Abstract
Objectives
To demonstrate how fuzzy cognitive maps may be used to extract, present and compare Aboriginal perspectives, using the determinants of diabetes as a case study.
Methods
Participants from the Mohawk Community of Akwesasne and the Miawpukek First Nation in Conne River created fuzzy cognitive maps (FCMs) (N=3) detailing their views of “the causes of diabetes in their community”, through a facilitated, group mapping session. For each FCM, the net causal effect of every determinant (direct or indirect) on diabetes was calculated from its transitive closure. The net causal effects were then compared across the set of FCMs to identify strong, weak and controversial determinants.
Results
Comparison of FCMs revealed significant heterogeneity in the perspectives of diabetes. The Akwesasne participants focused heavily on social, traditional and spiritual factors, while Conne River participants placed more importance on direct personal and lifestyle factors. There was, however, a core of strong, validated determinants related primarily to healthy diet and physical activity.
Conclusions
This work demonstrates how FCM may be used to extract and represent different perspectives of complex issues allowing for comparisons among stakeholders or knowledge groups. Comparison of multiple FCM employing the transitive closure may then be used to identify areas of agreement and controversy.
Résumé
Objectifs
Montrer comment les cartes cognitives floues peuvent être utilisées pour extraire, présenter et comparer des perspectives autochtones. Ici, ces perspectives ont porté sur les déterminants du diabète.
Méthode
Lors d’une séance de cartographie de groupe facilitée par un animateur, des participants de la communauté mohawk d’Akwesasne et de la Première nation Miawpukek de Conne River ont créé des cartes cognitives floues (CCF) (N=3) décrivant selon leurs points de vue « les causes du diabète dans leur communauté ». À partir de la fermeture transitive de chaque CCF, nous avons calculé l’effet causal net de chaque déterminant (direct ou indirect) sur le diabète. Les effets causals nets ont ensuite été comparés d’une CCF à l’autre pour repérer les déterminants forts, faibles et controversés.
Résultats
La comparaison des CCF a mis en évidence une grande hétérogénéité dans les perspectives du diabète. Les participants d’Akwesasne ont beaucoup insisté sur les facteurs sociaux, traditionnels et spirituels, tandis que ceux de Conne River ont accordé plus d’importance aux facteurs personnels directs et au mode de vie. Nous avons néanmoins extrait un solide noyau de déterminants validés, surtout liés à l’alimentation saine et à l’activité physique.
Conclusion
Ce travail montre comment on peut utiliser les CCF pour extraire et représenter des questions complexes selon différentes perspectives, et ainsi établir des comparaisons entre des intervenants ou des groupes détenant un savoir. La comparaison de multiples CCF par une opération de fermeture transitive peut ensuite servir à dégager des zones d’accord et de désaccord.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
McMillan HL, MacMillan AB, Offord DR, Dingle JL. Aboriginal health. CMAJ 1996;155(11):1569–78.
Young TK. Recent health trends in the Native American population. Population Res Policy Rev 1997;16:147–67.
Laupland KB, Karmali S, Kirkpatrick AW, Crowshoe L, Hameed SM. Distribution and determinants of critical illness among status Aboriginal Canadians. A population-based assessment. J Critical Care 2006;21:243–47.
Young TK, Reading J, Elias B, O’Neil JD. Type 2 diabetes mellitus in Canada’s First Nations: Status of an epidemic in progress. CMAJ 2000;163(5):561–65.
Health Canada. Diabetes among Aboriginal People in Canada: The Evidence. Ottawa, ON: Health Canada, 2000.
Anand SS, Yusuf S, Jacobs R, Davis AD, Yi Q, Gerstein H, et al. Risk factors, atherosclerosis and cardiovascular disease among Aboriginal people in Canada: The Study of Health Assessment and Risk Evaluation in Aboriginal People (SHARE-AP). Lancet 2001;358:1147–53.
Garro LC. Individual or societal responsibility? Explanations of diabetes in Anishinaabe (Ojibway) community. Soc Sci Med 1995;40(1):37–46.
London JA, Guthridge S. Aboriginal perspectives of diabetes in a remote community in the Northern Territory. Aust N Z J Public Health 1998;22(6):726–28.
Thompson SJ, Gifford SM. Trying to keep a balance: The meaning of health and diabetes in an urban Aboriginal community. Soc Sci Med 2000;51:1457–72.
Iwasaki Y, Bartlett J, O’Neil J. Coping with stress among Aboriginal women and men with diabetes in Winnipeg, Canada. Soc Sci Med 2005;60:977–88.
Sunday J, Eyles J. Managing and treating risk and uncertainty for health: A case study of diabetes among First Nation’s people in Ontario, Canada. Soc Sci Med 2001;52:635–50.
Garvey G, Towney P, McPhee JR, Little M, Kerridge IH. Is there an Aboriginal bioethic? J Med Ethics 2004;30:570–75.
Gibson N, Cave A, Doering D, Ortiz L, Harms P. Socio-cultural factors influencing prevention and treatment of tuberculosis in immigrant and aboriginal communities in Canada. Soc Sci Med 2005;61:931–42.
Boston P, Jordan S, MacNamara E, Kozolanka K, Bobbish-Rondeau E, Iserhoff H, et al. Using participatory action research to understand the meanings Aboriginal Canadians attribute to the rising incidence of diabetes. Chron Dis Can 1997;18(1):1–11.
Harris SB. What works? Success stories in Type 2 diabetes mellitus. Diabetic Med 1998;15(Suppl 4):S20–S23.
Bisset S, Cargo M, Delormier T, Macaulay AC, Potvin L. Legitimizing diabetes as a community health issue: A case analysis of an aboriginal community in Canada. Health Promot Int 2004;19(3):317–26.
Grams G, Herbert C, Heffernan C, Calam B, Wilson MA, Grzybowski S, Brown D. Haida perspectives on living with non-insulin-dependent diabetes. CMAJ 1996;155(11):1563–68.
Gregory D, Whalley W, Olson J, Bain M, Harper GG, Roberts L, Russell C. Exploring the experience of type 2 diabetes in urban aboriginal people. Can J Nurs Res 1999;31(1):1010–15.
Daniel M, Rowley KG, Herbert CP, O’Dea K, Green LW. Lipids and psychosocial status in aboriginal persons with and at risk for Type 2 diabetes: Implications for tertiary prevention. Patient Educ Counseling 2001;43:85–95.
Daniel M, Messer LC. Perceptions of disease severity and barriers to self-care predict glycemic control in Aboriginal persons with type 2 diabetes mellitus. Chron Dis Can 2002;23(4):130–38.
Giles BG, Haas G, Findlay CS. Incorporating First Nations health perspectives and traditional knowledge into health risk assessment models. Final Report to Assembly of First Nations. Ottawa, ON: Institute of the Environment, University of Ottawa, 2005.
Giles BG, Findlay CS, Haas G, LaFrance B, Laughing W, Pembleton S. Integrating conventional science and aboriginal perspectives on diabetes using fuzzy cognitive maps. Soc Sci Med 2007;64:562–76.
Kosko B. Fuzzy cognitive maps. Int Man and Machine Studies 1986;24:65–75.
Gross JL, Yellen J. Handbook of Graph Theory. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, 2004.
Šajna M. Two models for transitive closure of a bipolar weighted digraph. (Unpublished document) Available online at: https://doi.org/www.mathstat.uottawa.ca/ ~msajn339/articles/FCM.pdf (Accessed September 16, 2008).
Rowley KG, O’Dea K. Diabetes in Australian aboriginal and Torre Strait Islander peoples. Papua New Guinea Med J 2001;44(3-4):164–70.
Daniel M, Rowley KG, McDermott R, O’Dea K. Diabetes and impaired glucose tolerance in aboriginal Australians: Prevalence and risk. Diabetes Res Clin Pract 2002;57:23–33.
Ben-Haroush A, Yogev Y, Hod M. Epidemiology of gestational diabetes mellitus and its association with Type 2 diabetes. Diabetes Med 2004;21:103–13.
Bruce SG. The impact of diabetes mellitus among the Métis of Western Canada. Ethnicity and Health 2000;5(1):47–57.
Hanley AJ, Harris SB, Gittelsohn J, Wolever TM, Saksvig B, Zinman B. Overweight among children and adolescents in a Native Canadian community: Prevalence and associated factors. Am J Clin Nutr 2000;71:693–700.
Wang Z, Hoy WE. Hypertension, dyslipidemia, body mass index, diabetes and smoking status in Aboriginal Australians in a remote community. Ethnicity and Disease 2003;13(3):324–30.
Hobbs BF, Ludsin SA, Knight RL, Ryan PA, Biberhofer J, Ciborowski JJH. Fuzzy cognitive mapping as a tool to define management objectives for complex ecosystems. Ecological Applications 2002;12(5):1548–65.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Giles, B.G., Haas, G., Šajna, M. et al. Exploring Aboriginal Views of Health Using Fuzzy Cognitive Maps and Transitive Closure. Can J Public Health 99, 411–417 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03405252
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03405252