Abstract
Within six months of implementation, the Criminal Justice Act 1991, which had been hailed as the most important piece of criminal justice legislation in England and Wales for many years, was already being undermined in practice, and a new Act, which amends or even reverses some of its more progressive principles, was brought before Parliament. This paper looks at some problems of proportionality in practice — through discussion of penological principles, and through consideration of the kinds of cases which are most difficult for a desert approach. Alternative ideas are examined to see whether they could offer any better framework for penal policy and practice. A “mixed” theory is advocated, with parsimony as its most important principle.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes and references
Cavadino, M. and Dignan, J.,The Penal System: An Introduction (London: Sage, 1992).
Crook, F.,The 1991 Criminal Justice Act: A Reformer's Perspective (address to conference on the Criminal Justice Act, Center for Criminal Justice Studies, University of Northumbria, March 1993).
Hudson, B., “Punishing the poor: a critique of the dominance of legal reasoning in penal policy and practice”, in A. Duff, S. Marshall, R.E. Dobash and R.P. Dobash (eds)Penal theory and practice: Tradition and innovation in criminal justice (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1994).
Ashworth, A., “Criminal Justice and Deserved Sentences”,Criminal Law Review, 1989 (May), 340–55.
Hudson, B.,Justice through Punishment (Basingstoke: Macmillan, 1987).
Hall, S.,Drifting into a Law and Order Society (London: Cobden Trust, 1980).
Scraton, P. (ed),Law, Order and the Authoritarian State (Milton Keynes: Open University Press, 1987).
Loveday, B., “Right Agendas: Law and Order in England and Wales”,International Journal of the Sociology of Law, 1992 (20), 297–319.
Gamble, A.,The Free Economy and the Strong State: the Politics of Thatcherism (Basingstoke: Macmillan, 1988).
Hall, S. (1980), oc cit); (London: Cobden Trust, Gamble, A. (1988, op cit); Scraton, P. (1987), op cit).
Smart, C.,Feminism and the Power of Law (London: Routledge, 1989).
Ashworth, A.,Principles of Criminal Law (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1991); Von Hirsch, A.,Doing Justice (New York): Hill and Wang, 1976); Van den Haag, E.,Punishing Criminals (New York: Basic Books, 1975); Wilson, J.Q.,Thinking About Crime (New York: Basic Books, 1975).
Von Hirsch, A.,Past or Future Crimes? (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1985).
Braithwaite, J. and Pettit, P.,Not Just Deserts (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1990).
Ashworth, A. and Von Hirsch, A., “NotNot Just Deserts: A Reply to Braithwaite and Pettit”,Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 1992 (12: 1) 83–98.
Williams, B., “Bail Bandits: the construction of a moral panic”,Critical Social Policy, 1993 (37), 104–112.
Nash, M. “Dangerousness Revisited”,International Journal of the Sociology of Law, 1992 (20), 337–49.
Hudson, B.,Penal Policy and Social Justice (Basingstoke: Macmillan, 1993).
see, for example, Cook, D.,Paying for Crime (Milton Keynes: Open University Press, 1989) on social security fraud and tax evasion.
Kerruish, V.,Jurisprudence as Ideology (London: Routledge, 1991).
for example Carlen, P.,Alternatives to Women's Imprisonment (Milton Keynes: Open University Press, 1990) for a model of “woman wise” penology and Hudson, B., “Penal Policy and Racial Justice”, in L. Gelsthorpe and W. McWilliams (eds)Minority Ethnic Groups in the Criminal Justice System (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993) on racially just penology.
for a fuller discussion of these issues, see Hudson, B.,Penal Policy and Social Justice (op cit“ (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993), chapter 6.
Von Hirsch, A. and Ashworth, A. (eds),Principled Sentencing (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 1992).
Von Hirsch, A. and Jareborg, N., “Gauging Criminal Harm: A Living-Standard Analysis”,Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 1991 (11:1), 1–38.
Hudson, B.,Penal Policy and Social Justice (op cit)“.
Tonry, M., “Proportionality, parsimony, and interchangeability of punishments” in A. Duff, S. Marshall, R.E. Dobash and R.P. Dobash (eds) (1994), oc cit).
Kerruish, V. (1991, op cit).
Marenin, O., “Parking tickets and class repression: the concept of policing in critical theories of criminal justice”,Contemporary Crises, 1982 (6), 241–66.
Von Hirsch, A., “Proportionality in the Philosophy of Punishment”, in M. Tonry (ed),Crime and Justice — A Review of Research, 16 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992).
Braithwaite, J. and Pettit, P., (1990, op cit).
Hart, H.L.A.,Punishment and Responsibility: Essays in the Philosophy of Law (Oxford: University of Oxford Press, 1968).
Lacey, N.,State Punishment (London: Routledge, 1988).
Hart, H.L.A. (1968, op cit).
Von Hirsch, A.,Censure and Sanctions (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1993); Walker, N.,Why Punish? (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1991).
Morris, N.,Madness and the Criminal Law (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1982).
Braithwaite, J. and Pettit, P. (1990, op cit).
Rotman, E.,Beyond Punishment (Westport, Conn: Greenwood Press, 1990).
see, for example, Matthews, R., “Alternatives to and in prisons: a realist approach”, in P. Carlen and D. Cook (eds),Paying for Crime (Milton Keynes: Open University Press, 1989).
Mathiesen, T.,Prison on Trial (London: Sage, 1990).
Gilligan, C.,In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women's Development (Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 1982).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
I am grateful to Nicola Lacey, Mike Levi, Mike Maguire and Andrew Von Hirsch for comments on the first draft of this paper.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hudson, B.A. Beyond proportionate punishment: Difficult cases and the 1991 Criminal Justice Act. Crime Law Soc Change 22, 59–78 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01300839
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01300839