Privatizing public housing in Canada, A public policy agenda

  • Cyrus Vakili-Zad
Article

Abstract

The new Progressive Conservative (PC) government in Ontario is planning to sell the 84,500 units (using the UK model) of public housing that it owns. This paper presents an evaluation of the programs to sell off public housing in the United Kingdom, the United States, and Canada. After a comparative evaluation, the author makes several recommendations for the Ontario government. The author argues that Canadian public-housing tenant characteristics are different from those in the UK. Ontario's public-housing tenants are too poor to purchase these units. They would be unable to maintain the unit and carry the costs (property tax, insurance, and utilities) even if the units were given to them free.

The author concurs that the sale of public housing units in the USA and the UK may have generated some revenue and saved some costs. However, he points out that in the long run, the modest financial gains will be offset by higher operating costs. The sale of the best units and those that are easy to maintain, along with the loss of higher-income tenants, will no doubt result in higher average operating costs for the remaining Units. Such unintended consequences of the sale should be avoided by the Ontario government. The author recommends that the province develop a comprehensive and multi-purpose plan covering an array of programs (including the sale of some units) rather than concentrate exclusively on the sale.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Achtenberg, E.P. (1989) “Subsidized Housing at Risk: The Social Costs of Private Ownership”, in Rosenberry S., and C. Hartman,Housing Issues of the 1990s, Philadelphia: Praeger.Google Scholar
  2. Adrianow S. (1995) “Social Management and the Applicability of British and French Experiences to the Netherlands,”Netherlands Journal of Housing and the Built Environment (10), no. 1, pp. 27–44.Google Scholar
  3. Autry, C.J. (1994) “‘HOPE’ for Home Ownership”,Journal of Housing, September/October, pp. 36–38.Google Scholar
  4. Boelhouwer, P.J., and J. Van Weesep (1988) “The Sale of Public Housing and the Social Structure of Neighbourhoods”,Built Environment (14), no. 3/4, pp. 145–154.Google Scholar
  5. Borgos, S. (1986) “Low-Income Home-ownership and the ACORN Squatters Campaign”, in Bratt R.G., C. Hartman, and A. Meyerson (eds.),Critical Perspective on Housing, Temple University Press.Google Scholar
  6. Bratt, R.G. (1986) “Public Housing, the Controversy and Contribution,” in Bratt, G., C. Hartman, and A. Meyerson,Critical Perspective on Housing, Philadelphia: Temple University Press.Google Scholar
  7. Bratt, R.G. (1989)Rebuilding a Low-Income Housing Policy, Philadelphia: Temple University Press.Google Scholar
  8. Bratt, R.G. (1991) “Public Housing Authorities: Determining an Appropriate Role in a National Preservation Strategy”,Housing Policy Debate (2), no. 2, pp. 535–556.Google Scholar
  9. Caprara, D. and B. Alexander (1989)Empowering Residents of Public Housing, Washington, D.C., National Center for Neighborhood Enterprise.Google Scholar
  10. Clay, W.L. (1990) “Don't Sell Public Housing!”,Journal of Housing, July/August, pp. 189–194.Google Scholar
  11. CMHC (1990)Public Housing Program, Program Evaluation Report.Google Scholar
  12. CMHC (1991)Research & Development Highlights, Issue 12.Google Scholar
  13. Cole, I., and R. Furbey (1994)The Eclipse of Council Housing, London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  14. Connerly, C.E. (1986) “What Should be Done with the Public Housing Program?”,Journal of the American Planning Association (52), no. 2, pp. 142–155.Google Scholar
  15. Cramer, J. (1988a) “Bootstrap Home Owners”,Times (132), no. 19, November 7, p. 37.Google Scholar
  16. Cramer, J. (1988b) “Turning Public Housing Over to Resident Owners”,Times (132), no. 24, December 12, p. 15.Google Scholar
  17. Dreier, P. and J. Atlas (1995) “US Housing Problems, Politics, and Policies in the 1990s”,Housing Studies (10), no. 2, pp. 245–269Google Scholar
  18. Emms, P. (1990).Social Housing, A European Dilemma?, Bristol: School for Advanced Urban Studies (SAUS).Google Scholar
  19. Forrest, R., D. Gordon, and A. Murie (1996) “The Position of Former Council Homes in the Housing Market”,Urban Studies (33), no. 1, pp. 125–136.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Glasheen, M., and C. Horing (1993) “Public Housing Authorities and HOPE 1: May HUD Give Away What It Doesn't Own?”,The Urban Lawyer (25), no. 1, pp. 69–95.Google Scholar
  21. Goering, J.M. (1993) “Towards the Comparative Exploration of Public Housing Segregation in England and the United States”,Housing Studies (8), no. 4, pp. 256–273.Google Scholar
  22. Harris, M. (1994)The Common Sense Revolution, Ontario, Canada.Google Scholar
  23. Harloe, M. (1994) “Social Housing-Past, Present and Future”,Housing Studies (9), no. 3, pp. 407–416.Google Scholar
  24. Housing Costs & Other Characteristics of Canadian Households (1993), Statistics Canada, Ottawa, p. 8.Google Scholar
  25. Howenstine, E.J. (1983)Converting Public Housing to Individual and Cooperative Ownership: Lessons from Foreign Experiences, Washington, D.C.: HUD.Google Scholar
  26. Kandell, M.J. (1995) “Public Housing: The Ostrich Strategy”,Planning, June, pp. 10–13.Google Scholar
  27. Linneman, P.D. and I.F. Megbolugbe (1994) “Privatisation and Housing Policy”,Urban Studies (31), no. 4/5, pp. 635–651.Google Scholar
  28. Malpass, P. (1993) “Housing Management—By the People for the People”,Housing Review (42), no. 4, pp. 58–61.Google Scholar
  29. NAHRO (1977), Housing Assistance Program,Journal of Housing (11), no. 77.Google Scholar
  30. MTHA (1995), Tenant Income Data, District 6, August.Google Scholar
  31. Ontario Housing Corporation (1995), Comprehensive Asset Management Program, Ontario, Canada.Google Scholar
  32. Rapp, L. (1994) “Tory Leader Rules out New Public Housing,”The Toronto Star, January 11.Google Scholar
  33. Reid, B. (1995) “Inter-organizational networks and the delivery of Local Housing services”,Housing Studies (10), no. 2, pp. 133–149.Google Scholar
  34. Reinvention: From Blueprint to Action (1995)HUD, March.Google Scholar
  35. Rohe, W.M., and M.A. Stegman (1990)Public Home-ownership Demonstration Assessment, Washington, D.C.: HUD.Google Scholar
  36. Rohe, W.M., and M.A. Stegman (1992) “Public Housing Home ownership, Will it Work and for Whom?”,Journal of the American Planning Association (58), no. 2, pp. 144–157.Google Scholar
  37. Rohe, W.M., and M.A. Stegman (1994) “The Effect of Home Ownership on the Self-Esteem, Perceived Control and Life Satisfaction”,Journal of American Planning Association, pp. 173–184.Google Scholar
  38. Sayegh, K.S. (1987)Housing, A Canadian Perspective, Academy Book, Ottawa.Google Scholar
  39. Schill, M.H. (1990) “Privatizing Federal Low Income Housing Assistance: The Case of Public Housing”,Cornell Law Review (69), no. 2, pp. 878–948.Google Scholar
  40. Schill, M.H. (1993) “Distressed Public Housing, Where Do We Go From Here”,The University of Chicago Law Review (60) no. 2, p. 512.Google Scholar
  41. Schwartz, D.C., R.C. Ferlanto, and D.N. Hoffman (1988)A New Housing Policy for America, Philadelphia: Temple University Press.Google Scholar
  42. Silver, H., J. McDonald, and R.J. Ortiz (1985) “Selling Public Housing: the Methods and Motivations”,Journal of Housing, November/December, pp. 213–228.Google Scholar
  43. Silver, H. (1990) “Privatization, Self-Help, and Public Housing Home ownership in the United states”, W. van Vliet and J. van Weesep,Government and Housing, Developments in Seven Countries, Sage Publications.Google Scholar
  44. Strathcona heights, A Community Renewed (1994) City of Ottawa Non-profit Housing Company, Ottawa, September.Google Scholar
  45. Streich, P. (1976a)Home ownership for Low-Income Canadians, CMHC.Google Scholar
  46. Streich, P. (1976b)Tenant Purchase Program: Ontario 1971–1976, CMHC.Google Scholar
  47. Struyk, R.J. (1977)Should Government Encourage Home ownership?, Urban Institute.Google Scholar
  48. Symon, P. (1988) “Home-Owning Dreams that End in Nightmare: For a Growing Minority of Householders the Drain of their Mortgage is Leading to Financial Disaster,”Daily Telegraph, London, 31 October pp. 1–3.Google Scholar
  49. Vakili-Zad, C. (1993) “Tenant Participation and Control in Public Housing in Canada”,Habitat International (17), no. 2, pp. 91–103.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Whitehead, C.M.E. (1993) “Privatizing Housing: An Assessment of U.K. Experience”,Housing Policy Debate (4), Issue 1, Fannie Mae, pp 101–139.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Delft University Press 1996

Authors and Affiliations

  • Cyrus Vakili-Zad

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations