Journal for General Philosophy of Science

, Volume 24, Issue 2, pp 303–313 | Cite as

Korrespondenz und Kohärenz

Fragen an ein Versöhnungsprogramm
  • Geo Siegwart
Discussion
  • 46 Downloads

Summary

Coherence and Correspondence. Questions on a Programme of Reconciliation. Nicholas Rescher has recently proposed an original synthesis of the correspondence and the coherence idea. My purpose is a critical examination of this proposal. Against the background of a sketch of Rescher's general truth-conception and the synthesis mentioned above, I ask two questions. First: Given that coherence can only be the criterion of truth, if it forms a constitutive part of the concept of truth too; why not accept the inverse idea, which postulates the criterion-presence of correspondence? Secondly: Given the plausibility of the theoretical framework which allows the synthesis; why not accept a framework which allows a global synthesis between all truth-theories?

Key words

Korrespondenz Kohärenz Wahrheit Wahrheitsdefinition Wahreitskriterium Rescher 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Literatur

  1. Blanshard, B.:The Nature of Thought (2 vols.), London 1939.Google Scholar
  2. Blanshard, B.: ‘Reply to Nicholas Rescher’; in Schilpp, P. A. (ed.),The Philosophy of Brand Blanshard, La Salle (Illinois) 1980, 589–600.Google Scholar
  3. Coomann, H.:Die Kohärenztheorie der Wahrheit. Eine kritische Darstellung der Theorie Reschers vor ihrem historischem Hintergrund, Frankfurt/M., Bern, New York 1983.Google Scholar
  4. Heckmann, H.-D.:Was ist Wahrheit? Eine systematisch-kritische Untersuchung philosophischer Wahrheitsmodelle, Heidelberg 1981.Google Scholar
  5. Khatchadourian, H.:The Coherence Theory of Truth. A Critical Reappraisal, Beirut 1961.Google Scholar
  6. Puntel, L. B.:Wahrheitstheorien in der neueren Philosophie. Eine kritisch-systematische Darstellung, Darmstadt 1978.Google Scholar
  7. Rescher, N.:The Coherence Theory of Truth, Oxford 1973.Google Scholar
  8. Rescher, N.:Methodological Pragmatism. A Systems-Theoretic Approach to the Theory of Knowledge, New York 1977.Google Scholar
  9. Rescher, N.:Induction. An Essay on the Justification of Inductive Reasoning, Oxford 1980.Google Scholar
  10. Rescher, N.: ‘Blanshard and the Coherence Theory of Truth’, in Schilpp, P. A. (ed.),The Philosophy of Brand Blanshard, La Salle (Illinois) 1980, 574–588.Google Scholar
  11. Rescher, N.:Scepticism. A Critical Reappraisal, Oxford 1980.Google Scholar
  12. Rescher, N.:Empirical Inquiry, Totawa (N.J.) 1983.Google Scholar
  13. Rescher, N.: ‘Truth as Ideal Coherence’, in ders.:Forbidden Knowledge and other Essays on the Philosophy of Cognition, Dordrecht, Boston 1987, 17–27 u. 145 (deutsche Übersetzung in: Puntel, L. B. (Hg.):Der Wahrheitsbegriff. Neue Erklärungsversuche, Darmstadt 1987, 284–297).Google Scholar
  14. Schmuck, N.:Idealismus und Kohärenz. Eine philosophiehistorische Studie, Frankfurt/M., Bern 1985.Google Scholar
  15. Siegwart, G.:Vorfragen zur Wahrheit. Ein Traktat über kognitive Sprachen, München 1993.Google Scholar
  16. Woozley, A. D.:Theory of Knowledge. An Introduction, London 1949.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 1993

Authors and Affiliations

  • Geo Siegwart
    • 1
  1. 1.Universität/Gesamthochschule Essen Fb. 1, Fach PhilosophieEssen 1Germany

Personalised recommendations