano L, Tawfik DS (2008) How protein stability and new functions trade off. PLoS Comput Biol 4(2):e1000002. doi:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1000002
Hocker B, Beismann-Driemeyer S, Hettwer S, Lustig A, Sterner R (2001) Dissection of a (βα)8-barrel enzyme into two folded halves. Nat Struct Biol 8:32–36
Hocker B, Claren J, Sterner R (2004) Mimicking enzyme evolution by generating new (beta-alpha)8-barrels from (beta-alpha)4-half-barrels. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 101:16448–16453
Hocker B, Lochner A, Seitz T, Claren J, Sterner R (2009) High-resolution crystal structure of an artificial (betaalpha)(8)-barrel protein designed from identical half-barrels. Biochemistry 48(6):1145–1147. doi:10.1021/bi802125b
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Blaber, M., Lee, J. & Longo, L. Emergence of symmetric protein architecture from a simple peptide motif: evolutionary models. Cell. Mol. Life Sci. 69, 3999–4006 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00018-012-1077-3
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00018-012-1077-3