Modeling the bank regulator's closure option: A two-step logit regression approach

  • James B. Thomson

Abstract

This article models the regulator's decision to close a bank as a call option. A two-equation model of bank failure that treats bank closings as an event timed by bank regulators is constructed and estimated for bank failures occurring from 1984 through 1989. The results of the regression experiment are consistent with the underlying theoretical model, as the majority of the regressors in the closure equation are significant with the correct sign.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Amemiya, T. “Qualitative Response Models: A Survey.”Journal of Economic Literature 19 (December 1981), 1483–1536.Google Scholar
  2. Avery, R.B., and Hanweck, G.A. “A Dynamic Analysis of Bank Failures.”Proceedings from a Conference on Bank Structure and Competition, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicgo (May 1984), 380–395.Google Scholar
  3. Barth, J.R., Brumbaugh, D. Jr., Sauerhaft, D., and Wang G.K. “Thrift Institution Failures: Causes and Policy Issues.”Proceedings from a Conference on Bank Structure and Competition, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago (May 1985), 184–216.Google Scholar
  4. Barth, J.R., Brumbaugh, D. Jr., Sauerhaft, D., and Wang, G.K. “Thrift-Institution Failures: Estimating the Regulator's Closure Rule.” Research Working Paper 125, Federal Home Loan Bank Board, January 1987.Google Scholar
  5. Belsley, D., Kuh, E., and Welsch, R.Regression Diagnostics. New York: Wiley, 1980.Google Scholar
  6. Benston, G.J., Eisenbeis, R.A., Horvitz, P.M., Kane, E.J., and Kaufman, G.G.Perspectives on Safe and Sound Banking: Past, Present, and Future. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1986.Google Scholar
  7. Bovenzi, J.F., Marino, J.A., and McFadden, F.E. “Commercial Bank Failure Prediction Models.”Economic Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta (November 1983), 27–34.Google Scholar
  8. Brumbaugh, D., and Hemmel, E. “Federal Deposit Insurance as a Call Option: Implications for Depository Institution and Insurer Behavior.” Working Paper 116, Federal Home Loan Bank Board, October 26, 1984.Google Scholar
  9. Buser, S.A., Chen, A.H., and Kane, E.J. “Federal Deposit Insurance, Regulatory Policy, and Optimal Bank Capital.”Journal of Finance 36 (September 1981), 775–787.Google Scholar
  10. Caliguire, D.B., and Thomson, J.B. “FDIC Policies for Dealing with Failed and Troubled Institutions.”Economic Commentary, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, October 1, 1987.Google Scholar
  11. Demirgüc-Kunt, A. “Modeling Large Commercial-Bank Failures: A Simultaneous-Equations Analysis.” Working Paper 8905, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, March 1989a.Google Scholar
  12. Demirgüc-Kunt, A. “Deposit-Institution Failures: A Review of the Empirical Literature.”Economic Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland (4th quarter 1989b), 2–18.Google Scholar
  13. Demirgüc-Kunt, A. “On the Valuation of Deposit Institution.” Working Paper 9104, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, March 1991a.Google Scholar
  14. Demirgüc-Kunt, A. “Principal-Agent Problems in Commercial Bank Failure Decisions.” Working Paper 9106, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, April 1991b.Google Scholar
  15. Gajewski, G.R. “Assessing the Risk of Bank Failure.”Proceedings from a Conference on Bank Structure and Competition, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago (May 1989), 432–456.Google Scholar
  16. Gajewski, G.R. “Modeling Bank Closures in the 1980s: The Roles of Regulatory Behavior, Farm Lending, and the Local Economy.”Research in Financial Services: Private and Public Policy 2 (1990).Google Scholar
  17. Geske, R. “The Valuation of Compound Options.”Journal of Financial Economics 7 (1979), 63–81.Google Scholar
  18. Hanweck, G.A. “Predicting Bank Failure.” Working Paper, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, November 1977.Google Scholar
  19. Kane, E.J. “Appearance and Reality in Deposit Insurance Reform.”Journal of Banking and Finance 10 (1986), 175–188.Google Scholar
  20. Kane, E.J.The S&L Insurance Mess: How Did It Happen? Washington, DC: The Urban Institute, 1989.Google Scholar
  21. Kane, E.J., and Unal, H. “Modeling Structural and Temporal Variation in the Market's Valuation of Banking Firms.”Journal of Finance 45 (March 1990), 113–136.Google Scholar
  22. Korobow, L., and Stuhr, D.P. “The Relevance of Peer Groups in Early Warning Analysis.”Economic Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta (November 1983), 27–34.Google Scholar
  23. Korobow, L., Stuhr, D.P., and Martin, D. “A Nationwide Test of Early Warning Research in Banking.”Quarterly Review, Federal Reserve Bank of New York (Autumn 1977), 37–52.Google Scholar
  24. Lane, W.R., Looney, S.W., and Wansley, J.W. “An Application of the Cox Proportional Hazards Model to Bank Failure.”Journal of Banking and Finance 10 (1986), 511–531.Google Scholar
  25. Lane, W.R., Looney, S.W., and Wansley, J.W. “An Examination of Bank Failure Misclassifications Using the Cox Model.”Proceedings from a Conference on Bank Structure and Competition, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago (May 1987), 214–229.Google Scholar
  26. Maddala, G.S. “Econometric Issues in the Empirical Analysis of Thrift Institutions' Insolvency and Failure.” Invited Research Working Paper 56, Federal Home Loan Bank Board, October 1986.Google Scholar
  27. Martin, D. “Early Warning of Bank Failure: A Logit Regression Approach.”Journal of Banking and Finance 1 (1977), 249–276.Google Scholar
  28. Merton, R.C. “An Analytic Derivation of the Cost of Deposit Insurance and Loan Guarantees: An Application of Modern Option Pricing.”Journal of Banking and Finance 1 (June 1977), 3–11.Google Scholar
  29. Merton, R.C. “On the Cost of Deposit Insurance When There are Surveillance Costs.”Journal of Business 51 (July 1978), 439–452.Google Scholar
  30. Meyer, P.A., and Pifer, H.W. “Prediction of Bank Failures.”Journal of Finance 25 (September 1970), 853–868.Google Scholar
  31. Pantalone, C.C., and Platt, M.B. “Predicting Commercial Bank Failure Since Deregulation.”New England Economic Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Boston (July/August 1987), 37–47.Google Scholar
  32. Pettway, R.H., and Sinkey, J.F. Jr. “Establishing On-Site Bank Examination Priorities: An Early Warning System Using Accounting and Market Information.”Journal of Finance 35 (March 1980), 137–150.Google Scholar
  33. Rose, P.S., and Kolari, J.W. “Early Warning Systems as a Monitoring Device for Bank Condition.”Quarterly Journal of Business and Economics 24 (Winter 1985), 43–60.Google Scholar
  34. Rose, P.S., and Scott, W. “Risk in Commercial Banking: Evidence from Postwar Failures.”Southern Economic Journal 45 (July 1978), 90–106.Google Scholar
  35. Santomero, A.M., and Vinso, J.D. “Estimating the Probability of Failure for Commercial Banks and the Banking System.”Journal of Banking and Finance 1 (1977), 185–205.Google Scholar
  36. Short, E.D., O'Driscoll, G.P. Jr., and Berger, F.D. “Recent Bank Failures: Determinants and Consequences.”Proceedings from a Conference on Bank Structure and Competition, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago (May 1985), 150–165.Google Scholar
  37. Sinkey, J.F. Jr. “A Multivariate Statistical Analysis of the Characteristics of Problem Banks.”Journal of Finance 30 (March 1975), 21–36.Google Scholar
  38. Sinkey, J.F. Jr. “Problem and Failed Banks, Bank Examinations and Early-Warning Systems: A Summary.” In: Edward I. Altman and Arnold W. Sametz, eds,Financial Crises. New York: Wiley Interscience Inc., 1977.Google Scholar
  39. Sinkey, J.F. Jr. “Identifying ‘Problem’ Banks: How do the Banking Authorities Measure a Bank's Risk Exposure?”Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 10 (May 1978), 184–193.Google Scholar
  40. Sinkey, J.F. Jr., Terza, J., and Dince, R. “A Zeta Analysis of Failed Commercial Banks.”Quarterly Journal of Business and Economics 26 (Autumn 1987), 35–49.Google Scholar
  41. Sinkey, J.F.Jr., and Walker, D.A. “Problem Banks: Definition, Importance and Identification.”Journal of Bank Research (Winter 1975), 209–217.Google Scholar
  42. Stuhr, D.P., and Van Wicklen, R. “Rating the Financial Condition of Banks: A Statistical Approach to Aid Bank Supervision.”Monthly Review, Federal Reserve Bank of New York (September 1974), 233–238.Google Scholar
  43. Stulz, R.M. “Options on the Minimum or Maximum of Two Risky Assets.”Journal of Financial Economics 10 (1982), 161–185.Google Scholar
  44. Thomson, J.B. “FSLIC Forbearances to Stockholders and the Value of Savings and Loan Shares.”Economic Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland (3rd Quarter 1987), 26–35.Google Scholar
  45. Thomson, J.B. “An Analysis of Bank Failures: 1984 to 1989.” Working Paper 8916, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, December 1989.Google Scholar
  46. Thomson, J.B. “Predicting Bank Failures in the 1980s.”Economic Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland (1st Quarter, 1991), 9–20.Google Scholar
  47. Wang, G.H.K., Sauerhaft, D., and Edwards, D. “Predicting Thrift Institution Examination Ratings.”Journal of Financial Services Research 2 (October 1989), 319–340.Google Scholar
  48. West, R.C. “A Factor-Analytic Approach to Bank Condition.”Journal of Banking and Finance 9 (1985), 253–266.Google Scholar
  49. Whalen, G.W. “A Proportional Hazards Model of Bank Failure: An Examination of Its Usefulness as an Early Warning Tool.”Economic Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland (1st Quarter 1991), 20–31.Google Scholar
  50. Whalen, G.W., and Thomson, J.B. “Using Financial Data to Identify Changes in Bank Condition.”Economic Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland (2nd Quarter 1988), 17–26.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 1992

Authors and Affiliations

  • James B. Thomson
    • 1
  1. 1.Federal Reserve Bank of ClevelandClevelandUSA

Personalised recommendations