Summary
In the past, it has often been the case that congenital malformations have been categorized in terms of their presumed embryologic development. The knowledge of development, however, has itself often been derived from studies of the normal heart during its development coupled with inferences drawn from the morphology of the abnormal hearts. This can lead to circular thinking which, often, has little basis in fact. It is our belief that cardiac embryology is an important science which should stand in its own right, but that knowledge of abnormal development should be derived from observation rather than inference. The potential dangers of concepts derived by extrapolation are illustrated with reference to hearts having deficiencies of atrioventricular septation (‘endocardial cushion defects’) and those with double inlet left ventricle (‘single ventricle’). It is shown that description of these hearts is greatly facilitated by eschewing those concepts derived from ‘armchair embryology’. Once a clear description is established, the scene is set to understand the real mechanisms underscoring the maldevelopment of these lesions.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anderson, R. H., Arnold, R., Thaper, M. K., Jones, R. S., and Hamilton, D. I., Cardiac specialized tissues in hearts with an apparently single ventricular chamber. (Double inlet left ventricle.). Am. J. Cardiol.33 (1974) 95–106.
Anderson, R. H., Becker, A. E., Wilkinson, J. L., and Gerlis, L. M., Morphogenesis of univentricular hearts. Br. Heart J.38 (1976) 558–572.
Anderson, R. H., Becker, A. E., Freedom, R. M., Quero-Jimenez, M., Macartney, F. J., Shinebourne, E. A., Wilkinson, J. L., and Tynan, M. J., Problems in the nomenclature of the univentricular heart. Herz4 (1979) 97–106.
Anderson, R. H., and Becker, A. E., Left atrioventricular valve in atrioventricular septal defect. Am. J. Cardiol.53 (1984) 1411–1412.
Anderson, R. H., Becker, A. E., and Tynan, M., Description of ventricular septal defects — or how long is a piece of string? Editorial review. Int. J. Cardiol.13 (1986) 267–278.
Anderson, R. H., Crupi, G., and Parenzan, L., Double Inlet Ventricle. Anatomy, Diagnosis and Surgical Management. Castle House Publications Ltd., Tunbridge Wells 1987.
Anderson, R. H., Macartney, F. J., Tynan, M., Becker, A. E., Freedom, R. M., Godman, M. J., Hunter, S., Quero-Jimenez, M., Rigby, M. L., Shinebourne, E. E., Sutherland, G., Smallhorn, J. G., Soto, B., Thiene, G., Wilkinson, J. L., Wilcox, B. R., and Zuberbuhler, J. R., Univentricular atrioventricular connection: the single ventricle trap unsprung. Ped. Cardiol.4 (1983) 273–280.
Anderson, R. H., and Taylor, I. M., Development of atrioventricular specialized tissue in the human heart. Br. Heart J.34 (1972) 1205–1214.
Becker, A. E., and Anderson, R. H., Atrioventricular septal defects. What's in a name? J. thorac. cardiovasc. Surg.83 (1982) 461–469.
Bharati, S., and Lev, M., The spectrum of common atrioventricular orifice (canal). Am. Heart J.86 (1973) 553–561.
De la Cruz, M. V., and Miller, B. L., Doube-inlet left ventricle. Two pathological specimens with comments on the embryology and on its relation to single ventricle. Circulation37 (1968) 249–260.
Di Segni, E., and Edward, J. E., Cleft anterior leaflet of the mitral valve with intact septa. A study of 20 cases. Am. J. Cardiol.51 (1983) 919–926.
Edwards, J. E., Discussion, in: 2nd Henry Ford Hospital International symposium on Cardiac Surgery, p. 242. Ed. J. C. Davila. Appleton-Century-Crofts. New York 1977.
Ellis, K., Angiography in complex congenital heart disease: Single ventricle, double inlet, double outlet and transposition, in: 2nd Henry Ford Hospital International Symposium on Cardiac Surgery, pp. 222–224. Ed. J. C. Davila. Appleton-Century-Crofts, New York 1977.
Netter, F. H., in: The Heart. The Ciba Collection of Medical Illustrations, vol. 5, 1969, p. 13.
Penkoske, P. A., Neches, W. H., Anderson, R. H., and Zuberbuhler, J. R., Further observations on the morphology of atrioventricular septal defects. J. thorac. cardiovasc. Surg.90 (1985) 611–622.
Streeter, G. L., Developmental horizons in human embryos. Description of age group XI, 13 to 20 somites and age group XII, 21 to 29 somites. Contrib. Embryol.30 (1942) 211–245.
Van Gils, F. A. W., The fibrous skeleton in the human heart: embryological and pathogenetic considerations. Virchows Arch.393 (1981) 61–73.
Van Mierop, L. H. S., Pathology and pathogenesis of endocardial cushion defects. Surgical implications, in: 2nd Henry Ford Hospital International Symposium on Cardiac Surgery pp. 201–207, Ed. C. Davila. Appleton-Century-Crofts, New York 1977.
Van Praagh, R., David, I., and Van Praagh, S., What is a ventricle? The single ventricle trap. Ped. Cardiol.2 (1982) 79–84.
Van Praagh, R., Ongley, P. A., and Swan, H. J. C., Anatomic types of single or common ventricle in man: morphologic and geometric aspects of sixty necropsied cases. Am. J. Cardiol.13 (1964) 367–386.
Wenink, A. C. G., Development of the human cardiac conducting system. J. Anat.121 (1976) 617–631.
Wenink, A. C. G., The conduction tissues in primitive ventricle with outlet chamber: two different possibilities. J. thoraz. cardiovasc. Surg.75 (1978) 747–753.
Wenink, A. C. G., Embryology of the ventricular septum. Separate origin of its components. Virchows Arch.390 (1981) 71–79.
Wenink, A. C. G., and Erkelens, C. W., Quantitative morphology in the developing heart. Acta morphol. neerl. scand; in press.
Wenink, A. C. G., and Gittenberger-de Groot, A. C., Left and right ventricular trabecular patterns. Consequences of ventricular septation and valve development. Br. Heart J.48 (1982) 462–468.
Wenink, A. C. G., Gittenberger-de Groot, A. C., and Brom, A. G., Developmental considerations of mitral valve anomalies. Int. J. Cardiol.11 (1986) 85–98.
Wenink, A. C. G., and Zevallos, J. C., Developmental aspects of atrioventricular septal defects. Int. J. Cardiol.18 (1988) 65–78.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Anderson, R.H., Wenink, A.C.G. Thoughts on concepts of development of the heart in relation to the morphology of congenital malformations. Experientia 44, 951–960 (1988). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01939889
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01939889