Abstract
Field tests with genetically modified organisms go beyond the boundaries of the politically and morally neutralized space that normally surrounds scientific experiments. They enter public areas. As a social process of shaping nature they are political in a fundamental sense. Consequences of this observation concern the legitimacy of decisions and the legitimacy of deciding procedures. The political rights of citizens and their human rights can only be respected if these procedures are democratic. Without a more serious exploration of the specific circumstances of release tests — for example, the precise ecological context, the consequences for the future development of the affected ecosystem, the social consequences, and the possible institutional ways of establishing gene technology in agriculture — we do not really know what we are doing when we release transgenic organisms. Moral judgements today can therefore only be prima facie, not free from shortcomings. As responsible judges we must confess that we are still morally blind.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Altmann, M., and Ammann, K., Gentechnologie im gesellschaftlichen Spannungsfeld: Züchtung transgener Kulturpflanzen. Gaia1 (1992) 204–213.
Altner, G., Krauth, W., Lünzer, 1., and Vogtmann, H. (eds), Gentechnik und Landwirtschaft. C. F. Müller, Karlsruhe, 2nd ed. 1990.
Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics (div. editions).
Aquinas, Summa Theologia (div. editions).
Bärlocher, Ch., Diethelm, H., Koechlin, F., and Ammann, D., Manipulierte Organismen in der Nutur? ökoscience. Zürich 1990.
Böhme, G., The end of the Baconian age, in: Coping with Science, pp. 1–17. Ed. G. Böhme, Westview Press. Boulder 1992.
Diggelmann, H., Introducing the Guidelines of the Swiss Commission on Biological Security (SKBS/CSSB) for the Deliberate Release of Genetically Modified Organisms. lecture at SAGUF-Symposium. Basel 2 October 1992.
Gasser, Ch. S., and Fraley, R., Genetically engineering plants for crop improvement. Science244 (1989) 1293–1299.
Gasser, Ch. S., and Fraley, R., Transgenic crops. Scient. Am.266/6 (1992) 34–39.
Gen-Ethischer Informations Dienst GID, Journal published by Genethisches Netzwerk c.V., Berlin esp. vol. 73–80.
Gill, B., Gentechnik ohne Politik. Campus, Frankfurt and New York 1991 (=Gentechnologie28).
Ginzburg, L. R. (ed.), Assessing Ecological Risks of Biotechnology. Butterworth-Heinemann, Boston 1991.
Hodgeson, J., and Sugden, A. M. (eds), Planned Release of Genetically Engineered Organisms. Elsevier, Cambridge 1988.
Jonas, H., Das Prinzip Verantwortung. Versuch einer Ethik für die technologische Zivilisation. Insel. Frankfurt 1979.
Jonsen, A. R., and Toulmin, S., The Abuse of Casuistry. A History of Moral Reasoning, Univ. of Calif. Press, Berkeley 1988.
Kant, I., Kritik der reinen Vernunft. Hartknoch, Riga 1787.
Kollek, R., Natur und Wissenschaft — von Finden zum Erfinden. Reflexionen über die Verluste der instrumentellen Vernunft. epd Dokumentation Frankfurt17 (1991) 26–34.
Kowarik, I., and Sukopp, H., Oekologische Folgen der Einführung neuer Pflanzenarten. Gentechnologic10 (1986) 111–135.
Kuhlmann, W., Diskursethik — Problem der Begründung und Anwendung, in: Prinzip und Applikation in der praktischen Philosophie, pp. 105–121. Ed. T. S. Seebohm. Frank Steiner, Stuttgart 1990.
Levy, S. B., and Miller, R. V. (eds), Gene Transfer in the Environment. McGraw-Hill, New York 1990.
Mooney, H. A., and Bernardi, G. (eds), Introduction of Genetically Modified Organisms into the Environment. Wiley, Chichester 1990.
Naimon, J. S., Using expert panels to assess risks of environmental biotechnology applications: A case study of the 1986 Frostban risk assessments, in: Risk Assessment in Genetic Engineering, pp. 319–353. Eds M. A. Levin and H. S. Strauss. McGraw-Hill, New York 1991.
Popitz, H., Die normative Konstruktion von Gesellschaft. J. C. B. Mohr, Tübingen 1980.
Popper, K. R., Logik der Forschung. J. C. B. Mohr, Tübingen 9th ed. 1989.
Rehmann-Sutter, Ch., Macht über Gene und Menschen. Metakritisches zur Auseinandersetzung um die Gentechnologie und zu den Defiziten der Ethikdebatte. Widerspruch (Zürich)18 (1989) 115–126.
Rehmann-Sutter, Ch., Biomedizinische Ethik als Diskurs über Politisches. Studia philosophica50 (1991) 21–38.
Rehmann-Sutter, Ch., Technologieethik und die Gemeinschaft der Betroffenen. Bioethica Forum8 (1992) 6–8.
Rehmann-Sutter, Ch., Gefährlichkeit unbekannter Gefahren. Transgene Pflanzen im Freiland? Eine Kontroverse mit Barbara Weber und Ingo Potrykus. Schweiz. Ges. für Biomedizin. Ethik, Genf 1992. (=Folia bioethica 11).
Rehmann-Sutter, Ch., Mehr aufs Spiel setzen als das Leben. Zur Ethik technologischer Risiken, in: Leben mit Risiko. Christoph Merian Verlag, Basel 1993 (in press).
Rehmann-Sutter, Ch., Welsen des Wahrnehmens. Aesth-Ethik, in: Sinnengegenwart. Essays zur Wahrnehmung. Eds Ch. Rehmann-Sutter, T. Lehmann, B. Lüem and D. Palestrina. R+R, Bottmingen 1993 (in press).
Sagoff, M., On making nature safe for biotechnology, in: Assessing Ecological Risks of Biotechnology, pp. 341–365. Ed. L. R. Ginzburg. Butterworth-Heinemann, Boston 1991.
Schmitt, C., Der Begriff des Politischen. Text from 1932 with foreword and three corollaries. Duncker & Humblot. Berlin 1963.
Stiftung Gen Suisse, Die Gentechnik, eine Chance und Herausforderung. Bern 1991.
Sukopp, H., Ecological long-term effects of cultivated plants returning to the wild state and of the introduction of nonnative species, Experientia49 (1993) 201–218.
Tiedje, J. M., Colwell, R. K., Grossman, Y. L., Hodson, R. E., Lenski, R. E., Mack, R. N., and Regal, P. S., The planned introduction of genetically engineered organisms: ecological considerations and recommendations. Ecology70 (1989) 298–315.
Walgate, R., Miracle or Menace? Biotechnology and the Third World. Panos, Budapest 1990.
Weber, M., Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft. Grundriß einer verstehenden Soziologie. J. C. B. Mohr, Tübingen 5th ed. 1985.
Winner, L., The Whale and the Reactor. A Search for Limits in an Age of High Technology. Univ. of Chicago Press, Chicago and London 1986.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rehmann-Sutter, C. Nature in the laboratory — nature as a laboratory. Considerations about the ethics of release experiments. Experientia 49, 190–200 (1993). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01923526
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01923526