The effectiveness of ten different ear-protectors (6 types of earmuffs and 4 types of earplugs) has been tested under laboratory conditions and in the real occupational environment. Three methods were used: (1) physical, utilizing a dummy head; (2) subjective, real-ear, executed on trained human subjects; (3) subjective, measuring TTS2 resulting from occupational, one-workday exposure. It could be shown that the ear protection efficiency ascertained on the basis of TTS2 measurements on workers exposed to noise in their occupational environment is, in nearly all cases, smaller than the efficiency expected, taking into account the sound damping of the same protectors, tested under laboratory conditions, using the physical or real-ear method. Measurements of TTS2 were found to give the best data needed to define the protectors' efficiency, since they include, simultaneously, the impact of various environmental factors, the subjective reactiveness, the nature of the professional task and the acoustical features of the protector used. Therefore this method enables the estimation of the real protection given to workers with a risk of noise-induced hearing loss.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Price includes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Berger EH (1986) Methods of measuring the attenuation of hearing protection devices. J Acoust Soc Am 79:1655–1687
Chillery JA (1979) Measurement of the real-ear attenuation of hearing protectors according to the South African Standards SABS 572 1973. J Sound Vibration 67:21–34
Else P (1973) A note on the protection afforded by hearing protector-implications of the energy principle. Ann Occup Hyg 16:81–83
ISO/DIS 6290 (1979) Acoustics. Simplified method for a measurement of insertion loss of hearing protectors of earmuff type for quality control purposes
Lundin R (1978) The effectiveness of hearing protectors in practical situation. Bilsom AB Internal Report. Bilesholm, Sweden
Mrukwa W (1981) New polish earplugs. Bezpieczeństwo Pracy 3:8–15 (in Polish)
Pawlas K, Grzesik J: Effectiveness of hearing protection determined on experimental data and on measurements in occupational environments. Inst Occup Med in Sosnowiec, Poland. Final Report 1976 (in Polish)
PN-76/N-01309 (Polish Standard) (1976) Hearing protectors. Measurement of attenuation and acoustical effectiveness
PN-84/N-01307 (1984) Noise. Permissible sound levels
Trynkowska D (1985) Survey of hearing protectors and principle of their use. Bezpieczeństwo Pracy 4:7–12 (in Polish)
Recommendation of the Polish General Sanitary Inspector (1985) Measurement and evaluation of environmental chemical and physical factors. Editor: PZWL, Warsaw
About this article
Cite this article
Pawlas, K., Grzesik, J. Efficiency of ear protectors in laboratory and real life tests. Int. Arch Occup Environ Heath 62, 323–327 (1990). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00640841
- Noise induced TTS2
- Hearing protectors
- Hearing protection efficiency