Is ERCP manometry useful in the choice of treatment of stones of the common bile duct?

Summary

To verify the appropriateness of sphincterotomy as the treatment of choice of choledocholithiasis, since 1980 we have been using endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatographic (ERCP) manometry of the sphincter of Oddi (SO). This method allows direct investigation of SO motor activity and provides useful information regarding the presence of benign papillary stenosis (BPS). Thirty-four patients were investigated because the radiological examination indicated BPS might be present. Of these, 20 had common bile duct (CBD) stones, while the remaining 14 presented with biliarylike pain and one or more of the following: CBD dilation (larger than 12 mm); emptying of the ERCP contrast medium took longer than 45 min; abnormal liver function tests. Moreover, 8 healthy volunteers served as controls. Our results show that the incidence of SO motor anomalies is very low in the presence of choledocholithiasis, while it is substantial in patients with suspected SO dysfunction. These observations would suggest that, unlike the traditional view, BPS is rarely secondary to biliary lithiasis. Therefore, most of the sphincterotomies performed that are based on the assumption of underlying SO pathology should be considered unnecessary. Under these circumstances, the physiological role of a functioning SO has induced us to advocate sphincterotomy, surgical or endoscopic, in selected cases only.