Abstract
Since the mid-1970s many western governments have felt that liberalization of market forces through deregulation and better control or privatization of public enterprises would raise productivity and reduce inflation and government deficits. This paper reviews the recent literature on public enterprise and draws on the Canadian experience. It discusses the rationale for and concept of public enterprise and focuses on two reform proposals, accountability and privatization. To increase the degree of accountability would require, on the one hand, that the government establish a formal mandate and role for the enterprise and periodically provide formal government directives, and on the other hand, provide an appropriate evaluation framework. Government compensation for imposed public duties is addressed. Full or partial privatization should be pursued when the rationale for a public enterprise has been significantly altered. This applies particularly to public transport enterprises which are in competition with the private sector.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alchian, A. A. & R. A. Kessel (1962) Competition, monopoly and the pursuit of money. In: Aspects of Labour Economics. National Bureau of Economic Research (Ed) Princeton, Princeton University Press
Borcherding, T. E. (1983) Toward a positive theory of public sector supply arrangements. In: J. R. S. Prichard (Ed) Crown Corporations in Canada. Toronto, Buttersworth
Borins, S. F. & B. Boorman (1985) Crown corporations and economic efficiency. In: Canadian Industrial Policy in Action. Vol. 4 (of the research studies prepared for the Royal Commission on the Economic Union and Development Prospects for Canada). Toronto, University of Toronto Press
Caves, D. W. & L. R. Christensen (1980) The relative efficiency of public and private firms in a competitive environment: the case of canadian railroads. Journal of Political Economy (October 1980) pp. 958–76
Caves, D. W., L. R. Christensen, J. A. Swanson & M. Trethaway (1982) Economic performance of US and canadian railroads: the significance of ownership and the regulatory environment. In: W. T. Stanbury & F. Thompson (Eds) Managing Public Enterprise(pp. 123–511) New York, Praeger
Denny, M., A. de Fontenay & M. Werner (1983) Comparing the efficiency of firms: canadian telecommunications companies. In: L. Gourville, A. de Fontenay & A. R. Dobell (Eds) Economic Analysis of Telecommunications: Theory and Applications (pp. 115–130) New York, Elsevier
Denny, M. (1984) Government enterprises in western canada's telecommunications. (Paper prepared for the Economic Council of Canada's Conference on Government Enterprises). Toronto
Economic Council of Canada (1984) Government enterprise: roles and rationales. Ottawa
Freedom To Move (1985) Transport Canada. Ottawa, Ministry of Supply and Services
Gillen, D. W., T. H. Oum & M. W. Trethaway (1984) Identifying and measuring the impact of government ownership and regulation of airline performance. (Paper presented to the Economic Council of Canada's Conference on Government Enterprise), Toronto
Gordon, M. (1981) Government in Business. C. D. Howe Institute, Montreal
Halpern, P., A. Plourde & L. Waverman (1984) Petro-Canada: its role, control and operations. (p. 79). (Paper presented to the Economic Council of Canada's Conference on Government Enterprise). Toronto
Haritos, Z. J. (1984) Transport state enterprises: the canadian experience. Transportation Reviews. Vol. 4, No. 3
Jordan, W. (1982a) Performance on north American and Australian airlines: regulation and public enterprise. In: W. T. Stanbury & F. Thompson (Eds) Managing Public Enterprise. New York, Praeger
Jordan, W. (1982b) Performance of regulated canadian airlines in domestic and transborder operations. Ottawa, Department of Consumer and Corporate Affairs
Lambert Commission (1979) Royal Commission of Financial Management and Accountability. Ottawa, Ministry of Supply and Services
Laux, J. K. & M. A. Molot (1981). The potash corporation of Saskatchewan. In: A. Tupper & B. Doern (Eds) Public Corporation and Public Policy in Canada. Montreal. Institute for Research on Public Policy
McFetridge, D. G. (1985) Commercial and political efficiency: a comparison of government, mixed, and private enterprises. (A study prepared for the Royal Commission on the Economic Union and Development Prospects for Canada), Ottawa
Prichard, J. R. S. ed (1983) Crown corporations in Canada: the calculus of instrument choice. Toronto, Buttersworth
Rotstein, A. (1984) The origin of Canadian wheat board. In: Government Enterprise: Roles and Rationale. Economic Council of Canada, Ottawa
Trebilcock, M. T. & J. R. S. Prichard (1983) Crown corporations in Canada: the calculus of instrument choice. In: J. R. S. Prichard (Ed) Crown Corporations in Canada. Toronto, Buttersworth
Tupper, A. (1977) The Nation's business: Canadian concepts of public enterprise. (Ph.D. thesis), Queen's University, Kingston
UNESCO. A Dictionary of Social Sciences (1964)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Haritos, Z.J. Public transport enterprises in transition. Transportation 14, 193–207 (1987). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00837529
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00837529