Abstract
In August 1982, Anchor Press publishedProgress and Privilege, a book by William Tucker. Tucker's thesis was that environmentalism represented “the ideas of aristocratic conservatism translated onto a popular scale,” and that it had entwined itself with the protection of social and economic privilege. The book was riddled with fundamental errors of fact and of logic, but it also was literate and superficially impressive. It was widely reviewed. An examination of 23 reviews shows this: Most of the reviews in daily newspapers were written by laymen who couldn't analyze Tucker's arguments or recognize his mistakes. Most of the reviews in specialized publications were done by competent analysts who brought some special knowledge to their work. With the latter group of reviewers,Progress and Privilege fared poorly.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
Literature Cited
Barnes, F. 1982. Environmentalists: aristocrats resisting inroads of hoi polloi?Baltimore Sun.
Chickering, A. L. 17 September 1982. Do poor people belong to the Sierra Club?Wall Street Journal.
Dolnick, E. 20 October 1982. Untitled.Chattanooga Times (Chattanooga, TN).
Florman, S. C. 8 August 1982. The environmental elite.New York Times Book Review.
Gerlach, L. P. 1982. Environmental putdown.Natural History 91(11):30.
Graber, D. 12 September 1982. Taking wild shots at the ecological herd.Los Angeles Times.
Hardin, G. 1968. The tragedy of the commons.Science 166:1103–1107.
Johnson, J. 19 September 1982. Pendulum swings and goes“bonk.”Anniston Star (Anniston, AL).
Logan, G. 10 October 1982. Author says environmentalism part of our national personality.Macon Telegraph & News (Macon, GA).
Meadows, D. H. and others. 1972. The limits to growth. Universe Books, New York. 205 pp.
Peterson, R. W. 1983. Watch out for Mother Nature!Across the Board 20(4):64–67.
Schaeffer, R. 1982. Untitled.Not Man Apart 12(9): 18.
Scharfenberg, K. 15 August 1982. Can the environmentalists go too far?Boston Globe.
Stegner, W. 1982. Regress and pillage.The New Republic 187(9):35.
Stocker, M. 12 September 1982. To have or have not.Commercial Appeal (Memphis, TN).
Ten Harmsel, L. 29 August 1982. Environmentalism: a bold critique.Grand Rapids Press (Grand Rapids, MI).
Tucker, W. 1977. Environmentalism and the leisure class.Harper's 255(1531):49–56 and 73–80.
Tucker, W. 1978. Of mites and men.Harper's 257(1539):43–58.
Tucker, W. 1981. Marketing pollution.Harper's 262(1572):31–38.
Tucker, W. 1982.Progress and Privilege. Anchor Press Division, Doubleday & Co., Inc., Garden City, NY. xvi + 314 pp.
Tucker, W. 1983. The conservatism of the liberals.Across the Board 20(4):52–63.
Zukosky, J. 1982. A devastating attack on environmental “purity”.Business Week 756:11.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bennetta, W.J. Progress and Privilege: A book about environmentalism meets the press. Environmental Management 8, 455–462 (1984). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01871570
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01871570