# *Z*γ production at NNLO including anomalous couplings

- 52 Downloads
- 2 Citations

## Abstract

In this paper we present a next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO) QCD calculation of the processes *pp* → *l* ^{+} *l* ^{−}γ and \( pp\to \nu \overline{\nu}\gamma \) that we have implemented in MCFM. Our calculation includes QCD corrections at NNLO both for the Standard Model (SM) and additionally in the presence of *Zγγ* and *ZZγ* anomalous couplings. We compare our implementation, obtained using the jettiness slicing approach, with a previous SM calculation and find broad agreement. Focusing on the sensitivity of our results to the slicing parameter, we show that using our setup we are able to compute NNLO cross sections with numerical uncertainties of about 0.1%, which is small compared to residual scale uncertainties of a few percent. We study potential improvements using two different jettiness definitions and the inclusion of power corrections. At \( \sqrt{s}=13 \) TeV we present phenomenological results and consider *Zγ* as a background to *H* → *Zγ* production. We find that, with typical cuts, the inclusion of NNLO corrections represents a small effect and loosens the extraction of limits on anomalous couplings by about 10%.

## Keywords

QCD Phenomenology## Notes

**Open Access**

This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC-BY 4.0), which permits any use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.

## References

- [1]CMS collaboration,
*Measurement of W γ and Zγ production in pp collisions at*\( \sqrt{s}=7 \)*TeV*,*Phys. Lett.***B 701**(2011) 535 [arXiv:1105.2758] [INSPIRE]. - [2]ATLAS collaboration,
*Measurement of W γ and Zγ production in proton-proton collisions at*\( \sqrt{s}=7 \)*TeV with the ATLAS detector*,*JHEP***09**(2011) 072 [arXiv:1106.1592] [INSPIRE]. - [3]ATLAS collaboration,
*Measurement of W γ and Zγ production cross sections in pp collisions at*\( \sqrt{s}=7 \)*TeV and limits on anomalous triple gauge couplings with the ATLAS detector*,*Phys. Lett.***B 717**(2012) 49 [arXiv:1205.2531] [INSPIRE]. - [4]CMS collaboration,
*Measurement of the production cross section for*\( \mathrm{Z}\gamma \to \nu \overline{\nu}\gamma \)*in pp collisions at*\( \sqrt{s}=7 \)*TeV and limits on ZZγ and Zγγ triple gauge boson couplings*,*JHEP***10**(2013)164 [arXiv:1309.1117] [INSPIRE]. - [5]ATLAS collaboration,
*Measurements of W γ and Zγ production in pp collisions at*\( \sqrt{s}=7 \)*TeV with the ATLAS detector at the LHC*,*Phys. Rev.***D 87**(2013) 112003 [*Erratum ibid.***D 91**(2015) 119901] [arXiv:1302.1283] [INSPIRE]. - [6]CMS collaboration,
*Measurement of the W γ and Zγ inclusive cross sections in pp collisions at*\( \sqrt{s}=7 \)*TeV and limits on anomalous triple gauge boson couplings*,*Phys. Rev.***D 89**(2014) 092005 [arXiv:1308.6832] [INSPIRE]. - [7]ATLAS collaboration,
*Search for new resonances in W γ and Zγ final states in pp collisions at*\( \sqrt{s}=8 \)*TeV with the ATLAS detector*,*Phys. Lett.***B 738**(2014) 428 [arXiv:1407.8150] [INSPIRE]. - [8]CMS collaboration,
*Measurement of the Zγ production cross section in pp collisions at*8*TeV and search for anomalous triple gauge boson couplings*,*JHEP***04**(2015) 164 [arXiv:1502.05664] [INSPIRE]. - [9]ATLAS collaboration,
*Measurements of Zγ and Zγγ production in pp collisions at*\( \sqrt{s}=8 \)*TeV with the ATLAS detector*,*Phys. Rev.***D 93**(2016) 112002 [arXiv:1604.05232] [INSPIRE]. - [10]CMS collaboration,
*Measurement of the*\( \mathrm{Z}\gamma \to \nu \overline{\nu}\gamma \)*production cross section in pp collisions at*\( \sqrt{s}=8 \)*TeV and limits on anomalous ZZγ and Zγγ trilinear gauge boson couplings*,*Phys. Lett.***B 760**(2016) 448 [arXiv:1602.07152] [INSPIRE]. - [11]CMS collaboration,
*Measurement of the production cross section for pp*→*Z*(*νν*)*γ at*\( \sqrt{s}=13 \)*TeV at CMS*, CMS-PAS-SMP-16-004, CERN, Geneva Switzerland, (2016). - [12]ATLAS collaboration,
*Searches for the Zγ decay mode of the Higgs boson and for new high-mass resonances in pp collisions at*\( \sqrt{s}=13 \)*TeV with the ATLAS detector*,*JHEP***10**(2017)112 [arXiv:1708.00212] [INSPIRE]. - [13]ATLAS collaboration,
*Search for heavy resonances decaying to a Z boson and a photon in pp collisions at*\( \sqrt{s}=13 \)*TeV with the ATLAS detector*,*Phys. Lett.***B 764**(2017) 11 [arXiv:1607.06363] [INSPIRE]. - [14]U. Baur and E.L. Berger,
*Probing the weak boson sector in Zγ production at hadron colliders*,*Phys. Rev.***D 47**(1993) 4889 [INSPIRE].ADSGoogle Scholar - [15]M. Spira, A. Djouadi, D. Graudenz and P.M. Zerwas,
*Higgs boson production at the LHC*,*Nucl. Phys.***B 453**(1995) 17 [hep-ph/9504378] [INSPIRE]. - [16]A. Djouadi, V. Driesen, W. Hollik and A. Kraft,
*The Higgs photon-Z boson coupling revisited*,*Eur. Phys. J.***C 1**(1998) 163 [hep-ph/9701342] [INSPIRE]. - [17]I. Low, J. Lykken and G. Shaughnessy,
*Singlet scalars as Higgs imposters at the Large Hadron Collider*,*Phys. Rev.***D 84**(2011) 035027 [arXiv:1105.4587] [INSPIRE].ADSGoogle Scholar - [18]P.J. Fox, R. Harnik, J. Kopp and Y. Tsai,
*Missing energy signatures of dark matter at the LHC*,*Phys. Rev.***D 85**(2012) 056011 [arXiv:1109.4398] [INSPIRE].ADSGoogle Scholar - [19]G. Bélanger, M. Heikinheimo and V. Sanz,
*Model-independent bounds on squarks from monophoton searches*,*JHEP***08**(2012) 151 [arXiv:1205.1463] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [20]E. Gabrielli, M. Heikinheimo, B. Mele and M. Raidal,
*Dark photons and resonant monophoton signatures in Higgs boson decays at the LHC*,*Phys. Rev.***D 90**(2014) 055032 [arXiv:1405.5196] [INSPIRE].ADSGoogle Scholar - [21]F. Maltoni, A. Martini, K. Mawatari and B. Oexl,
*Signals of a superlight gravitino at the LHC*,*JHEP***04**(2015) 021 [arXiv:1502.01637] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [22]R.W. Brown, D. Sahdev and K.O. Mikaelian,
*W*^{±}*Z*^{0}*and W*^{±}γ*pair production in νe, pp and*\( \overline{p}p \)*collisions*,*Phys. Rev.***D 20**(1979) 1164 [INSPIRE].ADSGoogle Scholar - [23]F.M. Renard,
*Tests of neutral gauge boson selfcouplings with e*^{+}*e*^{−}→*γZ*,*Nucl. Phys.***B 196**(1982) 93 [INSPIRE]. - [24]J. Ohnemus,
*Order α*_{s}*calculations of hadronic W*^{±}*γ and Zγ production*,*Phys. Rev.***D 47**(1993) 940 [INSPIRE]. - [25]J. Ohnemus,
*Hadronic Zγ production with QCD corrections and leptonic decays*,*Phys. Rev.***D 51**(1995) 1068 [hep-ph/9407370] [INSPIRE]. - [26]U. Baur, T. Han and J. Ohnemus,
*QCD corrections and anomalous couplings in Zγ production at hadron colliders*,*Phys. Rev.***D 57**(1998) 2823 [hep-ph/9710416] [INSPIRE]. - [27]L.J. Dixon, Z. Kunszt and A. Signer,
*Helicity amplitudes for O*(*α*_{s})*production of W*^{+}*W*^{−}*, W*^{±}*Z, ZZ, W*^{±}*γ, or Zγ pairs at hadron colliders*,*Nucl. Phys.***B 531**(1998) 3 [hep-ph/9803250] [INSPIRE]. - [28]D. De Florian and A. Signer,
*W γ and Zγ production at hadron colliders*,*Eur. Phys. J.***C 16**(2000) 105 [hep-ph/0002138] [INSPIRE]. - [29]J.M. Campbell and R.K. Ellis,
*An update on vector boson pair production at hadron colliders*,*Phys. Rev.***D 60**(1999) 113006 [hep-ph/9905386] [INSPIRE]. - [30]L. Ametller, E. Gava, N. Paver and D. Treleani,
*Role of the QCD induced gluon-gluon coupling to gauge boson pairs in the multi-TeV region*,*Phys. Rev.***D 32**(1985) 1699 [INSPIRE].ADSGoogle Scholar - [31]J.J. van der Bij and E.W.N. Glover,
*Photon*Z*boson pair production via gluon fusion*,*Phys. Lett.***B 206**(1988) 701 [INSPIRE].ADSGoogle Scholar - [32]K.L. Adamson, D. de Florian and A. Signer,
*Gluon induced contributions to Zγ production at hadron colliders*,*Phys. Rev.***D 67**(2003) 034016 [hep-ph/0211295] [INSPIRE]. - [33]J.M. Campbell, R.K. Ellis and C. Williams,
*Vector boson pair production at the LHC*,*JHEP***07**(2011) 018 [arXiv:1105.0020] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [34]W. Hollik and C. Meier,
*Electroweak corrections to γZ production at hadron colliders*,*Phys. Lett.***B 590**(2004) 69 [hep-ph/0402281] [INSPIRE]. - [35]E. Accomando, A. Denner and S. Pozzorini,
*Electroweak correction effects in gauge boson pair production at the CERN LHC*,*Phys. Rev.***D 65**(2002) 073003 [hep-ph/0110114] [INSPIRE]. - [36]E. Accomando, A. Denner and C. Meier,
*Electroweak corrections to W γ and Zγ production at the LHC*,*Eur. Phys. J.***C 47**(2006) 125 [hep-ph/0509234] [INSPIRE]. - [37]A. Denner, S. Dittmaier, M. Hecht and C. Pasold,
*NLO QCD and electroweak corrections to Z*+*γ production with leptonic Z-boson decays*,*JHEP***02**(2016) 057 [arXiv:1510.08742] [INSPIRE]. - [38]M. Grazzini, S. Kallweit, D. Rathlev and A. Torre,
*Zγ production at hadron colliders in NNLO QCD*,*Phys. Lett.***B 731**(2014) 204 [arXiv:1309.7000] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [39]M. Grazzini, S. Kallweit and D. Rathlev,
*W γ and Zγ production at the LHC in NNLO QCD*,*JHEP***07**(2015) 085 [arXiv:1504.01330] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [40]S. Catani, L. Cieri, D. de Florian, G. Ferrera and M. Grazzini,
*Diphoton production at hadron colliders: a fully-differential QCD calculation at NNLO*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***108**(2012) 072001 [arXiv:1110.2375] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [41]J.M. Campbell, R.K. Ellis, Y. Li and C. Williams,
*Predictions for diphoton production at the LHC through NNLO in QCD*,*JHEP***07**(2016) 148 [arXiv:1603.02663] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [42]S. Catani, L. Cieri, D. de Florian, G. Ferrera and M. Grazzini,
*Erratum: Diphoton production at hadron colliders: a fully-differential QCD calculation at NNLO*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***117**(2016) 089901 [arXiv:1110.2375v2].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [43]S. Frixione,
*Isolated photons in perturbative QCD*,*Phys. Lett.***B 429**(1998) 369 [hep-ph/9801442] [INSPIRE]. - [44]R. Boughezal, C. Focke, X. Liu and F. Petriello,
*W -boson production in association with a jet at next-to-next-to-leading order in perturbative QCD*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***115**(2015) 062002 [arXiv:1504.02131] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [45]J. Gaunt, M. Stahlhofen, F.J. Tackmann and J.R. Walsh,
*N -jettiness subtractions for NNLO QCD calculations*,*JHEP***09**(2015) 058 [arXiv:1505.04794] [INSPIRE].CrossRefGoogle Scholar - [46]S. Catani and M. Grazzini,
*An NNLO subtraction formalism in hadron collisions and its application to Higgs boson production at the LHC*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***98**(2007) 222002 [hep-ph/0703012] [INSPIRE]. - [47]R. Boughezal et al.,
*Color singlet production at NNLO in MCFM*,*Eur. Phys. J.***C 77**(2017) 7 [arXiv:1605.08011] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [48]T. Gehrmann and L. Tancredi,
*Two-loop QCD helicity amplitudes for*\( q\overline{q}\to {W}^{\pm}\gamma \)*and*\( q\overline{q}\to {\mathrm{Z}}^0\gamma \),*JHEP***02**(2012) 004 [arXiv:1112.1531] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefMATHGoogle Scholar - [49]T. Gehrmann and E. Remiddi,
*Numerical evaluation of two-dimensional harmonic polylogarithms*,*Comput. Phys. Commun.***144**(2002) 200 [hep-ph/0111255] [INSPIRE]. - [50]J.M. Campbell, H.B. Hartanto and C. Williams,
*Next-to-leading order predictions for Zγ+jet and Zγγ final states at the LHC*,*JHEP***11**(2012) 162 [arXiv:1208.0566] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [51]Z. Bern, L.J. Dixon and D.A. Kosower,
*One loop amplitudes for e*^{+}*e*^{−}*to four partons*,*Nucl. Phys.***B 513**(1998) 3 [hep-ph/9708239] [INSPIRE]. - [52]T. Gehrmann, E.W.N. Glover, T. Huber, N. Ikizlerli and C. Studerus,
*Calculation of the quark and gluon form factors to three loops in QCD*,*JHEP***06**(2010) 094 [arXiv:1004.3653] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefMATHGoogle Scholar - [53]P.A. Baikov, K.G. Chetyrkin, A.V. Smirnov, V.A. Smirnov and M. Steinhauser,
*Quark and gluon form factors to three loops*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***102**(2009) 212002 [arXiv:0902.3519] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [54]R.N. Lee, A.V. Smirnov and V.A. Smirnov,
*Analytic results for massless three-loop form factors*,*JHEP***04**(2010) 020 [arXiv:1001.2887] [INSPIRE].ADSMathSciNetCrossRefMATHGoogle Scholar - [55]T. Matsuura, S.C. van der Marck and W.L. van Neerven,
*The calculation of the second order soft and virtual contributions to the Drell-Yan cross-section*,*Nucl. Phys.***B 319**(1989) 570 [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [56]F. Cascioli, P. Maierhofer and S. Pozzorini,
*Scattering amplitudes with open loops*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***108**(2012) 111601 [arXiv:1111.5206] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [57]J. Alwall et al.,
*MadGraph/MadEvent v*4*: the new web generation*,*JHEP***09**(2007) 028 [arXiv:0706.2334] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [58]K. Hagiwara, R.D. Peccei, D. Zeppenfeld and K. Hikasa,
*Probing the weak boson sector in e*^{+}*e*^{−}→*W*^{+}*W*^{−},*Nucl. Phys.***B 282**(1987) 253 [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [59]G.J. Gounaris, J. Layssac and F.M. Renard,
*Signatures of the anomalous Zγ and ZZ production at the lepton and hadron colliders*,*Phys. Rev.***D 61**(2000) 073013 [hep-ph/9910395] [INSPIRE]. - [60]F.A. Berends, W.T. Giele and H. Kuijf,
*Exact expressions for processes involving a vector boson and up to five partons*,*Nucl. Phys.***B 321**(1989) 39 [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [61]Z. Bern, D. Forde, D.A. Kosower and P. Mastrolia,
*Twistor-inspired construction of electroweak vector boson currents*,*Phys. Rev.***D 72**(2005) 025006 [hep-ph/0412167] [INSPIRE]. - [62]W.T. Giele and E.W.N. Glover,
*Higher order corrections to jet cross-sections in e*^{+}*e*^{−}*annihilation*,*Phys. Rev.***D 46**(1992) 1980 [INSPIRE].ADSGoogle Scholar - [63]L.W. Garland, T. Gehrmann, E.W.N. Glover, A. Koukoutsakis and E. Remiddi,
*Two loop QCD helicity amplitudes for e*^{+}*e*^{−}→ 3*jets*,*Nucl. Phys.***B 642**(2002) 227 [hep-ph/0206067] [INSPIRE]. - [64]T. Gehrmann and E. Remiddi,
*Analytic continuation of massless two loop four point functions*,*Nucl. Phys.***B 640**(2002) 379 [hep-ph/0207020] [INSPIRE]. - [65]I.W. Stewart, F.J. Tackmann and W.J. Waalewijn,
*N -jettiness: an inclusive event shape to veto jets*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***105**(2010) 092002 [arXiv:1004.2489] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [66]J. Gao, C.S. Li and H.X. Zhu,
*Top quark decay at next-to-next-to leading order in QCD*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***110**(2013) 042001 [arXiv:1210.2808] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [67]S. Catani and M.H. Seymour,
*A general algorithm for calculating jet cross-sections in NLO QCD*,*Nucl. Phys.***B 485**(1997) 291 [*Erratum ibid.***B 510**(1998) 503] [hep-ph/9605323] [INSPIRE]. - [68]S. Catani and M.H. Seymour,
*The dipole formalism for the calculation of QCD jet cross-sections at next-to-leading order*,*Phys. Lett.***B 378**(1996) 287 [hep-ph/9602277] [INSPIRE]. - [69]Particle Data Group collaboration, C. Patrignani et al.,
*Review of particle physics*,*Chin. Phys.***C 40**(2016) 100001 [INSPIRE]. - [70]L.A. Harland-Lang, A.D. Martin, P. Motylinski and R.S. Thorne,
*Parton distributions in the LHC era: MMHT*2014*PDFs*,*Eur. Phys. J.***C 75**(2015) 204 [arXiv:1412.3989] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [71]I. Moult, L. Rothen, I.W. Stewart, F.J. Tackmann and H.X. Zhu,
*Subleading power corrections for N -jettiness subtractions*,*Phys. Rev.***D 95**(2017) 074023 [arXiv:1612.00450] [INSPIRE].ADSGoogle Scholar - [72]I.W. Stewart, F.J. Tackmann and W.J. Waalewijn,
*Factorization at the LHC: from PDFs to initial state jets*,*Phys. Rev.***D 81**(2010) 094035 [arXiv:0910.0467] [INSPIRE].ADSGoogle Scholar - [73]I.W. Stewart, F.J. Tackmann and W.J. Waalewijn,
*The beam thrust cross section for Drell-Yan at NNLL order*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***106**(2011) 032001 [arXiv:1005.4060] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [74]C.F. Berger, C. Marcantonini, I.W. Stewart, F.J. Tackmann and W.J. Waalewijn,
*Higgs production with a central jet veto at NNLL+NNLO*,*JHEP***04**(2011) 092 [arXiv:1012.4480] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [75]J.M. Campbell, R.K. Ellis and C. Williams,
*Direct photon production at next-to-next-to-leading order*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***118**(2017) 222001 [arXiv:1612.04333] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [76]R. Boughezal, X. Liu and F. Petriello,
*Power corrections in the N -jettiness subtraction scheme*,*JHEP***03**(2017) 160 [arXiv:1612.02911] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [77]S. Dawson, P. Jaiswal, Y. Li, H. Ramani and M. Zeng,
*Resummation of jet veto logarithms at N*^{3}*LL*_{a}*+ NNLO for W*^{+}*W*^{−}*production at the LHC*,*Phys. Rev.***D 94**(2016) 114014 [arXiv:1606.01034] [INSPIRE].ADSGoogle Scholar - [78]ATLAS collaboration,
*Search for Higgs boson decays to a photon and a Z boson in pp collisions at*\( \sqrt{s}=7 \)*and*8*TeV with the ATLAS detector*,*Phys. Lett.***B 732**(2014) 8 [arXiv:1402.3051] [INSPIRE]. - [79]D.R. Green, P. Meade and M.-A. Pleier,
*Multiboson interactions at the LHC*,*Rev. Mod. Phys.***89**(2017) 035008 [arXiv:1610.07572] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [80]CDF collaboration, T. Aaltonen et al.,
*Limits on anomalous trilinear gauge couplings in Zγ events from pp collisions at*\( \sqrt{s}=1.96 \)*TeV*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***107**(2011) 051802 [arXiv:1103.2990] [INSPIRE]. - [81]D0 collaboration, V.M. Abazov et al.,
*Zγ production and limits on anomalous ZZγ and Zγγ couplings in*\( p\overline{p} \)*collisions at*\( \sqrt{s}=1.96 \)*TeV*,*Phys. Rev.***D 85**(2012) 052001 [arXiv:1111.3684] [INSPIRE]. - [82]A. Banfi, P.F. Monni, G.P. Salam and G. Zanderighi,
*Higgs and Z-boson production with a jet veto*,*Phys. Rev. Lett.***109**(2012) 202001 [arXiv:1206.4998] [INSPIRE].ADSCrossRefGoogle Scholar - [83]I.W. Stewart and F.J. Tackmann,
*Theory uncertainties for Higgs and other searches using jet bins*,*Phys. Rev.***D 85**(2012) 034011 [arXiv:1107.2117] [INSPIRE].ADSGoogle Scholar