Abstract
Component commonality — the use of the same version of a component across multiple products — is being increasingly considered as a promising way to offer high external variety while retaining low internal variety in operations. However, increasing commonality has both positive and negative cost effects, so that optimization approaches are required to identify an optimal commonality level. As components influence to a greater or lesser extent nearly every process step along the supply chain, it is not surprising that a multitude of diverging commonality problems is being investigated in literature, each of which are developing a specific algorithm designed for the respective commonality problem being considered. The paper on hand aims at a general framework which is flexible and efficient enough to be applied to a wide range of commonality problems. Such a procedure based on a two-stage graph approach is presented and tested. Finally, flexibility of the procedure is shown by customizing the framework to account for different types of commonality problems.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Avella, Pasquale, Maurizio Boccia, Carmine Di Martino, Giuseppe Oliviero, Antonio Sforza, and Igor Vasil’ev (2005): A decomposition approach for a very large scale optimal diversity management problem, 4OR, 3 (1): 23–37.
Baker, Kenneth R. (1985): Safety stocks and component commonality, Journal of Operations Management, 6 (1): 13–22.
Baker, Kenneth R., Michael J. Magazine, and Henry L. W. Nuttle (1986): The effect of commonality on safety stock in a simple inventory model, Management Science, 32 (8): 982–988.
Boysen, Nils and Malte Fliedner (2008): A versatile algorithm for assembly line balancing, European Journal of Operational Research, 184 (1): 39–56.
Boysen, Nils, Malte Fliedner, and Armin Scholl (2009a): Level scheduling of mixed-model assembly lines under storage constraints, International Journal of Production Research, 47 (1): 2669–2684.
Boysen, Nils, Malte Fliedner, and Armin Scholl (2009b): Assembly line balancing: Joint precedence graphs under high product variety, IIE Transactions, 41 (1): 183–193.
Briant, Olivier (2000): Etude théorique et numérique du problème de la gestion de la diversité, Ph.D. thesis, Institut national polytechnique de Grenoble, Grenoble, France.
Briant, Olivier and Denis Naddef (2004): The optimal diversity management problem, Operations Research, 52 (4): 515–526.
Burbidge, John L. (1991): Production flow analysis for planning group technology, Journal of Operations Management, 10 (1): 5–27.
Collier, David A. (1982): Aggregate safety stock levels and component part commonality, Management Science, 28 (11): 1296–1303.
Dar-El, Ezey M. (2000): Human learning: From learning curves to learning organizations, 1st ed., Springer: Berlin.
Desai, Preyas, Sunder Kekre, Suresh Radhakrishnan, and Kannan Srinivasan (2001): Product differentiation and commonality in design: Balancing revenue and cost drivers, Management Science, 47 (1): 37–51.
Dogramaci, Ali (1979): Design of common components considering implications of inventory costs and forecasting, AIIE Transactions, 11 (2): 129–135.
Dorigo, Marco, Gianni Di Caro, and Luca M. Gambardella (1999): Ant algorithms for discrete optimization, Artificial Life, 5 (2): 137–172.
Ervolina, Thomas R., Markus Ettl, Young M. Lee, and Daniel J. Peters (2009): Managing product availability in an assemble-to-order supply chain with multiple customer segments, OR Spectrum, 31 (1): 257–280.
Eynan, Amit and Meir J. Rosenblatt (1996): Component-commonality effects on inventory costs, IIE Transactions, 28 (2): 93–104.
Fisher, Marshall, Kamalini Ramdas, and Karl Ulrich (1999): Component sharing in the management of product variety: A study of automotive braking systems, Management Science, 45 (3): 297–315.
Gerchak, Yigal, Michael J. Magazine, and Bruce A. Gamble (1988): Component commonality with service level requirements, Management Science, 34 (6): 753–760.
Green, Paul E. and Abba M. Krieger (1985): Models and heuristics for product line selection, Marketing Science, 4 (1): 1–19.
Gupta, Saurabh and Vish Krishnan (1999): Integrated component and supplier selection for a product family, Production and Operations Management, 8 (2): 163–182.
Hanssmann, Friedrich (1957): Determination of optimal capacities of service for facilities with a linear measure of ineffciency, Operations Research, 5 (5): 713–717.
Hesse, Hans Sebastian and Jayashankar M. Swaminathan (2006): Product line design with component commonality and cost-reduction effort, Manufacturing Service Operations Management, 8 (2): 206–219.
Hillier, Mark S. (2000): Component-commonality in multiple-period, assemble-to-order systems, IIE Transactions, 32: 755–766.
Hillier, Mark S. (2002): Using commonality as backup safety stock, European Journal of Operational Research, 136 (2): 353–365.
Jans, Raf, Zeger Degreave, and Luc Schepens (2008): Analysis of an industrial component commonality problem, European Journal of Operational Research, 186 (2): 801–811.
Karup, Jakob and Peter M. Pruzan (1983): The simple plant location problem: Survey and synthesis, European Journal of Operational Research, 12 (1): 36–81.
Kim, Kilsun and Dilip Chhajed (2000): Commonality in product design: Cost savings, valuation change and cannibalization, European Journal of Operational Research, 125 (3): 602–621.
King, John R. and Vias Nakornchai (1982): Machine-component group formation in group technology: Review and extension, International Journal of Production Research, 20 (2): 117–133.
Klose, Andreas and Andreas Drexl (2005): Facility location models for distribution system design, European Journal of Operational Research, 162 (1): 4–29.
Krishnan, Viswanathan, Rahul Singh, and Devanath Tirupati (1999): A model-based approach for planning and developing a family of technology based products, Manufacturing Service Operations Management, 1(2): 132–156.
Labro, Eva (2004): The cost effects of component commonality: a literature review through a management-accounting lens, Manufacturing Service Operations Management, 6 (4): 358–367.
Lang, Jan C. and Wolfgang Domschke (2008): Efficient reformulations for dynamic lot-sizing problems with product substitution, OR Spectrum, 23 (1): 1–29.
Ma, Shihua, Weii Wang, and Liming Liu (2002): Commonality and postponement in multistage assembly systems, European Journal of Operational Research, 142 (3): 523–538.
McClain, John O., William L. Maxwell, John A. Muckstadt, L. Joseph Thomas, and Elliott N. Weiss (1984): Comment on: Aggregate safety stock levels and component part commonality, Management Science, 30 (6): 772–773.
Nair, Suresh K., Lakshman S. Thakur, and Kuang-Wei Wen (1995): Near optimal solutions for product line design and selection: Beam search heuristics, Management Science, 41 (5): 767–785.
Pentico, David W. (2008): The assortment problem: A survey, European Journal of Operational Research, 190 (2): 95–309.
Perera, H. S. C., Nagen Nagarur, and Mario T. Tabucanon (1999): Component part standardization: A way to reduce the life-cycle costs of products, International Journal of Production Economics, 60–61 (1): 109–116.
Ramdas, Kamalini (2003): Managing product variety: An integrative review and research directions, Production and Operations Management, 12 (1): 79–101.
Ramdas, Kamalini and Mohanbir S. Sawhney (2001): A Cross-functional approach to evaluating multiple line extensions for assembled products, Management Science, 47 (1): 22–36.
Ramdas, Kamalini, Marshall Fisher, and Karl Ulrich (2003): Managing variety for assembled products: Modeling component systems sharing, Manufacturing Service Operations Management, 5 (2): 142–156.
Rutenberg, David P. (1971): Design commonality to reduce multi-item inventory: Optimal depth of a product line, Operations Research, 19 (2): 491–509.
Sadowski, Wieslaw (1959): A few remarks on the assortment problem, Management Science, 6 (1): 13–24.
Saigal, Romesh (1968): A constrained shortest route problem, Operations Research, 16 (1): 205–209.
Stützle, Thomas and Marco Dorigo (1999): ACO algorithms for the quadratic assignment problem, in: David W. Corne, Marco Dorigo, and Fred Glover (eds.): New Ideas in Optimization, McGraw-Hill: 33–50.
Swaminathan, Jayashankar M. (2001): Enabling customization using standardized operations, California Management Review, 43 (3): 125–135.
Swaminathan, Jayashankar M. and Hau L. Lee (2004): in: S.C. Graves, and A.G. De Kok (eds.): Handbooks in Operations Research and Management Science 11, Supply Chain Management: Design, Coordination, and Operation, Elsevier: 199–226.
Swift, Ken G., Julian Booker, and Nigel Foden Edmondson (2004): Strategies and case studies in assembly system selection, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part B: Journal of Engineering Manufacture, 218 (7): 675–688.
Tallon, William J. (1989): A comparative analysis of master production scheduling techniques for assembly-to-order products, Decision Science, 20 (3): 492–506.
Thomas, Lawrence Dale (1991): Commonality analysis using clustering methods, Operations Research, 39 (4): 677–680.
Thonemann, Ulrich W. and Margaret L. Brandeau (2000): Optimal commonality in component design, Operations Research, 48 (1): 1–19.
Ulrich, Karl (1995): The role of product architecture in the manufacturing firm, Research Policy, 24 (3): 419–440.
Wagner, Harvey M. and Thomson M. Whitin (1958): Dynamic version of the economic lot size model, Management Science, 5 (1): 89–96.
Wildemann, Horst (1994): Fertigungsstrategien, 2nd ed., TCW: München.
Wright, T.P. (1936): Factors Affecting the Cost of Airplanes, Journal of Aeronautical Sciences, 3(2): 122–128.
Yelle, Louis E. (1979): The learning curve: Historical review and comprehensive survey, Decision Science, 10 (2): 302–328.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits use, duplication, adaptation, distribution, and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
About this article
Cite this article
Boysen, N., Scholl, A. A General Solution Framework for Component-Commonality Problems. Bus Res 2, 86–106 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03343530
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03343530