Abstract
The notion of cerebral death is examined in relation to those of cardiopulmonary and whole-brain death. It is argued that rather than being a new concept of death, it is merely a new criterion that leaves the old concept — death as loss of personhood — intact. The argument begins on a theoretical level with the distinction between criteria and concepts, places both into context with the notion of a conceptual framework in its relation to empirical reality, and then particularizes the result to criteria for the determination of death. It is argued that the suggestion of the cerebral criterion is nothing more than an attempt to realign the concept of death with the empirical data with which it has come out of step due to new developments in the empirical field. The paper considers tutioristic objections to the criterion, and shows its compatibility with dualistic religio-metaphysical positions by considering an actual example. It also addresses briefly the ethical impact of the criterion on medical practice.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics.
Beauchamp, T. L. and Perlin, S. (eds.): Ethical Issues in Death and Dying, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, 1978.
Black, P. M.: ‘Definition of brain death’, in ([2], pp. 5–10).
Bonhoeffer, F.: Ethik, edited by E. Bethge, Munich, 1956.
Brandt, R.: Ethical Theory, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, 1959.
Cutler, D. (ed.): Updating Life and Death, Beacon Press, Boston, 1969.
Donceel, J. F.: ‘Abortion: Mediate and immediate animation’, Continuum 5, (1967) pp. 167–171.
Fletcher, J.: ‘Indicators of humanhood: A tentative profile of man’, Hastings Center Report 2/5, (1972) pp. 1–4.
Frege, G.: Nachgelassene Schriften, Felix Meiner, Hamburg, 1969.
Häring, B.: Medical Ethics, Fides, Notre Dame, 1973.
Illich, I.: Limits to Medicine, Penguin Books, Hammondsworth, 1976.
Jonas, H.: ‘Against the stream: Comments on the definition and redefinition of death’, in ([2], pp. 51–59).
Jonas, H.: ‘Philosophical reflections on experimenting with human subjects’, Daedalus, Spring 1969, reprinted in Munson, R. (ed.), Intervention and Reflection: Basic Issues in Medical Ethics, Wadsworth Publishing, Belmont, California 1979, pp. 248–264.
Kluge, E.-H. W.: ‘Abstraction: A contemporary look’, The Thomist XL, (1976) pp. 337–367.
Kluge, E.-H. W.: ‘St. Thomas, abortion and euthanasia: Another look’, Philosophy Research Archives, Sept. 1981.
Kluge, E.-H. W.: The Ethics of Deliberate Death, Kennikat Press, Port Washington, 1981.
Kluge, E.-H. W.: The Practice of Death, Yale University Press, New Haven, 1975.
Law Reform Commission of Canada, Criteria for the Determination of Death, Working Paper 23, Ottawa, 1979.
Ramsey, P.: The Patient as Person, Yale University Press, New Haven, 1970.
‘The definition of irreversible coma’, Report of the Ad Hoc Committee of the Harvard Medical School, Journal of the American Medical Association 205, (1968) pp. 337–340.
Ross, W. D.: The Right and the Good, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1930.
Schwager, R. L.: ‘Life, death, and the irreversibly comatose’, in ([2], pp. 38–50).
Shils, E.: ‘The sanctity of life’, in Labby, D. H. (ed.), Life and Death: Ethics and Options, University of Washington Press, Seattle, 1968, pp. 2–38.
Thielicke, H.: ‘The doctor as judge of who shall live and who shall die’, in Vaux, K. (ed.), Who Shall Live? Medicine, Technology, Ethics, Fortress Press, Philadelphia, 1970.
Van Till, H. A. H.: ‘Diagnosis of death in comatose patients under resuscitation treatment: A critical review of the Harvard Report’, American Journal of Law and Medicine 2, (1976) pp. 1–40.
Veatch, R. M.: Death, Dying, and the Biological Revolution, Yale University Press, New Haven, 1976.
Veith, F. L.: ‘Brain death’, Parts 1 and 2, Journal of the American Medical Association 238, (1977) pp. 1651–1655 and 1744–1748.
Walters, LeRoy, (ed.): Bibliography of Bioethics, Gale Research Co., Detroit, 1973 to 1976.
Walton, D. N.: Brain Death: Ethical Considerations, Purdue University Press, West Lafayette, 1980.
Walton, D. N.: On Defining Death: An Analytic Study of the Concept of Death in Philosophy and Medical Ethics, McGill-Queen's University Press, Montreal, 1979.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kluge, EH.W. Cerebral death. Theor Med Bioeth 5, 209–231 (1984). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00489492
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00489492