Summary
An analysis is given of a series of 25 patients suffering from lumboischialgic pain of different causes, which have been treated by discolysis. Literature reports are taken into consideration.
As a result of analysis, the following statements seem justified:
In no kind of lumbar disc prolapse are the results of discolysis superior to those of modern operative treatment. Discolysis results are indisputably worse in cases with the usual operative indication, which consists of neurological deficit and large disc prolapse. Favourable results by discolysis can be obtained in cases with disc protrusion or small prolapse, but these cases can mostly be cured also by consequent conservative treatment.
Contraindications are marked neurological deficit, demonstration of a large disc prolapse by contrast methods, Verbiest's stenosis of the lumbar spinal canal, low back pain and ischialgia without positive proof of a disc protrusion, cases with low back pain as the main or only feature, spondylolisthesis.
Disc prolapse recurrences after discolysis often occur about one month afterwards. Structural instability at this stage is likely. Therefore, as with post-operative treatment, it is advisable to avoid major physical stress for the first weeks after discolysis.
Major complications after discolysis are possible, and have occurred. Because discolysis offers no real advantages but some shortcomings compared to conservative treatment for disc protrusions, and to operative treatment in real disc prolapses, its justification seems more than questionable.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Branemark, P.-I., Ekholm, R., Lundskog, J.,et al., Tissue response to Chymopapain in different concentrations: animal investigations on microvascular effects. Clin. Orthop.67 (1969), 52–67.
Brown, J. E., Clinical studies on chemonucleolysis. Clin. Orthop.67 (1969), 94–99.
Feffer, H. L., Therapeutic intradiscal hydrocortisone, a long-term study. Clin. Orthop.67 (1969), 100–104.
Ford, L. T., Clinical use of chymopapain in lumbar and dorsal disc, lesions. An end-result study. Clin. Orthop.67 (1969), 81–87.
Garvin, P. J., Jennings, R. B., Smith, L.,et al., Chymopapain in experimental animals. Clin. Orthop.41 (1965), 204–223.
Gesler, R. M., Pharmacologic properties of chymopapain. Clin. Orthop.67 (1969), 47–51.
Grahan, C. E., Back ache and sciatica. A report of 90 patients treated by intradiscal injection of chymopapain (Discase). Med. J. Australia1 (1974), 5–8.
Herrick, B., 1974, Zitiert nach Wattset al. 1975..
Jansen, E. F., Balls, A. K., Chymopapain: a new chrystalline proteinase from papaya latex. J. Biol. Chem.137 (1941), 459–460.
Loew, F., Kivelitz, R., First results of a series of chemonucleolysis. J. Neurosurg. Sciences17 (1973), 77–79.
Loew, K., Die Behandlung von Lumboischialgien verschiedener Genese durch intradiskale Injektion von Chymopapain (Diskolyse). Eine Analyse des Schrifttums und des eigenen Krankengutes. Dissertation 1978, Saarlanduniversität Saarbrücken/Homburg-Saar.
Macnab, J., Chemonucleolysis. Clin. Neurosurg.20 (1973), 183–192.
Murphy, F., Sources and patterns of pain in disc disease. Clin. Neurosurg.15 (1968), 343–351.
Naylor, A., The biochemical changes in the human intervertebral disc in degeneration and nuclear prolapse. Orth. Clin. North Am.2 (1971), 343–358.
Nordby, E. J., Lucas, G. L., A comparative analysis of lumbar disc disease treated by laminectomy or chemonucleolysis. Clin. Orthop.90 (1973), 110–129.
Onofrio, B. M., Injection of chymopapain into intervertebral discs. Preliminary report on 72 patients with symptoms of disc disease. J. Neurosurg.42 (1975), 384–388.
Parkinson, D., Shields, C. B., Treatment of protruded lumbar intervertebral discs with chymopapain (Discase). J. Neurosurg.39 (1973), 203–208.
Shealy, C. N., Tissue reaction to chymopapain in cats. J. Neurosurg.26 (1967), 327–330.
Smith, L., Chemonucleolysis. Clin. Orthop.67 (1969), 72–80.
- “Discase paper.” American Orthopaedic Association, 1972.
—, Chemonucleolysis. J. Bone Jt. Surg. (Am.)54 (1972), 1975-Abstract.
—, Brown, J. E., Treatment of lumbar intervertebral disc lesions by direct injection of chymopapain. J. Bone Jt. Surg. (Br.)49 (1967), 502–519.
Sussman, B. L., Inadequacies and hazards of chymopapain injections as treatment for intervertebral disc disease. J. Neurosurg.42 (1975), 389–396.
Schoedinger, G. R., III., Ford, L. T., The use of chymopapain in ruptured lumbar discs. South Med. J.64 (1971), 333–336.
Schwetschenau, P. R., Ramirez, A., Johnstone, J., Wiggs, Ch., Martins, A. N., Double-blind evaluation of intradiscal chymopapain for herniated lumbar discs. J. Neurosurg.45 (1976), 622–627.
Stern, I. J., Biochemistry of chymopapain. Clin. Orthop.67 (1969), 42–46.
—, Smith, L., Dissolution by chymopapain in vitro of tissue from normal or prolapsed intervertebral discs. Clin. Orthop.50 (1967), 269–277.
Stewart, W. J., Lateral discograms and chemonucleolysis in the treatment of ruptured or deteriorated lumbar discs. Clin. Orthop.67 (1969), 88–89.
Travenol Laboratories, Discase dossier, July 1974.
Tsaltas, T. T., Papain-induced changes in rabbit cartilage. Alterations on the chemical structure of the cartilage matrix. J. exp. Med.108 (1958), 507–513.
Verbiest, H., Neurogenic intermittent claudication with special reference to stenosis of the lumbar vertebral canal. Amsterdam-Oxford-New York: North-Holland/American Elsevier. 1976.
Watts, C., Hutchinson, G., Stern, J., Clark, H., Comparison of intervertebral disc disease treatment by chymopapain injection and open surgery. J. Neurosurg.42 (1975), 397–400.
—, Knighton, R. S., Roulhac, G., Chymopapain treatment of intervertebral disc disease. J. Neurosurg.42 (1975), 374–383.
Wiltse, L. L., Widell, E. H., Jr., Yuan, H. A., Chymopapain chemonucleolysis in lumbar disc disease. JAMA231 (1975), 474–479.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Loew, F., Loew, K. & Kivelitz, R. Treatment of lumbo-ischialgias of different origins by intradiscal injection of chymopapain (discolysis). Acta neurochir 61, 73–88 (1982). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01740073
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01740073