Abstract
Since the Sarbanes-Oxley Act was passed in 2002, it has become commonplace in the advertising industry to use creativity-award-show prizes instead of gross income figures to attract new customers. Therefore, achieving a top creativity ranking and winning creativity awards have become high priorities in the advertising industry. Agencies and marketers have always wondered what elements in the advertising creation process would lead to the winning of creativity awards. Although this debate has been dominated by pure speculation about the success of different routines, approaches and strategies in winning creativity awards, for the first time our study delivers an empirical insight into the key drivers of creativity award success. We investigate what strategies and which elements of an advertising campaign are truly likely to lead to winning the maximum number of creativity awards. Using a sample of 108 campaigns, we identify factors that influence campaign success at international advertising award shows. We identify innovativeness and the integration of multiple channels as the key drivers of creativity award success. In contrast to industry beliefs, meaningful or personally connecting approaches do not seem to generate a significant benefit in terms of winning creativity awards. Finally, our data suggest that the use of so-called “fake campaigns” to win more creativity awards does not prove to be effective.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Aitchison, Jim (1999): Cutting Edge Advertising: How to Create the World’s Best for Brands in the 21st Century, Prentice Hall: Singapore.
Amabile, Teresa M. (1983): The Social Psychology of Creativity: A Componential Conceptualization, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 45 (2): 357–376.
Amabile, Teresa M. (1988): A Model Of Creativity And Innovation In Organizations, Research in Organizational behavior, 10: 123–169.
Amabile, Teresa M. (1993): What Does a Theory of Creativity Require?, Psychological Inquiry, 4 (3): 179–181.
Amabile, Teresa M. (1997): Motivating Creativity in Organizations: On Doing What You Love and Loving What You Do, California Management Review, 40 (1): 39–58.
Amabile, Teresa M. (1998): How to Kill Creativity, Harvard Business Review, 76 (5): 76–86.
Amabile, Teresa M., Regina Conti, Heather Coon, Jeffrey Lazenby, and Michael Herron (1996): Assesing the Work Enviroment for Creativity, Academy of Management Journal, 39 (5): 1154–1184.
Amabile, Teresa M., Elizabeth M. Tighe, Karl G. Hill, and Beth A. Hennessey (1994): The Work Preference Inventory: Assessing Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivational Orientations, Journal of Personality & Social Psychology, 66 (5): 950–967.
Andrews, Jonlee and Daniel C. Smith (1996): In Search of the Marketing Imagination: Factors Affecting the Creativity of Marketing Programs for Mature Products, Journal of Marketing Research, 33 (2): 174–187.
Ang, Swee Hoon, Yih Hwai Lee, and Siew Meng Leong (2007): The Ad Creativity Cube: Conceptualization and Initial Validation, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 35 (2): 220–232.
Ang, Swee Hoon and Sharon Y.M Low (2000): Exploring the Dimensions of Ad Creativity, Psychology & Marketing, 17 (10): 835–854.
Baack, Daniel W., Rick T. Wilson, and Brian D. Till (2008): Creativity and Memory Effects, Journal of Advertising, 37 (4): 85–94.
Barney, Jay (1991): Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage, Journal of Management, 17 (1): 99–120.
Barney, Jay (2001): Is the Resource-Based ‘View’ a Useful Perspective for Strategic Management Research? Yes, Academy of Management Review, 26 (1): 41–56.
Barron, Frank (1955): The Disposition toward Originality, Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 51 (3): 478–485.
Barron, Frank and David M. Harrington (1981): Creativity, Intelligence, and Personality, Annual Review of Psychology, 32 (1): 439–476.
Bell, Jack A. (1992): Creativity, TV Commercial Popularity, and Advertising Expenditures, International Journal of Advertising, 11 (2): 165–183.
Bergkvist, Lars and John R. Rossiter (2007): The Predictive Validity of Multiple-Item Versus Single-Item Measures of the Same Constructs, Journal of Marketing Research, 44 (2): 175–184.
Bergkvist, Lars and John R. Rossiter (2008): The Role of Ad Likability in Predicting an AD’s Campaign Performance, Journal of Advertising, 37 (2): 85–97.
Besemer, Susan and Karen O’Quin (1986): Analyzing Creative Products: Refinement and Test of a Judging Instrument, Journal of Creative behavior, 20 (2): 115–126.
Besemer, Susan and Donald Treffinger (1981): Analysis of Creative Products: Review and Synthesis, Journal of Creative behavior, 15 (3): 158–178.
Blasko, Vincent, J. and Michael P. Mokwa (1986): Creativity in Advertising: A Janusian Perspective, Journal of Advertising, 15 (4): 43–50+72.
Bogart, Leo, B. Stuart Tolley, and Frank Orenstein (1970): What One Little Ad Can Do, Journal of Advertising Research, 10 (4): 3–13.
Bruner, Jerome (1962): The Conditions of Creativity, in: Howard E. Gruber, Glenn Terrell and Michael Wertheimer (eds.): Contemporary Approaches to Creative Thinking, Atherton Press: New York, 1–30.
Butkys, Adolph S. and George Herpel (1992): How Advertising Agencies Handle Their Own Advertising Strategy: An Industry-Wide Overview of its Self-Promotion Efforts, Journal of Advertising Research, 32 (5): 18–22.
Buzzell, Robert D. (1964): Predicting Short-Term Changes in Market Share as a Function of Advertising Strategy, Journal of Marketing Research, 1 (3): 27–31.
Chin, Wynne (1998): The Partial Least Squares Approach to Structural Equation Modeling, in: George A. Marcoulides (ed.): Modern Methods for Business Research, Erlbaum: Mahwah, NJ et al., 295–336.
Chin, Wynne and Peter A. Todd (1995): On the Use, Usefulness, and Ease of Use of Structural Equation Modeling in MIS Research: A Note of Caution, MIS Quarterly, 19 (2): 237–246.
Chong, Mark (2006): How Do Advertising Creative Directors Perceive Research?, International Journal of Advertising, 25 (3): 361–380.
Churchill, Gilbert A. (1979): A Paradigm for Developing Better Measures of Marketing Constructs, Journal of Marketing Research, 16 (1): 64–73.
Csikszentmihalyi, Mihaly (1997): Creativity: Flow and the Psychology of Discovery and Invention, Harper Collins: New York.
Dahlén, Micael, Sara Rosengren, and Fredrik Törn (2008): Advertising Creativity Matters, Journal of Advertising Research, 48 (3): 392–403.
Deshpandé, Rohit, John U. Farley, and Frederick E. Webster (1993): Corporate Culture, Customer Orientation, and Innovativeness in Japanese Firms: A Quadrad Analysis, Journal of Marketing, 57 (1): 23–37.
Devinney, Timothy, Grahame Dowling, and Michael Collins (2005): Client and Agency Mental Models in Evaluating Advertising, International Journal of Advertising, 24 (1): 35–50.
El-Murad, Jaafar and Douglas C. West (2003): Risk and Creativity in Advertising, Journal of Marketing Management, 19 (5/6): 657–673.
El-Murad, Jaafar and Douglas C. West (2004): The definition and measurement of creativity: What do we know?, Journal of Advertising Research, 44 (2): 188–201.
Fornell, Claes and Fred L. Bookstein (1982): Two Structural Equation Models: LISREL and PLS Applied to Consumer Exit-Voice Theory, Journal of Marketing Research, 19 (4): 440–452.
Fornell, Claes and Jaesung Cha (1994): Partial Least Squares, in: Richard P. Bagozzi (ed.): Advanced Methods of Marketing Research, Blackwell: Cambridge, MA et al., 52–78.
Fornell, Claes and David F. Larcker (1981): Evaluating Structural Equation Models with Unobservable Variables and Measurement Error, Journal of Marketing Research, 18 (1): 39–50.
Gibson, Lawrence D. (1996): What Can One TV Exposure Do?, Journal of Advertising Research, 36 (2): 9–18.
Goldenberg, Jacob, David Mazursky, and Sorin Solomon (1999): Creative Sparks, Science, 285 (5433): 1495–1496.
Haberland, Gabriele S. and Peter A. Dacin (1992): The Development of a Measure to Assess Viewers’ Judgments of the Creativity of an Advertisement, Advances in Consumer Research, 19 (1): 817–825.
Haitovsky, Yoel (1969): A Note on Maximization of R2, American Statistician, 23 (1): 20–21.
Helgesen, Thorolf (1994): Advertising Awards and Advertising Agency Performance Criteria, Journal of Advertising Research, 34 (4): 43–53.
Im, Subin and John P. Workman (2004): Market Orientation, Creativity, and New Product Performance in High-Technology Firms, Journal of Marketing, 68 (2): 114–132.
Jackson, Philip, W. and Samuel Messick (1965): The Person, the Product, and the Response: Conceptual Problems in the Assessment of Creativity, Journal of Personality, 33 (3): 309–329.
Johnson, Michael (2003): All Together Now, Design Week, 18 (48): 14–15.
Jones, John Philip (1995): Single-Source Research Begins to Fulfill its Promise, Journal of Advertising Research, 35 (3): 9–16.
Keil, John M. (1975): Can You Become a Creative Judge?, Journal of Advertising, 4 (1): 29–31.
Kilgour, Mark and Scott Koslow (2009): Why and How do Creative Thinking Techniques Work? Trading Off Originality and Appropriateness to Make More Creative Advertising, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 37 (3): 298–309.
Koslow, Scott, Sheila L. Sasser, and Edward A. Riordan (2003): What Is Creative to Whom and Why? Perceptions in Advertising Agencies, Journal of Advertising Research, 43 (1): 96–110.
Koslow, Scott, Sheila L. Sasser, and Edward A. Riordan (2006): Do Marketers get the Advertising They Need or the Advertising They Deserve?, Journal of Advertising, 35 (3): 81–101.
Kotler, Philip and Kevin Keller (2006): Marketing Management, Prentice Hall: Upper Saddle River, NY.
Kover, Arthur J. (1995): Copywriters’ Implicit Theories of Communication: An Exploration, Journal of Consumer Research, 21 (4): 596–611.
Kover, Arthur J. (1996): Why Copywriters Don’t Like Advertising Research — and What Kind of Research Might They Accept, Journal of Advertising Research, 36 (2): 8–11.
Kover, Arthur J., Stephen Goldberg, and William James (1995): Creativity vs. Effectiveness? An Integrating Classification for Advertising, Journal of Advertising Research, 35 (6): 29–40.
Kover, Arthur J., William James, and Brenda S. Sonner (1997): To Whom Do Advertising Creatives Write? An Inferential Answer, Journal of Advertising Research, 37 (1): 41–53.
Lee, Yih Hwai and Charlotte Mason (1999): Responses to Information Incongruency in Advertising: The Role of Expectancy, Relevancy, and Humor, Journal of Consumer Research, 26 (2): 156–169.
Li, Hairong, Wenyu Dou, Guangping Wang, and Nan Zhou (2008): The Effect of Agency Creativity on Campaign Outcomes: The Moderating Role of Market Conditions, Journal of Advertising, 37 (4): 109–120.
Lubart, Todd (2001): Models of the Creative Process: Past, Present and Future, Creativity Research Journal, 13 (3/4): 295–308.
MacKinnon, Donald W. (1987): Some Critical Issues for Future Research in Creativity, in: Scott G. Isaksen (ed.): Frontiers of Creativity Research: Beyond the Basics, Bearly: Buffalo, NY, 120–130.
McGraw, Kenneth O. and S. P. Wong (1996): Forming Inferences About Some Intraclass Correlation Coefficients, Psychological Methods, 1 (1): 30–46.
Michell, Paul C. (1984): Accord and Discord in Agency-Client Perceptions of Creativity, Journal of Advertising Research, 24 (5): 9–24.
Moorman, Christine and Anne S. Miner (1997): The Impact of Organizational Memory on New Product Performance and Creativity, Journal of Marketing Research, 34 (1): 91–106.
Mumford, Michael D. and Dean K. Simonton (1997): Creativity in the Workplace: People, Problems, and Structures, Journal of Creative behavior, 31 (1): 1–6.
Myers, Jack (2004): Advertising Accountability, R-o-I & Sarbanes-Oxley Concerns Spawn Audit Industry, http://www.mediavillage.com/jmr/2004/07/07/jmr-7-7-04/ (Access date: 2008-01-14).
Naik, Prasad A. and Kalyan Raman (2003): Understanding the Impact of Synergy in Multimedia Communications, Journal of Marketing Research, 40 (4): 375–388.
Newell, Allen, J.C. Shaw, and Herbert A. Simon (1959): The Processes of Creative Thinking, Rand Corporation: Santa Monica, CA.
Nunnally, Jum C. and Ira H. Bernstein (1994): Psychometric Theory, McGraw-Hill: New York.
Nyilasy, Gergely and Leonard N. Reid (2009): Agency Practitioner Theories of How Advertising Works, Journal of Advertising, 38 (3): 81–96.
Ogilvy, David (1963): Confessions of an Advertising Man, Atheneum: New York.
Pieters, Rik, Luk Warlop, and Michel Wedel (2002): Breaking Through the Clutter: Benefits of Advertisement Originality and Familiarity for Brand Attention and Memory, Management Science, 48 (6): 765–781.
Reinartz, Werner, Manfred Krafft, and Wayne D. Hoyer (2004): The Customer Relationship Management Process: Its Measurement and Impact on Performance, Journal of Marketing Research, 41 (3): 293–305.
Ringle, Christian, Sven Wende, and Alexander Will (2005): SmartPLS, http://www.smartpls.de (Access date: 2007-09-15).
Rossiter, John R. (2002): The C-OAR-SE Procedure for Scale Development in Marketing, International Journal of Research in Marketing, 19 (4): 305–335.
Rossiter, John R. (2008): Defining the Necessary Components of Creative, Effective Ads, Journal of Advertising, 37 (4): 139–144.
Runco, Mark A. and Robyn E. Charles (1993): Judgments of Originality and Appropriateness as Predictors of Creativity, Personality and Individual Differences, 15 (5): 537–546.
Ruscio, John, Dean Whitney and Teresa Amabile (1997): How Do Motivation and Task Behaviors Affect Creativity? An Investigation in Three Domains, http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=buh&AN=9013580&site=ehost-live (Access date: 2011-11-28).
Saffert, Peter and Werner Reinartz (2011): Creativity in Advertising and Implications for Product Sales Performance, Proceedings of the 33rd INFORMS Marketing Science Conference, Houston, USA.
Sarbanes-Oxley-Act (2002): § 1519. Destruction, Alteration, or Falsification of Records in Federal Investigations and Bankruptcy.
Sasser, Sheila L. and Scott Koslow (2008): Desperately Seeking Advertising Creativity, Journal of Advertising, 37 (4): 5–19.
Sasser, Sheila L., Scott Koslow, and Edward A. Riordan (2007): Creative and Interactive Media Use by Agencies: Engaging an IMC Media Palette for Implementing Advertising Campaigns, Journal of Advertising Research, 47 (3): 237–256.
Sethi, Rajesh, Daniel C. Smith, and C. Whan Park (2001): Cross-Functional Product Development Teams, Creativity, and the Innovativeness of New Consumer Products, Journal of Marketing Research, 38 (1): 73–85.
Smith, Robert E., Scott B. MacKenzie, Xiaojing Yang, Laura M. Buchholz, and William K. Darley (2007): Modeling the Determinants and Effects of Creativity in Advertising, Marketing Science, 26 (6): 819–833.
Song, Michael and Mitzi M. Montoya-Weiss (2001): The Effect of Perceived Technological Uncertainty on Japanese New Product Development, Academy of Management Journal, 44 (1): 61–80.
Sternberg, Robert J. and Todd Lubart (1999): The Concept of Creativity: Prospects and Paradigms, in: Robert J. Sternberg (ed.): Handbook of Creativity, Cambridge University Press: Cambrigde, 3–15.
Stone, Gerald, Donna Besser, and Loran E. Lewis (2000): Recall, Liking, and Creativity in TV Commercials: A New Approach, Journal of Advertising Research, 40 (3): 7–18.
Sullivan, Luke (2003): Hey, Whipple, Squezze This: A Guide to Create Great Ads, Wiley: New York.
Thorndyke, Perry (1977): Cognitive Structures in Comprehension and Memory of Narrative Discourse, Cognitive Psychology, 9 (1): 77–110.
Till, Brian D. and Daniel W. Baack (2005): Recall and Persuasion: Does Creative Advertising Matter?, Journal of Advertising, 34 (3): 47–57.
Van Bruggen, Gerrit H., Gary L. Lilien, and Manish Kacker (2002): Informants in Organizational Marketing Research: Why Use Multiple Informants and How to Aggregate Responses, Journal of Marketing Research, 39 (4): 469–478.
W&V-Kreativ-Ranking (2009): W&V Kreativ Ranking, Werben und Verkaufen, 83 (24): 1–4.
Wentz, Laurel (2005): At Cannes, the Lions Say “Grrr”, Advertising Age, 76 (26): 1–2.
West, Douglas C. (1993): Cross-National Creative Personalities, Processes, and Agency Philosophies, Journal of Advertising Research, 33 (5): 53–62.
West, Douglas C., Arthur J. Kover, and Albert Caruana (2008): Practitioner and Customer Views of Advertising Creativity, Journal of Advertising, 37 (4): 35–45.
White, Erin (2003): Agencies Face New Accountability, Wall Street Journal, 10 (2): 16.
Young, Charles E. (2000): Creative Differences Between Copywriters and Art Directors, Journal of Advertising Research, 40 (3): 19–26.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits use, duplication, adaptation, distribution, and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
About this article
Cite this article
Kübler, R.V., Proppe, D. Faking or Convincing: Why Do Some Advertising Campaigns Win Creativity Awards?. Bus Res 5, 60–81 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03342732
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03342732