Abstract
Selected health status data for elderly populations from similar industrial cities-Youngstown, Ohio, USA, and Debrecen, Hungary—were compared. Because of their impoverished health care system, unregulated heavily industrialized society, and unhealthful life-styles Hungarians were hypothesized to have poorer health status than Americans, even after taking into account demographic mediating factors. The study provides a health status baseline for elderly Hungarians shortly after communism's fall in 1989–1990 and shows how great a gap exists between Hungarian health status and that in the West. Hungarians were in much poorer health as measured by functional status, symptomatology, medical condition, depression, and subjective health status. Distinctions persisted when controlling for gender, age, and education. Poverty-level (and income) did not explain health status differences. The paper concludes that Hungary should pay more attention to health promotion, prevention, and primary care, as well as to reforming patient management in hospitals, nursing homes, and home care programs.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adam, G. 1989 Gratuity for Doctors and Medical Ethics. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 14:315–322.
“Affected by Change” 1992 Hungarian Observer 5(6):9.
American Medical Association 1992 30,000 Doctors, Nurses Protest in Hungary. AMA News 62:20.
Andorka, R. 1989 The Role of the Family in the Care of the Elderly in Hungary. In Aiding and Aging. John Mogey, ed. Pp. 35–48. New York: Westport.
“Any Hope for Recovery” 1991 The Hungarian Observer 3:2–13.
Beres, C. 1991 Debrecen and Hajdu-Bihar Country. Debrecen, Hungary: Lajos Kossuth University.
Blasszauer, B. 1986 In Hungary, the Old Medical Ethics Meet the New. Hastings Center Report 16:25–27.
Burnam A.M., K.B. Wells, B. Leake, and J. Landsverk 1988 A New Depression Scale Measure. Medical Care 26:775–789.
Buss, T.F. and D. Gemmel 1990 Yougnstown, Ohio: Warren A Reflection of the Boom and Bust of the Steel Industry. In Economic Restructuring of the American Midwest. R. Bingham and R. Eberts, eds. Pp. 289–307. New York: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Csaszi, L. 1990 Interpreting Inequalities in the Hungarian Health System. Social Science and Medicine 31:275–284.
Csaszi, L. and P. Kullberg 1985 Reforming Health Care in Hungary. Social Science and Medicine 21:849–855.
Deacon, B. 1984 Medical Care and Health Under State Socialism. International Journal of Health Services 14:453–480.
Derogatis, L.R., R.S. Lepinan, K. Rickels, E.H. Unlentruth, and L. Covi 1974 The Hopkins Symptom Checklist (HSCL): A Self-Report Symptom Inventory. Behavioral Science 19:1–15.
Deyo, R.A. and D.L. Patrick 1989 Barriers to the Use of Health Status Measures in Clinical Investigation, Patient Care, and Policy Research. Medical Care 27:254–268.
Forgacs, I. and M. Kokeny 1987 Toward a New Health Policy in Hungary. Health Policy 8:183–192.
Forster, D.P. and P. Jozan 1990 Health in Eastern Europe. Lancet 335:458–460.
Gillanders, W.R., T.F. Buss, and D. Gemmel 1991 Assessing the Denominator Problem in Community Oriented Primary Care. Family Medicine 23:75–79.
Gulacsi, L. 1992 Health Status of the Elderly in Debrecen, Hungary. Proceedings of the First National Conference on Quality Assurance. Debrecen, Hungary, June 10–13.
Gy, M. 1986 The Critical Age. Esti Hirlap 30:3.
Illinois Department of Aging 1983 Determination of Need. IL-402-0195. Springfield, IL: Department of Aging.
Ikels, C. 1991 Aging and Disability in China. Social Science and Medicine 32(6):649–665.
Kaser, M. 1976 Health Care in the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe. Boulder: Westview Press.
Kis, G. 1989 Economic Aspects in Developing the Health Care System in Hungary. La Sante Publique 32:99–106.
Kullberg, P. 1986 Social Visions and Social Control: The Evolution of Medical Thought in Postwar Hungary. International Journal of Health Services 16:391–408.
Kvale, J.N., W.R. Gillanders, T.F. Buss, C.R. Hofstetter, and D. Gemmel 1990 Health and Poverty Among Elderly Persons. Journal of the American Board of Family Practice 3:231–239.
Lahelma, E. and V. Tapani 1990 Health and Social Inequalities in Finland and Elsewhere. Social Science and Medicine 3:265–275.
Liang, J., J. Bennett, N. Whitelow, and D. Maeda 1991 The Structure of Self-Reported Physical Health Among the Aged in the US and Japan. Medical Care 29:1161–1180.
Lipinsky, E. and R. Illsley 1990 International Comparative Analysis. Social Science and Medicine 31:879–889.
Makara, K. 1991 A Wasting Disease: Health of a Nation. New Hungarian Review 32:45–51.
Megyeri, K. 1982 Care of the Elderly in Hungary. The Journal of Nursing Care 15:12–15.
Mogey, J., ed. 1989 Aiding and Aging. New York: Westport.
Orosz, E. 1991 Handicapped by Old and New Traps: Hungary's Health Care Reform. International Social Security Review 44:19–30.
Orosz, E. 1990 The Hungarian Country Profile: Inequalities in Health and Health Care in Hungary. Social Science and Medicine 31:847–857.
Petrovics-Ofner, L. 1992 The Healing Profession Needs Healing. Budapest Weekly 2:6–8.
Pope, G.C. 1988 Medical Conditions, Health Status, and Health Service Utilization. Health Services Research 22:857–880.
“Program of Reform of Our Health Care System” 1991 Budapest: Ministry of Health, Working Paper.
Raffel, N.K. and M.W. Raffel 1989 The Medical Care System of Hungary. Journal of Medical Practice Management 4:142–149.
Rihmer, Z., J. Barsi, K. Veg, and C.L. Katona 1990 Suicide Rates in Hungary Correlate Negatively with Reported Rates of Depression. Journal of Affective Disorders 20:87–91.
Schiff, A.F. 1990 Medicine in Budapest. Sourthern Medical Journal 83:313–314.
Tabachnick, B.G. and L.S. Fidell 1989 Using Multivariate Statistics, 2nd edition. New York: Harper & Row, Publishers.
Tamasy, J. 1982 Aging and Some Aspects of Its Public Health Implications in Hungary. World Health Statistics 35:259–280.
Velkoff, V.A. 1992 Aging Trends: Hungary. Journal of Cross-Cultural Gerontology 7:429–437.
Weinerman, E.R. 1969 Social Medicine in Eastern Europe. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
World Health Organization 1991 World Health Statistics Annual, 1990. Geneva: WHO.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Buss, T.F., Beres, C., Hofstetter, C.R. et al. Health status among elderly Hungarians and Americans. J Cross-Cultural Gerontol 9, 301–322 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00978216
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00978216