Abstract
Suggesting that licensing may not only fail to accomplish its intended purpose, but may be counterproductive, the author asserts that licensing may not improve the quality of professional services, that licensing boards fail to discipline unethical or incompetent practitioners, and that actions taken against the unlicensed are more often aimed at eliminating competition, not incompetence. In addition, licensing laws may have negative side effects, including an increase in the cost of professional services, the creation of shortages and maldistributions in supply, ineffective use of paraprofessionals, and impediments to needed reforms in education, training, and services. He concludes that equally effective alternatives may be available that are less expensive and have less negative impact, and advocates a system of registration for all practitioners, as well as making other suggestions to improve the overall functioning of licensing boards. Finally, because of political realities, the author proposes a compromise between his ideal model and the current system.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
American Bar Association, Special Committee on Evaluation of disciplinary Enforcement.Problems and recommendations in disciplinary enforcement. Chicago: American Bar Association, 1970.
American Council on Education.Survey of dentistry in the United States. Washington, D.C.: American Council on Education, 1961. Cited by L. Shepard, Licensure Restrictions and the Cost of Dental Care. Mimeographed. Department of Agricultural Economics, University of California, Davis, undated, p. 22.
American Medical Association, Center for Health Services Research and Development.Physician distribution and medical licensure in the U.S., 1976 Chicago, Illinois: American Medical Association, 1977.
American Medical Association, Department of Medical Ethics. 1969 Medical disciplinary report.Journal of the American Medical Association, 1970,213, 588–90.
American Medical Association, Office of the General Counsel. Personal communication, February 17, 1972.
American Psychiatric Association.The nation's psychiatrist—1970 survey. Washington, D.C.: American Psychiatric Association, 1973.
Arnhoff, F. N.: Psychiatry, manpower, and mental health. (Working Paper of the American Psychological Association, Division of Manpower Research and Development.) Mimeographed. University of Virginia School of Medicine, Charlottesville, Va., 1971.
Austin, J.The province of jurisprudence determined. 1832. Reprint. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1954.
Behavior Today. Pressure builds to improve occupational licensing by states.Behavior Today, 1976,August 23, 1–2.
Benham, L. The effect of advertising on the price of eyeglasses.Journal of Law and Economics, 1972,15, 337–352.
Business Week. How licensing hurts consumers.Business Week, 1977,November 28, 127–129.
Carlin, J. E.Lawyers' ethics: A survey of the New York City bar. New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 1966.
Carroll, S. L. & Gaston, R. J.Occupational licensing. (Final Report to the National Science Foundation.) Knoxville, Tennessee: Department of Economics, University of Tennessee, 1977.
Council of State Governments.Occupational licensing legislation in the states: A study of state legislation licensing the practice of professions and other occupations. Chicago: Council of State Governments, 1952.
Crabb, M. H. Secretary, Federation of State Medical Boards. Personal communication, January 3, 1977.
Crooks, Lois A. Personal factors related to careers of MBAs.Findings, 1977,4(1), 4–8.
Demsetz, H. Why regulate utilities?Journal of Law and Economics, 1968,11, 55–65.
Derbyshire, R. C.Medical Licensure and Discipline in the United States. Baltimore, Maryland: Johns Hopkins Press, 1969.
Dornette, W. H. L. Role of the healing arts licensing board in the current medical malpractice crisis.Journal of Legal Medicine, 1976,4(3), 9–13.
Egelston, E. M. Licensure and career mobility.Hospitals, 1970,December 1, 42–46.
Forgotson, E. H., & Cook, J. L. Innovations and experiments in the uses of health manpower—The effect of licensure laws.Law and Contemporary Problems, 1967,32, 731–750.
Friedman, M.Capitalism and freedom. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1962.
Fuller, L. L.The morality of law. (2nd ed., rev.) New Haven, Connecticut: Yale University Press, 1969.
Garceau, O.The political life of the American Medical Association. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1941.
Gellhorn, W. The abuse of occupational licensing.University of Chicago Law Review, 1976,44, 6–27.
Gellhorn, W.Individual freedom and governmental restraints. Baton Rouge, Louisiana: Louisiana State University Press, 1956.
Gilb, C. L.Hidden hierarchies: The professions and government. New York: Harper and Row, 1966.
Hart, H. L. A.,The concept of law. Oxford, England: Clarendon Press, 1961.
Hogan, D. B. When little is know, what are we to do?: The implications of social science research for regulatory policy.Professional Practice of Psychology, 1982,3(1), 19–25.
Hogan, D. B. The impact of professional certification on counseling psychology.Counseling Psychologist, 1980,9(1), 39–43.
Hogan, D. B. Is licensing public protection or professional protectionism? In P. Pottinger and J. Goldsmith (Eds.),Defining and Measuring Competence. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1979a, pp. 13–24.
Hogan, D. B. Licensing mental therapists. (Opinion Editorial).New York Times, 1979b,July, 18, A23.
Hogan, D. B.The regulation of psychotherapists, Vol. I: A study in the philosophy and practice of professional regulation. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Ballinger, 1979c.
Hogan, D. B.The regulation of psychotherapists, Vol. II: A handbook of state licensure laws. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Ballinger, 1979d.
Hogan, D. B.The regulation of psychotherapists, Vol. III: A review of malpractice suits in the U.S. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Ballinger, 1979e.
Hogan, Daniel B.The regulation of psychotherapists, Vol. IV: A resource bibliography. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Ballinger, 1979f.
Hogan, D. B. Encounter groups and human relations training: The case against applying traditional forms of statutory regulation.Harvard Journal on Legislation. 1974,11, 659–701.
Holen, A. The economics of dental licensing. Mimeographed. The Public Research Institute of the Center for Naval Analyses. Arlinton, Virginia, November 1977.
Holen, A. Effects of professional licensing arrangements on interstate labor mobility and resource allocation.Journal of Political Economy, 1965,73(5), 492–498.
Howard, D. R., & Ball, J. R. The legal and professional recognition of physician's assistant.Federations Bulletin, 1973,60, 7–21.
Hyde, D. R., & Wolff, P. The American Medical Association: Power, purpose, and politics in organized medicine.Yale Law Journal, 1954,63, 938–1022.
Jervey, H. E., Jr. A survey of medical discipline.Federation Bulletin, 1961,48, 83–95.
Jordan, W. A.Airline regulation in America: Effects and imperfections. Baltimore, Maryland: Johns Hopkins Press, 1970.
Kelsen, H.General theory of law and state. (Translated by A. Wedberg.) Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1945.
Kessel, R. The A.M.A. and the supply of physicians.Law and Contemporary Problems, 1970,35, 267–283.
Kett, J. F.The formation of the American medical profession 1780–1860. New Haven, Connecticut: Yale University Press, 1968.
Lave, J. R., & Lave, L. B. Medical care and its delivery: An economic appraisal.Law and Contemporary Problems, 1970,35, 252–266.
Levine, M. E. Is regulation necessary? California air transportation and national regulation policy.Yale Law Journal, 1965,74, 1416–1447.
Lieberman, J. K.The tyranny of the experts: How professionals are closing the open society. New York: Walker, 1970.
Lieberman, J. K.The tyranny of the experts: How professionals are closing the open society. New York: Walker, 1970.
McCleery, R. S., Keelty, L. T., Lam, M., Phillips, R. E., & Quirin, T. M.One life—One physician: An inquiry into the medical profession's performance in self-regulation. (A Report to the Center for Study of Responsive Law) Washington, D.C.: Public Affairs Press, 1971.
McClelland, D. C. Testing for competence rather than for “intelligence.”American Psychologist, 1973,28, 1–14.
Maurizi, A. Occupational licensing and the public interest.Journal of Political Economy, 1974,82, 399–413.
Nader, R., & Green, M. (Eds.)Verdicts on Lawyers. New York: Thomas Y. Crowell, 1976.
Newman, F.The second Newman report: National policy on higher education. (Report of a Special Task Force to the Secretary of Health, Education and Welfare.) Cambridge, Massachusetts MIT Press, 1973.
Peterson, O. L., Andrews, L. P., Spain, R. S., & Greenberg, B. G. An analytical study of North Carolina general practice, 1953–1954.Journal of Medical Education, 1956,31, (Special Supp., Part II).
Pfeffer, J. Administrative regulation and licensing: Social problem or solution?Social Problems, 1974,21, 468–479.
Phelan, J. J.Regulation of the television repair industry in Louisiana and California: A case study. (Staff Report to the Federal Trade Commission.) Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1974.
Price, P. B., Taylor, C. W., Richards, J. M., Jr. & Jacobsen, T. L. Measurement of physician performance.Journal of Medical Education, 1964,39, 203–211.
Public Citizen. Unauthorized practice.Public Citizen, 1978,Winter, 2.
Rayack, E.Professional power and American medicine: The economics of the American Medical Association. Cleveland, Ohio: World Publishing Co., 1967.
Roemer, M. I. Controlling and promoting quality in medical care. In C. C. Havighurst, “Health Care: Part I.” (Special issue.)Law and Contemporary Problems, 1970,35, 284–304.
Roemer, R. Legal and other institutional impediments to realignment of health service functions. In American Medical Association, National Congress on Health Manpower,Expanding the Supply of Health Services in the 1970's. (Sponsored by The Council on Health Manpower.) Chicago: American Medical Association, 1970, pp. 43–64.
Rouse, M. O., Walter, L. Bierring lecture.Federation Bulletin, 1968,55, 70–78.
Sadler, B. Recent legal developments relative to physician's assistants and nurse practitioners.Physician's Assistant Journal, 1974,Winter-Spring, 35–44.
Shepard, L. Licensing restrictions and the cost of dental care.Journal of Law and Economics, 1978,28, 187–201.
Shryock, R. H.Medical Licensing in America, 1650–1965. Baltimore, Maryland: Johns Hopkins Press, 1967.
Stigler, G. J., & Friedland, C. What can regulators regulate? The Case of Electricity.Journal of Law and Economics, 1962,5, 1–16.
Taylor, C. W., Smith, W. R., & Ghiselin, B. The creative and other contributions of one sample of research scientists. In C. W. Taylor and F. Barron (Eds.),Scientific Creativity: Its Recognition and Development: New York: John Wiley, 1963, 53–76.
Taylor, R. L., & Torrey, E. F. The pseudo-regulation of American psychiatry.American Journal of Psychiatry, 1972,129, 658–663.
U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare.Analysis of 1974 State Health Manpower Licensure Legislation. (DHEW Publication No. HRA 106-74-125). Springfield, Virginia: National Technical Information Service, March 1975.
U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare.Report on Licensure and Related Health Personnel Credentialing (to the Congress of the United States). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1971.
U.S. Department of Labor.Hiring Standards and Job Performance. (Manpower Research Monograph No. 18, prepared by D. Diamond and F. Bedrosian.) Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1970.
U.S. Department of Labor.Occupational Licensing and the Supply of Nonprofessional Manpower. (Manpower Research Monograph No. 11) Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1969.
U.S. National Advisory Commission on Health Manpower.Report of the National Advisory Commission on Health Manpower. (Vol. 2). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1967.
Werner, E. A review of the examination for professional practice in psychology. Report to the Central Testing Unit, California Department of Consumer Affairs. Mimeographed, Sacramento, California, 1981.
White, D. M., & Francis, R. L. Title VII and the masters of reality: Eliminating credentialism in the American labor market.Georgetown Law Journal, 1976,64, 1213–1244.
Willig, S. H. The medical board's role in physician assistancy.Federation Bulletin, 1971,58, 126–159, 167–201.
Young, J. H.The medical messiahs: A social history of health quackery in twentieth-century America. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1967.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
About this article
Cite this article
Hogan, D.B. The effectiveness of licensing. Law Hum Behav 7, 117–138 (1983). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01044517
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01044517