Abstract
Economic evaluations of restored or enhanced lakes in Florida indicated gravity drawdown was the least expensive action, whereas effluent diversion was 10,000 times more costly on a per hectare basis, with the other lake treatment costs occurring in the following order: gravity drawdown < grass carp introduction < mechanical drawdown < aeration < stormwater control = drawdown-dredging < effluent diversion. Within a particular treatment category, the costs spanned approximately one and one half orders of magnitude. Contrary to the abundant cost data, which permitted an economic analysis, inappropriate statistical design and lack of commitment toward sampling Florida's restored lakes undermines attempts to understand long-term water quality responses to various enhancement techniques. Using Lake Tohopekaliga as a case study, ordinary statistical tests produced contradictory and unreliable interpretations on the effectiveness of drawdown and phosphorus removal at sewage treatment plants in improving the trophic state index. This emphasizes the need for more robust statistical approaches and more detailed data collection in evaluating lake restoration activities It is unfortunate for Florida's lake restoration program that quantitative conclusions based on inferential statistics, replete with tests of assumptions, is limited to very few lakes
Similar content being viewed by others
Literature cited
Baker, L. A., P. L. Brezonik, and C. R. Kratzer. 1985. Nutrient loading models for Florida lakes. Pages 253–258in Lake and reservoir management: Practical applications. Proceedings 4th annual conference and international symposium, October 16–19, 1984, McAfee, New Jersey. North American Lake Management Society, Merrifield, Virginia.
Brezonik, P. L. 1984. Trophic state indices: rationale for multivariate approaches. Pages 441–445in Lake and reservoir management, Proceedings 3rd annual conference of the North American Lake Management Society, October 18–23, 1983, Knoxville, Tennessee, US Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC. EPA 440/5-84-001.
Collier, C. A., and W. B. Ledbetter. 1982. Engineering costs analysis. Harper & Row, New York.
Dierberg, F. E., V. P. Williams, and W. Schneider. 1988. Evaluating water quality effects of lake management in Florida.Lake and Reservoir Management 4(2):101–111.
Huber, W. D., P. L. Brezonik, J. P. Heaney, R. E. Dickinson, S. D. Preston, D. S. Dwornik, and M. A. DeMaio. 1982. A classification of Florida lakes. Final report to the Florida Department of Environmental Regulation. Tallahassee, Florida.
Jones, W. W., N. O'Reilly, R. Pitt, R. Wedepohl, D. Knauer, and S. Peterson. 1986. Lake sediment workshop summary. Pages 431–435in Lake and reservoir management, Proceedings 5th annual conference and international symposium on applied lake and watershed management, Nov. 13–16, 1985. Lake Geneva, Wisconsin. North American Lake Management Society, Merrifield, Virginia.
North American Lake Management Society. 1988. The lake and reservoir restoration guidance manual. L. Moore and K. Thornton (eds.). US Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC. EPA 440/5-88-002.
Murphy, M. M., H. H. Harper, and E. H. Livingston. 1987. Operational results from the restoration of Lake Ella. Pages 702–707in J. D. Dietz (ed.), Proceedings of the 1987 specialty conference, Orlando, Florida. American Society of Civil Engineers, New York.
Osborne, J. A. 1982. $Herbicide vs. grass carp$.Aquatics 4:13–14.
Preston, S. D., and P. L. Brezonik. 1985. Water quality in the Oklawaha chain of lakes: A case study on problems and limitations in compiling long-term data bases. Pages 101–107in Lake and reservoir management: practical applications. Proceedings of the fourth annual conference and international symposium, October 16–19, 1984. McAfee, New Jersey. North American Lake Management Society, Merrifield, Virginia.
Shireman, J. V., D. E. Colle, and D. E. Canfield, Jr. 1986. Efficacy and cost of aquatic weed control in small ponds.Water Resources Bulletin 22:43–48.
Smith, V. H., and J. Shapiro. 1981. Chlorophyll-phosphorus relations in individual lakes: their importance to lake restoration strategies.Environmental Science and Technology 15:444–451.
Stewart-Oaten, A., W. W. Murdoch, and K. R. Parker. 1986. Environmental impact assessment: “Pseudoreplication” in time?Ecology 67:929–940.
Williams, V. P., E. Moyer, and M. Hulon. 1982. Completion report—Lake Tohopekaliga drawdown. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission, Tallahassee, Florida.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dierberg, F.E., Williams, V.P. Lake management techniques in Florida, USA: Costs and water quality effects. Environmental Management 13, 729–742 (1989). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01868312
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01868312