Abstract
The major modalities of therapy, namely, surgery, radiotherapy, chemotherapy, and immunotherapy, are each of value in selected cases of malignant melanoma. However, because none of these therapies, alone, is capable of curing or controlling some subgroups of melanoma patients, combined modality therapy needs to be used more extensively. Surgery is of particular value in the treatment of primary tumors and in recurrent or regional metastatic disease. Chemotherapy for malignant melanoma has been disappointing. The most active single agent, DTIC, induces only about a 20% response rate, and little or no significant improvement is seen when DTIC is combined with other agents. However, chemotherapeutic agents when utilized by isolation perfusion in the treatment of primary or recurrent melanoma of the extremities, in conjunction with surgical excision of the primary tumor, produce cure rates of approximately 85% in patients with stage I disease and 50% in those with stage II disease. Immunotherapy appears to be of significant value in primary melanoma, and intra-lesional BCG immunotherapy of cutaneous or subcutaneous metastatic lesions has yielded a 50% response rate.
Successful combined modality therapy would take into account the natural history and course of the disease. Conventional therapy consists of surgery as primary therapy, followed by chemo- or immunotherapy. Further research is needed to determine if better results can be achieved by altering the sequence of utilization of the various treatment modalities.
Résumé
Dans les mélanomes malins, les principales possibilités thérapeutiques, chirurgie, radiothérapie, chimiothérapie, immunothérapie, ont des indications bien précises. Aucune n'est, à elle seule, capable de guérir ou d'apporter une palliation valable dans tous les sous-groupes de mélanomes. Il faut donc utiliser fréquemment des thérapeutiques combinées. La chirurgie est particuliérement utile pour la tumeur primitive, pour les récidives locales et pour les métastases régionales. Les résultats de la chimiothérapie ne sont guère encourageants. L'agent le plus actif, le DTIC, ne donne que quelques 20% de réponses lorsqu'il est utilisé isolément, et guère mieux lorsqu'il est associé à d'autres drogues. Mais la chimiothérapie par perfusion régionale, lorsqu'elle est combinée à l'excision de la tumeur primitive dans le traitement des mélanomes ou des récidives de mélanomes des membres, donne près de 85% de guérisons pour les malades au stade I et 50% pour les stades II. L'immunothérapie parait efficace pour la tumeur primitive et l'injection intralésionnelle de BCG dans les métastases cutanées ou sous-cutanées donne 50% de réponses favorables.
Pour être efficaces, les thérapeutiques combinées devraient tenir compte de l'histoire naturelle et de l'évolution de la maladie. Le traitement classique est basé sur la chirurgie, suivie de chimio-ou d'immunothérapie. Mais on obtiendrait peut-être de meilleurs résultats en modifiant la séquence des modalités thérapeutiques. Des recherches devraient être poursuivies dans ce sens.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Pitt, T.T.E.: Aspects of surgical treatment for malignant melanoma: the place of biopsy and wide excision. Aust. N.Z. J. Surg.47:757, 1977
Seigler, H.F., Fetter, B.F.: Surgical progress: current management of melanoma. Ann Surg.186:1, 1977
Fortner, J.G., Strong, E.W., Mulcare, R.J., Schottenfeld, D., MacLean, B.J.: The surgical treatment of recurrent melanoma. Surg. Clin. North Am.54:865, 1974
Gupta, T.K.D.: Results of treatment of 269 patients with primary cutaneous melanoma: a five-year prospective study. Ann. Surg.186:201, 1977
Norvell, S.T., McCleave, J.J., Bodurtha, A.J., Irwin, A.C.: Prophylactic node dissection for malignant melanoma. Can. J. Surg.20:429, 1977
Sim, F.H., Taylor, W.F., Ivins, J.C., Pritchard, D.J., Soule, E.H.: A prospective randomized study of the efficacy of routine elective lymphadenectomy in management of malignant melanoma. Preliminary results. Cancer41:948, 1978
Veronesi, U.: Regional lymph node dissection in melanoma of the limbs stage I: a cooperative international trial (WHO Collaborating Centers for Diagnosis and Treatment of Melanoma). Recent Results Cancer Res.62:8, 1977
Veronesi, U., Adamus, J., Bandiera, D.C., Brennhovd, I.O., Caceres, E., Cascinelli, N., Claudio, F., Ikonopisov, R.L., Javorskj, V.V., Kirov, S., Kulakowski, A., Lacour, J., Lejeune, F., Mechl, Z., Morabito, A., Rode, I., Sergeev, S., van Slooten, E., Szczygiel, K., Trapeznikov, N.N., Wagner, R.I.: Inefficacy of immediate node dissection in stage I melanoma of the limbs. N. Engl. J. Med.297:627, 1977
Holmes, C., Moseley, H.S., Morton, D.L., Clark, W., Robinson, D., Marshall, M.U.: A rational approach to the surgical management of melanoma. Ann. Surg.186:481, 1977
Cohen, M.H., Ketcham, A.S., Felix, E.L., Li, S.-H., Tomaszewski, M.-M., Costa, J., Rabson, A.S., Simon, R.M., Rosenberg, S.A.: Prognostic factors in patients undergoing lymphadenectomy for malignant melanoma. Ann. Surg.186:635, 1977
Sugarbaker, E.V., McBride, C.M.: Melanoma of the trunk: the results of surgical excision and anatomic guidelines for predicting nodal metastasis. Surgery80:22, 1976
Ames, F.C., Sugarbaker, E.V., Ballantyne, A.J.: Analysis of survival and disease control in stage I melanoma of the head and neck. Am. J. Surg.132:484, 1976
Stehlin, J.S., Jr., Giovanella, B.C., De Ipolyi, P.D., Muenz, L.R., Anderson, R.F., Gutierrez, A.A.: Hyperthermic perfusion of extremities for melanoma and soft tissue sarcomas. Recent Results Cancer Res.59:171, 1977
McBride, C.M., Sugarbaker, E.V., Hickey, R.C.: Prophylactic isolation perfusion as the primary treatment for invasive malignant melanoma of the limbs. Ann. Surg.182:316, 1975
Bauman, M.L., Price, T.R.: Intracranial metastatic malignant melanoma: long-term survival following subtotal resection. South. Med. J.65:344, 1972
Jones, R.F., Dickinson, W.E.: Total integumentectomy of the leg for multiple “in-transit” metastases of melanoma. Am. J. Surg.123:558, 1972
Oeseburg, H.B., Oldhoff, J., Koops, H.S., De Gast, G.C., The, T.H.: Cryosurgery in metastatic malignant melanoma. Panminerva Med.17:382, 1975
Ariel, I.V.: Results of treating malignant melanoma intralymphatically with radioactive isotopes. Surg. Gynecol. Obstet.139:726, 1974
Moot, E.S., Martin, H.: Melanoma of the upper respiratory tract and oral cavity. Cancer8:1167, 1955
Harrison, D.F.N.: Malignant melanomata of the nasal cavity. Proc. R. Soc. Med.61:13, 1968
Walker, E.A., Jr., Snow, J.B.: Management of melanoma of nose and paranasal sinuses. Arch. Otolaryngol.89:114, 1969
Pande, Y.N.: Malignant melanoma of the post-nasal space. J. Laryngol. Otol.84:1065, 1970
Ghamrawi, K.A.E., Glennie, J.M.: Clinical records. The value of radiotherapy in the management of malignant melanoma of the nasal cavity. J. Laryngol. Otol.88:71, 1974
Habermalz, H.J., Fischer, J.J.: Radiation therapy of malignant melanoma. Experience with high individual treatment doses. Cancer38:2258, 1976
Weitzel, G.: Die Strahlenbehandlung des melanoms. Schweiz. Med. Wochenschr.100:982, 1970
Storek, H.: Zur klinik und therapie des malignen melanomas. Hautarzt21:187, 1970
Hellriegel, W.: Radiation therapy of primary and metastatic melanoma. Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci.126:131, 1976
Wood, W.C., Cosimi, A.B., Carey, R.W., Kaufman, S.D.: Randomized trial of adjuvant therapy for “high-risk” primary malignant melanoma. Surgery83:677, 1978
Banzet, P., Jacquillat, D., Civatte, J., Puissant, A., Maral, J., Chastang, C., Israel, L., Belaich, S., Jourdain, J.-C., Weil, M., Auclere, G.: Adjuvant chemotherapy in the management of primary malignant melanoma. Cancer41:1240, 1978
Hill, G.J., Grage, T.B., Menton, J.P., Johnson, R.O.: DTIC melanoma adjuvant study: final report. Sixtyninth Annual Meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research, ASCO abstract, 309, 1978
Khementz, E.T., Ryan, R.F.: Chemotherapy of melanoma of the extremities by perfusion: fourteen years' clinical experience. Ann. Surg.175:900, 1972
Einhorn, L.H., McBride, C.M., Luce, J.K., Caoill, E., Gottlieb, J.A.: Intra-arterial infusion therapy with 5-(3,3-dimethyl-1-triazeno) imidazole-4-carboxamide (NSC-45388) for malignant melanoma. Cancer32:749, 1973
Costanza, M.E., Nathanson, L., Schoenfeld, D., Wolter, J., Colsky, J., Regelson, W., Cunningham, T., Sedransk, N.: Results with methyl-CCNU and DTIC in metastatic melanoma. Cancer40:1010, 1977
Costanza, M.E., Nathanson, L., Costello, W.G., Wolter, J., Brunk, S.F., Colsky, J., Hall, T., Oberfield, R.A., Regelson, W.: Results of a randomized study comparing DTIC with TIC mustard in malignant melanoma. Cancer37:1654, 1976
Bellet, R.E., Catalano, R.B., Mastrangelo, M.J., Berd, D.: Phase II study of subcutaneously administered 5-azacytidine (NSC-102816) in patients with metastatic malignant melanoma. Med. Pediatr. Oncol.4:11, 1978
Ahmann, D.L., Edmonson, J.H., Frytak, S., Kvois, L.K., Bisel, H.F., Rubin, J.: Phase II study of ICRF-159 versus combination cis-dichlorodiammineplatinum(II) and DTIC in patients with disseminated malignant melanoma. Cancer Treat. Rep.62:151, 1978
Ahmann, D.L.: Nitrosoureas in the management of disseminated malignant melanoma. Cancer Treat. Rep.60:747, 1976
Young, R.C., Canellos, G.P., Chabner, B.A., Schein, P.S., Brereton, H.D., DeVita, V.T.: Treatment of malignant melanoma with methyl CCNU. Clin. Pharmacol. Ther.15:617, 1974
Benjamin, R.S., Hall, S.W., Burgess, M.A., Wheeler, W.L., Murphy, W.K., Blumenschein, G.R., Gottlieb, J.A.: A pharmacokinetically based phase I–II study of single-dose actinomycin-D (NSC-3053). Cancer Treat. Rep.60:289, 1976
Cohen, S.M., Greenspan, E.M., Weiner, M.J., Karakow, B.: Triple combination chemotherapy of disseminated melanoma. Cancer29:1489, 1972
Moon, J.H., Gailani, S., Cooper, M.R., Hayes, D.M., Rege, V.B., Blom, J., Falkson, G., Maurice, P., Brunner, K., Glidewell, O., Holland, J.F.: Comparison of the combination of 1,3-BIS(2-chloroethyl)-1-nitrosourea (BCNU) and vincristine with two dose schedules of 5-(3,3-dimethyl-1-triazino) imidazole 4-carboxamide (DTIC) in the treatment of disseminated malignant melanoma. Cancer35:368, 1975
Costanzi, J.J., Vaitkevicius, V.K., Quagliana, J.M., Hoogstraten, B., Coltman, C.A., Jr., Delaney, F.C.: Combination chemotherapy for disseminated malignant melanoma. Cancer35:342, 1975
Beretta, G., Bonadonna, G., Cascinelli, N., Morabito, A., Veronesi, U.: Comparative evaluation of three combination regimens for advanced malignant melanoma: results of an international cooperative study. Cancer Treat. Rep.60:33, 1976
Carbone, P.P., Costello, W.: Eastern cooperative oncology group studies with DTIC (NSC-45388). Cancer Treat. Rep.60:193, 1976
Einhorn, L.H., Furnas, B.: Combination chemotherapy for disseminated malignant melanoma with DTIC, vincristine, and methyl-CCNU. Cancer Treat. Rep.61:881, 1977
McKelvey, E.M., Luce, J.K., Vaitkevicius, V.K., Talley, R.W., Bodey, G.P., Lane, M., Moon, T.E.: BIS chloroethyl nitrosourea, vincristine, dimethyl triazeno imidazole carboxamide and chlorpromazine combination chemotherapy in disseminated malignant melanoma. Cancer39:5, 1977
Wittes, R.E., Wittes, J.T., Golbey, R.B.: Combination chemotherapy in metastatic malignant melanoma. A randomized study of three DTIC-containing combinations. Cancer41:415, 1978
Didolkar, M.S., Baffi, R.R., Catane, R., Kaufman, J., Holyoke, E.D.: Use of methyl-CCNU and procarbazine in advanced malignant melanoma resistant to DTIC therapy. Cancer Treat. Rep.61:1738, 1977
Nordman, E.M., Mantyla, M.: Treatment of metastatic melanoma with combined 5-fluorouracil and procarbazine. Cancer Treat. Rep.61:1709, 1977
Byrne, M.J.: Cyclophosphamide, vincristine and procarbazine in the treatment of malignant melanoma. Cancer38:1922, 1976
De Wasch, G., Bernheim, J., Michel, J., Lejeune, F., Kenis, Y.: Combination chemotherapy with three marginally effective agents, CCNU, vincristine, and bleomycin, in the treatment of stage III melanoma. Cancer Treat. Rep.60:1273, 1976
Everall, J.D., O'Doherty, C.J., Wand, J., Dowd, P.M.: Treatment of primary melanoma by intralesional vaccinia before excision. Lancet2:583, 1975
Malek-Mansour, S.: Immunotherapy of melanoma with 2–4 dinitrochlorobenzine (DNCB). In Adjuvant Therapy of Cancer, Salmon, S.E., Jones, S.E., editors. Amsterdam, North Holland Publishing Co., 1977, pp. 447–454
Pliskin, M.E., Mastrangelo, M.J., Bellet, R., Berkelhammer, J.: BCG immunotherapy of a mucous membrane malignant melanoma. Report of a case. Oral Surg.42:73, 1976
Pinsky, C.M., Hirshout, Y., Oettgen, H.F.: Treatment of malignant melanoma by intratumoral injection of BCG. Natl. Cancer Inst. Monogr.39:225, 1973
Mastrangelo, M.J., Bellet, R.E., Berkelhammer, J., Clark, W.H., Jr.: Regression of pulmonary metastatic disease associated with intralesional BCG therapy of intracutaneous melanoma metastases. Cancer36:1305, 1975
Coates, A.S., Peters, M.: Complete remission of metastatic malignant melanoma following immunotherapy with Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG): report of a case. Aust. N.Z. J. Surg.47:362, 1977
Gutterman, J.U., Mavligit, G., McBride, C., Frei, E., III, Freireich, E.J., Hersh, E.M.: Active immunotherapy with BCG for recurrent malignant melanoma. Lancet1:1208, 1973
Gutterman, J.U., Mavligit, G.M., Blumenshein, Burgess, M.A., McBride, C.M., Hersh, E.M.: Immunotherapy of human solid tumors with Bacillus Calmette-Guérin. Prolongation of disease-free interval and survival in malignant melanoma, breast, and colorectal cancer. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci.277:135, 1976
Pinsky, C.M., Hirshaut, Y., Wanebo, H.J., Fortner, J.G., Mike, V., Schottenfeld, D., Oettgen, H.F.: Randomized trial of Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (percutaneous administration) as surgical adjuvant immunotherapy for patients with stage II melanoma. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci.277:187, 1976
Eilber, F.R., Morton, D.L., Holmes, E.C., Sparks, F.C., Ramming, K.P.: Adjuvant immunotherapy with BCG in treatment of regional-lymphnode metastases from malignant melanoma. N. Engl. J. Med.294:237, 1976
McCulloch, P.B., Dent, P.B., Blajchman, M., Muirhead, W.M., Price, R.A.: Recurrent malignant melanoma: effect of adjuvant immunotherapy on survival. Can. Med. Assoc. J.117:33, 1977
MacGregor, A.B., Falk, R.E., Landi, S., Ambus, U., Samuel, S.S., Langer, B.: Adjuvant immuno-stimulation in malignant melanoma with oral Bacille Calmette-Guérin. Can. J. Surg.20:25, 1977
Holmes, E.C., Morton, D.L., Eilber, F.R., Golub, S.E., Sulit, H.L.: Immunotherapy in malignant melanoma. Natl. Cancer Inst. Monogr.44:85, 1976
Morton, D.L., Eilber, F.R., Holmes, E.C., Townsend, C.M., Jr., Mirra, J., Weisenburger, T.H.: Adjuvant therapy in melanoma and sarcomas. In Adjuvant Therapy of Cancer, Salmon, S.E., Jones, S.E., editors. Amsterdam, North Holland Publishing Co., 1977, pp. 391–397
McPherson, T.A., Paterson, A.H., Willans, D., Watson, M.: A pilot study of adjuvant chemo-immuno-therapy. In Adjuvant Therapy of Cancer, Salmon, S.E., Jones, S.E., editors. Amsterdam, North Holland Publishing Co., 1977, pp. 439–446
Shibata, H.R., Jerry, L.M., Lewis, M.G., Mansell, P.W.A., Capek, A., Marquis, G.: Immunotherapy of human malignant melanoma with irradiated tumor cells, oral Bacillus Calmette-Guérin, and levamisole. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci.277:355, 1976
Laucius, J.F., Bodurtha, A.J., Mastrangelo, M.J., Bellet, R.E.: A phase II study of autologous irradiated tumor cells plus BCG in patients with metastatic malignant melanoma. Cancer40:2091, 1977
McCarthy, W.H., Cotton, G., Carlon, A., Milton, G.W., Kossard, S.: Immunotherapy of malignant melanoma. A clinical trial. Cancer32:97, 1973
Cassel, W.A., Murray, D.R., Torbin, A.H., Olkowski, Z.L., Moore, M.E.: Viral oncolysate in the management of malignant melanoma. I. Preparation of the oncolysate and measurement of immunologic responses. Cancer40:672, 1977
Murray, D.R., Cassel, W.A., Torbin, A.H., Olkowski, Z.L., Moore, M.E.: Viral oncolysate in the management of malignant melanoma. II. Clinical studies. Cancer40:680, 1977
McIllmurray, M.B., Embleton, M.J., Reeves, W.G., Langman, M.J.S., Deane, M.: Controlled trial of active immunotherapy in management of stage IIB malignant melanoma. Br. Med. J.1:540, 1977
Bukowski, R.M., Hewlett, J.S., Deodhar, S.: The transfer factor therapy of stage II malignant melanoma. In Adjuvant Therapy of Cancer, Salmon, S.E., Jones, S.E., editors. Amsterdam, North Holland Publishing Co., 1977, pp. 431–438
Einhorn, L.H., Burgess, M.A., Vallejos, C., Bodey, G.P., Sr., Gutterman, J., Mavligit, G., Hersh, E.M., Luce, J.K., Frei, E., III, Freireich, E.J., Gottlieb, J.A.: Prognostic correlations and response to treatment in advanced metastatic malignant melanoma. Cancer Res.34:1995, 1974
Gutterman, J.U., Mavligit, G., Gottlieb, J.A., Burgess, M.A., McBride, C.E., Einhorn, L., Freireich, E.J., Hersh, E.M.: Chemoimmunotherapy of disseminated malignant melanoma with dimethyl triazeno imidazole carboxamide and Bacillus Calmette-Guérin. N. Engl. J. Med.291:592, 1974
Currie, G.A., McElwain, T.J.: Active immunotherapy as an adjunct to chemotherapy in the treatment of disseminated malignant melanoma: a pilot study. Br. J. Cancer31:143, 1975
Hedley, D.W., McElwain, T.J., Currie, G.A.: Tumour regression and survival of patients with disseminated malignant melanoma treated with chemotherapy and specific active immunotherapy. Eur. J. Cancer13:1169, 1977
Newlands, E.S., Oon, C.J., Roberts, J.T., Elliott, P., Mould, R.F., Topham, C., Madden, F.J.F., Newton, K.A., Westbury, G.: Clinical trial of combination chemotherapy and specific active immunotherapy in disseminated melanoma. Br. J. Cancer34:174, 1976
Ghose, T., Norvell, S.T., Guclu, A., MacDonald, A.S.: Immunochemotherapy of human malignant melanoma with chlorambucil-carrying antibody. Eur. J. Cancer11:321, 1975
Ghose, T., Norvell, S.T., Guclu, A., Bodurtha, A., Tai, J., MacDonald, A.S.: Immunochemotherapy of malignant melanoma with chlorambucil-bound anti-melanoma globulins: preliminary results in patients with disseminated disease. J. Natl. Cancer Inst.58:845, 1977
Everall, J.D., Dowd, P., Davies, D.A.L., O'Neill, G.J., Rowland, G.F.: Treatment of melanoma by passive humoral immunotherapy using antibody drug synergism. Lancet1:1105, 1977
Cavalier, R., Ciocatto, E.C., Giovanella, B.C., Heidelberger, C., Johnson, R.O., Margotini, M., Mardovi, B., Moricca, G., Rossi-Fanelli, A.: Selective heat sensitivity of cancer cells: bioclinical and clinical studies. Cancer20:1351, 1967
Barlogie, B., Corry, P.M., Yip, E., Lippman, L., Johnston, D.A., Khalil, K., Tenczynski, T.F., Reilly, E., Lawson, R., Dosik, G., Rigor, B., Freireich, E.J.: Systemic hypothermia for advanced malignancies. I. Feasibility study. Cancer Res. (in press)
Corry, P., Armour, E., McGinne, J., Barlogie, B.: Ultrasonic treatment of melanotic tumors. Radiation Research Society 26th Annual Meeting, 1978, abstract Ge-1, p. 126
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Supported by Grant CA 05831 and Contract N01 CB 33888 from the National Cancer Institute.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hersh, E.M., Gutterman, J.U. & McBride, C.M. Combined modality therapy of malignant melanoma. World J. Surg. 3, 329–339 (1979). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01556586
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01556586