The anencephalic as organ donor: Whose baby is it anyway?
- 31 Downloads
Should an anencephalic newborn, lacking cerebral hemispheres but possessing a functional brain stem, be eligible for organ donation? The dialectical method is used here to envision how a protagonist and an antagonist might debate the ethics of the issue.
KeywordsBrain Stem Organ Donation Cerebral Hemisphere Functional Brain Dialectical Method
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- 1.Martin, L.W.; Gonzalez, L.L.; West, C.D.; Swartz, R.A.; and Sutorius, D.J., “Homotransplantation of Both Kidneys from an Anencephalic Monster to a 17-Pound Boy with Eagle-Barrett Syndrome,”Surgery, 1969, 66, 603–607.Google Scholar
- 2.Holzgreve, W.; Beller, F.K.; Buchholz, B.; Hansmann, M.; and Kohler, K., “Kidney Transplantation from Anencephalic Donors,”New England J. Medicine, 1987, 316, 1067–1070.Google Scholar
- 3.Walters, J.W., and Ashwal, S., “Organ Prolongation in Anencephalic Infants: Ethical and Medical Issues,”Hastings Center Report, October/November 1988, 18, 19–27.Google Scholar
- 4.Mavroudis, C.; Willis, R.W.; and Malias, M., “Orthotopic Cardiac Transplantation for the Neonate,”J. Thoracic Cardiovascular Surgery, 1989, 97, 389–391.Google Scholar
- 5.Shewmon, D.A.; Capron, A.M.; Peacock, W.J.; and Schulman, B.L., “The Use of Anencephalic Infants as Organ Sources,J. Amer. Medical Association, 1989, 261, 1773–1781.Google Scholar