Abstract
One of the few integrating theories related to allocation is the hypothesis of optimization. While optimization theory has great heuristic appeal and has been used to describe a range of physiological and ecological phenomena, it has major limitations. Optimization is necessarily based on a definite time integral and an optimal control strategy must be specific to the same patterns exhibited by the driving variables over this same period of time. Optimization tends to employ the use of oversimplifications in order to facilitate analytical solutions to the optimal control strategy, i.e. the mechanism governing the response of plants, which is the critical issue of interest. It is difficult to define objective criteria that can account for the natural variability in plants and testing the quantitative predictions of optimality models is also difficult. Thus, we suggest that optimization theory is too limited for practical use in modelling whole plant allocation. In this paper, we introduce the use of coordination theory as a practical alternative. We develop a simple plant growth allocation model using both coordination and optimization approaches and show that coordination theory is easily applied, produces results that are quantitatively similar to optimization, and overcomes the inherent limitations of optimization theory.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alekseev V M, Tikhomirov V M and Fomin S V 1987 Optimal Control. Consultants Bureau, New York, USA.
Chapin F S III 1980 The mineral nutrition of wild plants. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 11, 233–260.
Charles-Edwards D A 1976 Shoot and root activities during steady state plant growth. Ann. Bot. 40, 767–772.
Chen J-L, Reynolds J F, Harley P C and Tenhunen J D 1993 Coordination theory of leaf nitrogen distribution in a canopy. Oecologia 93, 63–69.
Chen J-L and Wang Q 1988 A theoretical analysis of the potential productivity of ryegrass under grazing. J. Theor. Biol. 133, 371–383.
Davidson R L 1969 Effect of root/leaf temperature differentials on root/shoot ratios in some pasture grasses and clover. Ann. Bot. 33, 561–569.
Field C and Mooney H A 1986 The photosynthesis-nitrogen relationship in wild plants.In On the Economy of Plant Form and Function. Ed. T G Givnish. pp 25–55. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, UK.
Friend A L, Coleman M D and Isebrands J G 1994 Carbon allocation to root and shoot systems of woody plants.In Biology of Adventitious Root Formation. Eds. T D Davis and B E Haissig. pp 245–273. Plenum Press, New York, USA.
Hilbert D W 1990 Optimization of plant root:shoot ratios and internal nitrogen concentration. Ann. Bot. 66, 91–99.
Hilbert D W and Reynolds J F 1991 A model allocating growth among leaf proteins, shoot structure, and root biomass to produce balanced activity. Ann. Bot. 68, 417–425.
Iwasa Y and Roughgarden J 1984 Shoot/root balance of plants: Optimal growth of a system with many vegetative organs. Theor. Pop. Biol. 25, 78–105.
Johnson I R and Thornley J H M 1987 A model of shoot:root partitioning with optimal growth. Ann. Bot. 60, 133–142.
Kastner-Maresch A E and Mooney H A 1994 Modelling optimal plant biomass partitioning. Ecol. Model. 75/76, 309–320.
Luo Y, Field C B and Mooney H A 1994 Predicting responses of photosynthesis and root fraction to elevated [CO2] (a): Interactions among carbon, nitrogen, and growth: theoretical paper. Plant Cell Environ. 17, 1195–1204.
Makela A 1986 Partitioning coefficients in plant models with turnover. Ann. Bot. 57, 291–297.
McMurtrie R and Wolf L 1983 A model of competition between trees and grass for radiation, water and nutrients. Ann. Bot. 52, 449–458.
Orzack S H and Sober E 1994 How (not) to test an optimality model. Trends Ecol. Evol. 9, 265–276.
Rao S S 1984 Optimization, Theory and Applications. Second edn. Wiley Eastern Limited, New York, USA.
Reynolds J F and Thornley J H M 1982 A root:shoot partitioning model. Ann. Bot. 49, 585–597.
Reynolds J F, Kemp P R, Acock B, Chen J-L and Moorhead D L 1996 Limitations, uncertainties and challenges in modelling the effects of elevated CO2 on plants and ecosystems.In Carbon Dioxide and Terrestrial Ecosystems. Eds. G. Koch and H A Mooney. pp 347–380. Physiological Studies Series, Academic Press, San Diego, USA.
Schulze E D, Schilling K and Nagarajah S 1983 Carbohydrate partitioning in relation to whole plant production and water use ofVigna unguiculata (L.) Walp. Oecologia 58, 169–177.
Thornley J H M 1995 Shoot:root allocation with respect to C, N and P: An investigation and comparison of resistance and teleonomic models. Ann. Bot. 75, 391–405.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Reynolds, J.F., Chen, J. Modelling whole-plant allocation in relation to carbon and nitrogen supply: Coordination versus optimization: Opinion. Plant Soil 185, 65–74 (1996). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02257565
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02257565