Abstract
The best estimate of indigenous lunar siderophiles comes from 29 pristine lunar rocks, characterized by low siderophile abundances, plutonic textures, and high age. Delano and Ringwood's blanket rejection of these rocks, on the contention that they are impact melts, is not justified by the petrologic evidence. Contrary to their claims, gold in highland breccias is largely meteoritic and is unaffected by fumarolic volcanism, as shown by its correlation with Ir and noncorrelation with fumarolic T1 (r=0.896 and 0.272). Delano and Ringwood's approach, involving subtraction of an H-chondrite meteoritic component from highland breccias, ignores the variation of Ir/Au ratios in modern and ancient meteorites, and hence leads to spurious excesses of Au, Ni, and volatiles, and in some cases to physically meaningless, negative residuals. Their ‘excess volatiles’ in highland crust relative to mare basalts disappear when the highland composition is based on pristine lunar rocks rather than under-corrected breccias. Contrary to claims by Delano and Ringwood, the Ni/Co trend in Apollo 16 samples cannot be explained by an indigenous component rich in Ni (150–200 ppm) and Co (30–45ppm); mixing lines show that much lower Ni and Co contents are required (e.g.,∼ 7 ppm each).
Chondrites and lunar highland breccias show essentially parallel fractionation trends for the siderophile-element ratios Re/Ir, Au/Ir, Ni/Ir, Ni/Pd, and Os/Ir. Because the chondritic ratios were established in the solar nebula, it appears that the lunar ratios also reflect nebular processes, and have not been modified by planetary processes.
Properly derived abundances for the lunar highlands show large, systematic depletions relative to terrestrial oceanic tholeiites, by the following factors: Ge 270, Re 230, Sb170, Zn150, Au60, Tl 50, Ag 48, Ni 42, Se 12. It would seem that the resemblance to the Earth's mantle is not quite as ‘striking’ as claimed by Delano and Ringwood.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
de Albuquerque, C. A. R.: 1972, ‘Thallium in Basalts and Related Rocks,Chem. Geology 10 41–58.
Bickel, C. E. and Warner, J. L.: 1977, ‘Survey of Lunar Plutonic and Granulitic Lithic Fragments (abstract)’ inLunar Science VIII, pp. 112–114. The Lunar Science Institute, Houston.
Bickel, C. E. and Warner, J. L.: 1978, ‘Survey of Lunar Plutonic and Granulitic Lithic Fragments’,Proc. Lunar and Planetary Sci. Conf. 9th, in press.
Brett, R.: 1976, ‘Reduction of Mare Basalts by Sulfur Loss’,Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 40 997–1004.
Chou, C.-L., Boynton, W. V., Sundbert, L. L., and Wasson, J. T.: 1975, ‘Volatiles on the Surface of Apollo 15 Green Glass and Trace-Element Distributions among Apollo 15 Soils’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 6th pp. 1701–1727.
Delano, J. W. and Ringwood, A. E. 1978a, ‘Indigenous Siderophile Element Component of the Lunar Highlands and Its Significance’, inLunar and Planetary Science IX pp. 238–240. The Lunar Science Institute, Houston.
Delano, J. W. and Ringwood, A. E.: 1978b, ‘Indigenous Abundances of Siderophile Elements in the Lunar Highlands: Implications for the Origin of the Moon’,The Moon and the Planets,18, 385–425.
Delano, J. W. and Ringwood, A. E.: 1978c, ‘Siderophile Elements in the Lunar Highlands: Nature of the Indigenous Component and Implications for the Origin of the Moon’,Proc. Lunar and Planetary Sci. Conf. 9th, in press.
Delano, J. W. and Ringwood, A. E.: 1978d, ‘Reply’,The Moon and the Planets (submitted).
Dixon, J.R. and Papike, J. J.: 1975, ‘Petrology of Anorthosites from the Descartes Region of the Moon: Apollo 16’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 6th, pp. 263–292.
Dowty, E., Keil, K., Prinz, M., Gros, J., and Takahashi, H.: 1976, ‘Meteorite-Free Apollo 15 Crystalline KREEP’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 7th, pp. 1833–1844.
Dreibus, G., Kruse, H., Spettel, B., and Wänke, H.: 1977, ‘The Bulk Composition of the Moon and the Eucrite Parent Body’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 8th, pp. 211–237.
Ganapathy, R., Keays, R. R., Laul, J. C., and Anders, E.: 1970, ‘Trace Elements in Apollo 11 Lunar Rocks: Implications for Meteorite Influx and Origin of Moon’,Proc. Apollo 11 Lunar Sci. Conf., pp. 1117–1142.
Ganapathy, R., Morgan, J. W., Krähenbühl, U., and Anders, E.: 1973, ‘Ancient Meteoritic Components in Lunar Highland Rocks: Clues from Trace Elements in Apollo 15 and 16 Samples’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 4th, pp. 1239–1261.
Ganapathy, R., Morgan, J. W., Higuchi, H., Anders, E., and Anderson, A. T.: 1974a, ‘Meteoritic and Volatile Elements in Apollo 16 Rocks and in Separated Phases from 14306 (abstract)’, inLunar Science V pp. 257–259. The Lunar Science Institute, Houston.
Ganapathy, R., Morgan, J. W., Higuchi, H., Anders, E., and Anderson, A. T.: 1974b, ‘Meteoritic and Volatile Elements in Apollo 16 Rocks and in Separated Phases from 14306’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 5th, pp. 1659–1683.
Gibson, E. K., Jr., Brett, R., and Andrawes, F.: 1977, ‘Sulfur in Lunar Mare Basalts as a Function of Bulk Composition’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 8th pp. 1417–1428.
Grieve, R. A.: 1978, ‘Meteoritic Component and Impact Melt Composition at the Lac a l'Eau Claire (Clearwater) Impact Structures, Quebec’,Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 42, 429–431.
Gros, J., Takahashi, H., Hertogen, J., Morgan, J. W., and Anders, E.: 1976, ‘Composition of the Projectiles that Bombarded the Lunar Highlands’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 7th, pp. 2403–2435.
Grossman, L. and Larimer, J. W.: 1974, ‘Early Chemical History of the Solar System’,Rev. Geophys. Space Phys. 12, 71–101.
Haines, E. L., Hutcheon, I. D., and Weiss, J. R.: 1975, ‘The Fission Track Record of Apennine Front KREEP Basalts’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 6th, pp. 3527–3540.
Hertogen, J., Janssens, M.-J., Takahashi, H., Palme, H., and Anders, E.: 1977, ‘Lunar Basins and Craters: Evidence for Systematic Compositional Changes of Bombarding Population,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 8th, pp. 17–45.
Herzberg, C.: 1978, ‘The Bearing of Spinel Cataclasites on the Crust-Mantle Structure of the Moon’,Proc. Lunar and Planetary Sci. Conf. 9th, in press.
Higuchi, H. and Morgan, J. W.: 1975, ‘Ancient Meteoritic Component in Apollo 17 Boulders’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 6th, pp. 1625–1651.
Irving, A. J.: 1975, ‘Chemical, Mineralogical, and Textural Systematics of Non-Mare Melt Rocks: Implications for Lunar Impact and Volcanic Processes,’Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 6th, pp. 363–394.
James, O. B.: 1973, ‘Crystallization History of Lunar Feldspathic Basalt 14310’, Geological Survey Professional Paper 841, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C.
Janssens, M.-J., Palme, H., Hertogen, J., Anderson, A. T., and Anders, E.: 1978, ‘Meteoritic Material in Lunar Highland Samples from the Apollo 11 and 12 Sites’,Proc. Lunar and Planetary Sci. Conf. 9th in press.
Kimura, K., Lewis, R. S., and Anders, E.: 1974, ‘Distribution of Gold and Rhenium between Nickel-Iron and Silicate Melts: Implications for the Abundance of Siderophile Elements on the Earth and Moon’,Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 38, 683–701.
Krähenbühl, U., Ganapathy, R., Morgan, J. W., and Anders, E.: 1973, ‘Volatile Elements in Apollo 16 Samples: Implications for Highland Volcanism and Accretion History of the Moon’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 4th, pp. 1325–1348.
Laul, J. C., Morgan, J. W., Ganapathy, R., and Anders, E.: 1971, ‘Meteoritic Material in Lunar Samples: Characterization from Trace Elements’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 2nd, pp. 1139–1158.
Lovering, J. R. and Hughes, T. C.: 1971, ‘Rhenium and Osmium Abundance Determinations and Meteoritic Contamination Levels in Apollo 11 and Apollo 12 Lunar Samples’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 2nd pp. 1331–1335.
Meyer, C., Jr., McKay, D. S., Anderson, D. H., and Butler, B., Jr.: 1975, ‘The Source of Sublimates on the Apollo 15 Green and Apollo 17 Orange Glass Samples’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf 6th, pp. 1673–1699.
Morgan, J. W. Laul, J. C., Krähenbühl, U., Ganapathy, R., and Anders, E.: 1972, ‘Major Impacts on the Moon: Characterization from Trace Elements in Apollo 12 and 14 Samples’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 3rd pp. 1377–1395.
Morgan, J. W., Krähenbühl, U., Ganapathy, R., Anders, E., and Marvin, U. B.: 1973, ‘Trace Element Abundances and Petrology of Separates from Apollo 15 Soils’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 4th, pp. 1379–1398.
Morgan, J. W., Ganapathy, R., Higuchi, H., Krähenbühl, U., and Anders, E.: 1974, ‘Lunar Basins: Tentative Characterization of Projectiles, from Meteoritic Elements in Apollo 17 Boulders’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 5th, pp. 1703–1737.
Morgan, J. W., Higuchi, H., and Anders, E.: 1975a, ‘Meteoritic, Material in a Boulder from the Apollo 17 Site: Implications for Its Origin’,The Moon 14, 505–517.
Morgan, J. W., Higuchi, H., Ganapathy, R., and Anders, E.: 1975b, ‘Meteoritic Material in Four Terrestrial Meteorite Craters’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 6th, pp. 1609–1623.
Palme, H., Janssens, M.-J., Takahashi, H., Anders, E., and Hertogen, J.: 1978, ‘Meteoritic Material at Five Large Impact Craters’,Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 42, 313–323.
Rammensee, W. and Wänke, H.: 1977, ‘On the Partition Coefficient of Tungsten between Metal and Silicate and Its Bearing on the Origin of the Moon’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 8th, pp., 399–409.
Ringwood, A. E. and Kesson, S. E.: 1977, ‘Basaltic Magmatism and the Bulk Composition of the Moon. II. Siderophile and Volatile Elements in Moon, Earth and Chondrites: Implications for Lunar Origin’,The Moon 16, 425–464.
Sato, M., Hickling, N., and McLane, J. W.: 1973, ‘Oxygen Fugacity Values of Apollo 12, 14 and 15 Lunar Samples and Reduced State of Lunar Magmas’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 4th, pp. 1601–1079.
Simonds, C. H., Phinney, W. C., and Warner, J. L.: 1974, ‘Petrography and Classification of Apollo 17 Non-Mare Rocks with Emphasis on Samples from the Station 6 Boulder’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 5th, pp. 337–353.
Simonds, C. H., Warner, J. L., Phinney, W. C., and McGee, P. E.: 1976, ‘Thermal Model for Impact Breccia Lithification: Manicouagan and the Moon’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 7th, pp. 2509–2528.
Takahashi, H., Janssens, M.-J., Morgan, J. W., and Anders, E.: 1978, ‘Further Studies of Trace Elements in C3 Chondrites’,Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 42, 927–930.
Wai, C. M. and Wasson, J. T.: 1977, ‘Nebular Condensation of Moderately Volatile Elements and Their Abundances in Ordinary Chondrites’,Earth and Planet. Sci. Lett. 36, 1–13.
Wänke, H., Baddenhausen, H., Dreibus, G., Jagoutz, E., Kruse, H., Palme, H., Spettel, B., and Teschke, F.: 1973, ‘Multielement analyses of Apollo 15, 16, and 17 Samples and the Bulk Composition of the Moon’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 4th, pp. 1461–1481.
Warner, J. L. and Bickel, C. E.: 1978, ‘Lunar Plutonic Rocks: A Suite of Materials Depleted in Trace Siderophile Elements’,Am. Mineralogist, in press.
Warren, P. H. and Wasson, J. T.: 1977, ‘Pristine Nomare Rocks and the Nature of the Lunar Crust’,Proc. Lunar Sci. Conf. 8th, pp. 2215–2235.
Warren, P. H., McEwing, C. E., Afiattalab, F., and Wasson, J. T.: 1978, ‘The Quest for Pristine Nonmare Rocks: Nine Nonmare Samples Free of Meteoritic Siderophiles’, inLunar and Planetary Sci. IX, pp. 1228–1230. The Lunar Science Institute, Houston.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Anders, E. Procrustean science: Indigenous siderophiles in the lunar highlands, according to Delano and Ringwood. The Moon and the Planets 20, 219–239 (1979). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00907576
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00907576