Premenstrual syndrome as a criminal defense

Abstract

Premenstrual syndrome may be effective as an affirmative defense to a criminal charge if the defendant can show that (i) she was suffering from premenstrual syndrome at the time the crime was committed; and (ii) because of her condition, either that the criminal act was an involuntary act or that at the time of the criminal act she did not possess the mental state required by law for the commission of a crime. Premenstrual syndrome has been successfully pleaded as a criminal defense in Great Britain but has not been tested in American criminal courts. It may now be possible, however, because of the increase of behavioral, psychological, and physiological studies precisely characterizing premenstrual syndrome and elucidating the necessary criteria for its accurate diagnosis, for the appropriate defendant to assert this defense in an American court. This paper discusses (i) the use of recent scientific data to demonstrate the existence of premenstrual syndrome; (ii) the use of standardized psychological tests or physiological assays to demonstrate that the defendant suffers from premenstrual syndrome; and, (iii) the legal choices to be made and evidentiary hurdles that must be overcome in presenting a premenstrual syndrome defense.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.

References

  1. American Law Institute. (1962).Model Penal Code, American Law Institute, Philadelphia.

    Google Scholar 

  2. American Law Reports. (1968 and Suppl. 1982). Mental or emotional condition as diminishing responsibility for crimes,Am. Law Rep.: Cases Annot. 22 A.L.R.3d 1128.

  3. American Psychiatric Association. (1987).Diagnosis and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 3rd ed., Rev., A.P.A., Washington, DC.

    Google Scholar 

  4. Andersch, B., and Hahn, L. (1985). Progesterone treatment of premenstrual tension: A double blind study.J. Psychosom. Res. 29: 489–493.

    PubMed  Article  Google Scholar 

  5. Ashby, C. R., Carr, L. A., Cook, C. L., Steptoe, M. M., and Franks, D. D. (1988). Alteration of platelet serotonergic mechanisms and monamine oxidase activity in premenstrual syndrome.Biol. Psychiat., 24: 225–233.

    PubMed  Article  Google Scholar 

  6. Backstrom, T., and Carstensen, H. (1974). Estrogen and progesterone in plasma in relation to premenstrual tension.J. Steroid Biochem. 5: 257–260.

    PubMed  Article  Google Scholar 

  7. Backstrom, T., Sander, D., and Laesk, R. (1983). Mood, sexuality, hormones and the menstrual cycle II: Hormone levels and their relationship to premenstrual syndrome.Psychosom. Med. 45: 503–507.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  8. Barefoot v. Estelle. 463 U.S. 880, 920 (Blackmun, dissent) 1982.

  9. Benedak-Jaszmann, L. J., and Hern-Sturtevant, M. D. (1976). Premenstrual tension and functional infertility.Lancet 1: 1095–1098.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  10. Berreby, D. (1982). PMS case ends with guilty plea.Natl. Law J. Nov. 15, at 36, col. 1.

    Google Scholar 

  11. Blundell, J. E. (1984). Serotonin and appetite.Neuropharmacology 23: 1537–1551.

    PubMed  Article  Google Scholar 

  12. Brown, G. L., Goodwin, F. K., and Bunney, W. E. Jr. (1982). Human aggression and suicide: Their relationship to neuropsychiatric diagnoses and serotonin metabolism, In Ho, B. Y., Schoolar, J. C., and Usdin, E. (eds.),Advances in Biochemistry and Pharmacology, Vol. 34, Raven Press, New York, pp. 287–306.

    Google Scholar 

  13. Brush, M. G. (1977). The possible mechanics causing the premenstrual tension syndrome.Curr. Med. Res. Opinion Suppl 4: 9–15.

    Google Scholar 

  14. Chiat, L. (1986). Premenstrual syndrome and our sisters in crime: A feminist dilemma.Women's Rights Law Rep. 9: 267–293.

    Google Scholar 

  15. Chihal, H. J. (1987). Indications for drug therapy in premenstrual syndrome patients.J. Reprod. Med. 32: 449–452.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  16. Chuong, C. J., Colligan, R. C., Coulam, C. B., and Bergstralh, E. J. (1988). The MMPI as an aid in evaluating patients with premenstrual syndrome.Psychosomatics 29: 197–202.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  17. Cleary, E. W. (ed.). (1984).McCormick on Evidence, 3d. ed., West Publishing Co., St. Paul, MN.

    Google Scholar 

  18. Dalton, K. (1960). Menstruation and accidents.Brit. Med. J. 1960: 1425–1426.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  19. Dalton, K. (1980) Cyclical criminal acts in premenstrual syndrome.Lancet 1: 1070–1071.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  20. Dalton, K. (1984). Definition. InThe Premenstrual Syndrome and Progesterone Therapy, 2nd ed., Year Book Medical, Chicago, pp. 3–9.

    Google Scholar 

  21. Dalton, K. (1986). Premenstrual syndrome.Hamline Law Rev. 9: 143–154.

    Google Scholar 

  22. Diliberto Jr., R. A. (1986). Premenstrual stress syndrome defense: Legal, medical and social aspects.Med. Trial Tech. Quart. 35: 351–359.

    Google Scholar 

  23. Edwards v. Ford, 69 G.App. 578 (1923).

  24. Endo, M. Daiguji, M., Asano, Y., Yamashita, I., and Takahashi, S. (1978). Periodic psychosis recurring in association with menstrual cycle.J. Clin. Psychiat. 39: 456–466.

    Google Scholar 

  25. Fennell, T. (1984). Premenstrual shoplifting: Two PMS illness pleas bring justice with mercy.Alberta Report, May 7, pp. 30–34.

  26. Floody, O. R. (1983). Hormones and aggression in female mammals. In Svare, B. B. (ed.),Hormones and Agressive Behavior, Plenum Press, New York.

    Google Scholar 

  27. Frank, R. T. (1931). The hormonal causes of premenstrual tension,Arch. Neurol. Psychiat. 26: 1053–1057.

    Google Scholar 

  28. Freeman, E. W., Sondheimer, S. J., and Rickels, K. (1988). Effects of medical history factors on symptom severity in women meeting criteria for premenstrual syndrome.Obstet. Gynecol. 72: 236–239.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  29. Frye v. United States, 293 F. 1013 (1923, D.C. Cir.).

  30. Fulcher v. Wyoming, 633 P.2d 142 (1981).

  31. Ganten, D., and Pfaff, D. (1985).Actions of Progesterone on the Brain, Springer-Verlag, New York.

    Google Scholar 

  32. Halbreich, U., Endicott, J., Goldstein, S.,et al. (1976). Serum prolactin in women with premenstrual tension.Lancet 2: 654–656.

    PubMed  Article  Google Scholar 

  33. Halbreich, U., Endicott, J., and Schacht, S. (1982a). Premenstrual syndromes: A new instrument for their assessment.J. Psychiat. Treat. Eval. 4: 161–164.

    Google Scholar 

  34. Halbreich, U., Endicott, J., Schacht, S., and Nee, J. (1982b). The diversity of premenstrual changes as reflected in the Premenstrual Assessment Form.Acta Psychiat. Scand. 65: 46–65.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  35. Halbreich, U., Endicott, J., Goldstein, S.,et al. (1986). Premenstrual changes and changes in gonadal hormones.Acta Psychiat. Scand. 74: 576–586.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  36. Halbreich, U., Holtz, I., and Paul, L. (1988). Premenstrual changes: Impaired hormonal homeostasis.Neurol. Clin. 6: 173–194.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  37. Hartman, E., Chung, R., and Chien, C. (1971). L-tryptophan and sleep.Psychopharmacologia 19: 114–127.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  38. Hathaway, S. R., and McKinley, J. C. (1940). A multiphasic personality schedule (Minnesota): I. Construction of the schedule.J. Psychol. 10: 249–255.

    Google Scholar 

  39. Heggestad, K. A. (1986). The devil made me do it: The case against using premenstrual syndrome as a defense in a court of law.Hamline Law Rev. 9: 155–163.

    Google Scholar 

  40. Holtzman, E. (1986). Premenstrual symptoms: No legal defense.St. John's Law Rev. 60: 712–715.

    Google Scholar 

  41. Hopson, J. and Rosenfeld, A. (1984). PMS: Puzzling monthly symptoms.Psychology Today, August, pp. 30–38.

  42. In re Irvin, 31 B.R. 251 (Bkrtcy. 1983).

  43. Jakubowicz, D. L., Godard, F., and Dewhurst, J. (1984). The treatment of premenstrual tension with mefanamic acid: Analysis of prostaglandin concentration.Br. J. Obstet. Gynaecol. 91: 78–86.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  44. Janowsky, D. S., and Rausch, J. (1985). Biochemical hypotheses of premenstrual tension syndrome.Psychol. Med. 15: 3–8.

    PubMed  Article  Google Scholar 

  45. Johnson, S. R., McChesney, C., and Bean, J. A. (1988). Epidemiology of premenstrual symptoms in a nonclinical sample: I. Prevalence, natural history, and help-seeking behavior.J. Reprod. Med. 33: 340–346.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  46. Kirsch, M. A., and Geer, J. H. (1988). Skin conductance and heart rate in women with premenstrual syndrome.Psychosom. Med. 50: 175–182.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  47. Lapin, I. P., and Oxenkrug, G. F. (1969). Intensification of the central serotonergic processes as possible determinant of the thymoleptic effect.Lancet, 1: 132–135.

    PubMed  Article  Google Scholar 

  48. Loosen, P. T. (1985). The TRH induced TSH response in psychiatric patients: A possible neuroendocrine marker.Psychoneuroendocrinology 10: 237–260.

    PubMed  Article  Google Scholar 

  49. Maddocks, S., Hahn, P., Moller, F.,et al. (1986). A double blind placebo controlled trial of progesterone vaginal suppositories in the treatment of premenstrual syndrome.Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol., 154: 573–581.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  50. Matter of Parshall, 406 N.W.2d 913 (Mich.App. 1987).

  51. M'Naghten's Case, 10C1 & F 200, 8 Eng. Rep 718 (H.L. 1843).

  52. Moos, R. H. (1968). The development of a menstrual distress questionnaire.Psychosom. Med. 30: 853–867.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  53. Mundy, M. R., Brush, M. G., and Taylor, R. W. (1981). Correlations between progesterone, oestradiol and aldosterone levels in the premenstrual syndrome.Clin. Endocrinol. 14: 1–9.

    Google Scholar 

  54. Oakes, R. T. (1986). PMS: A plea bargain in Brooklyn does not a rule of law make.Hamline Law Rev. 9: 203–217.

    Google Scholar 

  55. O'Brien, P. M. (1985). The premenstrual syndrome: A review.J. Reprod. Med. 30: 113–126.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  56. Pahl-Smith, C. (1984/1985). Premenstrual syndrome as a criminal defense: The need for a medicolegal understanding.N.C. Central Law Rev. 15: 246–273.

    Google Scholar 

  57. People v. Grant, 46 Ill.App. 3d 125 (1977).

  58. People v. Magnus, 155 N.Y.S. 1013 (1915).

  59. People v. Newton, 8 Cal.App. 3d 359 (1970).

  60. People v. Santos, (unreported, 1K046229, New York Criminal Court, Nov. 3, 1982).

  61. People v. White, (Crim. No. 98663, Cal Super. Ct., S. F. County, 1979) (unreported).

  62. Rapkin, A. J., Chang, L. C., and Reading, A. E. (1988). Comparison of retrospective and prospective assessment of premenstrual symptoms.Psychol. Rep. 62: 55–60.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  63. Regina v. Craddock (1 C.L. 49, 1981)

  64. Regina v. English (unreported, cited in Chiat, 1986)

  65. Regina v. Smith, Criminal Law Review 531, 1982.

  66. Reid, R. L. (1985). Premenstrual syndrome.Curr. Prob. Obstet. Gynecol. Fertil. 8: 21–24.

    Google Scholar 

  67. Reid v. Florida Real Estate Comm'n, 188 So.2d 846 (Fla. 1986).

  68. Reuben, C. (1984). PMS, Part II: Causes,L.A. Weekly, pp. 75–76.

  69. Riley, T. L. (1986). Premenstrual syndrome as a legal defense.Hamline Law Rev. 9: 193–202.

    Google Scholar 

  70. Roberts, M. H. T. (1984). 5-Hydroxytryptamine and antinociception.Neuropharmacology 23: 1529–1536.

    PubMed  Article  Google Scholar 

  71. Rosen, L. N., Moghadam, L. Z., and Endicott, J. (1988). Psychosocial correlates of premenstrual dysphoric subtypes.Acta Psychiat. Scand. 77: 446–453.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  72. Roy-Byrne, P. P., Rubinow, D. R., and Hoban, M. C. (1988). TSH and prolactin responses to TRH in patients with premenstrual syndrome.Am. J. Psychiat. 145: 581–588.

    Google Scholar 

  73. Siegel, J. P., Myers, B. J., and Dinnen, M. K. (1987). Premenstrual tension syndrome symptom clusters: Statistical evaluation of the subsyndromes.J. Reprod. Med. 32: 395–399.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  74. Stahl, S. M. (1977). The human platelet: Diagnostic and research tool for the study of biogenic amines in psychiatric and neurologic disorders.Arch. Gen. Psychiat. 34: 509–516.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  75. State v. Caddell, 287 N.C. 266 (1975).

  76. State v. Gooze, 14 N.J. Super. 277 (1951).

  77. State v. Lashwood, 384 N.W.2d 319 (S.D. 1986).

  78. State v. Pike, 49 N.H. 399 (1870).

  79. Swanson v. State, 759 P.2d 898 (Idaho 1988).

  80. Taylor, J. W. (1979). Plasma progesterone, oestradiol 17 beta and premenstrual symptoms.Acta Psychiat. Scand. 60: 76.

    PubMed  Google Scholar 

  81. Taylor, L., and Dalton, K. (1983). PMS: A new criminal defense?California West Law Rep. 19: 269–287.

    Google Scholar 

  82. Tingen v. Tingen, 251 Or. 438 (1968).

  83. Trimble, J., and Fay, M. (1986). PMS in today's society.Hamline Law Rev. 9: 183–192.

    Google Scholar 

  84. United States v. Hinckley (525 F. Supp. 1342 (D.D.C. 1981), op. clarified, recon. denied, 529 F.Supp. 520 (D.D.C. 1982), aff'd 672 F.2d 115 (D.D. Cir. 1982).

  85. Wood, N. F., Most, A., and Dery, G. K. (1982). Prevalence of perimenstrual symptoms.Am. J. Public Health 72: 1257–1264.

    Article  Google Scholar 

Download references

Author information

Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to James W. Lewis J.D., Ph.D..

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Lewis, J.W. Premenstrual syndrome as a criminal defense. Arch Sex Behav 19, 425–441 (1990). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02442346

Download citation

Key Words

  • premenstrual syndrome
  • aggressive behavior
  • criminal behavior
  • aggression
  • violence