Abstract
In Rudolf Wittkower’s influential view, Renaissance musical theory, based on Pythagorean and Platonic proportions, is a paradigm of harmony, order, and spatial organisation in architecture from Alberti to Palladio. However, sources from Hypnerotomachia Poliphili (1499) and other sixteenth-century French treatises, through René Ouvrard’s Architecture Harmonique (1679) seem to show another, undiscovered story. The keys to interpretation include a different philological reading of Vitruvian theory of proportion, as Fra’ Giocondo’s French lessons show. This is a starting point for a particular sixteenth-century passage between two differents conceptions of architecture – from anthropomorphic to rhetoric, from volumetric to linear, and from quantitative to qualitative – which will find a definitive arrangement in the seventeenth century.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allard Joseph C. (1982) Mechanism, Music, and Painting in 17th Century France. The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 40(3): 269–279
Barker Naomi Joy. (2000) ‘Diverse Passions’: Mode, Interval and Affect in Poussin’s Paintings. Music in Art 25(1-2): 5–24
Battisti Eugenio. (1968) Le tendenze all’unità verso la metà del Cinquecento. Bollettino del Centro Internazionale di Studi di Architettura Andrea Palladio 10: 127–146
Battisti Eugenio. (1973) Un tentativo di analisi strutturale del Palladio tramite le teorie musicali del Cinquecento e l’impiego di figure retoriche. Bollettino del Centro Internazionale di Studi di Architettura Andrea Palladio 15: 211–232
Bernin De Saint-Hilarion, François. 1680. Des Proportions d’Architecture. Münich, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, Cod. Icon 193.
Blondel, François. 1675–1683. Cours d’Architecture enseigné dans l’Académie Royale d’Architecture. Paris: P. Abouin and F. Clouzier.
Blunt Anthony. (1937) The Hypnerotomachia Poliphili in the 17th Century France. Journal of the Warburg Institute I, 2: 117–127
Blunt Anthony. (1958) Philibert De l’Orme. Zwemmer, London
Bonhôte Jean-Marc. (1971) Resonance musicale d’une ville de Palladio. Musica Disciplina 25: 171–178
Borsi, Stefano. 1995. Polifilo architetto. Cultura architettonia e teoria artistica nell’ ‘Hypnerotomachia Poliphili’ di Francesco Colonna, 1499. Rome: Officina.
Brault, Yoann. 2006. La défense des proportions dans le ‘Cours d’Architecture’ de François Blondel. Pp. 30–38 in Claude Nicolas Ledoux et le livre d’architecture – Étienne Louis Boullée l’utopie et la poésie de l’art, Daniel Rabreau and Dominique Massounie eds. Paris: Monum.
Brenet, Michel [Bobillier, Marie]. 1910. Les Musiciens de la Sainte-Chapelle du Palais. Paris: Picard.
Briseux, Charles-Estienne. 1752. Traité du beau essentiel dans les arts, Appliqué particulierement à l’Architecture, et demontré Phisiquement et par l’Expérience; Avec Un traité des Proportions Harmoniques, et l’on fait voir que c’est de ces seules Proportions que les Édifices généralement approuvés, empruntent leur Beauté réelle et invariable . Paris: Chez l’Auteur et Chereau.
Buch David J. (1989) The Coordination of Text, Illustration, and Music in a Seventeenth- Century Lute Manuscript: ‘La Rhétorique des Dieux’. Imago Musicae 6: 39–81
Campanini, Saverio. 2007. Francesco Zorzi: armonia del mondo e filosofia simbolica. Pp. 239–260 in Il pensiero simbolico nella prima età moderna, Annarita Angelini and Pierre Caye, eds. Florence: Olschki.
Caye, Pierre and Choay Françoise. 2004. Leon Battista Alberti: L’Art d’Édifier. Paris: Seuil.
Caye, Pierre. 2007. L’édition du ‘De architectura’ de Vitruve et la constitution du savoir architecturale à la Renaissance, comunicazione letta al Colloquio Internazionale L’ ‘Archivium’ et le travaille de la pensée. Humanisme philologique, humanisme philosophique, Paris, 22–23 May 2007.
Carpo, Mario. 1993. La maschera e il modello. Teoria architettonica ed evangelismo nell’ ‘Extraordinario Libro’ di Sebastiano Serlio . Milan: Jaca Book.
Carpo, Mario. 1998. L’architettura dell’età della stampa. Oralità, scrittura, libro stampato e riproduzione meccanica dell’immagine nella storia delle teorie architettoniche. Milano: Jaca Book (Eng. trans. Architecture in the Age of Printing. Orality, Writing, Typography, and Printed Images in the History of Architectural Theory, Sarah Benson, trans. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 2001).
Carpo Mario. (2001) How Do You Imitate a Building That You Have Never Seen? Printed Images, Ancient Models, and Handmade Drawings in the Renaissance Architectural Theory. Zeitschrift für Kunstgeschichte 64(2): 223–233
Cohen, Albert. 1974. René Ouvrard (1624–1694) and the beginnings of French Baroque Theory. Report of the Eleventh ISM Congress – Copenhagen 1972. Copenhagen: Wilhelm Hansen, vol. I, pp. 336–342.
Carpo, Mario. 1975. The Ouvrard-Nicaise correspondence (1663–93). Music & Letters 56, 3–4: 356-363.
Colonna Francesco. (1499) Hypnerotomachia Poliphili. Venice, In aedibus Aldi Manutii
Colonna Francesco. (1999) Hypnerotomachia Poliphili. The Strife of Love in a Dream. Joscelyn Godwin, trans. Thames & Hudson, London
Collins Judd Cristle. (2000) Reading Renaissance Music Theory. Hearing with the Eyes. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Costantini Michela. (2002) La trasformazione storica dell’applicazione dei rapporti musicali all’architettura attraverso la lettura armonica della base attica. Le culture della tecnica, nuova serie 14: 75–102
Delorme, Philibert [Philibert de l’Orme]. 1567. Premier tome de l’architecture de Philibert De l’Orme conseiller et aumônier ordinier du Roi, et abbé de S. Serge les Angiers. Paris: Federic Morel.
Dionisotti Carlo. (1968) Gli umanisti e il volgare fra Quattro e Cinquecento. Florence, Le Monnier
Fichet Françoise. (1979) La théorie architecturale à l’âge classique. Essai d’anthologie critique. Liége, Mardaga
Foscari Antonio., Tafuri Manfredo. (1983) L’armonia e i conflitti: la chiesa di San Francesco della Vigna nelle Venezia del 500. Torino, Einaudi
Fréart De Chambray, Roland. 1650. Parallèle de l’Architecture Antique et Moderne, avec un Recueil des Six Principaux Autheurs qui ont écrit des Cinq Ordres, savoir: Palladio et Scamozzi, Serlio et Vignola, D. Barbaro et Cataneo, L. B. Alberti et Viola, Bullant et De L’Orme, comparés entre eux. Par R. Fréart, sieur de Chambray. Paris: E. Martin. (Modern ed.: Parallèle de l’architecture antique avec la moderne suivi de Idée de la perfection de la peinture, Frédérique Lemerle-Pauwels and Milovan Stanic, eds. Paris: Ecole Nationale Supérieure des Beaux-Arts, 2005.)
Frommel Sabine. (1998) Sebastiano Serlio architetto. Electa, Milan
Gerbino, Anthony. 2002. The Library of François Blondel 1618–1686. Architectural History 45: 289–324.
Gerbino Anthony. (2010) François Blondel: Architecture, Erudition, and the Scientific Revolution. London & New York, Routledge
Giani, Maurizio. 2000. Scala musica. Vicende di una metafora. Pp. 31–48 in Le parole della musica. III. Studi di lessicologia musicale, Fiamma Nicolodi and Paolo Trovato, eds. Florence: Olschki.
Gioseffi Decio. (1972) Il disegno come fase progettuale dell’attività palladiana. Bollettino del Centro Internazionale di Studi di Architettura Andrea Palladio 14: 45–62
Gioseffi Decio. (1978) Dal progetto al trattato: incontro e scontro con la realtà. Bollettino del Centro Internazionale di Studi di Architettura Andrea Palladio 20: 27–45
Gioseffi, Decio. 1980a. I disegni dei ‘Quattro Libri’ come modelli: modellistica architettonica e teoria dei modelli. Bollettino del Centro Internazionale di Studi di Architettura Andrea Palladio 22: 147–64.
Gioseffi Decio. (1980) Convegno palladiano: precisazioni dovute. Bollettino del Centro Internazionale di Studi di Architettura Andrea Palladio 22(2): 193–203
Gioseffi Decio. (1989) Palladio oggi: dal Wittkower al postmoderno. Annali di architettura 1: 105–121
Godman, Rob. 2008. The Enigma of Vitruvian Resonating Vases and the Relevance of the Concept for Today. International Computer Music Conference Proceedings, Queen’s University, Belfast. Available at: http://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/pagevieweridx?c=icmc;idno=bbp2372.2008.065;cc=icmc;view=image (last accessed 3 January 2011).
Gozza, Paolo. 2007 (2009). I suoni taumaturghi. Un’estetica musicale barocca dello spossessamento. Musica e Storia 15, 2: 417–441
Herrmann, Wolfgang. 1967. Unknown designs for the ‘Temple of Jerusalem’ by Claude Perrault. Pp. 143–158 in Essays in the History of Architecture presented to Rudolf Wittkower, Douglas Fraser, Howard Hibbard and Milton J. Lewine, eds. London: Phaidon.
Herrmann Wolfgang. (1973) The theory of Claude Perrault. Zwemmer, London
Hersey George L. (1976) Pythagorean Palaces. Magic and Architecture in the Italian Renaissance. Cornell University Press, Ithaca
Hersey George L. (2000) Architecture and Geometry in the Age of the Baroque. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Howard Deborah., Malcolm Longair. (1982) Harmonic Proportion and Palladio’s ‘Quattro Libri’. Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians 41(2): 116–143
Jouanny Charles. (1911) Correspondance de Nicolas Poussin. Jean Schemit, Paris
Kappraff Jay., Ernest G., Ernest G. (2005) The System of Proportions of the Parthenon: A Work of Musically Inspired Architecture. Music in Art 30(1-2): 5–16
Le Camus De Mézières, Nicolas. 1780. Le génie de l’architecture; ou, L’analogie de cet art avec nos sensations. Paris: B. Morin. (Eng. trans. The Genius of Architecture; or, The Analogy of That Art with Our Sensations, Robin Middleton, ed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992.)
Lefaivre Liane. (1997) Leon Battista Alberti’s Hypnerotomachia Poliphili. Re-Cognizing the Architectural Body in the Early Italian Renaissance. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Lemerle, Frédérique. 2006. Claude Perrault théoricien: l’ ‘Ordonnance des Cinq Espéces de Colonnes’ (1683). Pp. 18–29 in Claude Nicolas Ledoux et le livre d’architecture – Étienne Louis Boullée l’utopie et la poésie de l’art, Daniel Rabreau and Dominique Massounie eds. Paris: Monum.
Lemonnier, Henry. 1912. Procés-Verbaux de l’Académie Royale d’Architecture 1671–1793. 10 vols (1911–1929). Paris, Jean Schemit.
Lockspeiser Edward. (1967) Poussin et les modes. Revue de Musicologie 53: 61–64
Mambella, Guido. 2008. Corpo sonoro, geometria e temperamenti. Zarlino e la crisi del fondamento numerico della musica. Pp. 185–233 in Music and Mathematics in Late Medieval and Early Modern Europe, Philippe Vendrix ed. Turnhout: Brepol.
March Lionel. (1998) Architectonics of Humanism: Essays on Number in Architecture. Wiley-Academy, London
March Lionel. (2008) Palladio, Pythagoreanism and Renaissance Mathematics. Nexus Network Journal 10(2): 227–244
Martin, Marie-Pauline. 2006. L’analogie des proportions architecturales et musicales: évolution d’une stratégie. Pp. 40–47 in Claude Nicolas Ledoux et le livre d’architecture – ÉÉtienne Louis Boullée l’utopie et la poésie de l’art, Daniel Rabreau and Dominique Massounie eds. Paris: Monum.
Mérot, Alain. 1994. Les modes, ou les paradoxes du peintre. Pp. 80–86 in Nicolas Poussin 1594–1665, exhibition catalogue, Pierre Rosenberg and Louis-Antoine Prat eds. Paris: RMN.
Millon Henry A. (1972) Rudolf Wittkower, ‘Architectural Principles in the Age of Humanism’: Its Influence on the Development and Interpretation of Modern Architecture. Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians 31(2): 83–91
Mitrovic Branko. (1990) Palladio’s Theory of Proportions and the Second Book of the ‘Quattro Libri dell’Architettura’. Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians 49(3): 279–292
Mitrovic Branko. (1998) Paduan Aristotelianism and Daniele Barbaro’s Commentary on Vitruvius ‘De Architectura’. Sixteenth Century Journal 29(3): 667–688
Mitrovic Branko. (1999) Palladio’s Theory of the Classical Order and the First Book of ‘I Quattro Libri dell’Architettura’. Architectural History 42(2): 110–140
Mitrovic Branko. (2001) A Palladian Palinode: Reassessing Wittkower’s ‘Architectural Principles in the Age of Humanism’. Architectura 31(2): 113–131
Mitrovic Branko. (2004) Learning from Palladio. Norton, New York
Mourjopoulos Vassilantopopoulos. (2003) A study of Ancient Greek and Roman Theater. Acta Acoustica 89: 123–136
Naredi-Rainer., Paul von. (1977). Musikalische Proportionen, Zahlenästhetik und Zahlensymbolik im architektonischen Werk L. B. Albertis. Jahrbuch des Kunsthistorischen Institutes der Universität Graz 12: 81-213.
Naredi-Rainer Paul von. (1982). Architecktur und Harmonie. Zahl, Maß und Proportion in der abendländischen Baukunst. Köln: DuMont.
Naredi-Rainer, Paul von. 1985. Musiktheorie und Architektur. Pp. 149–174 in Geschichte der Musiktheorie. I. Ideen zu einer Geschichte der Musiktheorie, Frieder Zaminer ed. Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft.
Naredi-Rainer, Paul von. 1994. La bellezza numerabile: l’estetica architettonica di Leon Battista Alberti. Pp. 292–299 in Leon Battista Alberti , Joseph Rykwert and Anne Engel eds. Milan: Olivetti-Electa.
Onians John. (1988) Bearers of Meaning. The Classical Orders in Antiquity, the Middle Ages and the Renaissance. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Ouvrard, René. 1679. Architecture Harmonique, ou l’Application de la Doctrine des Proportions de la Musique à l’Architecture. Paris: J. B. de la Caille.
Payne Alina A. (1994) Rudolf Wittkower and Architectural Principles in the Age of Modernism. Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians 53: 322–342
Pauwels, Yves. 2000. ‘Harmonia est discordia concors’: le modèle musical dans l’architecture des temps modernes. Pp. 313–325 in L’Harmonie, Charles Charraud ed. Orléans: Meaux.
Pauwels Yves. (2002) L’architecture au temps de la Pléiade. Monfort, Paris
Pérouse De Montclos, Jean-Marie. 2000. Philibert de l’Orme. Architecte du Roi (1514–1570). Paris: Mengé.
Picon Antoine. (1989) Claude Perrault ou la curiosité d’un classique. Picard, Paris
Pintore Angela. (2004) Musical Symbolism in the Works of Leon Battista Alberti. From ‘De re aedificatoria’ to the Ruccelai Sepulchre. Nexus Network Journal 6(2): 49–70
Pomme De Mirimonde Albert. (1972) Poussin et la musique. Gazette des Beaux-Arts 79: 129–150
Portoghesi Paolo. (2008) La mano di Palladio. Torino, Allemandi
Ramírez, Juan Antonio, ed. 1991. Dios Arquitecto. J. B. Villalpando y el Templo de Salómon. Madrid: Siruela.
Rykwert Joseph. (1996) The Dancing Column: On Order of Architecture. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Robison, Elwin C. 1998–99. Structural Implications in Palladio’s Use of Harmonic Proportions. Annali di architettura 10-11: 175–182.
Samsa Danilo. (2003) L’Alberti di Wittkower. Albertiana 6: 51–94
SanchezDe Enciso Sabina. (2008) Música y arquitectura en el ‘De postrema Ezechielis prophetae visione’ de J.B. Villalpando. Cuadernos de Música Iberoamericana 15: 7–40
Serravezza, Antonio and Paolo GOZZA. 2004. Estetica ‘e’ musica. L’origine di un incontro. Bologna: CLUEB.
Scalvini Maria Luisa., Sergio Villari. (1991) Claude Perrault: L’ordine dell’architettura. Palermo, Aesthetica Preprint
Scalvini Maria Luisa., Sergio Villari. (1994) Il manoscritto sulle proporzioni di François Bernin de Saint-Hilarion. Palermo, Aesthetica Preprint
Schmidt, Dorothea. 1978. Untersuchungen zu den Architekturekphrasen in der Hypnerotomachia Poliphili. Die Beschreibung des Venus-Tempels. Frankfurt am Main: R. G. Fischer.
Stewering, Roswitha. 2000. Architectural Representations in the ‘Hypnerotomachia Poliphili’ (Aldus Manutius, 1499). Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians 59: 16–25.
Stumpfhaus Bernhard. (2005) Modus – Affekt – Allegorie bei Nicolas Poussin. Reimer, Dietrich
Szambien, Werner. 1986. Symétrie Goût Caractére. Théorie et terminologie de l’architecture à l’âge classique 1550–1800. Paris: Picard.
Tafuri Manfredo. (1985) Venezia e il Rinascimento. Religione, scienza, architettura. Torino, Einaudi
Testa Fausto. (2003) Il ‘Traité du Beau Essentiel’ di C-E Briseux e il tema delle proporzioni armoniche nella teoria architettonica del secolo dei Lumi. Oltrecorrente 7(1): 143–154
Vasoli Cesare. (1998) Il tema musicale e architettonico della ‘Harmonia Mundi’ da Francesco Giorgio veneto all’Accademia degli Uranici e a Gioseffo Zarlino. Musica e Storia 6(1): 193–210
Vendrix Philippe. (1988) René Ouvrard et l’évolution de l’art musical. Revue belge de musicologie 42: 193–197
Vendrix, Philippe. 1989. Proportions harmoniques et proportions architecturales dans la théorie française des XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles. International Review of the Aesthetics and Sociology of Music 20, 1: 3–10.
Vendrix Philippe. (1992) L’augustinisme musical en France au XVIIe siécle. Revue de Musicologie 78: 237–255
Vergo Peter. (2005) That Divine Order. Music and the Visual Arts from Antiquity to the Eighteenth Century. Phaidon, London
Villalpando, Juan Bautista and Jeronimo Del prado. 1595–1604. Ezechielem Explanationes et Apparatus Urbis ac Templi Hierosolymitani, Rome: A. Zanetti.
Vitruvius. 1511. M. Vitruvius per Iocundum solito castigatior factus cum figuris et tabula ut iam legi et intelligi possit. Venice: Giovanni Tacuino de Tridino.
Vitruvius. 1543. M. Vitruvii viri svæ professionis peritissimi, de architectura libri decem, ad Augustum Cæsarem accuratiss. conscripti: & nunc primum in Germania qua potuit diligentia excusi, atque hinc inde schematibus non iniucundis exornati. Strasbourg: Knobloch-Machæropioeus [Messerschmidt].
Vitruvius. 1552. M. Vitruvii Pollionis de architectura libri decem ad Cæsarem Augustum, omnibus omnium editionibus longé emendatiores, collatis veteribus exemplis, Guillaume Philandrier, ed. Lyon: Jean de Tournes.
Vitruvius. 1567. M. Vitruvii Pollionis de architectura libri decem, cum commentariis Danielis Barbari, electi Patriarchæ Aquileiensis. Venice: Franciscus Franciscium Sensensis & Ioannes Crugher Germanus.
Wittkower, Rudolf. 1949. Architectural Principles in the Age of Humanism. London: Warburg Institute. (Citations in this present paper taken from the 3rd ed., London: Academy Editions, 1962.)
Zanoncelli, Luisa. 1999. Reciproche influenze dell’idea di ‘divina proporzione’. Pp. 199–212 in Leon Battista Alberti. Architettura e cultura, Claudio Gallico ed. Florence: Olschki.
Zanoncelli, Luisa. 2007. La musica e le sue fonti nel pensiero di Leon Battista Alberti. Pp. 85–116 in Leon Battista Alberti teorico delle arti e gli impegni civili del ‘De re aedificatoria’, Arturo Calzona, Francesco Paolo Fiore, Alberto Tenenti and Cesare Vasoli eds., 2 vols. Florence: Olschki.
Zara Vasco. (2005) Musica e Architettura tra Medio Evo e Età moderna Storia critica di un’idea. Acta Musicologica 77(1): 1–26
Zara Vasco. (2006) Antichi e Moderni tra Musica e Architettura. All’origine della ‘Querelle des Anciens et des Modernes’. Intersezioni 26(2): 191–210
Zara, Vasco. 2007. Da Palladio a Wittkower. Questioni di metodo, di indagine e di disciplina nello studio dei rapporti tra musica e architettura. Pp. 153–190 in Prospettive di iconografia musicale, Nicoletta Guidobaldi ed. Milan: Mimesis.
Zara Vasco. (2008) Una storia della musica all’ombra di Port-Royal: la ‘Musique Rétablie’ di René Ouvrard. Studi Musicali 37(1): 59–100
Zara Vasco. (2008) Modes musicaux et ordres d’architecture: migration d’un modèle sémantique dans l’oeuvre de Nicolas Poussin. Musique – Images – Instruments. Revue française d’organologie et d’iconographie musicale 10: 62–79
Zara Vasco. 2007 (2009). Suono e carattere della base attica. Itinerari semantici d’un metafora musicale nel linguaggio architettonico francese del Settecento. Musica e Storia 15, 2: 443–474
Zara, Vasco. 2010. Dall’ ‘Hypnerotomachia Poliphili’ al Tempio di Salomone. Modelli architettonicomusicali nell’ ‘Architecture Harmonique’ di René Ouvrard, 1679. Pp. 131–156 in La réception de modèles ‘cinquecenteschi’ dans la théorie et les arts français du XVIIe siècle, Sabine Frommel and Flaminia Bardati, eds. Geneva: Droz.
Zarlino Gioseffo. (1558) Le istitutioni harmoniche. Venetia, Francesco de’ Franceschi
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
About this article
Cite this article
Zara, V. From Quantitative to Qualitative Architecture in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries: A New Musical Perspective. Nexus Netw J 13, 411–430 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00004-011-0074-4
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00004-011-0074-4