Summary
‘Technological optimism’ is the doctrine that a growing number of technological improvements in such areas as food production, environmental quality and energy will sustain life as human population soars. It evolved as a response to the Malthusian study The Limits to Growth (The Club of Rome, 1972). Like population biologist Paul Ehrlich, Professor James Krier of the University of Michigan Law School believes that the technological optimists may be wrong. Krier describes how the marginal costs of pollution control increasingly rise. He faults biologist Barry Commoner for neglecting population growth as the cause of pollution and positing the postwar technological transition as its cause. He argues that population growth forced this transition as science searched for substitutes for dwindling resources. Krier criticises as “an article of faith” the technological optimists' belief that ‘S-curve’ patterns of technological advance will always arrive in response to the ‘J-curve’ of exponential population growth. He thinks that the technological optimists may be deluding humanity by predicting the continual emergence of technological breakthroughs at ever-increasing rates. He favours growth policies that would allow humanity to ease into a steady state of resource use and minimise the maximum cost, which would be a global crash after technological innovation fails. Krier laments that modern technolgy can worsen pollution and invites problems of latency, irreversibility, ‘zero-infinity’ risk and remoteness. He thinks that approapriate technologies which have failed economically may fail politically because the political process has been captured by opposing interests. Krier urges that the population crisis should be adressed instead
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Commoner, B., Corr, M. and Stamler, P.J. 1971. The causes of pollution.Environment, April.
Ehrlich, P.R. 1968.The Population Bomb. Ballantine Books.
Ehrlich, P.R. and Holdren, J.P. 1971. Impact of population growth.Science,171, 1212–1217.
Goldfarb, T. 1993.Taking Sides. Clashing Views on Controversial Environmental Issues. The Dushkin Publishing Group.
Inter Press Service. 1992. Environment: Technology More Harmful than Population, says Expert. 22nd January.
Krier, J.E. 1989. Remarks delivered at Northwestern School of Law of Lewis and Clark College, Portland, Oregon, USA; 3rd October.
Krier, J.E. 1990. The political economy of Barry Commoner.Environmental Law. J.,11 23.
Krier, J.E. and Gillette, C.P. 1985. The un-easy case for technological optimism.Michigan Law Review, p. 405.
The Club of Rome. 1972.The Limits to Growth. the Club of Rome.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Andrew D. Basiago is a graduate of UCLA and Northwestern School of Law's environmental law programme. As writer, lawyer and environmental planner he has written articles about ecology for the Cousteau Society and interviewed such luminaries as R. Buckminster Fuller, Amory B. Lovins and
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Basiago, A.D. The limits of technological optimism. Environmentalist 14, 17–22 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01902656
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01902656