Summary
Studies of the spectrum of the intermediate hosts of schistosomes and the relationships between parasites and intermediate host snails have been carried out with each researcher using different methods. A comparison between compatibility studies has therefore been impossible. The following three basic problems in these kind of studies are discussed in this paper: (1) the standardization of experimental materials such as schistosomes, intermediate and final hosts, (2) the methods involved in the experiments, and (3) the sort of data which must be collected. Standardized methods and materials are described in this paper.
The relationships between the genusSchistosoma and the intermediate host snails belonging to the two generaBiomphalaria andBulinus, and the mechanisms behind the process resulting in various degrees of compatibility between the two involved organisms are reviewed and discussed. Why certain combinations of schistosomes and snails result in the production of cercariae and others do not is still unknown, but there is now some indication of a camouflage behaviour during the intramolluscan stages, e.g., the larvae in the snails cover themselves with snail material and are not recognized as foreign objects. The same mechanism has already been found in the schistosomules in the final host.
Much of the confusion in the discussion of the relationships between schistosomes and intermediate hosts is the result of a lack of an objective way to describe and assess the compatibility between the two. Based on a series of experiments withS. haematobium, S. intercalatum, S. bovis, S. mansoni, and several species of possible intermediate hosts, the following index for estimating the degree of compatibility is proposed: the total cercarial production from 100 exposed snails (TCP/100 exposed snails). Seven classes have been suggested: the first one (Class 0) with a TCP/100 exposed snails of zero, is called ‘refractory’; the next one (Class I) called ‘not very compatible’ has a TCP/100 exposed snails between 1 and 10,000; the last group (Class IV) called ‘extremely compatible’ produced more than 500,001 per 100 exposed snails during the entire lifespan.
The ability to use a spectrum of intermediate hosts and the compatibility in the taxonomy of schistosomes is discussed. The results for the different species of schistosomes indicated that each species consists of strains with ‘hybrid populations’ in between.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- B. afr. :
-
Bulinus africanus
- B. ale. :
-
Biomphalaria alexandrina
- B. glo. :
-
Bul. globosus
- B. nat. :
-
Bul. natalensis
- B.c. cam. :
-
Biomph. camerunensis camerunensis
- B.c. wan. :
-
Biomph. camerunensis wansoni
- B. cer. :
-
Bul. cernicus
- B. cho. :
-
Biomph. choanomphala
- B. cou. :
-
Bul. coulboisi
- B. for. :
-
Bul. forskalii
- B. gla. :
-
Biomph. glabrata
- B. per. :
-
Bul. permembranaceus
- B. pfe. :
-
Biomph. pfeifferi
- B. sal. :
-
Biomph. salinarum
- B. sud. :
-
Biomph. sudanica
- B. tro. :
-
Bul. tropicus
- B. tru. :
-
Bul. truncatus
- B. tru. :
-
Bul. wrighti
References
Barbosa, F.S., Barreto, C.: Differences in susceptibility of Brazilian strains ofAustralorbis glabratus toSchistosoma mansoni. Exp. Parasitol.9, 137–140 (1960)
Barbosa, F.S., Coelho, M.D.: Pesquisa de imunidade adquirida homóloga emAustralorbis glabratus nas infestações porSchistosoma mansoni. Rev. Bras. Malariol. Doenças Trop.8, 49–56 (1956)
Basch, P.F.: An interpretation of snail-trematode infection rates: specificity based on concordance of compatible phenotypes. Int. J. Parasitol.5, 449–452 (1975)
Basch, P.F.: Intermediate host-specificity inSchistosoma mansoni. Exp. Parasitol.39, 150–164 (1976)
Basch, P.F., Diconza, J.J.: The miracidium-sporocyst transition inSchistosoma mansoni: surface changes in vitro with ultrastructural correlations. J. Parasitol.60, 935–941 (1974)
Brooks, C.P.: A comparative study ofSchistoma mansoni inTropicorbis havanensis andAustralorbis glabratus. J. Parasitol.39, 159–165 (1953)
Brown, D.S., Burch, J.B.: Distribution of cytologically different populations of the genusBulinus (Basommatophora: Planorbidae) in Ethiopia. Malacologia6, 189–198 (1967)
Bruce, J.I., Radke, M.G.: CulturingBiomphalaria andOncomelania (Gastropoda) for large-scale studies of schistosomiasis. Bio-medical report number nineteen, 406th Medical Laboratory. USArmy Medical Department Activity. Japan-APO San Francisco 96343 1971
Burch, J.B., Lindsay, G.K.: An immuno-cytological study ofBulinus s.s. (Basommatophora: Planorbidae). Malacol. Rev.3, 1–18 (1970)
Chauhan, A.S., Srivastava, C.B., Chauhan, B.S.: Studies of the trematode fauna of India. 6. Digenea: Schistosomatidae. A monographic aid to the identification of Indian schistosomes. J. Zool. Soc. India25, 83–127 (1973)
Cheng, T.C.: The compatibility and incompatibility concept as related to trematodes and mollusca. Pacific Sci.22, 141–160 (1968)
Cheng, T.C., Lee, F.O.: Glucose levels in the molluscBiomphalaria glabrata infected withSchistosoma mansoni. J. Invertebr. Pathol.18, 395–399 (1971)
Chernin, E.: Transplantation of larvalSchistosoma mansoni from infected to uninfected snails. J. Parasitol.52, 473–482 (1966)
Chernin, E.: Interference with the capacity ofSchistosoma mansoni miracidia to infect the molluscan host. J. Parasitol.54, 509–516 (1968)
Christensen, N.Ø., Nansen, P., Frandsen, F.: Studies on the infectivity ofFasciola hepatica miracidia toLymnaea truncatula. Attachment and penetration of miracidia into non-infected and infected snails. Z. Parasitenkd.50, 67–71 (1976)
Cridland, C.C.: Results of exposure of batches from highly susceptible and less susceptible strains ofBiomphalaria alexandrina alexandrina from Egypt to strains ofSchistosoma mansoni from Cairo and Alexandria. Bull. WHO39, 955–961 (1968)
Cridland, C.C.: Susceptibility of the snailBiomphalaria alexandrina alexandrina from UAR and the Sudan to infection with a strain ofSchistosoma mansoni from Tanzania. Bull. WHO43, 809–815 (1970)
Deschiens, R., Delas, A., Ngalle-Edimo, S., Poirier, A.: La schistosomiase àSchistosoma intercalatum en République fédérale du Cameroun. Bull. WHO40, 893–898 (1969)
Dinnik, J.A., Dinnik, N.N.: The schistosomes of domestic ruminants in Eastern Africa. Bull. Epizoot. Afr.13, 341–359 (1965)
Dorsey, C.H.:Schistosoma mansoni: Development of acetabular glands of cercariae at ultrastructural level. Exp. Parasitol.37, 37–59 (1975)
Farley, J.: A review of the family Schistosomatidae: excluding the genusSchistosoma from mammals. J. Helminthol.45, 289–320 (1971)
File, S.K.: Superinfection ofBiomphalaria glabrata withSchistosoma mansoni. J. Parasitol.61, 75–78 (1975)
Files, V.S.: A study of the vector-parasite relationships inSchistosoma mansoni. Parasitology,41, 264–269 (1951)
Files, V.S., Cram, E.B.: A study of the comparative susceptibility of snail vector to strains ofSchistosoma mansoni. J. Parasitol.35, 555–560 (1949)
Frandsen, F.: Host-parasite relationship ofBulinus forskalii (Ehrenberg) andSchistosoma intercalatum Fisher, 1934, from Cameroun. J. Helminthol.49, 73–84 (1975)
Frandsen, F.: Hybridization between different strains ofSchistosoma intercalatum Fisher, 1934, from Cameroun and Zaïre. J. Helminthol.52, 11–22 (1978)
Frandsen, F.: Studies of the relationship betweenSchistosoma and their intermediate hosts. I. The genusBulinus andSchistosoma haematobium from Egypt. J. Helminthol.53 (in press 1978)
Frandsen, F.: Studies of the relationship betweenSchistosoma and their intermediate hosts. II. The genusBulinus andSchistosoma haematobium from Sudan, Zaïre, and Zambia. J. Helminthol.53 (in press 1978b)
Frandsen, F.: Studies of the relationship betweenSchistosoma and their intermediate hosts. III. The genusBiomphalaria andSchistosoma mansoni from Egypt, Kenya, Sudan, Uganda, West Indies, and Zaïre (Katanga and Kinshasa). J. Helminthol.53 (in press 1978c)
Frandsen, F.: Studies of the relationship betweenSchistosoma and their intermediate hosts. IV. The genusBulinus andSchistosoma bovis from Morocco. J. Helminthol.53 (in press 1978d)
Frandsen, F., Bennike, I., Cridland, C.C.: Studies onSchistosoma intercalatum Fisher, 1934 and its intermediate snail host in the Kisangani area, Zaïre. Ann. Soc. Belg. Med. Trop.58, 21–31 (1978)
Fripp, P.J.: The taxonomy of the genusSchistosoma. Cent. Afr. J. Med.16, 12–14 (1970)
Ghandour, A.M., Webbe, G.: A comparative study of the death of schistosomula ofSchistosoma haematobium andSchistosoma mansoni in the skin of mice and hamsters. J. Helminthol.50, 39–43 (1976)
Gilbertson, D.E., Etges, F.J., Ogle, J.D.: Free aminoacids ofAustralorbis glabratus hemolymph: comparison of four geographic strains and effect of infection bySchistosoma mansoni. J. Parasitol.53, 565–568 (1967)
Hsü, H.F., Hsü, S.Y.L.: On the intraspecific and interstrain variations of the male sexual glands ofSchistosoma japonicum. J. Parasitol.43, 456–463 (1957)
Hunter, G.W., Ritchie, L.S., Otori, Y.: A comparison of the infectivity ofSchistosoma japonicum occuring in Japan forOncomelania nosophora andOncomelania formosana. J. Parasitol.38, 492 (1952)
Ishak, M., Mohamed, A.M., Sharaf, A.A.: Carbohydrate metabolism in uninfected and trematode-infected snailsBiomphalaria alexandrina andBulinus truncatus. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. [8]51, 499–505 (1975)
James, C., Webbe, G.: A comparison of Egyptian and East African strains ofSchistosoma haematobium. J. Helminthol.47, 49–59 (1973)
James, C., Webbe, G.: A comparison of Sudanese and South African strains ofSchistosoma haematobium. J. Helminthol.49, 191–197 (1975)
Kuntz, E.R.: Exposure of planorbid snails from the Western Hemisphere to miracidia of the Egyptian strain ofSchistosoma mansoni. Proc. Helminthol. Soc. Wash.19, 9–15 (1952)
Kuntz, R.E.: Biology of the schistosome complexes. Am. J. Trop. Med. Hyg.4, 383–414 (1955)
Kuntz, R.E., Malakatis, G.M.: Susceptibility studies in schistosomiasis. III. Infection of various experimental hosts withSchistosoma haematobium. Exp. Parasitol.4, 1–20 (1955)
Kuntz, R.E., Tulloch, G.S., Davidson, D.L., Huang, T.: Scanning electron microscopy of the integumental surfaces ofSchistosoma haematobium. J. Parasitol.62, 63–69 (1976)
Kuntz, R.E., Tulloch, G.S., Huang, I., Davidson, D.L.: Scanning electron microscopy of integumental surfaces ofSchistosoma intercalatum. J. Parasitol.63, 401–406 (1977)
Leroux, P.L.: The validity ofSchistosoma capense (Harley, 1864) amended as a species. Trans. R. Soc. Trop. Med. Hyg.52, 12–14 (1958)
Leroux, P.L.: Some problems in bilharziasis in Africa and the adjoining countries. J. Helminthol.35, (suppl.) 117–126 (1961)
Lim, S.H.K.: Parametres and mechanisms of antagonistic interactions betweenSchistosoma mansoni andParyphostomum segregatum in the snailBiomphalaria glabrata. Doctoral dissertation, University of California, San Francisco 1970
Mandahl-Barth, G.: Intermediate hosts ofSchistosoma: AfricanBiomphalaria andBulinus. WHO Monogr. Ser.37, 1–132 (1958)
McCullough, F.S.: A preliminary note on the degree of compatibility betweenSchistosoma haematobium and its bulinid vectors. West Afr. Med. J.6, 98–100 (1957)
McQuay, R.M., Jr.: Studies on variability in the susceptibility of a North American snailTropicorbis havanensis to infection with the Puerto Rican strain ofSchistosoma mansoni. Trans. R. Soc. Trop. Med. Hyg.47, 56–61 (1953)
Miller, F.M., Tulloch, G.S., Kuntz, R.E.: Scanning electron microscopy of integumental surface ofSchistosoma mansoni. J. Parasitol.58, 693–698 (1972)
Moore, D.V., Meleney, H.F.: Comparative susceptibility of common laboratory animals to experimental infection withSchistosoma haematobium. J. Parasitol.40, 392–397 (1954)
Morris, G.P., Threadgold, L.T.: Ultrastructure of the tegument of adultSchistosoma mansoni. J. Parasitol.54, 15–27 (1968)
Nansen, P., Frandsen, F., Christensen, N.Ø.: A study on snail location byFasciola hepatica using radioisotopically labelled miracidia. Parasitology72, 163–172 (1976)
Nelson, G.S.: Schistosome infections as zoonoses in Africa. Trans. R. Soc. Trop. Med. Hyg.54, 301–316 (1960)
Newton, W.L.: The comparative tissue reaction of two strains ofAustralorbis glabratus to infection withSchistosoma mansoni. J. Parasitol.38, 362–366 (1952)
Newton, W.L.: The inheritance of susceptibility to infection withSchistosoma mansoni inAustralorbis glabratus. Exp. Parasitol.2, 242–257 (1953)
Pan, C.T.: Generalized and focal tissue responses in the snail,Australorbis glabratus, infected withSchistosoma mansoni. Ann. NY Acad. Sci.113, 475–485 (1963)
Paraense, W.L., Correâ, L.R.: Variations in susceptibility of populations ofAustralorbis glabratus to a strain ofSchistosoma mansoni. Rev. Inst. Med. Trop. Sao Paulo5, 15–22 (1963)
Pitchford, R.J.: Differences in the egg morphology and certain biological characteristics of some African and Middle Eastern schistosomes, genusSchistosoma, with terminal-spined eggs. Bull. WHO32, 105–120 (1965)
Richards, C.S.: Infectivity ofSchistosoma mansoni for Puerto Rican molluscs including a new potential intermediate host. Am. J. Trop. Med. Hyg.12, 26–33 (1963)
Richards, C.S.: Genetics of a molluscan vector of schistosomiasis. Nature227 806–810 (1970)
Richards, C.S.: Susceptibility of adultBiomphalaria glabrata toSchistosoma mansoni infection. Am. J. Trop. Med. Hyg.22, 748–756 (1973)
Richards, C.S.: Genetic factors in susceptibility ofBiomphalaria glabrata for different strains ofSchistosoma mansoni. Parasitology70, 231–241 (1975a)
Richards, C.S.: Genetic studies on variation in infectivity ofSchistosoma mansoni. J. Parasitol.6, 233–241 (1975b)
Richards, C.S.: Genetics of the host-parasite relationship betweenBiomphalaria glabrata andSchistosoma mansoni. In Genetic aspects of host-parasite relationships. Symposia of the British Society for Parasitology, A.E.R. Taylor and R. Muller, eds., Vol. 14 pp. 45–54. Oxford/London: Blackwell Sci. Publ. 1976
Richards, C.S.:Schistosoma mansoni: Susceptibility reversal with age in the snail hostBiomphalaria mansoni. Exp. Parasitol.42, 165–168 (1977)
Richards, C.S., Merritt, J.W., Jr.: Genetic factors in susceptibility of juvenileBiomphalaria glabrata toSchistosoma mansoni infection. Am. J. Trop. Med. Hyg.21, 425–434 (1972)
Ross, G.C.: Isoenzymes inSchistosoma ssp.: LDH, MDH and acid phosphatases separated by iselectric focussing in polyacrylamide gel. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. [B]55, 343–346 (1976)
Sadun, E.H., Lichtenberg, F. von, Bruce, J.I.: Susceptibility and comparative pathology of ten species of primates exposed to infection withSchistosoma mansoni. Am. J. Trop. Med. Hyg.15, 705–718 (1966)
Sakamoto, K., Ishii, Y.: Scanning electron microscope observations on adultSchistosoma japonicum. J. Parasitol.63, 407–412 (1977)
Saoud, M.F.A.: Comparative studies on the characteristics of some geographical strains ofSchistosoma mansoni in mice and hamsters. J. Helminthol.39, 101–112 (1965)
Saoud, M.F.A.: On the infra-specific variations of the male sexual glands ofSchistosoma mansoni. J. Helminthol.40, 385–394 (1966)
Schreiber, F.G., Schubert, M.: Experimental infection of the snailAustralorbis glabratus with the trematodeSchistosoma mansoni and the production of cercariae. J. Parasitol.35, 91–100 (1949)
Schwetz, J.: A comparative morphological and biological study ofSchistosoma haematobium, S. bovis, S. intercalatum (Fisher, 1934),S. mansoni andS. rodhaini (Brumpt. 1931). Ann. Trop. Med. Parasitol.45, 92–98 (1951)
Senft, A.: Studies in proline metabolism ofSchistosoma mansoni. I. Radioautography following in vitro exposure to radioproline C. Comp. Biochem. Physiol.27, 251–261 (1968)
Simoes, M., Gracio, M.A.: Fraga de Azevedo, J.: Effects of the populational density on the growth and fecundity of specimens of theBulinus sp. An. Inst. Hig. Nedic2, 535–539 (1974)
Smithers, V.R., Terry, R.J., Hockley, D.J.: Host antigens in schistosomiasis. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. [Biol.]171, 483–494 (1969)
Southgate, V.R., Knowles, R.J.: Observations onSchistosoma bovis Sonsino, 1876. J. Nat. Hist.9, 273–314 (1975)
Standen, O.D.: Experimental infection ofAustralorbis glabratus withSchistosoma mansoni. I. Individual and mass infections of snails, and the relationship of infection to temperature and season. Ann. Trop. Med. Parasitol.46, 48–53 (1952)
Stirewalt, M.A.: Effect of snail maintenance temperature on development ofSchistosoma mansoni. Exp. Parasitol.3, 504–516 (1954)
Stirewalt, M.A., Fregeau, W.A.: An invasive system present in cercariae but absent in schistosomules ofSchistosoma mansoni. Exp. Parasitol.19, 206–215 (1966)
Stirewalt, M.A., Kuntz, R.E., Evans, A.S.: The relative susceptibilities of the commonly used laboratory mammals to infection bySchistosoma mansoni. Am. J. Trop. Med.31, 57–82 (1951)
Sturrock, R.F., Sturrock, B.M.: Observations on the susceptibility toSchistosoma mansoni from St. Lucia of several Caribbean strains of snails of the genusBiomphalaria. West Indian Med. J.19, 9–13 (1970)
Sudds, R.H., Jr.: Observations of schistosome miracidial behaviour in the presence of normal and abnormal snail hosts and subsequent tissue studies of the normal hosts. J. Elisha Mitchell Sci. Soc.76, 121–123 (1960)
Targett, G.A.T.: A study of the amino acids present inLymnaea stagnalis, Planorbarius corneus andAustralorbis glabratus before and after infection withSchistosoma mansoni. Ann. Trop. Med. Parasitol.56, 210–215 (1962)
Taylor, M.G.: Hybridization experiments on five species of African schistosomes. J. Helminthol.44, 253–314 (1970)
Taylor, M.G., Andrews, B.J.: Comparison of the infectivity and pathogenicity of six species of African schistosomes and their hybrids. 1. Mice and hamsters. J. Helminthol.47, 439–453 (1973)
Taylor, M.G., James, E.R., Nelson, G.S., Bickle, Q., Dunne, D.W., Dobinson, A.R., Dargie, J.D., Berry, C., Hussein, M.F.: Modification of pathogenicity ofSchistosoma mattheei for sheep by passage of parasite in hamsters. J. Helminthol.51, 337–345 (1978)
Thomas, J.D.: Schistosomiasis and control of molluscan hosts of human schistosomes with particular reference to self-regulatory mechanisms. Adv. Parasitol.11, 307–394 (1973)
Thomas, J.D., Lough, A.S., Lodge, R.W.: The chemical ecology ofBiomphalaria glabrata (Say), the snail host ofSchistosoma mansoni Sambon: the search for factors in media conditioned by snails which inhibit their growth and reproduction. J. Appl. Ecol.12, 421–436 (1975)
Thurston, J.P.: Schistosomes fromHippopotamus amphibius. L. I. The morphology ofSchistosoma hippopotami sp. nov. Parasitology53, 49–54 (1963)
Thurston, J.P.: Schistosomes fromHippopotamus amphibius L. II. The morphology ofSchistosoma edwardiense sp. nov. Parasitology54, 67–72 (1964)
Tripp, M.R.: The fate of foreign materials experimentally introduced into the snailAustralorbis glabratus. J. Parasitol.47, 745–751 (1961)
Webbe, G.: The significance of infra-specific variations of hosts and parasites in the epidemiology of helminths of medical importance. J. Helminthol.45, 327–335 (1971)
Webbe, G., James, C.: Infraspecific variation ofSchistosoma haematobium. J. Helminthol.45, 403–413 (1971a)
Webbe, G., James, C.: The importation and maintenance of schistosomes of human and veterinary importance. In: Isolation and maintenance of parasites in vivo. Symp. Br. Soc. for Parasitol. Vol. 9, A.E.R. Taylor and R. Muller, eds., Oxford: Blackwell Sci. Publ. 1971b
Webbe, G., James, C.: A comparison of two geographical strains ofSchistosoma haematobium. J. Helminthol.45, 271–284 (1971c)
Webbe, G., James, C.: Host-parasite relationships ofBulinus globosus andB. truncatus with strains ofSchistosoma haematobium. J. Helminthol.46, 185–199 (1972)
Wium-Andersen, G.: Electrophoretic studies on esterases of some AfricanBiomphalaria species (Planorbidae). Malacologia12, 115–122 (1973)
Wright, C.A.: The crowding phenomenon in laboratory colonies of freshwater snails. Ann. Trop. Med. Parasitol.54, 224–232 (1960)
Wright, C.A.: The significance of infra-specific taxonomy in bilharziasis. CIBA Foundation Symposium in Bilharziasis, G.E.W. Wolstenholme and M. O'Connor, eds., pp. 103–120. London: Churchill 1962
Wright, C.A.: Biochemical variation inLymnaea peregra (Mollusca: Basommathophora). Proc. Zool. Soc. Lond.142, 371–378 (1964)
Wright, C.A.: Relationships between schistosomes and their molluscan hosts in Africa. J. Helminthol.40, 403–412 (1966)
Wright, C.A.:Bulinus on Aldabra and the subfamily Bulininae in the Indian Ocean area. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. [Biol.]260, 299–313 (1971)
Wright, C.A.: Snail susceptibility or trematode infectivity? J. Nat. Hist.8, 545–548 (1974)
Wright, C.A., Bennett, M.S.: Studies onSchistosoma haematobium in the laboratory. I. A strain from Durban, Natal, South Africa. Trans. R. Soc. Trop. Med. Hyg.61, 221–227 (1967a)
Wright, C.A., Bennett, M.S.: Studies onSchistosoma haematobium in the laboratory. II. A strain from South Arabia. Trans. R. Soc. Trop. Med. Hyg.61, 228–233 (1967b)
Wright, C.A., Southgate, V.R.: Hybridization of schistosomes and some of its implications. Genetic aspects of host-parasite relationships. Symp. Br. Soc. Parasitol. Vol. 14 A.E.R. Taylor and R. Muller, eds., pp. 55–86. Oxford: Blackwell Sci. Publ. 1976
Wright, C.A., Southgate, V.R., Knowles, R.J.: What isSchistosoma intercalatum Fisher, 1934? Trans. R. Soc. Trop. Med. Hyg.66, 28–64 (1972)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Frandsen, F. Discussion of the relationships betweenSchistosoma and their intermediate hosts, assessment of the degree of host-parasite compatibility and evaluation of schistosome taxonomy. Z. Parasitenkd. 58, 275–296 (1979). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00933934
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00933934