Abstract
In the late 1920s, the Viennese psychoanalyst Paul Schilder, after performing a conditioning experiment with human subjects, criticized I. P. Pavlov’s concept of “experimental neurosis.” Schilder maintained that subjective reports by conditioned human subjects were more informative than the objectively observed behavior of conditioned dogs. In 1932, Pavlov published a rejoinder to Schilder’s critique in theJournal of the American Medical Association. Pavlov maintained that Schilder misunderstood the value and implications of the scientific, objective method in the study of experimental neurosis. In 1934, Schilder subjected Pavlov’s theory of higher nervous activity to an incisive critique in a 1935 article inImago. Schilder objected to Pavlov’s narrow, reductionist conceptualization of the conditional reflex. Schilder reiterated his view that the psychological, subjective explanation of the conditional reflex is preferable to the physiological, objective explanation, and that the inference of cortical phenomena from experimental findings might be improper. Neither Pavlov nor any of his disciples replied to Schilder. The author provides an apology for the Pavlovian position, suggesting that Schilder was unfamiliar with early and late writings of Pavlov.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Beritoff, J. (1927). Über die Individuel-Erworbene Tätigkeit des Zentralnervensystems.Journal für Psychologie und Neurologie, 33, 113–335.
Curran, F.J. (1942). Paul Schilder, his contribution to psychopathology.British Journal of Medical Psychology, 19(2), 151–154.
Dollard, J., & Miller, N.E. (1950).Personality and psychotherapy. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Ivanov-Smolenskii, A.G. (1949).Ocherki Patofiziologii Vysshei Nervnoi Deiatel’nostivi (Po Dannym I. P. Pavlova i Ego Shkoly). Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe Izdatel’stvo Meditsinskoi Literatury Medgiz.
Kashereninova, N.A. (1906). Novyi iskusstvennyi uslovnyi refleks na sliunnyia zhelezy.Trudy Obshchestva Russkikh Vrachei v S.-Peterburge s Prilozheniem Protokolov Zasedanii Obshchestva za 1905–1906 God, 73, 283–289.
Köhler, W. (1933).Psychologische probleme. Berlin: Julius Springer.
Langer, D. (1979).Paul Ferdinand Schilder, Leben und Werk. Mainz: Doctoral Dissertation. Psychiatric Clinic of the Johannes-Gutenberg-University in Mainz.
Luria, A.R. (1926). Die moderne russische Physiologie und die Psychoanalyse.Internationale Zietschrift für Psychoanalyse und Imago, 12, 40–53.
Maiorov, F.P. (1954).Istoriia Ucheniia ob Uslovnykh Refleksakh. Moscow, Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo Akademii Nauk SSSR.
Orbeli, L.A. (Ed.). (1949a).Pavlovskie Sredy; Protokoly i Stenogrammy Fiziologicheskikh Besed. Vol. 1. Moscow, Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo Akademii Nauk SSSR.
Orbeli, L.A. (Ed.). (1949b).Pavlovskie Sredy; Protokoly i Stenogrammy Fiziologicheskikh Besed. Vol. 2. Moscow, Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo Akademii Nauk SSSR.
Pavlov, I.P. (1927).Conditioned reflexes; An investigation of the physiological activity of the cerebral cortex. trans. G.V. Anrep, London: Oxford University Press.
Pavlov, I.P. (1928).Lectures on conditioned reflexes. trans. W. Horsley Gantt. 2 Vols. New York: International Publishers.
Pavlov, I.P. (1932a). Neuroses in man and animal.Journal of the American Medical Association, 99, 1012–1013.
Pavlov, I.P. (1932b). The reply of a physiologist to psychologists.Psychological Review, 39, 91–127.
Pavlov, I.P. (1951a). Eksperimental’naia psikhologiia i psikhopatologiia na zhivotnykh. InI. P. Pavlov, Polnoe Sobranie Sochinenii. Vol. 3. Pt. 1. 2nd ed., enlarged. Moscow, Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo Akademii Nauk SSSR.
Pavlov, I.P. (1951b). Fiziologiia i psikhologiia pri izuchenii vysshei nervnoi deiatel’nosti zhivotnykh. InI. P. Pavlov, Polnoe Sobranie Sochnenii. Vol. 3, Pt. 1. 2nd ed., enlarged. Moscow, Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo Akademii Nauk SSSR.
Pavlov, I.P. (1951c). Vvedenie. InI. P. Pavlov, Polnoe Sobranie Sochinenii. Vol. 3, Pt. 1, 2nd ed., enlarged. Moscow, Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo Akademii Nauk SSSR.
Pavlov, I.P. (1975). Psikhologiia kak nauka. In E. M. Kreps (Ed.),Neopublikovannye i Maloizvestnye Materialy I. P. Pavlova. Leningrad: Izdatel’stvo “Nauka.”
Pipunyrov, P.N. (1952). Bor’ba I. P. Pavlova s burzhuaznoi idealisticheskoi psikhologiei.Sovetskaia Pedagogika, 1, 56–69.
Schilder, P. (1929a). Conditioned reflexes.Archives of Neurology and Psychiatry, 22, 425–443.
Schilder, P. (1929b). The somatic basis of the neurosis.Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 70, 502–519.
Schilder, P. (1935). Psychoanalyse und bedingte Reflexe.Imago, 21, 50–66.
Schilder, P. (1937). Psychoanalysis and conditioned reflexes.Psychoanalytic Review, 24, 1–17.
Shenger-Krestovnikova, N.R. (1921). K voprosu o differentsirovanii zritel’nykh razdrazhenii i o predelakh differentsirovaniia v glaznom analizatore sobaki.Izvestiia Petrogradskogo Nauchnogo Instituta Imeni P. F. Lesgafta, 3, 1–41.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Windholz, G. Schilder and Pavlov’s theory of higher nervous activity. Integr. psych. behav. 26, 248–258 (1991). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02912517
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02912517