Abstract
A state supreme court, in making and justifying choices, uses a variety of sources of information and authority—its own precedents, scholarly commentaries, articles in law reviews, encyclopedias, restatements, and so forth. Quite often a state supreme court appeals to the wisdom or rejects the lack of it in the decision of a sister court in order to arrive at or buttress reasoning in a particularly problematic case. These citations—construed as derogation or deference—yield very handy and nonreactive indicators of hierarchies of prestige between and among the highest appellate courts of the several states. In this paper, I develop a simple and general measure of judicial reputation, present evidence on the hierarchy of state supreme courts as of 1975, show how this ranking has changed in the last 50 years, and examine competing and sometimes complementary explanations of judicial prestige. Taken together, social diversity, judicial professionalism, political ideology, and the size of case load provide an impressive explanation of the reputation of state supreme courts.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Atkins, Burton M., and Henry R. Glick (1974). “Formal Judicial Recruitment and State Supreme Court Decisions.”American Politics Quarterly 6:427–449.
Atkins, Burton M., and Henry R. Glick (1976). “Environmental and Structural Variables as Determinants of Issues in State Courts of Last Resort.”American Journal of Political Science 20:97–115.
Baum, Lawrence A., and Bradley C. Canon (1982). “State Supreme Courts as Activists: New Doctrines in the Law of Torts.” In Mary Cornelia Porter and G. Alan Tarr (eds.),State Supreme Courts: Policymaking in the Federal System. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, pp. 83–108.
Beiser, Edward N. (1973). “The Rhode Island Supreme Court: A Well-Integrated Political System.”Law & Society Review 8:167–186.
Caldeira, Gregory A. (1982). “A Tale of Two Reforms: On the Work of the Supreme Court.” In Philip Dubois (ed.),The Politics of Judicial Reform. Lexington: D. C. Health, pp. 137–152.
Canon, Bradley C., and Lawrence Baum (1981). “Patterns of Adoption of Tort Law Innovations: An Application of Diffusion Theory to Judicial Doctrines.”American Political Science Review 75:975–987.
Canon, Bradley C., and Dean Jaros (1970). “External Variables, Institutional Structure, and Dissent on State Supreme Courts.”Polity 3:175–200.
Cartwright, Bliss (1975). “Conclusion: Disputes and Reported Cases.”Law & Society Review 9:369–384.
Casper, Gerhard, and Richard A. Posner (1976).The Workload of The Supreme Court. Chicago: American Bar Foundation.
Cyert, Richard, and James G. March (1963).A Behavioral Theory of the Firm. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.
Friedman, Lawrence M. (1973). “Functions of Trial Courts in the Modern World.” Paper presented at the Conference on the Sociology of the Judicial Process, University of Bielefeld, Federal Republic of Germany, September 24–26.
Friedman, Lawrence M. (1977).Law and Society. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.
Fry, Brian R., and Winter, Richard F. (1970). “The Politics of Redistribution.”American Political Science Review 64:508–522.
Glick, Henry R. (1971).Supreme Courts in State Politics. New York: Basic Books.
Glick, Henry R. (1981). “Innovations in State Judicial Administration: Effects on Court Management and Organization.”American Politics Quarterly 9:49–69.
Glick, Henry R., and Kenneth N. Vines (1972).State Court Systems. New York: Prentice-Hall.
Goldthorpe, John H., and Keith Hope (1972). “Occupational Grading and Occupation Prestige.” In Keith Hope (ed.),The Analysis of Social Mobility. Oxford: Clarendon Press, pp. 19–79.
Gray, Virginia (1973). “Innovations in the States: A Diffusion Study.”American Political Science Review 67:1174–1185.
Grossman, Joel B., and Austin D. Sarat (1975). “Litigation in the Federal Courts: A Comparative Perspective.”Law & Society Review 9:321–346.
Grupp, Fred W., and Alan R. Richards (1975). “Variations in Elite Perceptions of American States as Referents for Public Policymaking.”American Political Science Review 69:850–858.
Harris, Peter (1979). “Some Predictors of the Interstate Diffusion of State common Law, 1870–1970.“ Paper prepared for delivery at the 1979 Annual Meetings of the Law & Society Association, San Francisco, California.
Harris, Peter (1980). “Problematic Cases and the Judicial Search for Authority.” Paper prepared for delivery at the 1980 Annual Meetings of the Law & Society Association, Madison, Wisconsin.
Hofferbert, Richard I. (1974).The Study of Public Policy. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill.
Howard, J. Woodford, Jr. (1981).Courts of Appeals in the Federal Judicial System. Princeton: Princeton University.
Kagan, Robert, Bliss Cartwright, Lawrence Friedman, and Stanton Wheeler (1977). “The Business of State Supreme Courts.”Stanford Law Review 30:121–156.
Kagan, Robert, Bliss Cartwright, Lawrence Friedman, and Stanton Wheeler (1978). “The Evolution of State Supreme Courts, 1870–1970.”Michigan Law Review 76:961–1005.
Kingdon, John (1981).Congressmen's Voting Decisions (2nd ed.) New York: Harper and Row.
Landes, William M., and Richard A. Posner (1976). “Legal Precedent: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis.”Journal of Law and Economics 19:249–307.
Laumann, Edward O., and John P. Heinz (1977). “Specialization and Prestige in the Legal Profession: The Structure of Deference.”1977 American Bar Foundation Research Journal 1977:155–216.
Lenski, Gerhard (1966).Power and Privilege. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Lewis-Beck, Michael S. (1977). “The Relative Importance of Socioeconomic and Political Variables for Public Policy.”American Political Science Review 71:559–566.
Lewis-Beck, Michael S. (1980).Applied Regression. Beverly Hills: Sage Publications.
Llewellyn, Karl N. (1960).The Common Law Tradition: Deciding Appeals. Boston: Little, Brown.
March, James G., and Herbert A. Simon (1958).Organizations. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Marvell, Thomas B. (1978).Appellate Courts and Lawyers: Information Gathering in the Adversary System. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press.
Marvell, Thomas B., and Mae Kuykendall (1980). “Appellate Courts—Facts and Figures.”State Court Journal 4:9–14, 33–37.
Mason, Margaret P. (1978). “Courting Reversal: The Supervisory Role of State Supreme Courts.”Yale Law Journal 87:1191–1218.
Matthews, Donald R., and James A. Stimson (1975).Yeas and Nays: Normal Decision-Making in the U.S. House of Representatives. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Merryman, John Henry (1954). “The Authority of Authority: What the California Supreme Court Cited in 1950.”Stanford Law Review 6:613–673.
Merryman, John Henry (1977). “Toward a Theory of Citations: An Empirical Study of the Citation Practice of the California Supreme Court in 1950, 1960, and 1970.”Southern California Law Review 50:381–428.
Morris, Thomas R. (1975).The Virginia Supreme Court: An Institutional and Political Analysis. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press.
Mott, Rodney (1936). “Judicial Influence.”American Political Science Review 30:295–315.
Mott, Rodney, Spencer D. Albright, and Helen R. Semmerling (1933). “Judicial Personnel.”Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 167:143–155.
Nagel, Stuart S. (1962). “Sociometric Relations among American Courts.”Southwestern Social Science Quarterly 43:136–142.
Panning, William H. (1981). “Networks, Information Flow, and Party Influence.” Paper prepared for delivery at the 1981 Annual Meetings of the Western Political Science Association, Denver, Colorado.
Panning, William H. (1982). “Information Flow and Party Influence: Theory, Measurement, and Policy Consequences.” Paper prepared for delivery at the 1982 Annual Meetings of the Midwest Political Science Association, Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
Riess, Albert J., Jr. (1961).Occupations and Social Status. New York: Free Press.
Schick, Marvin D. (1972).Learned Hand's Court. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Schwartz, Richard D., and James C. Miller (1963). “Legal Evolution and Societal Complexity.”American Journal of Sociology 70:159.
Shapiro, Martin (1965). “Stability and Change in Judicial Decision-Making: Incrementalism or Stare Decisis?”Law in Transition Quarterly 2:134–157.
Shapiro, Martin (1970). “Decentralized Decision-Making in the Law of Torts.” In S. S. Ulmer (ed.),Political Decision-Making. New York: Van Nostrand, pp. 44–75.
Shapiro, Martin (1972). “Toward a Theory of Stare Decisis.”Journal of Legal Studies 1:125–134.
Shils, Edward (1968). “Deference.” In John A. Jackson (ed.),Social Stratification. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 104–132.
Walker, Jack L. (1969). “The Diffusion of Innovations among the American States.”American Political Science Review 63:880–899.
Walker, Jack L. (1971). “Innovations in State Politics.” In Herbert Jacob and Kenneth N. Vines (eds.),Politics in the American States. Boston: Little, Brown, pp. 354–387.
Wildavsky, Aaron B. (1975).Budgeting: A Comparative Theory of Budgetary Processes. Boston: Little, Brown.
Wold, John T. (1976). “Political Orientations, Social Backgrounds and Role Perceptions of State Supreme Court Judges.”Western Political Quarterly 27:239–248.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Caldeira, G.A. On the reputation of state supreme courts. Polit Behav 5, 83–108 (1983). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00989987
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00989987