Abstract
We present a detailed comparison of two models for relativistic classical particle interactions recently discussed in the literature—one based on independent particle variables, and the other on centre of mass plus relative variables. Basic to a meaningful comparison is a reformulation of the latter model which shows that it makes essential use of the concept of invariant relations from constrained Hamiltonian theory. We conclude that these two models have very different physical and formal structures and cannot be thought of as two equivalent descriptions of the same physical theory.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Balachandran A, Marmo G, Mukunda N, Nilsson J S, Simoni A, Sudarshan E C G and Zaccaria F 1982aNuovo Cimento A67 121
Balachandran A, Marmo G, Mukunda N, Nilsson J S, Simoni A, Sudarshan E C G and Zaccaria F 1982bUnified geometrical approach to relativistic particle dynamics Preprint DOE-ER-03992-489, CPT, University of Texas at Austin
Balachandran A, Dominici D, Marmo G, Mukunda N, Nilsson J S, Samuel J, Sudarshan E C G and Zaccaria F 1982cPhys. Rev. D26 3492
Cannon J T and Jordan T F 1964J. Math. Phys. 5 299
Currie D G, Jordan T F and Sudarshan E C G 1963Rev. Mod. Phys. 35 350
Dirac P A M 1949Rev. Mod. Phys. 21 392
Dominici D, Gomis J and Longhi G 1978aNuovo Cimento A48 257
Dominici D, Gomis J and Longhi G 1978bNuovo Cimento B48 152
Hsu J P and Shi T Y 1982Phys. Rev. D26 2745
Iranzo V, Llosa J, Molina A and Marques F 1982Comparison of several approaches to the relativistic dynamics of directly interacting particles Preprint, University of Barcelona FT 5–82
Kihlberg A, Marnelius R and Mukunda N 1981Phys. Rev. D23 2201
King M J and Rohrlich F 1980Ann. Phys. (N. Y.) 130 350
Komar A 1978aPhys. Rev. D18 1881
Komar A 1978bPhys. Rev. D18 1887
Komar A 1978cPhys. Rev. D18 3617
Leutwyler H 1965Nuovo Cimento 37 556
Mukunda N and Sudarshan E C G 1981Phys. Rev. D23 2210
Rohrlich F 1979aAnn. Phys. (N.Y.) 117 292
Rohrlich F 1979bPhysica A96 290
Samuel J 1982aPhys. Rev. D26 3475
Samuel J 1982bPhys. Rev. D26 3482
Samuel J 1984 Work in preparation
Sudarshan E C G, Mukunda N and Goldberg J N 1981Phys. Rev. D23 2218
Todorov I T 1971Phys. Rev. D3 2351
Todorov I T 1976Commun. JINR E.2-10125 Dubna
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Samuel, J., Mukunda, N. Relativistic particle interactions—A comparison of independent and collective variable models. Pramana - J Phys 22, 131–150 (1984). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02846368
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02846368