Abstract
Gender differences in work trip and job search patterns have received several analytical attention in recent years. A consistent finding in the literature is that women work closer to home than men because of their lower income, greater household responsibilities, and heavier reliance on public transit. While these findings pervade the literature, there has been little analysis into the extent to which they hold in the exclusive case of the urban poor. Can poor women afford to choose between jobs on the basis of journey to work considerations, any more than poor men? Using a survey data from Edmonton, this study examines the gender differences in commuting and job search patterns of the urban poor.
The findings suggest that, even among the low income population, women have shorter work trips and greater preference for part-time jobs than men because of their child care and household responsibilities. More women than men did not have enough time for their job search activities; and fewer women than men were prepared to accept job offers in all parts of the study area due to their household responsibilities. The results suggest that while males' employment problems are tied primarily to the working of the labour market, through inadequate skills and lack of good-paying jobs, females' employment problems are more explicable in terms of their role as mothers and homemakers.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alberta Municipal Affairs, Housing Division (1990) 1990–91 Housing Programs. Edmonton: Department of Municipal Affairs.
Blumen & Kellerman A (1990) Gender differences in commuting distance, residence, and employment location: Metropolitan Haifa, 1972 & 1983Professional Geographer 42(1): 54–71.
Broadway M (1992) Difference in inner city deprivation: An analysis of seven Canadian cities.The Canadian Geographer 36 (2): 189–196.
Campbell K & Rosenfeld R (1985) Job search and job mobility. In Research in the Sociology of Work vol. 3, ed. Simpson RL and Simpson IH. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press, pp 147–174.
City of Edmonton, Planning and Development Department (1989) The Edmonton labour market, 1989–1993. Edmonton: Planning Department.
City of Edmonton, Planning and Development Department (1991a) Edmonton demographic indicators. Edmonton: Planning Department.
City of Edmonton, Planning and Development Department (1991b) Business growth in Edmonton-1990, Research Paper #38. Edmonton: Planning Department.
Cubukgil A & Miller EJ (1982) Occupational status and the journey to work.Transportation 11: 251–279.
Dubin R (1991) Commuting patterns and firm decentralization.Land Economics (67)1: 15–29.
Dyck I (1989) Integrating home and wage workplace: Women's family lives in a Canadian suburb.The Canadian Geographer 4: 329–341.
Dyck I (1990) Space, time, and renegotiating motherhood: An exploration of the domestic workplace.Environment and Planning 8: 459–483.
Edmonton Food Policy Council (1991) Community food needs assessment (Preliminary findings).
Edmonton Housing Authority, (1990) Community housing projects by house numbers unpublished records.
Fagnani J (1983) Women's commuting patterns the Paris region.Tijdschrifl voor Economische en Sociale Geografie 74: 12–24.
Gorden P, Kumar A & Richardson HW (1989) Gender differences in metropolitan travel behaviour.Regional Studies 23(6): 499–510.
Giuliano G (1988) Commentary: Women and employment.Urban Geography (9)2: 203–208.
Hanson S & Johnston I (1985) Gender differences in work-trip length: Explanations and implications.Urban Geography (6)7: 193–219.
Hanson S & Hanson P (1980) Gender and urban activity patterns in Uppsala, Sweden.Geographical Review (70): 291–299.
Hanson S & Hanson P (1981) The impact of married women's employment on household travel patterns: A Swedish example.Transportation 10: 165–185.
Hanson S & Pratt G (1988) Reconceptualizing the link between home and work.Economic Geography 64(4): 299–321.
Hanson S & Pratt G (1990) Geographical perspectives on occupational segregation of women.National Geographic Research (4): 376–399.
Hanson S & Pratt G (1991) Job search and the occupational segregation of women.Annals of the Association of American Geographers 81(2): 229–253.
Hecht A (1974) The journey-to-work distance in relation to the socio-economic characteristics of workers.Canadian Geographer (XVIII)4: 367–378.
Henry GT (1990) Practical Sampling, Applied social methods series, No. 21. London: Sage Publications.
Hodge DC (1990) Geography and the political economy of urban transportation.Urban Geography (11)1: 87–100.
Howe A & O'Connor K (1982) Travel work and labour force participation on men and women in an Australian metropolitan area.Professional Geographer 34(1): 50–64.
Jackson LE & Johnson DB (1991) Geographic implication of mega-malls, with special reference to West Edmonton Mall.The Canadian Geographer 35(2): 226–232.
Kain JF (1968) Housing segregation, negro employment and metropolitan decentralization.The Quarterly Journal of Economics LXXXII(2): 175–197.
Kasarda JD (1988) Urban industrial transition and the underclass.Annals, American Association of Political & Social Sciences January (501): 26–47.
Madden FJ (1981) Why women work closer to home.Urban Studies 18: 181–194.
Madden FJ & Chiu LC (1990) The wage effects of residential location and commuting constraints on employed married women.Urban Geography (27)3: 353–369.
McDowell L (1991) The baby and the bath water: Diversity, deconstruction and feminist theory in geography.Geoforum 22(2): 123–133.
McLafferty S & Preston V (1991) Gender, race, and commuting among service sector workers.Professional Geographer 43(1): 1–15.
Michalak WZ & Fairbairn KF (1993) The location of producer services in Edmonton.The Canadian Geographer 37(1): 2–16.
National Council of Welfare (1990) Women and poverty revisited. Ottawa: Minister of Supply and Services.
Ross D & Shillington RE (1989) The Canadian fact book on poverty. Ottawa: The Canadian Council on Social Development.
Rutherford MB & Wekerle RG (1988) Captive rider, captive labour: Spatial constraints and women's employment.Urban Geography (9)2: 116–137.
Singell LD & Lillydahl JH (1986) An empirical analysis of the commute to work pattern of males and females in two-earner households.Urban Studies 2: 119–129.
Smith DM (1987) Geography, inequality and society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Smith PJ (1993) The cycle of growth, maturity, and abandonment in Edmonton's central whole-sale district.The Canadian Geographer 37(1): 62–69.
Villeneuve P & Rose D (1988) Gender and the separation of employment from home in metropolitan Montreal, 1971–1981.Urban Geography (9)2: 155–179.
Walters PO & Huang TJ (1992) An analysis of transit demand and changing city structure of Edmonton, 1965–1991. Edmonton: The City of Edmonton, Planning Department.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mensah, J. Journey to work and job search characteristics of the urban poor. Transportation 22, 1–19 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01151616
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01151616