Skip to main content
SpringerLink
Log in

The Search for Stimulus Equivalence in Nonverbal Organisms

  • Article
  • Published:
The Psychological Record Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

A currently unresolved issue in stimulus equivalence research is the relation of equivalence and language competence. The current consensus is that equivalence according to widely adopted criteria proposed by Sidman has not yet been demonstrated in nonverbal experimental subjects. This judgment rests primarily on the failure of nonhuman subjects to display the equivalence outcome under conditions comparable to those used with human subjects. We discuss theoretical and methodological issues that arise in research seeking to delineate the “lower limits” of equivalence phenomena in studies with laboratory animals or nonverbal humans. We propose a behavior-analytic approach to the question, examine the relationship between functional stimulus classes and equivalence classes, and describe some preliminary studies.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Log in via an institution

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • BHATT, R. S., WASSERMAN, E. A., REYNOLDS, W. F., & KNAUSS, K. S. (1988). Conceptual behavior in pigeons: Categorization of both familiar and novel examples from four classes of natural and artificial stimuli. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes, 14, 219–234.

    Google Scholar 

  • BOYSEN, S. T., & BERNTSON, G. G. (1989). Numerical competence in a chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes). Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology, 103, 23–31.

    Google Scholar 

  • CARRIGAN, P. F., Jr., & SIDMAN, M. (1992). Conditional discrimination and equivalence relations: A theoretical analysis of control by negative stimuli. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 58, 183–204.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • CARTER, D. E., & WERNER, T. J. (1978). Complex learning and information processing by pigeons: A critical analysis. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior; 29, 565–601.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • CERUTTI, D. T., & RUMBAUGH, D. M. (1993: this issue). Stimulus relations in comparative primate perspective. The Psychological Record, 43, 811–822.

    Google Scholar 

  • COHEN, J. S., GRASSI, J., & DOWSON, P. (1988). The role of within-trial location of the retention interval in rats delayed conditional discrimination performance’. Animal Learning and Behavior, 16, 40–66.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • D’AMATO, M. R., & COLOMBO, M. (1985). Auditory matching-to-sample in monkeys (Cebus apella). Animal Learning and Behavior, 13, 375–382.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • D’AMATO, M. R., & SALMON, D. (1982). Tune discrimination in monkeys (Cebus apella) and rats. Animal Learning and Behavior, 10, 126–134.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • D’AMATO, M. R., & SALMON, D. (1984). Processing of complex auditory stimuli (tunes) by rats and monkeys (Cebus apella). Animal Learning and Behavior, 12, 184–194.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • D’AMATO, M. R., SALMON, D., LOUKAS, E., & TOMIE, A. (1985). Symmetry and transitivity of conditional relations in monkeys (Cebus apella) and pigeons (Columba livia). Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 44, 35–47.

    PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • D’AMATO, M. R., SALMON, D. P., LOUKAS, E., & TOMIE, A. (1986). Processing of identity and conditional relations in monkeys (Cebus apella) and pigeons (Columba livia). Animal Learning and Behavior, 14, 365–373.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • DE ROSE, J. C., MCILVANE, W. J., DUBE, W. V., & STODDARD, L. T (1988). Stimulus class formation and functional equivalence in moderately retarded individuals conditional discrimination’. Behavioural Processes, 17, 167–175.

    Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  • DEVANY, J. M., HAYES, S. C., & NELSON, R. O. (1986). Equivalence class formation in language-able and language-disabled children. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 46, 243–257.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • DUBE, W. V., CALLAHAN, T. D., & MCILVANE, W. J. (1993). Serial reversals of concurrent auditory discriminations in rats. The Psychological Record, 43, 429–440.

    Google Scholar 

  • DUBE, W. V., IENNACO, F. M., ROCCO, F. J., KLEDARAS, J. B., & MCILVANE, W. J. (1992). Microcomputer-based programmed instruction in identity matching to sample for persons with severe disabilities. Journal of Behavioral Education, 2, 29–51.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • DUBE, W. V., MCDONALD, S. J., & MCILVANE, W. J. (1991). A note on the relationship between equivalence classes and functional stimulus classes. Experimental Analysis of Human Behavior Bulletin, 9, 7–11.

    Google Scholar 

  • DUBE, W. V., MCILVANE, W. J., & GREEN, G. (1992). An analysis of generalized identity matching-to-sample test procedures. The Psychological Record, 42, 17–28.

    Google Scholar 

  • DUBE, W. V, MCILVANE, W. J., MACKAY, H. A., & STODDARD, L. T. (1987). Stimulus class membership established via stimulus-reinforcer relations. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 47, 159–175.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • DUBE, W. V, MCILVANE, W. J., MAGUIRE, R. A., MACKAY, H. A., & STODDARD, L. T. (1989). Stimulus class formation and stimulus-reinforcer relations. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 51, 65–76.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • DUGDALE, N., & LOWE, C. F. (1990). Naming and stimulus equivalence. In D. E. Blackman & H. Lejeune (Eds.), Behviour analysis in theory and practice: Contributions and controversies (pp. 115–138). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

    Google Scholar 

  • GALLOWAY, C., & PETRIE, R. D. (1968). An analysis of the functional equivalence of stimulus class members. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 6, 384–390.

    Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  • GOETERS, S., BLAKELY, E., & POLING, A. (1992). The differential outcomes effect. The Psychological Record, 42, 389–411.

    Google Scholar 

  • GOLDIAMOND, I. (1962). Perception. In A. J. Bachrach (Ed.), Experimental foundations of clinical psychology (pp. 280–340). New York: Basic Books.

    Google Scholar 

  • GOLDIAMOND, I. (1966). Perception, language, and conceptualization rules. In B. Kleinmuntz (Ed.), Problem solving (pp. 183–224). New York: Wiley.

    Google Scholar 

  • GRAY, L. (1966). Backward associations in the pigeon. Psychonomic Science, 4, 333–334.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • HARRISON, J. M. (1988). Control of responding by sounds of different quality: An evolutionary analysis. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 50, 521–539.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • HARRISON, J. M. (1992). Avoiding conflicts between the natural behavior of the animal and the demands of discrimination experiments. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 92, 1331–1345.

    Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  • HAYES, S. C. (1989). Nonhumans have not yet shown stimulus equivalence. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 51, 385–392.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • HERMAN, L. M. (1988). The language of animal language research. The Psychological Record, 38, 349–362.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • HERMAN, L. M. (1989). In which Procrustean bed does the sea lion sleep tonight? The Psychological Record, 39, 19–50.

    Google Scholar 

  • HERMAN, L. M., HOVANCIK, J. R., GORY, J. D., & BRADSHAW, G. L. (1989). Generalization of visual matching by a bottlenosed dolphin (Tursiops truncatus): Evidence for invariance of cognitive performance with visual and auditory materials. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes, 15, 124–136.

    Google Scholar 

  • HERRNSTEIN, R. J., LOVELAND, D. H., & CABLE, C. (1976). Natural concepts in pigeons. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes, 2, 285–302.

    Google Scholar 

  • KENDALL, S. B. (1983). Tests for mediated transfer in pigeons. The Psychological Record, 33, 245–256.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • KONORSKI, J. (1959). A new method of psychological investigation of recent memory in animals. Bulletin de L’academie Polonaise des Sciences, 7, 115–119.

    Google Scholar 

  • LAZAR, R. (1977). Extending sequence-class membership with matching to sample. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 27, 381–392.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • LIPKENS, R., KOP, P. F. M., & MATTHIJS, W. (1988). A test for symmetry and transitivity in the conditional discrimination performances of pigeons. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 49, 395–409.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • MACKAY, H. A., & SIDMAN, M. (1984). Teaching new behavior via equivalence relations. In P. H. Brooks, R. Sperber, & C. MacCauley (Eds.), Learning and cognition in the mentally retarded (pp. 493–513). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

    Google Scholar 

  • MCILVANE, W. J., & DUBE, W. V. (1992). Stimulus control shaping and stimulus control topographies. The Behavior Analyst, 15, 89–94.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • MCILVANE, W. J., DUBE, W. V., KLEDARAS, J. B., IENNACO, F. M., & STODDARD, L. T. (1989). Stimulus-consequence relations and stimulus classes in mental retardation. Experimental Analysis of Human Behavior Bulletin, 7, 17–20.

    Google Scholar 

  • MCILVANE, W. J., DUBE, W. V., KLEDARAS, J. B., IENNACO, F. M., & STODDARD, L. T. (1990). Teaching relational discrimination to individuals with mental retardation: Some problems and possible solutions. American Journal on Mental Retardation, 95, 283–296.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  • MCILVANE, W. J., KLEDARAS, J. B., DUBE, W. V., & STODDARD, L. T. (1989). Automated instruction of severely and profoundly retarded individuals. In J. Mulick & R. Antonak (Eds.), Transitions in mental retardation, Vol. 4 (pp. 15–76). Norwood, NJ: Ablex.

    Google Scholar 

  • MCINTIRE, K. D., CLEARY, J., & THOMPSON, T. (1987). Conditional relations by monkeys: Reflexivity, symmetry, and transitivity. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 47, 279–285.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • MCINTIRE, K. D., CLEARY, J., & THOMPSON, T. (1989). Reply to Saunders and Hayes. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 51, 393–396.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • NEILL, J. C., & HARRISON, J. M. (1987). Auditory discrimination: Konorski’s quality-location effect. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 48, 81–95.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • ODEN, D. L., THOMPSON, R. K. R., & PREMACK, D. (1988). Spontaneous transfer of matching by infant chimpanzees. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes, 14, 140–145.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  • PACK, A. A., HERMAN, L. M., & ROITBLAT, H. L. (1991). Generalization of visual matching and delayed matching by a California sea lion (Zalophus californianus). Animal Learning and Behavior, 19, 37–48.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • PETERSON, G. B. (1984). How expectancies guide behavior. In H. L. Roitblat, T. G. Bever, & H. S. Terrace (Eds.), Animal cognition (pp. 135–148). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

    Google Scholar 

  • PISACRETA, R., GOUGH, D., KRAMER, J., & SCHULTZ, W. (1989). Some factors that influence transfer of oddity performance in the pigeon. The Psychological Record, 39, 221–246.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • POSNER, M. I., PETERSEN, S. E., FOX, P. T., & RAICHLE, M. E. (1988). Localization of cognitive operations in the human brain. Science, 240, 1627–1631.

    Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  • PREMACK, D. (1986). Gavagair or the future history of the animal language controversy Cambridge, MA: Mit Press.

    Google Scholar 

  • RODEWALD, H. K. (1974). Symbolic matching-to-sample by pigeons. Psychological Reports, 34, 987–990.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • RUMBAUGH, D. M. (1990). Comparative psychology and the great apes: Their competence in learning, language, and numbers. The Psychological Record, 40, 15–39.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  • RUMBAUGH, D. M., HOPKINS, W. D., WASHBURN, D. A., & SAVAGE-RUMBAUGH, E. S. (1989). Lana chimpanzee learns to count by “Numath”: A summary of a videotaped experimental report. The Psychological Record, 39, 459–470.

    Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  • SAUNDERS, K. J. (1989). Naming in conditional discrimination and stimulus equivalence. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 51, 379–384.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • SAUNDERS, R. R., & GREEN, G. (1992). The nonequivalence of behavioral and mathematical equivalence. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 57, 227–241.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • SAUNDERS, K. J., & SPRADLIN, J. E. (1990). Conditional discrimination in mentally retarded adults: The development of generalized skills. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 54, 239–250.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • SAVAGE-RUMBAUGH, E. S., RUMBAUGH, D. M., SMITH, S. T., & LAWSON, J. (1980). Reference: The linguistic essential. Science, 210, 922–925.

    Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  • SCHUSTERMAN, R. J., & GISINER, R. C. (1989). Please parse the sentence: Animal cognition in the procrustean bed of linguistics. The Psychological Record, 39, 3–18.

    Google Scholar 

  • SCHUSTERMAN, R. J., GISINER, R., GRIMM, B. K., & HANGGI, E. B. (1993). Behavior control by exclusion and attempts at establishing semanticity in marine mammals using match-to-sample paradigms. In H. Roitblat, L. Herman, & P. Nachtigall (Eds.), Language and communication: Comparative perspectives (pp. 249–274). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

    Google Scholar 

  • SIDMAN, M. (1986). The measurement of behavioral development. In N. A. Krasnegor, D. B. Gray, & T. Thompson (Eds.), Advances in behavioral pharmacology, Vol. 5: Developmental behavioral pharmacology (pp. 43–52). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

    Google Scholar 

  • SIDMAN, M. (1990). Equivalence relations: Where do they come from? In D. E. Blackman & H. Lejeune (Eds.), Behviour analysis in theory and practice: Contributions and controversies (pp. 93–114). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

    Google Scholar 

  • SIDMAN, M., RAUZIN, R., LAZAR, R., CUNNINGHAM, S., TAILBY, W., & CARRIGAN, P. (1982). A search for symmetry in the conditional discrimination of rhesus monkeys, baboons, and children. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 37, 23–44.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • SIDMAN, M., & STODDARD, L. T. (1966). Programming perception and learning for retarded children. In N. R. Ellis (Ed.), International Review of Research in Mental Retardation, Vol. 2 (pp. 151–208). New York: Academic Press.

    Google Scholar 

  • SIDMAN, M., & TAILBY, W. (1982). Conditional discrimination vs. matching-to-sample: An expansion of the testing paradigm. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 37, 5–22.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • SIDMAN, M., WYNNE, C. K., MAGUIRE, R. W., & BARNES, T. (1989). Functional classes and equivalence relations. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior; 52, 261–274.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • SILVERMAN, K., ANDERSON, S. R., MARSHALL, A. M., & BAER, D. M. (1986). Establishing and generalizing audience control of new language repertoires. Analysis and Intervention in Developmental Disabilities, 6, 21–40.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • SKINNER, B. F. (1935). The generic nature of the concepts of stimulus and response. Journal of General Psychology, 12, 40–65.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • STODDARD, L. T. (1982). An investigation of automated methods for teaching severely retarded individuals. In N. R. Ellis (Ed.), International review of research in mental retardation (pp. 163–207). New York: Academic Press.

    Google Scholar 

  • TOMONAGA, M. (1993). Tests for control by exclusion and negative stimulus relations of arbitrary matching to sample in a “symmetry-emergent” chimpanzee. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 59, 215–229.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • TOMONAGA, M., MATZUSAWA, T., FUJITA, K., & YAMAMOTO, J. (1991). Emergence of symmetry in a visual conditional discrimination by chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes). Psychological Reports, 68, 51–60.

    Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  • TRAPOLD, M. (1970). Are expectancies based upon different positive reinforcing events discriminably different? Learning and Motivation, 1, 129–140.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • URCUIOLI, P. J., & ZENTALL, T. R. (1993: this issue). A test of comparison-stimulus substitutability following one-to-many matching by pigeons. The Psychological Record, 43, 745–760.

    Google Scholar 

  • VAUGHAN, W. (1988). Formation of equivalence sets in pigeons. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes, 14, 36–42.

    Google Scholar 

  • VAUGHAN, W. (1989). Reply to Hayes. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 51, 397.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • WASHBURN, D. A., HOPKINS, W. D., & RUMBAUGH, D. M. (1989). Video-task assessment of learning and memory in macaques (Macaca mulatta): Effects of stimulus movement on performance. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes, 15, 393–400.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  • WASSERMAN, E. A. (1976). Successive matching-to-sample in the pigeon: Variations on a theme by Konorski. Behavior Research Methods and Instrumentation, 8, 278–282.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • WILKIE, D. M., & WILSON, C. S. (1977). Control of pigeons pecking by trace stimuli’. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 27, 293–299.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  • WRIGHT, A. A., COOK, R. G., RIVERA, J. J., SANDS, S. F., & DELIUS, J. D. (1988). Concept learning by pigeons: Matching-to-sample with trial-unique video picture stimuli. Animal Learning and Behavior, 16, 436–444.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • ZENTALL, T. R., & URCUIOLI, P. J. (1993: this issue). Emergent relations in the formation of stimulus classes by pigeons. The Psychological Record, 43, 795–810.

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

  1. Behavioral Sciences Division, E. K. Shriver Center, 200 Trapelo Road, Waltham, MA, 02254, USA

    William V. Dube, William J. McIlvane, Thomas D. Callahan & Lawrence T. Stoddard

Authors
  1. William V. Dube
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  2. William J. McIlvane
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  3. Thomas D. Callahan
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  4. Lawrence T. Stoddard
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Additional information

This research was supported by the Department of Mental Retardation of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts (Contract 100220023SC); manuscript preparation was supported in part by NICHD grants HD 25995 and HD 25488.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Dube, W.V., McIlvane, W.J., Callahan, T.D. et al. The Search for Stimulus Equivalence in Nonverbal Organisms. Psychol Rec 43, 761–778 (1993). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03395911

Download citation

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03395911

Search

Navigation