Abstract
The problem addressed is that of finding a sound characterization of ambiguity. Two kinds of characterizations are distinguished: tests and definitions. Various definitions of ambiguity are critically examined and contrasted with definitions of generality and indeterminacy, concepts with which ambiguity is sometimes confused. One definition of ambiguity is defended as being more theoretically adequate than others which have been suggested by both philosophers and linguists. It is also shown how this definition of ambiguity obviates a problem thought to be posed by ambiguity for truth theoretical semantics. In addition, the best known test for ambiguity, namely the test by contradiction, is set out, its limitations discussed, and its connection with ambiguity's definition explained. The test is contrasted with a test for vagueness first proposed by Peirce and a test for generality propounded by Margalit.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Akmajian, A., R. A. Demers, and R. M. Harnish: 1979, Linguistics: An Introduction to Language and Communication, 2nd edn., revised 1984, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Alston, W. P.: 1964, Philosophy of Language, Foundations at Philosophy Series, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey.
Aronoff, M.: 1976, Word Formation in Generative Grammar, Linguistic Inquiry: Monograph 1, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Atlas, J. D.: 1984, ‘Grammatical Non-Specification: The Mistaken Disjunction ‘Theory’’, Linguistics and Philosophy 7, 433–43.
Bach, E.: 1989, Informal Lectures on Formal Semantics, SUNY Series in Linguistics, State University of New York Press, Albany, New York.
Baldwin, J. M. (ed.): 1901, Dictionary of Philosophy and Psychology, 2 vols, Macmillan, New York.
Chomsky, N.: 1981, Lectures on Government and Binding. The Pisa Lectures, Studies in Generative Grammar, 2nd edn., revised 1982, Foris, Dordrecht.
Chomsky, N. and M. Halle: 1968, The Sound Pattern of English, Harper and Row, New York.
Cresswell, M. J.: 1973, Logics and Languages, Methuen, London.
Cresswell, M. J.: 1988, Semantical Essays: Possible Worlds and Their Rivals (Studies in Linguistics and Philosophy, Vol. 36), Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht.
Davidson, D.: 1967, ‘Truth and Meaning’, Synthese 17, 304–23.
Davidson, D.: 1970, ‘Semantics for Natural Language’, in Visentini et al., pp. 177–88.
Davidson, D. and G. Harman (eds.): 1972, Semantics of Natural Language, D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Dowty, D. R., R. E. Wall, and S. Peters: 1981, Introduction to Montague Semantics (Synthese Language Library, vol. 11), D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
DuCrôt, O.: 1972, Dire et Ne Pas Dire, Hermann, Paris.
DuCrôt, O.: 1973, Le Preuve et le Dire, Maison Mame, Paris.
Dummett, M.: 1973, Frege: Philosophy of Language, Duckworth, London.
Fodor, J. A., T. G. Bever, and M. Garett: 1974, The Psychology of Language, McGraw-Hill, New York.
Gillon, B. S.: 1990, ‘Truth Theoretical Semantics and Ambiguity’, Analysis 50, 178–82.
Grice, P.: 1967, ‘Logic and Conversation’, William James Lectures, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Higginbotham, J.: 1985, ‘On Semantics’, Linguistic Inquiry 16, 547–94, reprinted in LePore (ed.), 1987, pp. 1–54.
Horn, L. R.: 1983, ‘In Defense of Privative Ambiguity’, Proceedings of the Berkeley Linguistic Society 9, 141–56.
Horn, L. R.: 1989, A Natural History of Negation, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Kaplan, D.: 1978, ‘Dthat’, Syntax and Semantics 9, 221–43.
Katz, J. J.: 1972, Semantic Theory, Harper and Row, New York.
Katz, J. J.: 1977, Propositional Structure and Illocutionary Force: A Study of the Contribution of Sentence Meaning to Speech Acts, The Language and Thought Series, Thomas Crowell, New York.
Kempson, R. M.: 1977, Semantic Theory, Cambridge Textbooks in Linguistics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, England.
Kooij, J. G.: 1971, Ambiguity in Natural Language. An Investigation of Certain Problems in its Linguistic Description, North-Holland Linguistic Series, North-Holland, Amsterdam.
Leech, G.: 1974, Semantics, Penguin Books, (Pelican Books: Language and Linguistics), Harmondsworth, England.
LePore, E. (ed.): 1987, New Directions in Semantics, Cognitive Science Series, Academic Press, London.
Levinson, S. C.: 1983, Pragmatics, Cambridge Textbooks in Linguistics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, England.
Lewis, D.: 1972, ‘General Semantics’, in Davidson et al., pp. 169–218.
Lycan, W. G.: 1984, Logical Form in Natural Language, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Lyons, J.: 1977, Semantics, 2 vols., Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, England.
Margalit, A.: 1983, ‘A Review of Scheffler (1979)’, Journal of Philosophy 80, 129–37.
Mill, J. S.: 1843, A System of Logic, Ratiocinative and Inductive, Being a Connected View of the Principles of Evidence and the Methods of Scientific Investigation, 8th edn, abridged in Nagel (ed.), 1950.
Montague, R.: 1970a, ‘English as a Formal Language’, in Visentini et al. (eds.), 1970, pp. 189–224, reprinted in Thomason (ed.), 1974, pp. 188–221.
Montague, R.: 1970b, ‘Universal Grammar’, Theoria 36, 373–98, reprinted in Thomason (ed.), 1974, pp. 222–46.
Nagel, E. (ed.): 1950, John Stuart Mill's Philosophy of Scientific Methods, Hafner Library of Classics, reprinted 1974, Hafner Press, New York.
Parsons, K. P.: 1973, ‘Ambiguity and the Truth Definition’, Noûs 7, 379–94.
Peirce, C. S.: 1901, ‘Vague’, in J. M. Baldwin (ed.), vol. 2, p. 748.
Roberts, L.: 1984, ‘Ambiguity vs. Generality: Removal of a Logical Confusion’, Canadian Journal of Philosophy 14, 295–313.
Scheffler, I.: 1979, Beyond the Letter: A Philosophical Inquiry into Ambiguity, Vagueness, and Metaphor in Language, Routledge & Kegan Paul, Boston, Massachusetts.
Selkirk, E. O.: 1984, Phonology and Syntax: The Relation between Sound and Structure, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Tarski, A.: 1956, ‘The Concept of Truth in Formalized Languages’, in J. H. Woodger (trans., and ed.), pp. 152–278.
Thomason, R. H.: 1974, ‘Introduction’, in Thomason (ed.), pp. 1–69.
Thomason, R. H. (ed.): 1974, Formal Philosophy: Selected Papers of Richard Montague, Yale University Press, New Haven, Connecticut.
Visentini, B. et al. (eds.): 1970, Linguaggi nella Società e nella Tecnica, Edizioni de Communità, Milano, Italy.
Woodger, J. H. (trans. and ed.): 1956, Logic, Semantics, and Metamathematics, Oxford University Press, Oxford, England.
Zwicky, A. M. and J. M. Sadock: 1975, ‘Ambiguity Tests and How to Fail Them’, Syntax and Semantics 4, 1–36.
Zwicky, A. M. and J. M. Sadock: 1987, ‘A Non-test for Ambiguity’, Canadian Journal of Philosophy 17, 185–87.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
The earliest version of this paper was presented to The Logical Grammar Study Group at The University of Alberta, which included, at that time, Matthew Dryer, Bernard Linsky, Jeff Pelletier, and Len Schubert, Among others. Section 2 of the paper was presented 25 May, 1987 at the annual meeting of the Canadian Philosophical Association (Hamilton, Ontario); and Section 1 was presented 22 January, 1900 to the Department of Philosophy at the University of Ottawa. I am grateful to these audiences and others who have provided helpful criticism and comments.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gillon, B.S. Ambiguity, generality, and indeterminacy: Tests and definitions. Synthese 85, 391–416 (1990). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00484835
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00484835