IFRS 4 Insurance Contracts — verbesserte Versicherungsrechnungslegung?

Abstract

IFRS 4, issued at March 31^st, 2004, represents phase I of the IASB project on insurance accounting enabling insurance companies in the European Economic Area to prepare their financial statements according to IAS/IFRS by providing basic rules. The incentives resulting from the „temporary“ declaration are rather complex; IFRS 4 contains only few provisions including temporary choices in accounting treatment. Although phase II of the insurance project dealing with insurance liabilities and other actuarial positions is rather well predictable in many respects the IASB keeps a significant scope of discretion for this phase. IFRS 4 does not represent a self-contained accounting concept; the asset and the debit side of the balance sheet are not coordinated, the former is characterized by a significantly higher volatility. IFRS 4 merely aims at „limited improvements to accounting (…) for insurance contracts“. This moderate objective can be regarded as accomplished. Some of the new mandatory regulations, however, are internationally controversial issues. The effects of IFRS 4 on the price of shares and the cost of capital of insurance companies represent a worthwhile issue for research. Increased transparency, especially due to additional disclosure requirements, and enhanced volatility are opposing each other, and it is rather difficult to assess which effect will predominate under which circumstances.