Abstract
Few political scientists have undertaken systematic study of the determinants of greatness on the Supreme Court. In this article, I formulate and test a series of competing explanations for judicial eminence in a multivariate model. For the measure of performance on the Court, I use Blaustein and Mersky's ratings of the justices. The alternative explanations include social backgrounds, occupational experiences, political connections, experiences on the Court, and region of residence. Neither occupational experiences nor political connections have an appreciable impact on the level of achievement a justice reaches. Thus, contrary to one of the most popular hypotheses, previous judicial experience does not give an individual any advantage. Instead, in much greater measure, experiences on the Supreme Court and certain social backgrounds differentiate among the various levels of performance. In particular, the statistical analysis indicates the centrality and potency of parental status, religious affiliation, reputation as a dissenter, the number of opinions written in “landmark” cases, holding the office of chief justice, years of service, and the age of the justice at appointment.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abraham, Henry J. (1983). “A bench happily filled”: Some historical reflections on the Supreme Court appointment process.Judicature 66: 282–295.
Abraham, Henry J. (1984).Justices and Presidents: A Political History of Appointments to the Supreme Court. New York: Oxford University Press.
Bailey, Thomas A. (1966).Presidential Greatness: The Image and the Man from George Washington to the Present. New York: John Wiley.
Berkson, Larry C. (1978).The Supreme Court and Its Publics. Lexington, Mass.: Lexington Books.
Blaustein, Albert P., and Mersky, Roy M. (1972). Rating Supreme Court justices.American Bar Association Journal 58: 1183–1190.
Blaustein, Albert P., and Mersky, Roy M. (1978).The First One Hundred Justices: Statistical Studies of the Supreme Court of the United States. Hamden, Conn. Archon Books.
Bramwell, B. S. (1948). Galton's “Hereditary Genius” and the three following generations since 1869.Eugenics Review 39: 146–153.
Brenner, Saul (1985). Is competence related to majority opinion assignment on the United States Supreme Court?Capital University Law Review 15: 35–41.
Cardozo, Benjamin N. (1925). Law and literature.Yale Law Review 14: 699–715.
Currie, George R. (1964). A judicial all-star nine.Wisconsin Law Review 1964: 3–31.
Cushman, Robert F. (1979).Cases in Constitutional Law. 5th ed. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall.
Danelski, David J. (1960). The influence of the chief justice in the decisional process. Presented at the Annual Meetings of the American Political Science Association, New York, New York.
Daniels, William J. (1978). The geographic factor in appointments to the United States Supreme Court, 1789–1976.Western Political Quarterly 31: 226–237.
Douglas, William O. (1960). The Supreme Court and its caseload.Cornell Law Review 45: 401–414.
Evans, Evan D. (1948). The dissenting opinion: Its use and abuse.Missouri Law Review 3:121–128.
Ewing, Cortez A. M. (1938).The Judges of the Supreme Court, 1787–1937:A Study of Their Qualifications. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Fairman, Charles (1950). What makes a great justice? Mr. Justice Bradley and the Supreme Court, 1870–1892.Boston University Law Review 30: 49–102.
Feeley, Malcolm M., and Krislov, Samuel (1985).Constitutional Law. Boston: Little Brown.
Frank, John P. (1958).The Marble Palace: The Supreme Court in American Life. New York: Knopf.
Frankfurter, Felix (1957). The Supreme Court in the mirror of the justices.University of Pennsylvania Law Review 105: 781–796.
Galton, Francis (1869).Heredity genius. London: Macmillan.
Gibb, Cecil A. (1968). Leadership. InHandbook of Social Psychology, Gardner Lindzey and Elliott Aronson (eds.), Volume 4. Reading, Massachusetts: Addison Wesley.
Goertzel, V., and M. G. Goertzel (1962).Cradles of Eminence. Boston: Little, Brown.
Goldman, Sheldon (1982). Judicial selection and the qualities that make a “good” judge.Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences 462: 112–124.
Goldman, Sheldon (1971). American judges: Their selection, tenure, variety, and quality.Current History 60: 1–8.
Goldman, Sheldon (1982).Constitutional Law and Supreme Court Decision-Making. New York: Random House.
Hambleton, James E. (1983). The all-time all-star all-era Supreme Court.American Bar Association Journal 69: 463–464.
Hughes Charles Evans (1928).The Supreme Court of the United States. New York: Columbia University Press.
Hulbary, William E., and Walker, Thomas G. (1979). The Supreme Court selection process: Presidential motivations and judicial performance.Western Political Quarterly 33: 185–196.
Krislov, Samuel (1957). Oliver Wendell Holmes: The ebb and flow of judicial legendry.Northwestern University Law Review 52: 514–525.
Kynerd, Tom (1971). An analysis of presidential greatness of “presidential rating.”Southern Quarterly 9: 309–329.
Lindzey, Gardner, and Byrne, Donn (1968). Measurement of social choice and interpersonal attractiveness. InHandbook of Social Psychology, Gardner Lindzey and Elliott Aronson (eds.), Volume 2. Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley.
Maranell, Gary M. (1970). The evaluation of presidents: An extension of the Schlesinger polls.Journal of American History 57: 104–113.
Mason, Alpheus T., and Beaney, William M. (1978).American Constitutional Law. 6th ed. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall.
Mendelson, Wallace (1965).The Constitution and the Supreme Court, 2nd ed. New York: Dodd, Mead.
Murray, Robert K., and Blessing, Tim H. (1983). The presidential performance study: A progress report.Journal of American History 70: 535–555.
Nagel, Stuart S. (1970). Characteristics of Supreme Court greatness.Journal of the American Bar Association 56: 957–959.
Pound, Roscoe (1938).The Formative Era of American Law. Boston: Little, Brown.
Schmidhauser, John R. (1972).Supreme Court Justices Biographical Data. Ann Arbor, Mich.: Inter-University Consortium for Political Research.
Schmidhauser, John R. (1959). The justices of the Supreme Court: A collective portrait.Midwest Journal of Political Science 3: 1–55.
Schmidhauser, John R. (1979).Judges and Justices: The Federal Appellate Judiciary. Boston: Little, Brown.
Schwartz, Bernard (1979). The judicial ten: America's greatest judges.Southern Illinois University Law Review 1979: 405–447.
Scigliano, Robert (1972).The Supreme Court and the Presidency. Boston: Little, Brown.
Simonton, Dean Keith (1976). Biographical determinants of achieved eminence: A multivariate approach to the Cox data.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 33: 218–226.
Simonton, Dean Keith (1981). Presidential greatness and performance: Can we predict leadership in the White House?Journal of Personality 49: 306–323.
Simonton, Dean Keith (1983). Intergenerational transfer of individual difference in hereditary monarchs: Genes, role-modeling, cohort, or sociocultural effects?Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 44: 354–364.
Simonton, Dean Keith (1984).Genius, Creativity, and Leadership: Historiometric Inquiries. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Slotnick, Elliot E. (1979). The equality principle and majority opinion assignment on the United States Supreme Court.Polity 12: 318–332.
Slotnick, Elliot E. (1978). The chief justice and self-assignment of majority opinions: A research note.Western Political Quarterly 31: 219–225.
Walker, Thomas G., and Hulbary, William E. (1978). Selection of capable justices: factors to consider. In The First One Hundred Justices, Albert Blaustein and Roy Mersky (eds.), Hamden, Conn.: Archon Books.
ZoBell, Karl M. (1959). Division of opinion of the Supreme Court: A history of judicial disintegration.Cornell Law Quarterly 44: 186–214.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Caldeira, G.A. In the mirror of the justices: Sources of greatness on the Supreme Court. Polit Behav 10, 247–266 (1988). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00990554
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00990554