Environmental Management

, 17:563 | Cite as

The role of analytical science in natural resource decision making

  • Alan Miller


There is a continuing debate about the proper role of analytical (positivist) science in natural resource decision making. Two diametrically opposed views are evident, arguing for and against a more extended role for scientific information. The debate takes on a different complexion if one recognizes that certain kinds of problem, referred to here as “wicked” or “trans-science” problems, may not be amenable to the analytical process. Indeed, the mistaken application of analytical methods to trans-science problems may not only be a waste of time and money but also serve to hinder policy development. Since many environmental issues are trans-science in nature, then it follows that alternatives to analytical science need to be developed. In this article, the issues involved in the debate are clarified by examining the impact of the use of analytical methods in a particular case, the spruce budworm controversy in New Brunswick. The article ends with some suggestions about a “holistic” approach to the problem.

Key words

Natural resource decision making Positivism Scientific methods Pesticides Spruce budworm Forest protection 

Literature Cited

  1. Baskerville, G. 1992. The forestry problem. Unpublished paper, Forest Resources Department, University of New Brunswick, Fredericton, Canada.Google Scholar
  2. Bertell, R. 1985. No immediate danger?: Prognosis for a radioactive earth. Women's Educational Press, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.Google Scholar
  3. Blais, J. 1985. The spruce budworm and the forest. Pages 135–136in C. Sanders, R. Stark, E. Mullins, and J. Murphy (eds.), Recent advances in spruce budworms research. Canadian Forestry Service, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.Google Scholar
  4. Brookman, D., and others. 1984. Assessment of the potential of insecticides, emulsifiers, and solvent mixtures to enhance viral infection in cultured mammalian cells.Applied and Environmental Microbiology 47:80–83.Google Scholar
  5. Burrows, J. 1978. Friesen wins suit against aerial spraying.Daily Gleaner, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada, May 18.Google Scholar
  6. Canadian Press. 1981. Tree planters sprayed.Daily Gleaner, 4 June. Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada.Google Scholar
  7. Carvajal, J. 1982. The dialectics of analytical and synthetic approaches.European Journal of Operational Research 10:361–372.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Collingridge, D., and C. Reeve. 1986. Science speaks to power: The role of experts in policy making. Francis Pinter Publishers, London.Google Scholar
  9. Concerned Parents. 1977a. Bloomfield area: Depositions from sprayed citizens. Concerned Parents, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada.Google Scholar
  10. Concerned Parents. 1977b. Update. Concerned Parents, August, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada.Google Scholar
  11. Cotgrove, S. 1982. Catastrophe or cornucopia. Wiley, Chichester, England.Google Scholar
  12. Crocker, J., and P. Bagnell. 1981. Reye's syndrome: A clinical review.Canadian Medical Association Journal 124:375–381.Google Scholar
  13. Crocker, J., K. Rozee, R. Ozere, S. Digout, and D. Hutzinger. 1974. Insecticide and viral interaction as a cause of fatty visceral changes in encephalopathy in the mouse.Lancet 2:22–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Crocker, J., R. Ozere, S. Safe, S. Digout, K. Rozee, and D. Hutzinger. 1976. Lethal interactions of ubiquitous insecticide carriers with virus.Science 192:1351–1353.Google Scholar
  15. Crocker, J., K. Renton, S. Lee, K. Rozee, S. Digout, and D. Malatjalian. 1986. Biochemical and morphological characteristics af a mouse model of Reye's syndrome induced by the interaction of influenza B virus and a chemical emulsifier.Laboratory Investigation 54:32–40.Google Scholar
  16. Dickson, D. 1988. The new politics of science. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar
  17. Drohan, R. 1972. Clearcutting in New Brunswick.Mysterious East 19:3–9.Google Scholar
  18. Dupuis, A.-M. 1992. Unhappy with pesticide industry. Letter to editor.Daily Gleaner, 12 June, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada.Google Scholar
  19. Ecobichon, D. 1990. Chemical management of forest pest epidemics: A case study.Biomedical and Environmental Sciences 3:217–239.Google Scholar
  20. Ecobichon, D., R. Ozere, E. Reid, and J. Crocker. 1977. Acute Fenitrothion poisoning.Canadian Medical Association Journal 19:377–379.Google Scholar
  21. Efron, E. 1984. The apocalyptics. Simon and Schuster, New York.Google Scholar
  22. Fischer, F. 1990. Technocracy and the politics of expertise. Sage Publications, Newbury Park, California.Google Scholar
  23. Grimvall, A., and R. Ejvegard. 1986. The dynamics of scientific uncertainty and its implications for the use of conservative procedures in risk analysis. Pages 23–29in P. Oftedal and A. Brogger (eds.), Risk and reason: Risk assessment in relation to environmental mutagens and carcinogens. Alan R. Liss, New York.Google Scholar
  24. Hatcher, J., and F. White. 1985. Task force on chemicals in the environment and human reproductive problems in New Brunswick. Department of Health, Province of New Brunswick, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada.Google Scholar
  25. Hays, S. 1987. Beauty, health and permanence. Cambridge University Press, New York.Google Scholar
  26. Hunt, R. 1976. Biological warfare in New Brunswick.Weekend Magazine 26 May, St. John, New Brunswick, Canada.Google Scholar
  27. Inskip, H., and J. Davies. 1987. Methodological aspects of epidemiological studies on groups of workers and members of the public. Pages 13–23tin Proceedings of an NEA (Nuclear Energy Agency) workshop on epidemiology and radiation protection, 13–15 October, Paris, France.Google Scholar
  28. Ireland, N. 1976. Some side effects of the spruce budworm spray program. Speech to the Consumers Association of Canada, Fredericton branch, New Brunswick, Canada.Google Scholar
  29. Kotzwinkle, W. 1972. You are a worm.Mysterious East 19:11–16.Google Scholar
  30. Levine, A. 1982. Love Canal: Science, politics, and people. Lexington Books, Lexington, Massachusetts.Google Scholar
  31. Mahoney, M. 1976. Scientist as subject: The psychological imperative. Ballinger, Cambridge, Massachusetts.Google Scholar
  32. Marcus, A. 1988. Risk, uncertainty, and scientific judgement.Minerva 26:138–152.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. May, E. 1982. Budworm battles. Four East Publications, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.Google Scholar
  34. Menna, J. 1985. Effect of emulsifiers on influenza type A virus infection, in vivo and in vitro studies.Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health 16:441–448.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Milbrath, L. 1989. Envisioning a sustainable society. State University of New York Press, Albany, New York.Google Scholar
  36. Miller, A. 1985. Psychological biases in environmental judgements.Journal of Environmental Management 20:231–243.Google Scholar
  37. Miller, A. 1990. The competent environmental auditor: Educational issues and concerns.Environmental Auditor 1:191–203.Google Scholar
  38. Miller, A. 1992. Strategic errors in natural resource decision-making. Unpublished paper, University of New Brunswick, Frederiction, Canada.Google Scholar
  39. NRCC (National Research Council of Canada). 1985a. Epidemiological evidence of the effects of pesticides on human health in Canada. NRCC Publication No. 22852, Ottawa, Canada.Google Scholar
  40. NRCC (National Research Council of Canada). 1985b. Extrapolation of toxicological data from laboratory studies to the human situation. Publication No. 23909, Ottawa, Canada.Google Scholar
  41. Paigen, B. 1982. Controversy at Love Canal. The Hastings Center Report, June, pp. 29–37.Google Scholar
  42. Rittel, H., and M. Webber. 1973. Dilemmas in a general theory of planning.Policy Sciences 4:155–169.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Rozee, K., S. Lee, J. Crocker, S. Digout, and E. Arcinue. 1982. Is a compromised interferon response an etiological factor in Reye's syndrome?Canadian Medical Association Journal 126:798–802.Google Scholar
  44. Salter, L. 1988. Mandated science: Science and scientists in the making of standards. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, Holland.Google Scholar
  45. Schneider W., and others. 1976. Forest spray program and Reye's syndrome. Department of Health, Province of New Brunswick, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada.Google Scholar
  46. Schon, D. 1987. Educating the reflective practioner. Jossey Bass, San Francisco.Google Scholar
  47. Schuyler, G. 1982. Forest management and chemical spraying. Pages 1–6in M. Taylor (ed.), Brief to the Select Committee on Environment. Concerned Parents Group, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada.Google Scholar
  48. Spitzer, W., and others. 1982. Report of the New Brunswick task force on the environment and Reye's syndrome. Department of Health, Province of New Brunswick, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada.Google Scholar
  49. Spitzer, W., and others. 1984. Report of the New Brunswick task force on the environment and cancer. Department of Health, Province of New Brunswick, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada.Google Scholar
  50. Staff Reporter. 1962. Atlantic Advocate article discusses chemical poisoining.Daily Gleaner 20 November, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada.Google Scholar
  51. Staff Reporter. 1976. Minto school children complain of another spray incident.Daily Gleaner 26 May, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada.Google Scholar
  52. Staff Reporter. 1981. Spray map review urged.Daily Gleaner 17 July, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada.Google Scholar
  53. Taylor, M. 1982. Brief to the select committee on environment of the New Brunswick legislature. 13 January, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada.Google Scholar
  54. Thomas, P., and R. House. 1989. Pesticide-induced modulation of the immune system.American Chemical Society Symposium Series 414:94–106.Google Scholar
  55. Versteeg, H. 1984. The Spruce Budworm program and the perception of risk in New Brunswick. Pages 77–127in Friends of the Earth (eds.), Pesticide policy: The environmental perspective. Friends of the Earth, Ottawa, Canada.Google Scholar
  56. Weinberg, A. 1972. Science and trans-science.Minerva 10:209–222.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer-Verlag New York Inc. 1993

Authors and Affiliations

  • Alan Miller
    • 1
  1. 1.Psychology DepartmentUniversity of New BrunswickFrederictonCanada

Personalised recommendations