Evolution of upper urinary tract and renal function in patients with posterior urethral valves

Abstract

From January 1972 to June 1993, 166 patients with posterior urethral valves (PUV) were treated in our surgical department, 59 with a milder form of PUV (upper urinary tract [UUT] complication rate 29%) and 107 with a severer form (UUT complication rate 96.3%). Only the latter group was studied for long-term (mean 9.3 years) evaluation of the UUT and renal function. A temporary vesicostomy was the primary treatment in 25 patients. Indications for temporary diversion were very young age and/or low birth weight, severe and bilateral UUT complications, and severe renal damage. All the other patients were treated by primary endoscopic valve fulguration. After removal of the lower urinary tract obstruction, vesicorenal reflux (VRR) resolved spontaneously or was ameliorated in 59.2% of the renal units. Spontaneous normalization or evident amelioration were found at long-term follow-up in nearly 70% of dilated, non-refluxing ureters. Ureteral reimplantation was performed on 41 of the 202 dilated or refluxing ureters (surgical rate 20.3%). The surgical failure rate requiring reoperation was 5% (2/41). The prerequisite for successful reimplantation was a large-capacity, stable, and compliant bladder. Ten nephroureterectomies were carried out for unilateral, massive VRR and renal dysplasia; 1 late nephrectomy was performed for arterial hypertension. The evolution of renal function showed statistically significant overall improvement, which was more evident in patients diagnosed and treated in the 1st month of life (P = 0.000) than in those treated between 1 and 12 months (P = 0.004) or after 1 year of age (P = 0.025). Renal function considerably improved in the vesicostomy group (P = 0.000). Thirteen patients (12.4%) are now either dead (2) or have end-stage renal disease (6) or chronic renal insufficiency evolving toward end-stage renal disease (5); 5 of these 13 were treated by vesicostomy in the first days or months of life, and at presentation the glomerular filtration rate (GFR) was less than 25 ml/min . 1.73 m². Determination of basic GFR and, even more, functional renal reserve is relevant in predicting the long-term evolution. In the author's opinion, vesicostomy is the procedure of choice in very ill newborns or infants. Aggressive management with early surgical reconstruction is rarely justified, because frequently UUT complications resolve spontaneously or clearly improve, and their surgical treatment has limited and very precise indications.