Advertisement

Biofeedback and Self-regulation

, Volume 1, Issue 3, pp 253–271 | Cite as

Biofeedback and progressive relaxation treatment of sleep-onset insomnia

A controlled, all-night investigation
  • Robert Freedman
  • James D. Papsdorf
Articles

Abstract

Previous research suggests that self-defined insomniacs are distinguished from normals by high levels of anxiety and physiological arousal, which might be mitigated by muscle relaxation. This study assessed the relative effects of frontal EMG biofeedback, progressive relaxation, and a placebo set of “relaxation” exercises on the sleep of 18 onset insomniacs. Each subject was trained in one of these three methods for six half-hour sessions and slept in the laboratory for two consecutive nights before and after training. The experimental groups demonstrated significant decreases in physiological activity during training while changes in the control group were minimal. Reductions in sleep-onset time were: biofeedback group, 29.66 minutes; progressive relaxation group, 22.92 minutes; control group, 2.79 minutes. The experimental groups improved significantly(p<.05) more than the control group, but did not differ from each other. No significant relationships between physiological levels and sleep-onset time were found, which suggests that muscle relaxation alone was not responsible for subjects' improvements. Since 20 minutes of daily practice were required to achieve an approximate 30-minute decrease in sleep-onset time, the practical utility of the methods is questioned.

Keywords

Placebo Health Psychology Relative Effect Muscle Relaxation Daily Practice 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Benson, H., Beary, J., & Carol, M. The relaxation response.Psychiatry 1974,37 37–45.Google Scholar
  2. Bohlin, G. Monotonous stimulation, sleep onset and habituation of the orienting reaction.Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology 1974,31 593–601.Google Scholar
  3. Borkovec, T., & Fowles, D. Controlled investigation of the effects of progressive and hypnotic relaxation on insomnia.Journal of Abnormal Psychology 1973,82 153–158.Google Scholar
  4. Borkovec, R., & Nau, S. Credibility of analogue therapy rationales.Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychology 1972,3 257–260.Google Scholar
  5. Budzynski, T. Biofeedback procedures in the clinic.Seminars in Psychiatry 1973,5 537–547.Google Scholar
  6. Edelman, R. Effects of progressive relaxation on autonomic processes.Journal of Clinical Psychology 1970a,26 421–425.Google Scholar
  7. Edelman, R. Desensitization and physiological arousal.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1970b,17 259–266.Google Scholar
  8. Eisenman, R. Critique of “Treatment of insomnia by relaxation training.”Journal of Abnormal Psychology 1970,75 315–316.Google Scholar
  9. Feighner, J., Brown, S., & Olivier, F. Electrosleep therapy: A controlled, double-blind study.Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 1973,157 121–128.Google Scholar
  10. Frankel, B. Research on cerebral electrotherapy (Electrosleep): Some suggestions.American Journal of Psychiatry 1974,131 95–98.Google Scholar
  11. Gering, R., & Mahrer, A. Difficulty falling asleep.Psychological Reports 1972,30 523–528.Google Scholar
  12. Goldstein, L., Graedon, J., Willard, D., Goldstein, F., & Smith, R. A Comparative study of the effects of methaqualone and glutethimide on sleep in male chronic insomniacs.Journal of Clinical Pharmacology 1970,10 258–264.Google Scholar
  13. Good, R. Frontalis muscle tension and sleep latency.Psychophysiology 1975,12 465–467.Google Scholar
  14. Hauri, P. The influence of evening activity on the onset of sleep.Psychophysiology 1969,5 426–430.Google Scholar
  15. Hauri, P., & Good, R. Frontalis muscle tension and sleep-onset. Paper presented at the 15th Annual Meeting of the Association for the Psychophysiological Study of Sleep, Edinburgh, July, 1975.Google Scholar
  16. Haynes, S., Follingstad, D., & McGowan, W. Insomnia: Sleep patterns and anxiety level.Journal of Psychosomatic Research 1974,18 69–74.Google Scholar
  17. Johns, M., Gay, T., Masterson, J., & Bruce, D. Relationship between sleep habits, adrenocortical activity, and personality.Psychosomatic Medicine 1971,33 499–508.Google Scholar
  18. Johnson, D., & Spielberger, C. The effects of relaxation training and the passage of time on measures of state and trait anxiety.Journal of Clinical Psychology 1968,24 20–23.Google Scholar
  19. Kahn, M., Baker, B., & Weiss, J. Treatment of insomnia by relaxation training.Journal of Abnormal Psychology 1968,13 556–588.Google Scholar
  20. Kales, A. Hypnotic drug abuse: Clinical and experimental aspects.Medical Counterpoint 1969,3 (4), 13–17.Google Scholar
  21. Kales, A., Allen, C., Scharf, M., & Kales, J. Hypnotic drugs and their effectiveness.Archives of General Psychiatry 1970,23 226–232.Google Scholar
  22. Karacan, I., Williams, R. L., Littell, R. C., & Salis, P. J. Insomniacs: Unpredictable and idiosyncratic sleepers. In W. Koella, & P. Levin (Eds.),Sleep: Physiology, Biochemistry, Psychology, Pharmacology, Clinical Implications Basel: Karger, 1973.Google Scholar
  23. Karacan, I., Williams, R., Salis, P., & Hursch, C. New approaches to the evaluation and treatment of insomnia.Psychosomatics 1971,12 81–88.Google Scholar
  24. Lippold, O. Electromyography. In P. Venables, & I. Martin (Eds.),A Manual of Psychophysiological Methods Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1967.Google Scholar
  25. Lowell, G., & Morgan, J. Physiological and motor responses to a regularly recurring sound: A study in monotony.Journal of Experimental Psychology 1942,30 435–451.Google Scholar
  26. Luce, G. G., & Segal, J.Insomnia: The guide for troubled sleepers New York: Doubleday and Co., 1969.Google Scholar
  27. Monroe, L. Psychological and physiological differences between good and poor sleepers.Journal of Abnormal Psychology 1967,72 255–264.Google Scholar
  28. Nicassio, P., & Bootzin, R. A comparison of progressive relaxation and autogenic training as treatments for insomnia.Journal of Abnormal Psychology 1974,83 253–260.Google Scholar
  29. Oswald, I. Falling asleep open-eyed during intense rhythmic stimulation.British Medical Journal 1960,1 1450–1455.Google Scholar
  30. Paul, G. L.Insight Versus Desensitization in Psychotherapy Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1966.Google Scholar
  31. Paul, G. Inhibition of physiological response to stressful imagery by relaxation training and hypnotically suggested relaxation.Behavior Research and Therapy 1969a,1 249–256.Google Scholar
  32. Paul, G. Physiological effects of relaxation training and hypnotic suggestions.Journal of Abnormal Psychology 1969b,74 425–437.Google Scholar
  33. Peper, E. Frontiers of clinical biofeedback. In L. Birk (Ed.),Seminars in psychiatry (Vol. 5), New York: Grune & Stratton, 1973.Google Scholar
  34. Raskin, M., Johnson, G., & Rondesvedt, J. Chronic anxiety treated by biofeedback-induced muscle relaxation.Archives of General Psychology 1973,28 263–267.Google Scholar
  35. Rechtschaffen, A. Polygraphic aspects of insomnia. In H. Gastaut et al. (Eds.),The Abnormalities of Sleep in Man Bologna: Aulo Gaggi Editore, 1968.Google Scholar
  36. Rechtschaffen, A., & Kales, A. (Eds.),A Manual for Standardized Terminology, Techniques, and Scoring System for Sleep Stages of Human Subjects Los Angeles: Brain Information Service, 1968.Google Scholar
  37. Rechtschaffen, A., & Monroe, L. Laboratory studies of insomnia. In A. Kales (Ed.),Sleep Physiology and Pathology: A Symposium Philadelphia: Lippincott, 1969.Google Scholar
  38. Rosenthal, S. Electrosleep: a double-blind clinical study.Biological Psychiatry 1972,4 179–185.Google Scholar
  39. Rotter, J. Generalized expectancies for internal versus external control of reinforcement.Psychological Monographs 1966,80 1–28.Google Scholar
  40. Siddle, D., Smith, D., & Marcer, D. Effects of repetitive stimulation and reduced sensory input on cortical alertness.Biological Psychiatry 1974,1 181–188.Google Scholar
  41. Sittenfeld, P. The control of the EEG theta rhythm. In D. Shapiro et al. (Eds.),Biofeedback and Self Control Chicago: Aldine, 1972.Google Scholar
  42. Steinmark, S., & Borkovec, T. Active and placebo treatment effects on moderate insomnia under counterdemand and positive demand instructions.Journal of Abnormal Psychology 1975,83 157–163.Google Scholar
  43. Stoudenmire, J. Effects of muscle relaxation training on state and trait anxiety in introverts and extraverts.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1972,24 273–275.Google Scholar
  44. Vogel, G., Foulkes, D., & Trosman, G. Ego functions and dreaming during sleep onset. In C. Tart (Ed.),Altered States of Consciousness New York: Doubleday, 1972.Google Scholar
  45. Weiss, M. The treatment of insomnia through the use of electrosleep: An EEG study.Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 1973,157 108–120.Google Scholar
  46. Williams, P.The Lumbo-Sacral Spine: Emphasizing Conservative Management New York: McGraw-Hill, 1965.Google Scholar
  47. Zuckerman, M., & Lubin, B.Manual for the Multiple Affect Adjective Check List San Diego: Educational and Industrial Testing Service, 1965.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Plenum Publishing Corporation 1976

Authors and Affiliations

  • Robert Freedman
    • 1
  • James D. Papsdorf
    • 1
  1. 1.University of MichiganUSA

Personalised recommendations